Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy

259 replies

Shortjanet · 06/09/2022 21:43

I've read quite a few comments here where posters seem to think fixed or capped energy prices mean that you can pay a set or limited amount for unlimited energy. It's quite worrying to think how much debt people might run up. The way the headlines are describing it as "bills capped to £x" or similar is helping to fuel the misunderstanding (no pun intended) I think. AIBU to wish the media were being clearer that caps and fixes apply to each kWh used and standing charges, not the total you can pay.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Clavinova · 29/09/2022 17:13

Rachel Reeves has said that people in the UK will not see their costs increase by “a single penny” under Labour’s plan to tackle rapidly rising gas and electricity bills.

labourlist.org/2022/08/reeves-bills-will-not-rise-by-a-single-penny-under-labours-energy-plans/

Shortjanet · 29/09/2022 17:12

@jcyclops The main text (in quotations) is a cut and paste from the guardian article I read. Sorry, I should have bolded it to make it clearer. That said, you are quite right I have used average rather than typical elsewhere. Really interesting info, it seems like the situation is even more misleading than I'd realised!

OP posts:
Clavinova · 29/09/2022 17:06

NOBODY CORRECTED HER
Where is Ofgem?

Perhaps Ofgem could speak to Keir Starmer as well?

Labour leader Keir Starmer has announced new proposals to freeze the energy price cap to stop households paying more when prices are set to rise this winter.

Starmer said the plan would mean people would not pay a "penny more" on their energy bills later this year...

www.politicshome.com/news/article/labour-lays-out-energy-overhaul-to-stop-costofliving-crisis-at-source

jcyclops · 29/09/2022 16:44

Shortjanet · 29/09/2022 11:42

So just seen this in the guardian. Apparently Liz truss doesn't understand it either. Fantastic.

"Truss criticised for wrongly saying no household will pay more than £2,500 under energy price guarantee
In her interview round this morning Liz Truss sometimes gave the impression that her energy price guarantee will mean that no household will face a fuel bill of more than £2,500 a year.

That is not correct. Under the plan, unit prices are capped at a rate that means that the average household will pay no more than £2,500. But if you use more gas and electricity than average homes do, you will pay more. By the laws of maths, half of people will pay more than the average.

Some of the reporting on this probably has not been as clear as it should have been because headlines resist subtlety and making the point that average bills are notionally capped at £2,500 a year probably means more to people than explaining that unit prices are actually capped at 34.0p/kWh for electricity and 10.3p/kWh for gas.

In her interviews, when talking about the £2,500 figures, Truss mostly said it applied to a “typical” bill. (Typical is not the same as average, but never mind.)

But sometimes she said all bills would be capped at £2,500. She told Radio Leeds that people in West Yorkshire would not face energy bills of £6,000. She went on: “Through the energy price guarantee, the maximum will be £2,500.” And she told Radio Lancashire: “This is why we’ve taken action to make sure people’s bills are no more than £2,500.”"

Truss definitely gave lots of misleading statements in these interviews, and the "nobody will pay more than £2,500" is downright abysmal.

The correct terminology is Typical Domestic Consumption Values (TDCV) and they are set by Ofgem. These are for gas/electricity in kWh:
Low - 8,000/1,900
Medium -12,000/2,900
High - 17,000/4,600

You have also fell into the trap of calling these "average" - they are not - they are "typical" (Truss was actually correct when she used this term). Their real and original purpose was mainly to use for comparisons between energy suppliers.

You have also made the error of saying "By the laws of maths, half of people will pay more than the average" when it is the median that half would pay more than - the average (mean) could be higher or lower than the median (although it was actually median bills that Ofgem used when deriving the TDCVs).

The table in the picture shows actual average (mean) consumption by region. Note that only 2 regions (London & North East) use less electricity than the typical medium user, and only 3 regions (London, North Walest & South West) use less gas than the typical medium user.

To worry that people think the price cap means unlimited energy
GobbolinoTheWitchesCat · 29/09/2022 16:24

IncompleteSenten · 29/09/2022 16:08

I'm starting to think they voted Truss in so that we'll be grateful to have Sunak in or Johnson back!

Yanbu
Truss is as much as a pawn in Tory party power plays as May was.

IncompleteSenten · 29/09/2022 16:08

I'm starting to think they voted Truss in so that we'll be grateful to have Sunak in or Johnson back!

Madcats · 29/09/2022 15:02

R4 repeated quite a few soundbites from the local radio interviews (and I probably listened to the rest on Twitter).

NOBODY CORRECTED HER

Where is Ofgem? Why aren't they doing anything?

Rosehugger · 29/09/2022 13:48

I was just coming on here to post about that. Most families are more than the average household of 2.4 people, and most will be paying more than £2,500.

If the PM doesn't understand it, god help anyone else.

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 29/09/2022 13:42

Yes Truss made that claim several times during her round of disastrous radio interviews this morning.

The PM is either a liar or a moron. Perhaps both.

NewBootsAndRanty · 29/09/2022 13:39

Jfc 🤦‍♀️

IncompleteSenten · 29/09/2022 12:05

Oh my god. That woman. 🤦 As if her cheese obsession isn't stupid enough.

Shortjanet · 29/09/2022 11:42

So just seen this in the guardian. Apparently Liz truss doesn't understand it either. Fantastic.

"Truss criticised for wrongly saying no household will pay more than £2,500 under energy price guarantee
In her interview round this morning Liz Truss sometimes gave the impression that her energy price guarantee will mean that no household will face a fuel bill of more than £2,500 a year.

That is not correct. Under the plan, unit prices are capped at a rate that means that the average household will pay no more than £2,500. But if you use more gas and electricity than average homes do, you will pay more. By the laws of maths, half of people will pay more than the average.

