Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the new health secretary should spend a day at an abortion clinic ?

132 replies

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:03

So apart from the fact that she is clearly clinically obese and smokes cigars ! Our new health secretary is also an anti abortionist, being a practicing Catholic. I was also raised as a Catholic to be believe abortion was wrong, but becoming a doctor and a mother has changed my mind 360 (or 180) on this. The pivitol moment for me was attending TOP lists as a medical student and talking to the women, realising that it is nearly always the least worst choice of a variety of pretty dire options. If this women (Coffe) is to stand in judgment on thousands of women than perhaps she should dip her toe into the reality. BTW I would also advocate a 12 hr shift on her feet on as an HCA on the dementia wards.

OP posts:
VoiceOfCommonSense · 07/09/2022 14:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MelodyPondsMum · 07/09/2022 13:28

You don't share her values or experiences so I doubt spending time in an abortion clinic would change her views. Religious freedom is just as important as abortion. You can't and shouldn't sacrifice one for the other. We're not the US, abortion rights are not at risk and the groups trying to shift the Overtoun window to pretend they are, are doing vast damage.

I think the entire NHS is at risk under the Tories but using abortion as a trojan horse for fat-shaming, misogyny and religious bigotry, isn't the enlightened position you think it is.

averageavocado · 07/09/2022 13:20

RoseAndRose · 07/09/2022 08:48

Yes, that's why there are experts within Whitehall departments.

You're not going to find someone who is simultaneously expert as nurse, midwife, surgeon, physician, physio, porter, admin clerk, health economist, estates manager, procurement manager, dentist, carehome manager, safeguarding lead, OT, domiciliary carer etc etc etc

So instead you appoint people who are believed to be most capable of handling complexity, managing experts and generally being policy-capable

ah - that makes sense

Sunnydaysunny · 07/09/2022 12:26

Also as the op is also a practicing catholic supporter of abortion it shouldn't be impossible to wrap your head around the new HS having personal principles that she would personally live by, and political principles about what needs to be available in a modern humane society. You always have to make policy decisions for people doing nothing illegal and absolutely fine for them, but something you wouldn't personally choose to do, it's nothing new.

Sunnydaysunny · 07/09/2022 12:23

I would have thought that a doctor of all people would understand there are many reasons why a person might struggle to reach a healthy weight that are not connected to their attitude or knowledge.

Bideshi · 07/09/2022 11:11

With you, op. Looking forward to seeing her do the regular talk on how the rise is obesity is putting pressure on the NHS. Not knocking her appearance: it really doesn't matter what she looks like from a personal pov, but in that particular job she does provide validation for people in denial about excess weight impacting health.
I know Kenneth Clarke was a tubby cigar-smoking minister of health but that was in the late 80s and times have changed.
As for the abortion, gay marriage things, it's indicative of a mindset that's not going to be open to tolerance and empathy. But then again, perhaps only a ruthless analytical mind is capable of dealing with the multifarious problems of the NHS. It's not going to go well, I feel.

Overthisnow98 · 07/09/2022 10:25

health policy and personal health are not the same. I have a degree in healthcare and know almost everything there is to know about nutrition and lifestyle effects on health. I choose to eat what I want , smoke and drink alcohol fairly often because I’m 40 and I have had a wonderfully exciting life and I can’t be arsed to get old to the extent I’m no longer nice to look at or can go off and have fun ! I’m happy to have the family heart attack around the age they all do . No one in living memory in my family has ever gone into a care home or needed any help at home. The week before my gran died she cycled to do her weekly shop and mowed her own lawn . We all self destruct and drop dead around 70 and it’s great because no one needs looking after or becomes a burden and no ones money gets spent on care. So I’m fully aware I’m probably cultivating all kinds of nasties in my cells and blood vessels and I intend to continue because it beats getting old.
more people think like this than people realise I believe.
being anti abortion is being anti women though and I hope her Catholicism doesn’t come into play with any decisions around this. I think in the U.K. we’re reasonably safe from that happening . It’s only happened in America because they’re all bible mad and as a nation we aren’t .

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 10:14

justagirlstandinginfrontofcake · 07/09/2022 10:10

I am terrified about our new health secretary. And deputy PM. She is not a nice person - and yes I have met her on a number of occasions. I am quite heartbroken at the state of the whole new cabinet. As women you would think we should be celebrating, but frankly, as women, we are now f*cked.

She doesn’t have to nice she has to be effective and if she’s not then happy to see the back of her. I’m sorry you had a bad experience with her though.

Wouldloveanother · 07/09/2022 10:13

justagirlstandinginfrontofcake · 07/09/2022 10:10

I am terrified about our new health secretary. And deputy PM. She is not a nice person - and yes I have met her on a number of occasions. I am quite heartbroken at the state of the whole new cabinet. As women you would think we should be celebrating, but frankly, as women, we are now f*cked.

Genuine question but why ‘terrified’? What do you think is going to happen?

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 10:11

ShandaLear · 07/09/2022 10:05

I think it’s very naive to think that personal beliefs influence policy. Politicians are elected on the basis of their beliefs. They choose to stand for election in order to influence policy and set the direction of the UK.

I said "decide". She won't be allowed to just do whatever she wants. She may want to ban abortion, but that won't happen.

justagirlstandinginfrontofcake · 07/09/2022 10:10

I am terrified about our new health secretary. And deputy PM. She is not a nice person - and yes I have met her on a number of occasions. I am quite heartbroken at the state of the whole new cabinet. As women you would think we should be celebrating, but frankly, as women, we are now f*cked.

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 10:08

Tbh all this nonsense about Therese Coffey’s weight has depressed the shit out of me. We are facing serious challenges as a nation and people use their head space to worry about how much the health secretary weighs (I know, I know, I contributed to this thread).

