Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy

259 replies

Shortjanet · 06/09/2022 21:43

I've read quite a few comments here where posters seem to think fixed or capped energy prices mean that you can pay a set or limited amount for unlimited energy. It's quite worrying to think how much debt people might run up. The way the headlines are describing it as "bills capped to £x" or similar is helping to fuel the misunderstanding (no pun intended) I think. AIBU to wish the media were being clearer that caps and fixes apply to each kWh used and standing charges, not the total you can pay.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 07:44

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:07

Actually I think the comparison with petrol and diesel illustrates the point well. I have never seen those prices reported as the cost of filling a car's tank being capped at a figure. They report price per litre. People understand this and don't expect to fill a range rover for the same as a mini.

This type of misunderstanding re gas and electric is a direct result of the decision to report figures in terms of average annual spend. If they were reporting "price cap doubling from xp per kWh to yp per kWh" those who didn't understand what it meant would at least know they needed to educate themselves on it!

They do often say "the average cost of filing a typical family far has now reached £X" (last week or so it was £100) which is comparable. Am assuming (/desperately hoping!) no-one would think that means their car will cost exactly £100 to fill but wouldn't be surprised to discover someone has actually thought that...

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:40

I think I should have titled this "to be worried the media is misleading people to think the price cap means unlimited energy?"

I do believe most people have understood they pay per unit so far. I think if it was reported in those terms people would get it in the same way they do when the price of petrol rises in pence per litre. It's specifically they way it's being described in terms of X thousand per year for an average household bill I take issue with. It is not clear. I love @Sooverthisnow explanation in terms of apples. I think it needs to be said more.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 07:35

I honestly don't understand how people cant get that they use units (KWH) of electricity or gas and that the cost of each of these units has increased (but the increase has been regulated)

People have ALWAYS paid for gas and electricity in units. You have to give a meter reading. This has happened since we got gas and electrcity meters.

Don't people look at their bills?

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 07:25

Sooverthisnow · 06/09/2022 22:09

@Coconutmeg Its the cost per KWh that’s been capped. The more energy you use the higher your total will be.
Imagine it were apples, and the cost per apple was capped at £1 each and no higher, and the average family used 50 apples a year. The cost for them is £50.
If you decide to eat as many apples as you can and end up eating 200. The price is capped at £1 per apple, your bill £200 because you’ve eaten more.

Great analogy.

megletthesecond · 07/09/2022 07:16

Yanbu.
I made the mistake of looking at a local facebook page discussing energy bills and so many people didn't get it. Also a scary amount who didn't understand an energy DD builds up credit in the summer for winter use.

Kashmirsilver · 07/09/2022 07:13

People do not seem to grasp the cost of energy. They also do not seem to be understanding that our average energy use is actually very, very, very high.
This is my problem with government intervention, people will carry on as normal with the heating on 30 c and windows open.😂

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:13

I understand the point that everyone (or at least most) should and can take responsibility for educating themselves but I don't think the cost of failing to so so should be the world of shit they may find themselves in if they decide to go all out having paid for "fixed" (or unlimited in their minds) gad and electric. The reporting on this in average bills may seem simpler to understand than price per kWh but is so open to misinterpretation it becomes misleading imo.

OP posts:
loudlylikealion · 07/09/2022 07:08

JulesCobb · 06/09/2022 22:36

But you were taught skills on how to read and research. You cannot possibly be taught everything you need to know ever by the age of 16. At some point adults needs to be responsible for finding out these things for themselves.

Yes! There are going to be some people for who that isn't possible but a lot of the people who have it wrong just haven't bothered to work out what it is they are signing up to.

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:07

Actually I think the comparison with petrol and diesel illustrates the point well. I have never seen those prices reported as the cost of filling a car's tank being capped at a figure. They report price per litre. People understand this and don't expect to fill a range rover for the same as a mini.

