Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy

259 replies

Shortjanet · 06/09/2022 21:43

I've read quite a few comments here where posters seem to think fixed or capped energy prices mean that you can pay a set or limited amount for unlimited energy. It's quite worrying to think how much debt people might run up. The way the headlines are describing it as "bills capped to £x" or similar is helping to fuel the misunderstanding (no pun intended) I think. AIBU to wish the media were being clearer that caps and fixes apply to each kWh used and standing charges, not the total you can pay.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
bellac11 · 07/09/2022 10:46

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 10:37

@bellac11

By way of a quick example.. below is the last update from BBC news on the price people will pay...

It's fairly concise and clearly spells out:
-it's a typical household
-the change from current

What else would you want them to add in to make it more clear?

I cant remember if its this thread or the other one but the average reading and comprehension age in this country is very low

No where in that article does it state the unit cap, or explain what is meant by typical or average, let alone the fact that there is no typical or average in this scenario.

The entire article is completely meaningless. Unless of course you happen to be already paying around £1900 per year and are the person that the article is based on. Unlikely.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 07/09/2022 10:41

It's difficult. I can calculate my own bill based on my expected usage, but see a lot of people who don't really understand what it means. Generally speaking, energy bills are not easy to understand for the majority and people will look at the payment rather than the breakdown because of that.

Martin Lewis tends to explain it fairly well in so much as if you currently pay £x you'll be paying £y, which people typically take in as its relatable to them. Saying your kwh price is 7.4p means little to most as there's no relatability to what a kwh looks like.

It's quite horrible to mock people for not understanding things. Even moreso when the information has been put out in a misleading way. And saying if someone has time to use Facebook they have time to Google is ridiculous. Similarly, if you have time to mumsnet you have time to read up on how to be a better person.

Also to whoever said mortgages, credit cards and marriage vs cohabiting are on the curriculum, they aren't. Calculating APR is way beyond the capability of pupils who are studying intermediate or lower level maths, as are things like compound interest, LTV and so on. Religion is really not the area to teach about the practicalities of marriage vs cohabiting either, where the focus is on the moral view and not the pragmatic one.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 10:37

@bellac11

By way of a quick example.. below is the last update from BBC news on the price people will pay...

It's fairly concise and clearly spells out:
-it's a typical household
-the change from current

What else would you want them to add in to make it more clear?

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy
loudlylikealion · 07/09/2022 10:34

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 10:04

People get their main information from news outlets and they are reporting completely incorrect and misleading information. Its no wonder people are confused and dont understand it

They should be checking their bill and what they are signing up to not just blindly agreeing

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 10:33

People get their main information from news outlets and they are reporting completely incorrect and misleading information. Its no wonder people are confused and dont understand it

@bellac11 I'm just not sure they are... I mean, we've all understood it enough from the news to know what is meant by the cap and to decide whether or not we need to do some of our own research...

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 10:04

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 07:46

I understand why you're saying but I just don't think as a country we need to continue to stoop to lower levels of spoon feeding everyone everything. People need to assume responsibility for their own lives and decisions. After all, everyone is equal under the law and has the same entitlement to vote so presumably the same responsibility to educate themselves and make informed decisions.

People get their main information from news outlets and they are reporting completely incorrect and misleading information. Its no wonder people are confused and dont understand it

alwaysmovingforwards · 07/09/2022 09:57

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 09:30

agree that some people will struggle to understand but many others are just too lazy or disengaged to take responsibility

Exactly. People take pride in 'being bad at maths' and taking an interest in finances and financial responsibility/being careful with resources is seen as 'boring' and 'not living your best life'.

It's depressing, especially when these people are likely to expect help and sympathy when they get the massive bill because they didn't bother to take an interest and 'no-one told me it would cost this much'.

My eldest sent me this film to watch.
Even he said "it's a comedy... but maybe a documentary" 😂

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 09:30

agree that some people will struggle to understand but many others are just too lazy or disengaged to take responsibility

Exactly. People take pride in 'being bad at maths' and taking an interest in finances and financial responsibility/being careful with resources is seen as 'boring' and 'not living your best life'.

It's depressing, especially when these people are likely to expect help and sympathy when they get the massive bill because they didn't bother to take an interest and 'no-one told me it would cost this much'.

FourChimneys · 07/09/2022 09:14

I agree that some people will struggle to understand but many others are just too lazy or disengaged to take responsibility.

Read the thread this morning about a supply teacher planning to walk out because the Y11 pupils won't even acknowledge her. So much disregard and lack of respect for education, and that will have an impact on their future daily lives.

