Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy

259 replies

Shortjanet · 06/09/2022 21:43

I've read quite a few comments here where posters seem to think fixed or capped energy prices mean that you can pay a set or limited amount for unlimited energy. It's quite worrying to think how much debt people might run up. The way the headlines are describing it as "bills capped to £x" or similar is helping to fuel the misunderstanding (no pun intended) I think. AIBU to wish the media were being clearer that caps and fixes apply to each kWh used and standing charges, not the total you can pay.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 07/09/2022 20:01

@cakeorwine are you being deliberately obtuse or are you really that stupid that you don't understand that everyone doesn't share 1 mode of thinking?

As I said, terrific for you that you apparently know everything. Except there's lots you don't know, but you're naive to the things you don't know. Similarly for many people who think they understand their energy costs but actually don't.

For example, you don't seem to understand that a non smart gas meter doesn't read in kwh and most people would have no clue how the numbers on their bill correlate to the numbers on their meter.

The answer is not to tell people to just learn it, the answer is to make the information easier to read and understand.

cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 19:49

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 19:47

Sorry, but the idea that there's a meter so of course you can't have unlimited doesn't work. Phone contracts often have unlimited SMS, unlimited data, unlimited minutes etc. It's all measured but you can stil pay for unlimited (capped?) It's totally opaque and I fear that will cause much hardship.

See - my bill for my phone tells me how much data, calls I get.

Because I take responsibility and look at my phone bill. It says I have unlimited calls clearly on my bill.

PurpleFlower1983 · 07/09/2022 19:48

I know a fair few people who misunderstood their fixed tariffs. A friend of mine was disgusted that they had raised her ‘fixed tariff’ last month even though it was due to end in March next year. The reality is she’s been running a hot tub for the last six months so her usage has gone up by loads.

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 19:47

Sorry, but the idea that there's a meter so of course you can't have unlimited doesn't work. Phone contracts often have unlimited SMS, unlimited data, unlimited minutes etc. It's all measured but you can stil pay for unlimited (capped?) It's totally opaque and I fear that will cause much hardship.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 19:46

It is absolutely terrific that SOME people understand energy costs. But it isn't a life failure for those who don't. I could just as easily pick out something else that I understand perfectly well, but you probably would not

But if it was something to do with running a household - then I would try and find out what it meant and if I did not understand, I would try and find someone who could help me.

cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 19:45

It's silly saying people SHOULD look at their bills. People SHOULD fully read and understand terms and conditions before they agree to them but I'll bet my life that less than 10% of people actually do

I don't think it is. If you are get a bill, you should look at it to see if it's what you expect.

If you don't understand your bill, there are resources, charities and people out there who can help you.

If you get a bill and just pay it without checking, then you can easily be exploited, ripped off, confused etc.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 07/09/2022 19:39

It's silly saying people SHOULD look at their bills. People SHOULD fully read and understand terms and conditions before they agree to them but I'll bet my life that less than 10% of people actually do.

I know several people who don't understand what kwh means, and they have no desire to understand. The number they provide from their meter is not in kwh unless its a smart meter which converts it.

If we want people to understand information it should be given in the simplest, most easily digested and understood way. Not doing that means you're shit at communication and if you're shit at communication you've failed. Then you factor in different rates at different times, different types of rate, rebates etc and the bill can get quite complex actually.

It is absolutely terrific that SOME people understand energy costs. But it isn't a life failure for those who don't. I could just as easily pick out something else that I understand perfectly well, but you probably would not.

cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 19:30

@FrankLampardsBrokenHand

Martin Lewis tends to explain it fairly well in so much as if you currently pay £x you'll be paying £y, which people typically take in as its relatable to them. Saying your kwh price is 7.4p means little to most as there's no relatability to what a kwh looks like.

But people SHOULD look at their bills.

People know about meter readings. What do they think the meter is doing?

If you know that it is measuring in KWH and your bill says how many KWH you have used and you know what each one costs, you can see what your bill is.

People know that the more you buy of something, the more you pay.

You just need to know that the price of that 'something' has increased.

Shortjanet · 07/09/2022 18:16

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 14:10

Don't forget there will also be a few people who's bills are included in their rent so may be looking at this for the first time to get an idea of how much their rent might go up and how they can reduce the potential for that.

Then there are those with conditions that make understanding statistics a bit harder than for typical people - such as dysculia.

People with mental health conditions (which have rocketed in the last few years) often have trouble with concentration, especially when it comes to new or unfamiliar information/data.

The sneering on this thread is horrible.

Agree with all of this. The attitude that if people don't understand it serves them right is pretty horrible. Also the idea that it's a choice to use gas and electricity is mind boggling in 2022 UK. It's not like taking out credit for a car or mortgage. It's absolutely unavoidable.

OP posts:
MoltenLasagne · 07/09/2022 18:12

I think people are incredibly unaware of how many people struggle with financial literacy.