This type of misunderstanding re gas and electric is a direct result of the decision to report figures in terms of average annual spend. If they were reporting "price cap doubling from xp per kWh to yp per kWh" those who didn't understand what it meant would at least know they needed to educate themselves on it!

OP posts:
Madcats · 07/09/2022 07:03

I don't know whether this is helpful for people, but I was looking at our household energy usage and stumbled on this website.

If you have smart meters (or know your approx annual usage) it will be able to tell you how much it is costing:

www.theenergyshop.com

I was a little surprised that they seemed to have a pretty accurate record of our supplier and what we were using once I told them our address (but that's a whole different thread).

tttigress · 07/09/2022 06:59

Simonjt · 07/09/2022 06:54

I work in the financial sector, my boss thinks the cap means unlimited energy for that price in the same was a £20 phone contract means unlimited texts. Yes, a lot of people working in the financial sector shouldn’t be there!

I agree with this, also working bin financial services, it is scarry that many do not have basic maths skills.

JangolinaPitt · 07/09/2022 06:57

sarahc336 · 06/09/2022 22:04

Too many people don't actually understand why the price is going up though do they? There's a Facebook post doing the rounds suggesting it's purely for the people at the top to get more bonuses 🤷🏻‍♀️ it makes me want to scream as they just don't educate themselves about world problems they just read crap on Facebook. So yea so many they'll just think a fixed fee will mean use whatever you want and only pay a set amount 🤯 x

See yes even a supposedly educated person (teacher where I work) said this yesterday re the ‘fat cats’ - BBC is completely irresponsible by people just want sound bites and ate too lazy to hop befitting the headline.

Simonjt · 07/09/2022 06:54

I work in the financial sector, my boss thinks the cap means unlimited energy for that price in the same was a £20 phone contract means unlimited texts. Yes, a lot of people working in the financial sector shouldn’t be there!

Nothingbuttheglory · 07/09/2022 06:54

Explain to me like I’m 5 please
what does the price cap mean in real terms

Energy = Freddoes

Currently 1 Freddo costs 25p.

Price cap means chocolate companies will not be allowed to charge more than 50p per Freddo over the winter.

But the more Freddoes you eat, the more you'll have to pay.

(Standing charge is like paying road tax to get to the shop. It's the same whether you buy any Freddoes or not. People get het up over this. Last winter my standing charge was <10% of my overall bill)

IncompleteSenten · 07/09/2022 06:48

YANBU. It is worrying how many people seem to lack even basic understanding.

They are in for a shock.

alwaysfactor50 · 07/09/2022 06:44

I've just heard them say price cap of £2500 on BBC breakfast news. It sounds exactly like no household will pay more than that amount. The reporters need to be held to account as it is so easy to be confused by this.

Wallywobbles · 07/09/2022 06:13

@cakeorwine can you put your spreadsheet into a Google drive and share it. Would be really handy. And fascinating to know how many people use it.

Alternatively a template on Notion, if you are that way inclined.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 04:42

But you were taught skills on how to read and research. You cannot possibly be taught everything you need to know ever by the age of 16. At some point adults needs to be responsible for finding out these things for themselves.

@JulesCobb well said

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/09/2022 00:08

Although, we don't seem to have heard from the 'at least petrol hasn't gone up, I put £30 in every week like I always have' brigade yet.

It's weird, isn't it, because almost everybody understands the principle with petrol and diesel. Most people know that a bigger or faster car will not do as many miles as a smaller or more ordinary one, and thus they realise the inherent choices they make that mean they will pay more or less to fuel their car.

I like to think that the 'doesn't affect me because I always put £30 in' folk are just trying to make a silly joke, but I wouldn't put it past some not to quite get it. It's similar to the other old one, where an 80yo will claim to be much fitter and stronger than they were at 20, because they can easily carry £10-worth of shopping in one hand now, whereas 60 years ago, they would have needed a wheelbarrow to move shopping costing £10. Surely most people are just being silly/jocular, aren't they?!

