Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

an energy cap of 2500 - still double energy bills this winter?

183 replies

yih8979kh · 06/09/2022 20:39

The figure of 2500 a one possible energy cap has been doing the rounds on the media -www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-62801913. It's definitely better than 3500 but doesnt that still mean that our energy bills will be double this winter seeing as last winter's cap was 1200? We paid 180 per month last winter, will it be 360 this Dec? Yes, we get 67 pounds off or something but thats still quite a lot more per month than last year.

OP posts:
Zebedee55 · 07/09/2022 09:13

The new Business and Energy Secretary, Rees Mogg, wants to get back with starting fracking, nuclear power stations etc.

He's a climate change sceptic, and thinks cheap, independent fuel, including fossil fuels, is more worthwhile than "green" energy.

He intends to ignore NIMBYS.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jacob-reesmogg-energy-climate-change-b2161136.html

Leftbutcameback · 07/09/2022 09:13

Looks like details will be announced tomorrow so the most sensible thing to do is calculate your annual usage, and winter months usage, so you can do the maths when the actual unit and standing costs are announced (I expect the energy company websites will all go down with too many people looking to use the cost tools).

Personally I would prefer the standing charge to be reduced as this is effectively a tax - everyone pays it regardless of how poor they are and there is no opportunity for anyone to reduce it. As I understand it one reason it's gone up is because of the cost of failing companies which makes me furious - the regulator should have prevented that.

midgetastic · 07/09/2022 09:04

But it is also true that this approach penalises the less well off the most

They will send fuel costs rise significantly as a proportion of their spend whilst the rich will heat their swimming pools without a second glance

The people who use most will have least reason to reduce use ( which is desperately needed for both energy security and emissions)

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 09:03

MintJulia · 07/09/2022 08:59

Energy prices are set on the world market, so prices will be high until Russia stops holding their gas supplies to ransom or unless Opec agrees to pump more oil, which isn't in their economic interests and isn't good for the environment either.

So the govt can only do so much to ease the impact. The real answer is

  1. Use less. Insulate houses, adopt more frugal habits..
  2. Increase our renewables rapidly - solar and wind turbines
  3. Decide whether we accept nuclear long term or not.

I'd be a lot happier if there was scaled pricing, so the first amount, enough for heat and basics (light, cooking) are at a cheaper rate. Then a higher rate over a certain usage per month.

That way, there is a still a motivation for people to cut their usage, the debt the UK incurs is less, and people who insist on running tumble driers, hot tubs and swimming pools pay the world rate for their luxuries rather than expecting the rest of us to subsidise them.

Yes you put it well - I think there is appetite for nuclear but not sure whether it’s there on local nimby level

I’d be happy with that too re people who use over and above lower usage for those types of things to pay full price

Lincslady53 · 07/09/2022 09:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MintJulia · 07/09/2022 08:59

Energy prices are set on the world market, so prices will be high until Russia stops holding their gas supplies to ransom or unless Opec agrees to pump more oil, which isn't in their economic interests and isn't good for the environment either.

So the govt can only do so much to ease the impact. The real answer is

  1. Use less. Insulate houses, adopt more frugal habits..
  2. Increase our renewables rapidly - solar and wind turbines
  3. Decide whether we accept nuclear long term or not.

I'd be a lot happier if there was scaled pricing, so the first amount, enough for heat and basics (light, cooking) are at a cheaper rate. Then a higher rate over a certain usage per month.

That way, there is a still a motivation for people to cut their usage, the debt the UK incurs is less, and people who insist on running tumble driers, hot tubs and swimming pools pay the world rate for their luxuries rather than expecting the rest of us to subsidise them.

balalake · 07/09/2022 08:57

The rumoured level is still a very large increase from now or last winter. No doubt dressed up as a great improvement, but not. Probably being judged by the government as what they think they can get away with.

acrobatcaviar · 07/09/2022 08:55

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 08:14

@FreddyHG

The wealthy or larger energy users will be subsidized to for each unit of electricity so the largest users get more subsidy from the government. This policy is really stupid and simply penalises people who have done the right thing in preference to those who haven't.