Some of the reporting on this probably has not been as clear as it should have been because headlines resist subtlety and making the point that average bills are notionally capped at £2,500 a year probably means more to people than explaining that unit prices are actually capped at 34.0p/kWh for electricity and 10.3p/kWh for gas.

In her interviews, when talking about the £2,500 figures, Truss mostly said it applied to a “typical” bill. (Typical is not the same as average, but never mind.)

But sometimes she said all bills would be capped at £2,500. She told Radio Leeds that people in West Yorkshire would not face energy bills of £6,000. She went on: “Through the energy price guarantee, the maximum will be £2,500.” And she told Radio Lancashire: “This is why we’ve taken action to make sure people’s bills are no more than £2,500.”"

OP posts:
alwaysmovingforwards · 12/09/2022 07:25

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

Yes I've always known what my deal rates are and how the utility bills are calculated.
It's a fundamental & very basic aspect of running home imo.
I assumed everyone did this - why would anyone choose to not understand things that affect them and live in ignorance?

But this thread really has open my eyes.

Madcats · 10/09/2022 13:34

"Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to".

I certainly did because it was at about this time last year that BP pulled the plug on our provider PurePlanet and our fixed rate deal got cancelled! I remember how shocked we were to discover we'd be paying £600/more per annum.

Little did we know what was to come.....

cakeorwine · 09/09/2022 07:53

Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to

So you didn't bother to see the cost of what you were paying for?

I presume you realised that the more energy you used, the more it would cost?

Or were you one of those people who assumed that because you paid the same amount by DD every month, it didn't matter how much you used because you had fixed?

justfiveminutes · 09/09/2022 06:08

This has been a huge news story for the past year. I didn't pay a lot of attention to how my energy bills were calculated before then, but it was not difficult to find the information and educate myself once I realised that I needed to. I am not surprised some people are still confused as wilful ignorance starts young and everybody expects to be spoonfed now.

BarbaraofSeville · 09/09/2022 03:50

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

I had a basic idea of the cost and the formula but there's never been any need to commit either to memory because its printed on the bill, literally 'showing their workings' to use a term that a maths teacher will be familiar with.

And I disagree that energy used to be 'too cheap to worry about' it's always been a significant bill for most people and has never been cheap as far as the planet is concerned.

DreamOfSilence · 08/09/2022 22:31

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 22:10

They should be reporting it as price capped per KWh

Not sure that will help. If people are unable to understand 'The price cap is £X for typical use' and not think to look at their own circumstances and how they might compare to an average or go off and read up about it, they're not going to understand 'A pence per unit for electricity plus B pence per day standing charge plus C pence per unit for gas plus D pence per day standing charge' so if you want to know how much it will cost each month all you have do is solve the equation

(XA + 365B + YC + 365D)/12 where X is the number of electric units you use each year and Y is the number of gas units you use.

There was someone on a thread earlier claiming that people were unable to multiply or divide by 4 to work out which bottle of milk was best value, so I'm not sure quoting kWh rates is going to help anyone who hasn't done the bit of reading behind what the price cap figure actually means. It's not a secret, Martin Lewis must have said it a million times on TV and radio in the last few months.

Wow. Did none of these people ever attend school?

cakeorwine · 08/09/2022 22:06

You don't even need to know how to convert m3 to KWH

You just need to look at your bill and see how much energy they think you have used - look at the readings, look at the conversion and you will see the KWH.

You need to know that each KWH will cost you a certain amount.
You need to know that you pay a daily standing charge.

And that's it.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 08/09/2022 22:02

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

No, you don't need to know the formula, you should be able to work it out and doing so is basic - that's my point.

No I didn't know the price / KWH or cap this time last year but that's irrelevant.

For what's it's worth, I still don't know the price per kWh... I'm happy to be able to work out my spend by knowing roughly how I compare to average and scaling from there.

If it comes to the time where I need a more accurate estimate then I'll dig out the actual costs / unit and standing charge and calculate it - without consulting my mum - simple 🤷‍♂️

cakeorwine · 08/09/2022 22:00

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

And it's on your gas bill.
And available on the internet

Someone with a First in Maths should be able to access that information.

Yes - in Oct 21, I was paying 3p per KWH.
It was clearly stated on my gas bill

When I signed up for my deal, I was told what the costs per KWH and the standing charge was

NewBootsAndRanty · 08/09/2022 21:59

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

I've known mine for years - money's been tight enough for me to have to.

cakeorwine · 08/09/2022 21:58

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:27

So you automatically knew the formula for how to work out your gas bill from reading your meter did you? 🙄
DD had no idea of her useage in kwh because she’s never had to think about it before she bought a house last year.

How do you think you work out your gas bill?

Gas is a bit more complicated as you have to convert from cubic metres / feet to KWH. This is on the bill.

If you know your KWH and you know the cost per KWH, then you can work out your gas bill.

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:55

You have to actually know the formula for the conversion in the 1st place, of course she can bloody work it out with the formula.

She’s got a First in Maths ffs.
Did YOU know what rate you were paying per kwh or what the price cap was this time last year because I certainly didn’t, energy was so cheap we didn’t need to.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 08/09/2022 21:45

BorgQueen · 08/09/2022 21:27

So you automatically knew the formula for how to work out your gas bill from reading your meter did you? 🙄
DD had no idea of her useage in kwh because she’s never had to think about it before she bought a house last year.

Kids have to learn simple algebra at school. Calculating a gas bill is simply that: very simple algebra with 2 variables...

1 - how many units of gas used

2 - duration covered by the gas bill

This is very very basic stuff.

Any teacher (not just a maths teacher) should be able to work this out.

It's frightening, if not shameful, that DD as a head of maths can't. I honestly fear for and pity the kids she's teaching, and I'm sorry if that's putting too fine a point on it