There are some excellent discussions on mumsnet about what needs to be done on energy prices, on taxation on inflation. Then we have the threads basically populated with insults, “omg Liz Truss is sooooo thick, Therese Coffey is sooo fat.”

ShandaLear · 07/09/2022 10:05

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 09:57

She's a politician. Her personal beliefs don't decide policies. Her physical appearance doesn't reflect her competence in a particular area.

I think it’s very naive to think that personal beliefs influence policy. Politicians are elected on the basis of their beliefs. They choose to stand for election in order to influence policy and set the direction of the UK.

ShandaLear · 07/09/2022 10:03

I don’t care about her weight or looks. I care about her approach to the NHS and am anticipating moves to further privatise it. This is the most hardline, far right, government I’ve ever seen - so hardline that even Priti Patel had to stand down (let that sink in for a moment). I think we’re in for an absolute shit show, dismantling of rights, taxation that will benefit the rich, and an absolute lack of interest or care about anyone further down the food chain. The only consolation is that Truss is unlikely to last long enough to do much further damage.

Cheminaufaules · 07/09/2022 10:02

I always suspected, but now I know that reality is a cosmic joke.
Therese Coffey - health secretary?!!! My sides are splitting.

Wouldloveanother · 07/09/2022 10:01

I do find the appearance of some of our politicians to be embarrassing - scruffy, unkempt, no pride in their appearance. I know I’ll be shot down for that but I don’t care, I like my politicians to both look and act like professionals.

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 09:57

She's a politician. Her personal beliefs don't decide policies. Her physical appearance doesn't reflect her competence in a particular area.

Sparklfairy · 07/09/2022 09:54

You're a doctor? A doctor with terrible SPAG and more importantly, attention to detail (can't even get Coffey's name right)...

Mrsnononsense · 07/09/2022 09:52

She’s not a medical doctor, she’s got a PhD in Chemistry. The whole ‘doctors should be healthy’ BS doesn’t apply, and it has got little to do with reality. Many doctors and people working in the NHS lead very unhealthy lifestyles.

MonkNun · 07/09/2022 09:50

When DD was in hospital, a number of the clinical staff clearly had unhealthy BMIs. They still provided excellent care.

I know that binge drinking isn’t good for me. I still occasionally do it because life isn’t all about living like a puritan.

Mybestyear · 07/09/2022 09:45

Sarahconnor1 · 07/09/2022 07:12

This has nothing to do with her being female, I would say the same of a man. How can she really with a straight face talk about health promotion strategies?

So do you also think all doctors and nurses should be a healthy weight? They have to talk to the public face to face about issues surrounding obesity.

@Sarahconnor1 - this is an interesting one because the Nursing and Midwifery Council future nurse standards of proficiency upon which nurse education is based state that nurses must be “role models” and promote healthy behaviours, be fit and healthy enough to fulfil the role etc. and you can lose your NMC registration if you are not of “good health and character” and by extension, if you are obese to the point of being limited in how far you can walk for example, that could be considered poor health. As a nurse myself, I’m in two minds about it - on the one hand, I would struggle for example to attend an exercise class if the instructor was obese, but on the other, it’s the care the nurse provides which is most important.

in Scotland, our (former) chief nurse was obese until she got the chief nurse post. She then dramatically lost weight and said that she couldn’t stand in front of people and talk about the obesity epidemic when she was obese herself. Interesting now that she’s left that post, she’s put on a lot of weight again. Which to me shows just how hard it can be to maintain a healthy weight.

it’s a really interesting discussion!

ancientgran · 07/09/2022 09:36

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:31

I agree with your abortion statement but my god, the clinically obese bit… what are you saying here - that only someone with a good BMI can be Health Secretary?

Someone with a basic understanding of health ? - yes, I think that should be a pre- requisite for what is effectively the boss of the entire NHS.

People can understand health issues without being perfect physical specimens themselves. She might have alot of insight about why people do unhealthy things and the sort of support they need.

I understand I should eat healthily but I just had a mince pie for breakfast, it means I'm human. I don't smoke, do drugs or drink alcohol but my failing in relation to sugar means I can grasp why people have problems with addictions.

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 07/09/2022 09:32

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 07/09/2022 09:22

Obesity is irrelevant. Many many health care professionals are obese (sometimes as a result of their shift patterns). You can be obese and completely understand the health risks, and an understanding of the causes of obesity. Most if not all obese people do I’m sure.

The abortion views is more concerning to me. My initial thought was that she would quite likely accept her views are a minority and keep her personal views separate from her work. But I’m vegetarian (and quite a relaxed one at that, not a passionate animal rights activist) and I could never accept a role as minister for food and agriculture, it would be absurd.

On second thoughts, I hope this is a small enough part of the health service that her personal views are not an issue. We need someone to sort out the NHS and social care, desperately, so I’ll wait and see how she does.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/09/2022 09:27

ThickCutSteakChips · 07/09/2022 07:09

She said only this year that she doesn't like abortions and wishes people didn't get them, but wouldn't condemn people that do. And that the law isn't going to change on abortion.

Which is perfectly acceptable stance really.

You keep your reasonable and tolerant opinions to yourself please!

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 07/09/2022 09:22

Obesity is irrelevant. Many many health care professionals are obese (sometimes as a result of their shift patterns). You can be obese and completely understand the health risks, and an understanding of the causes of obesity. Most if not all obese people do I’m sure.

The abortion views is more concerning to me. My initial thought was that she would quite likely accept her views are a minority and keep her personal views separate from her work. But I’m vegetarian (and quite a relaxed one at that, not a passionate animal rights activist) and I could never accept a role as minister for food and agriculture, it would be absurd.

Swipe left for the next trending thread