The media cut to the chase and just go to the shortcut capped price based on average usage, but this will indeed go over a lot of people's heads. It might help if they made a conscious effort to stress that a unit is going up from Xp to Xp, meaning that people using the average household amount will thus pay £X, but it's too long and clumsy for the headlines.

Plus, people hear the unit price of 7p and that sounds negligibly cheap; then they hear that it's going up to 15p, and that also sounds too cheap to worry about. It's true that a single unit is cheap, but your total bill isn't when you're using tens of thousands of them!

I think it's very unkind and unfair to label people as fools for this and say that they deserve what they get if they don't understand. Different people have different strengths and weaknesses. I always rein myself in and tell myself, when I receive an invoice from a tradesman that's full of terrible spelling and poor phrasing: "I wouldn't have made all of those mistakes. I would have presented a SPAG-perfect invoice. However, give me a hundred years and I still would never have had the faintest idea or ability to begin doing the perfectly and efficiently-executed job that's just been done, to which the invoice relates."

bellac11 · 06/09/2022 23:45

StarDolphins · 06/09/2022 22:42

I totally understand the ‘fixed’ prices means but I admit I am struggling with this prices are capped at £2500’ I need it explained like i’ 5 too!

Currently use & pay £85 worth of combined G&E per month (obviously before Oct increase) so what will this mean for me?

You have to look at what your current unit price is and what your yearly estimated usage is based on the last year

Then you can work out based on the new capped rates how much this coming year will cost (although it will be goinng up again in January)

If you are on a fixed rate now, you need to work out when that will end

If you say you are using 85 pounds worth, then that will obviously go up anyway in winter because its summer now

bellac11 · 06/09/2022 23:36

Ive just made this point on another thread, exactly this, why on earth does this keep getting reported in terms of a cost per year, when nothing is average when it comes to energy costs because there is no average home, average area, average lifestyle, average number of people in the property etc etc

Its hugely irresponsible the way this has been and is being reported and referred to.

cakeorwine · 06/09/2022 23:33

I love maths and spreadsheets - I have each months projected usage plus variables for costs per unit of gas and electricity and I have put in scenarios for modelling percentage reductions.

I also understand exactly how energy is used in the house.

I can see what's coming and am ready for it.

The 'price cap' is more confusing as energy usage clearly varies through the year - especially with gas - and this is why it can clearly be seen that this winter is going to be hard for people as the cost of the gas they use will be more than double than last Christmas. People will have hardly had the gas on over summer and won't have seen the effect of April's gas price rise much yet.

watingroom2 · 06/09/2022 23:31

RetreatRetreatRetreat · 06/09/2022 22:11

Anyone who is on the "Energy support and advice" Facebook group can clearly see how financially illiterate 90% of the people on there are. It's terrifying that people have so little grasp on financial knowledge

The education system does not teach financial understanding -

It is far easier for people to not understand and make profits

snowballer · 06/09/2022 23:25

The way it's reported is in my view 100% of the reason so many people don't understand.

Saying the cap is being raised from £x,000 to £y,000 is as someone said up thread criminally irresponsible comms. It means nothing, but - crucially - appears to mean everything. The figures are so specific that they imply that this is the maximum a house could pay for energy, rather than an average example. I don't blame people at all for misunderstanding this.

It needs to be properly spelled out as "Today the price cap on one unit of electricity (1kwh) is X. In October it will be Y."

They could then say, "an average 3 bed household uses X number of units per month in the summer, and Y per month in the winter."

The rises are so high that no household will be able to cut their usage enough to even get down to their previous costs, let alone below them. If people are bowling into the winter thinking, "well I'm going to make the most of my increased direct debit and have the heating on all day," then the messaging from government and reporting by the media has been comprehensively fucked up and is downright dangerous.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 06/09/2022 23:04

Just because I wasn’t taught how an energy bill works at age 13 doesn’t mean I can’t use basic maths skills as an adult to figure it out.

But many people don't have those basic maths skills so will struggle to figure it out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread