Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the new health secretary should spend a day at an abortion clinic ?

132 replies

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:03

So apart from the fact that she is clearly clinically obese and smokes cigars ! Our new health secretary is also an anti abortionist, being a practicing Catholic. I was also raised as a Catholic to be believe abortion was wrong, but becoming a doctor and a mother has changed my mind 360 (or 180) on this. The pivitol moment for me was attending TOP lists as a medical student and talking to the women, realising that it is nearly always the least worst choice of a variety of pretty dire options. If this women (Coffe) is to stand in judgment on thousands of women than perhaps she should dip her toe into the reality. BTW I would also advocate a 12 hr shift on her feet on as an HCA on the dementia wards.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 07/09/2022 09:20

SynchronisedStrimmer · 07/09/2022 09:03

Your personal character assassination on her appearance and habits have no bearing on her ability to do the job and your prejudices are showing. Not a good look OP.

This.

Winnietheboo · 07/09/2022 09:20

I know this is ignorant and based on largely unfounded prejudices but I did find it hard when I was sectioned for an ED when I was younger having an obese support worker. I was terrified if I listened to them and what they were saying I should do I would also end up obese, which of course whilst not the worst thing in the world but to someone grappling with a potentially fatal eating disorder does seem like the end of the world whilst they're in that space. Other than that can't say I've ever overly noticed or been perturbed by a HCPs weight.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 07/09/2022 09:09

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:17

It is part of one's declaration to the GMC that you will look after your own health. I would argue carrying the amount of weight she clearly is, isn't looking after your health. But she isn't a doctor and doesn't have to answer to the GMC.

Best tell that to my what you would call obese, oncologist and nursing team who without I wouldn't be here and got through the last few years.

Guess you haven't heard of unhealthy slimmer people then either. 🙄

Winnietheboo · 07/09/2022 09:07

Not concerned what she looks like, her voting record doesn't align with my views personally and she seemed a shoe in for the job she wanted as she's liz' closest friend. A lot of the choices seem similarly illogical however will wait and see what she goes on to do rather than judging already.

Runwalkskijump · 07/09/2022 09:05

sorrynotathome · 07/09/2022 06:46

We have had male, obese smokers as Health secretaries before (you may be too young to remember) so YABU. Do we require chancellors to be self-made millionaires? Education secretaries to have PHDs? The photo of her with a cigar is clearly a very old one. It’s so tiring to see women happily slagging off other women for not being perfect.

This

gatehouseoffleet · 07/09/2022 09:03

ThickCutSteakChips · 07/09/2022 07:09

She said only this year that she doesn't like abortions and wishes people didn't get them, but wouldn't condemn people that do. And that the law isn't going to change on abortion.

Which is perfectly acceptable stance really.

Indeed. People are allowed their personal views as long as they don't try to impose them on others.

SynchronisedStrimmer · 07/09/2022 09:03

Your personal character assassination on her appearance and habits have no bearing on her ability to do the job and your prejudices are showing. Not a good look OP.

balalake · 07/09/2022 08:59

To me it is simple- the minister should support the policy. If they dissent, that is their choice, but then they should be appointed to another post if at all.

You would not have a Defence Secretary who did not believe in the UK keeping nuclear weapons, for example.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 07/09/2022 08:54

As long as she supports the right of women to access safe abortion, her personal attitudes shouldn't be relevant. I stress shouldn't. The UK is a much more progressive country than the US in many ways, and as long as we don't let religious beliefs get in the way of common sense we will stay that way.

FlimsySteve · 07/09/2022 08:53

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:31

I agree with your abortion statement but my god, the clinically obese bit… what are you saying here - that only someone with a good BMI can be Health Secretary?

Someone with a basic understanding of health ? - yes, I think that should be a pre- requisite for what is effectively the boss of the entire NHS.

Stop bullshitting about being a doctor

onlythreenow · 07/09/2022 08:52

How can you tell everyone else to be healthy when you're obese?!

I don't think that is actually what her job is!!!

Neverendingdust · 07/09/2022 08:52

She is grim, I agree OP. I also think it’s a bit rich having someone who is obese and smokes as the health secretary, she’s far from a picture of health but as others said it’s as tone deaf as a millionaire Chancellor, there’s clearly form for this from these people.