I used to support adults with very, very basic finances. When changes came in to give people their rent to give to landlords lots of these people got into serious debt because they couldn't do the simple maths of "I need to keep X amount for rent and then I need 4/5 weeks of groceries for Y amount".

The people who came to us were trying desperately to engage but they could not do the maths themselves. Very occasionally someone would get it, but mostly I had to do the sums and say "you can take out x cash each week for groceries and other spending and still have enough to pay your rent and bills" and hope that there was enough buffer in my calculations that things weren't going to go wrong at the next bill increase.

Sooverthisnow · 07/09/2022 17:51

But everyone thinks the are average. Except they’re not. Reporting on this has to change.

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 16:43

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 12:31

@bellac11

No where in that article does it state the unit cap, or explain what is meant by typical or average, let alone the fact that there is no typical or average in this scenario.

Oh come on, really? You're a) suggesting this needs to be included in every article (and that individuals aren't intelligent enough to research / work it out for themselves) and b) paradoxically, that one on hand you're saying people don't understand basic concepts ("typical", "average" etc) yet on the other you're saying the article should state the unit cap... as if they'd have a clue what that meant (even after explanation!) if they didn't know what "typical" meant?! Come on. Have faith in people and accept that adults have a responsibility to ensure they have a basic understanding of key aspects of their own lives, to inform themselves where they need to know more and fundamentally "act as adults" (rather than expect to be spoon fed, sheltered, handled with kid gloves etc).

It absolutely should state the unit price seeing as that is exactly the thing that is being capped and the price of it!!

And I didnt say someone wouldnt know what is meant by the word typical or average but that its almost impossible to say, given there is no definition in this scenario, whether the reader is typical or average.

I gave my own example where we pay exactly that at the moment, so our increase is exactly the amount quoted by other posters above, and yet we are not typical in the sense of 2.4 children type typical.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/09/2022 14:40

People understand this and don't expect to fill a range rover for the same as a mini.

Not the point at all, but I parked our little old Golf between a Range Rover (Evoque) and a new Mini some time ago, and they looked to be pretty much exactly the same size!

I do think it's the word 'cap' that's mainly to blame here, though - there's never been any talk of petrol or diesel prices being capped.

Also, when they say 'for the average household', those of us who are possibly a little more astute in this area know that 'average' means typical USAGE; however, I can see how some people could quite reasonably interpret 'average' in another way. If (as they see it), the government is 'setting/deciding' the charges, they may well think that 'average' relates to an average-sized family, an average 3-bed semi, a band-D house for council tax or whatever. They should definitely make it clear that it's average USAGE amount and dump any ambiguity that might make people believe it to be average STATUS/CIRCUMSTANCES households.

"The bills will be capped to £2,500 per year, as long as you don't use any more than the average amount of gas and electricity" - simple and clear, no?

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 14:10

Don't forget there will also be a few people who's bills are included in their rent so may be looking at this for the first time to get an idea of how much their rent might go up and how they can reduce the potential for that.

Then there are those with conditions that make understanding statistics a bit harder than for typical people - such as dysculia.

People with mental health conditions (which have rocketed in the last few years) often have trouble with concentration, especially when it comes to new or unfamiliar information/data.

The sneering on this thread is horrible.

MercurialMonday · 07/09/2022 14:02

On a related matter, are people not taught to assess reliability and interpretation of information at all? It would be a useful part of GCSE English, Maths and Science for a start.
Which are 'good' sources of information

History GCSE is good for the source work but DD1 couldn't take it as wasn't an option for her year - though we've been telling them about good sources since they were young.

The rest is hit and miss depending on school/teachers and syllabuses plus where IL are many didn't pass GCSE maths or English.

Plus IL know many their ages who left school at 15 went straight to work place and unlike my parents haven't really studied since.

Readability data suggest that the average reading age of the UK population is 9 years – that is, they have achieved the reading ability normally expected of a 9-year-old. The Guardian has a reading age of 14 and the Sun has a reading age of 8.
Are you aware how literate your employees are

Even in UK with universal education up to secondary school level for decades literacy rate is 99% so 1 in 100 struggles.

una.org.uk/international-literacy-day-factsheet

I'm more surprised on MN - tending towards younger and more educated than general population - that there is such confusion. People with fixed monthly direct debits for fuel surprised they pay for more than they use in summer building up credit - if you don't like doing that variable direct debits or quarterly bills are options but for many mean large bills in winter are avoided when income is same amount each month.

BorgQueen · 07/09/2022 12:37

If the ‘average’ is to be £2500 then it will mean electric at 35p per kwh and gas at 10p. So higher than it is currently but way below October’s previously predicted rates of 52p / 14p.
If we also still get the £400 then bills should barely rise this winter.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 07/09/2022 12:31

@bellac11

No where in that article does it state the unit cap, or explain what is meant by typical or average, let alone the fact that there is no typical or average in this scenario.