Baconking · 07/09/2022 09:12

Sooverthisnow · 06/09/2022 22:09

@Coconutmeg Its the cost per KWh that’s been capped. The more energy you use the higher your total will be.
Imagine it were apples, and the cost per apple was capped at £1 each and no higher, and the average family used 50 apples a year. The cost for them is £50.
If you decide to eat as many apples as you can and end up eating 200. The price is capped at £1 per apple, your bill £200 because you’ve eaten more.

Perfect explanation. Even a 5 year old can understand this 😊

CaptainBarbosa · 07/09/2022 09:01

Yes I've had to explain to vulnerable service users in the community what the price cap means.

Some get it some don't, so we will keep trying to explain with our service users.

I tried to demonstrate it with Lego blocks, saying this 4 brick is your capped standing charge, you will pay 7 days of these a week. But the government can't turn your 4 brick into a 6 brick (more) because of the cap. Then I used 2 Brick pieces as units, and did the same trying to show them if you use more you get more 2brick pieces, but all the cap means is they can't turn the 2brick piece into a 4 brick piece because of the cap.

I had to think outside the box whilst in their homes, and luckily many of their children had some form of Lego/Duplo 😳

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 08:57

I think the way it’s reported is extremely unhelpful. People really need to know for the winter what the price cap actually is before they get surprise bills. Yes they should have read up for themselves and it’s extremely worrying but we are where we are so we really do need the government to put out info adds on it.

But yes extremely concerning.

alwaysmovingforwards · 07/09/2022 08:52

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 07/09/2022 08:41

I never used to understand why my bills would go up when they’d given me a quote ‘for the year’. It was only when this all started that I realised. I think energy companies have been pulling this trick for years, knowing that most people are used to unlimited phone contracts so assume it’s the same. Sneaky but it works, especially if you don’t work in the industry.

No, the 'quote for the year' will state 'based on predicted usage of 'abc' at unit / standing charges or xyz.

If people decide to assume that's 'fixed and unlimited' as per their broadband... well I have no polite words to describe such people and more fool them.

MercurialMonday · 07/09/2022 08:50

I think some people may have a nasty shock.

MIL was talking few weeks ago about people in her hair dressers going on about having everyone round wearing t-shorts as they'd fixed.

We kept saying - it doesn't work like that which I not sure MIL understood but as they have wood burner and are frugal with heat and not fixed themselves is't as issue.

However it was unclear how much winding up these people were doing towards none fixed people and how many were assuming their fixed rate direct debit was like a Netflix subscription.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 07/09/2022 08:41

I never used to understand why my bills would go up when they’d given me a quote ‘for the year’. It was only when this all started that I realised. I think energy companies have been pulling this trick for years, knowing that most people are used to unlimited phone contracts so assume it’s the same. Sneaky but it works, especially if you don’t work in the industry.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 07/09/2022 08:37

When they said 'the cost of filling an average family car with petrol has gone past £100' we didn't have people saying 'it's not fair, why should Range Rover drivers fill their tanks for the same price as my Ford Focus' or 'I drive a Skoda Citigo, why should I pay £100 to fill my car when it only takes 35 litres' and energy pricing works in exactly the same way.

Perfect illustration 👍

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 08:30

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:53

I don't think we should spoon feed either, just make reporting clearer. I'd be totally ok with the media reporting "price cap to rise/fall/be frozen to/at X pence per kWh" Then anyone who doesn't get it can go and read up around it. It's the throwing out of figures whose context is explained down page in much smaller text that bothers me.

But it's not just 'X p per kWh' it's 'X p per kWh for electricity plus the daily standing charge and Y p per kWh for gas plus the daily standing charge' and that's before we get to complications about the various Economy 7/electric vehicle tariffs and slight variations between the different payment methods and regional variations in the cost of electricity.

'The price cap for typical use will be £2500 per year, it used to be half that and the government is intervening so it won't be double that amount next year' tells us everything we need to know then we need to go off and find out how we compare with typical use so how much it will cost us as individuals.

When they said 'the cost of filling an average family car with petrol has gone past £100' we didn't have people saying 'it's not fair, why should Range Rover drivers fill their tanks for the same price as my Ford Focus' or 'I drive a Skoda Citigo, why should I pay £100 to fill my car when it only takes 35 litres' and energy pricing works in exactly the same way.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 07/09/2022 08:15

Google 'what is oct price cap' or call your energy supplier. It's not secret buried info, it's right there

Tbf, it might as well be secret info for people on economy 7 tariffs, as there aren't price caps specifically for the day and night rates. Supppliers can choose what to set those at, and I think there may either be some sort of average price cap between the two, or some other sort of cap (perhaps on cost per x number of units??) but I can't find any simple straightforward explanation of how the cap works with economy 7.

alwaysmovingforwards · 07/09/2022 08:07

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:13

I understand the point that everyone (or at least most) should and can take responsibility for educating themselves but I don't think the cost of failing to so so should be the world of shit they may find themselves in if they decide to go all out having paid for "fixed" (or unlimited in their minds) gad and electric. The reporting on this in average bills may seem simpler to understand than price per kWh but is so open to misinterpretation it becomes misleading imo.