When someone shows you who they are, believe them…

Aberration · 07/09/2022 08:50

Should we start by firing all the obese doctors , nurses and paramedics ?

RoseAndRose · 07/09/2022 08:48

averageavocado · 07/09/2022 08:41

I'm not being goady, but don't we actually want and need experts in their field determining policy etc?

Yes, that's why there are experts within Whitehall departments.

You're not going to find someone who is simultaneously expert as nurse, midwife, surgeon, physician, physio, porter, admin clerk, health economist, estates manager, procurement manager, dentist, carehome manager, safeguarding lead, OT, domiciliary carer etc etc etc

So instead you appoint people who are believed to be most capable of handling complexity, managing experts and generally being policy-capable

Thereisnolight · 07/09/2022 08:45

Hmmm…some women (not all) who are very slim and well-groomed may be focusing more on themselves and their appearance than on other people. Fine for some careers but not politics imo. Give me someone who doesn’t care what they look like because they are too interested in what’s going on around them.

averageavocado · 07/09/2022 08:41

sorrynotathome · 07/09/2022 06:46

We have had male, obese smokers as Health secretaries before (you may be too young to remember) so YABU. Do we require chancellors to be self-made millionaires? Education secretaries to have PHDs? The photo of her with a cigar is clearly a very old one. It’s so tiring to see women happily slagging off other women for not being perfect.

I'm not being goady, but don't we actually want and need experts in their field determining policy etc?

notdaddycool · 07/09/2022 08:37

It’s fine to condemn Catholic beliefs, but keep your mouth shut if there’s anything in Islam you find offensive.

Kendodd · 07/09/2022 08:36

Oh God no. Those poor women (and girls) are suffering enough.

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 08:31

As much as I’d like population health overall to be tackled it shouldn’t become personal

How she looks is not relevant and I agree with pp that overweight middle aged with short hair is always more ridiculed

We should do better as many of us are middle aged and would prefer to work in professional settings without the same

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 08:28

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:31

I agree with your abortion statement but my god, the clinically obese bit… what are you saying here - that only someone with a good BMI can be Health Secretary?

Someone with a basic understanding of health ? - yes, I think that should be a pre- requisite for what is effectively the boss of the entire NHS.

How are you feeling about others appointed into pists they are not particularly versed in the way some of us would want them to be?

Or is just the particular woman you would like to take shots at?

With politicians their voting record is an issue. She doesn't need to fully understand health, she won't be advising anyone on how to manage conditions.
Now our visitor from 1877 on the other hand will probably take us back to coal mines.

Minee · 07/09/2022 08:27

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:31

I agree with your abortion statement but my god, the clinically obese bit… what are you saying here - that only someone with a good BMI can be Health Secretary?

Someone with a basic understanding of health ? - yes, I think that should be a pre- requisite for what is effectively the boss of the entire NHS.

I agree.

How can you tell everyone else to be healthy when you're obese?!

Sparklybanana · 07/09/2022 08:25

Considering she's her 'best mate', she's been set up for a lot of body criticism given her role. Not sure I'd do that to mine.
Personally, she may have more of an idea about health given her weight but if she's not been successful in gaining control of her own health issues are we supposed to believe she's going to help others with their issues?
I also think have someone against abortion working in the top job is not going help women's health rights. I don't think too many vegans would make effective agriculture ministers so why would this be different?

onlythreenow · 07/09/2022 08:24

The links between obesity, cancer and dementia has become clear in the last 10-15 yrs. Science is funny like that it makes progress and discovers new things.

You must have led a sheltered life - have you never seen overweight doctors, nurses etc.? Or health professionals who (shock, horror) smoked?

anniegun · 07/09/2022 08:19

She is awful in every way. There is not a single aspect of the DWP that improved under her tenure. However I doubt changes to abortion law are even on her agenda. At the moment she needs to visit A&E's , talk to GPs and see for herself how broken the NHS is. She will not, she will talk to consultants about how much can be done by the private sector.

ElBandito · 07/09/2022 08:17

If you knew you shouldn't have mentioned her weight then why did you? Shows a distinct lack of judgement for a doctor! I'm not sure that someone with such a lack of judgement should be a doctor really 🤷‍♀️.
Also, just to confirm, it is 180 degrees not 360.
Everything else I actually agree with you.