Oh come on, really? You're a) suggesting this needs to be included in every article (and that individuals aren't intelligent enough to research / work it out for themselves) and b) paradoxically, that one on hand you're saying people don't understand basic concepts ("typical", "average" etc) yet on the other you're saying the article should state the unit cap... as if they'd have a clue what that meant (even after explanation!) if they didn't know what "typical" meant?! Come on. Have faith in people and accept that adults have a responsibility to ensure they have a basic understanding of key aspects of their own lives, to inform themselves where they need to know more and fundamentally "act as adults" (rather than expect to be spoon fed, sheltered, handled with kid gloves etc).

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 12:29

@alwaysmovingforwards some nice judgement and prejudice there. You've never experienced an anxiety or panic disorder I take it?

alwaysmovingforwards · 07/09/2022 11:50

Gymnopedie · 07/09/2022 11:19

Energy price cap will rise by 80% to £3,549 a year from October 2022, Ofgem announces - The i

Ofgem raises energy price cap by 80% to £3,549 - the Guardian

Ofgem raises energy price cap by 80% to £3,549 - amid fears it could hit £7,200 next spring - Daily Mail

Some of the headlines from August when the new cap was announced. Not helpful. And if you were already struggling with your bills would you then go on to read the fine print in the article, or shut the page down quickly in a panic?

True, if I were struggling and saw some sensationalist / generalised news headlines that would likely impact me, I'd quickly close it down in a panic, shut my eyes, pray it goes away and hope a grown up would deal with it for me.
Sorry... this is what I'd do if I was 10 years old.

As an adult who takes accountability for myself, I'd probably use some incredibly basic reasoning / investigative skills to ascertain what this means for me specifically and figure out what I can do about it to mitigate.

Just close it down in a panic in order to shelter under the blanket of ignorance?? 😂
Jeez... I just can't convince myself that any adult (outside of learning difficulties who need assistance etc) who would actually think like that.

TheClitterati · 07/09/2022 11:24

Its extraordinary how one of lifes basic necessities for every single citizen has become so insanely complicated and misrepresetned in UK.

The whole energy thing is a shit show from A-Z.

Having said that surely everyone knows we all pay for the energy we use?

Gymnopedie · 07/09/2022 11:19

Energy price cap will rise by 80% to £3,549 a year from October 2022, Ofgem announces - The i

Ofgem raises energy price cap by 80% to £3,549 - the Guardian

Ofgem raises energy price cap by 80% to £3,549 - amid fears it could hit £7,200 next spring - Daily Mail

Some of the headlines from August when the new cap was announced. Not helpful. And if you were already struggling with your bills would you then go on to read the fine print in the article, or shut the page down quickly in a panic?

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 11:12

@NorthStarRising well said.

Most accountants use calculators because its been so long since they did mental arithmetic.

And maths in school isn't fantastic for helping everyone with real life situations- financial management is needed too. Answering 'if I had 8 apples and Sue stole 3 apples, how many apples would I have?' doesn't really set one up for working out the finer points of their energy bill 20 years later...

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 11:12

On a related matter, are people not taught to assess reliability and interpretation of information at all? It would be a useful part of GCSE English, Maths and Science for a start.

Which are 'good' sources of information, which have a fairly obvious hirearchy, ie official sources like gov.uk, regulators and the energy suppliers, followed by well regarded media and consumer sites like the BBC and Moneysaving Expert, then tabloids and social media where the tabloids liberal use of 'could', 'is thought to' and 'may' effectively make whatever is written fairly meaningless unless corroborated by a source further up the hirearchy, so comprehension of what is actually written down.

Forums and social media are obviously unreliable as people can write anything, especially when anonymous, so it can't be the case that people 'get most of their news' from there. 'I read it on social media' but never bothered to check it out properly myself, well more fool you.

Maths and science can obviously crunch the numbers but also teach people to ask more questions and check the validity of the data.

'The price cap is £X'

How is this worked out?
How do the usage figures compare to my situation?
If my use is above average, why is this and what can I do to improve?

NorthStarRising · 07/09/2022 10:56

Can I point out, as an aside, that you are taught a lot of things in school.
But if you don’t practise, maintain, improve and develop that knowledge, it doesn’t stay shiny and sharp and ready to use. It atrophies.
Most adults that passed GCSE maths comfortably would struggle a decade further on, unless they’ve continued to use those skills.
I spoke fluent German at one point in my life, not now.

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 10:48

I take it back, I have just realised that we are the exact family in the article. We currently pay 1900 a year based on last year

I would say we are very much not typical. We have a wood burner for one so a lot of our heat is subsidised by that, we have very low gas usage. But apparently (according to this forum) we have very high electric usage which I am still trying to figure out why.

Swipe left for the next trending thread