But where does it end? How far do we have to stoop to accommodate the people who make no effort??

You choose to consumer utilities.
You have a meter.
You have a bill from your supplier.
If you have Facebook you have access to the internet - literally the world in the palm of you hand.
Google 'what is oct price cap' or call your energy supplier. It's not secret buried info, it's right there.
Every phone has a calculator and I'm sure we can all rustle up a pen and a bit of paper.
All it needs then is 15mins or less of nursery school level maths.
That is all it takes.

I don't know anything about brain surgery. That's ok - it's not my field, I don't interact with it. I'll ask a qualified expert or two if I want to learn. Or I'll Google some medical papers in an effort to investigate if I decide I want to find out more.

But if you consumer gas and electricity, as a responsible adult you've got an obligation to proactively educate yourself to find out how it works. Because you use it and ultimately you get billed for it - you've got skin in the game.
To just join a Facebook group is lazy and effectively says I can't be bothered to do it myself, I'll rely on someone else to do it for me. And then the blind are leading the blind.

And so I stand by my point that if you then get a shock with your bill because you didn't choose to make an effort to understand it, then more fool you.

If one can't be bothered to find out simple info for oneself then that is ok, but then you can't then rue the outcome as well.

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:53

I don't think we should spoon feed either, just make reporting clearer. I'd be totally ok with the media reporting "price cap to rise/fall/be frozen to/at X pence per kWh" Then anyone who doesn't get it can go and read up around it. It's the throwing out of figures whose context is explained down page in much smaller text that bothers me.

OP posts:
DorchaAndLouis · 07/09/2022 07:51

Kashmirsilver · 07/09/2022 07:13

People do not seem to grasp the cost of energy. They also do not seem to be understanding that our average energy use is actually very, very, very high.
This is my problem with government intervention, people will carry on as normal with the heating on 30 c and windows open.😂

When people are interviewed about how they'll cope with increased energy costs they often say they'll "have to put a jumper on". As if this is something unusual.
Shocking how much gas and electricity must be wasted if people think it's normal to wear summer clothes indoors in the winter.

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:50

See I hadn't noticed that with car tanks but if they are explaining "the average car now costs whatever to fill" they have at least spelt it out. Tbh when I've seen it the headline is more likely to be fuel rises to X pence per litre with the illustration in terms of cost of a tank explained in the text.

The words annual, average and household are generally not making it through to headlines here. I'm seeing "price cap to be frozen at however many thousand pounds" and can see why that is confusing people.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 07:48

Kashmirsilver · 07/09/2022 07:13

People do not seem to grasp the cost of energy. They also do not seem to be understanding that our average energy use is actually very, very, very high.
This is my problem with government intervention, people will carry on as normal with the heating on 30 c and windows open.😂

I agree - and the Government don't seem to understand that it's a problem of supply now as well.

Other countries are rationing usage.

It's all well and good having a price cap and intervention - but if we have no gas, then not only will the cost of the intervention massively increase, people and businesses just won't have enough gas.

It's like when you get shipwrecked and people start to eat all the food instead of rationing it out.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 07:46

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 07:13

I understand the point that everyone (or at least most) should and can take responsibility for educating themselves but I don't think the cost of failing to so so should be the world of shit they may find themselves in if they decide to go all out having paid for "fixed" (or unlimited in their minds) gad and electric. The reporting on this in average bills may seem simpler to understand than price per kWh but is so open to misinterpretation it becomes misleading imo.

I understand why you're saying but I just don't think as a country we need to continue to stoop to lower levels of spoon feeding everyone everything. People need to assume responsibility for their own lives and decisions. After all, everyone is equal under the law and has the same entitlement to vote so presumably the same responsibility to educate themselves and make informed decisions.

cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 07:45

I don't know if people ever see those clips on You Tube where (mainly Americans) are shown a map and asked where England is etc - and they often get it wrong..

I wonder what would happen if people on the street were asked what the price cap was? Or to work out a simple bill? Or some other questions about financial literacy?

How many people could explain the price cap?