And indeed this shows the massive flaw in this policy there is no incentive to use energy efficiently...

What are you talking about?

Have you misunderstood the energy price cap???

I think what FreddyHC is saying is that the unit price is capped, so those who use more UNITS see more benefit.

"Another man looking for detail is Paul Johnson, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, who says a straightforward bill freeze would be "very poorly targeted" as the "majority of the money will go to better off people who use more energy"."

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-62812442

Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 08:52

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 08:38

I mean… I would be either doffing my cap or tugging my forelock but ANYWAY..

i’m not entitled to the COL payments of £650 and I have no objection to that. There’s always someone richer than me in any given situation. They will proportionately pay higher costs by means of their lifestyle - bigger houses, higher bills, bigger families, huge food shop, larger cars, whopping tankfuls of petrol. They pay more vat, more income tax, if they own businesses they have no cap at all and pay tax there too plus the Employers NI for their staff.

if I were a Tory I’d have voted for Rishi, personally but he got a lot of hate just for being rich so now we have Liz Truss. He was hated for having a rich wife. An Indian wife, whose businesses are Indian who completely paid her tax in India.

I don’t hate what is perceived as this homogenous group of Rich People. Be nice if I was one but I do like their taxes rolling into the coffers.

Lol yes doff cap/tug forelock...need more coffee.

But the point here is the country should not be going into huge debt to help out the very wealthy.

People at the lower end need far more help than a doubling of bills, they simply cannot afford it, the wealthy pay far smaller amounts proportionately and therefore can..

What your really saying is the rich pay enough already, so lets help them out instead.

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 08:48

yih8979kh · 06/09/2022 21:59

I appreciate that double is better than quadruple, it's still quite a lot though for quite a few families especially if they get rid of the £400 for everyone or the additional for those in need and/or pensioners.

In addition, I am also concerned about the lack of discussion about shortages. In the EU there is a general discussion about cutting usage by 15% - Germany is certainly talking about it, Switzerland has asked every large employer/company to save 15% now. None of this is being talked about in the UK

Sorry just to understand (I’m not having a go) you want the government to reduce usage and bills to stay low?

In Germany fuel prices have gone up but some of the ways in which they are reducing consumption include one of the biggest landlords in the country having a max setting on heatings for all tenants. Another has limited showers to certain times of the day. So it is impacting individual German households. I think the British public would kick off about something like that.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/09/2022 08:44

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 08:14

@FreddyHG

The wealthy or larger energy users will be subsidized to for each unit of electricity so the largest users get more subsidy from the government. This policy is really stupid and simply penalises people who have done the right thing in preference to those who haven't.

And indeed this shows the massive flaw in this policy there is no incentive to use energy efficiently...

What are you talking about?

Have you misunderstood the energy price cap???

I'm shocked but I agree with Freddie

Have you misunderstood the energy price cap?

Findwen · 07/09/2022 08:41

For anyone struggling with following the cap, perhaps this will help.

For every bit of electricity you use, think of it as chocolate smarties. When you turn your kettle on, smarties are being burnt up.

For every bit of gas heated hot water you use in either your tap or heating, think of it as tics-tacs being burnt to cause the heated water.

You can burn as many smarties and tic-tacs as you like, what the Tories are doing is preventing the price of a single tic tac or smartie rising to an even higher value. The price of every tic-tac or smartie is being capped.... NOT the number you can take.

Burn more, pay more since you have taken more.

Lemonyfuckit · 07/09/2022 08:41

1dayatatime · 06/09/2022 22:00

@Alexandra2001

"Germany is capping the price for the average number of units most use, to low levels, anyone without good reason who goes above this, pays market rate & is taxing oil company profits.

& what happens when Putin is still in power in 18 months time and gas is still super high? Borrow another 130 billion??? this is Corbyn madness on steroids'!

Where is the money going to come from for NHS which will now have to get far more because inflation has gone from 3% to 10% plus?"

+++

Excellent post

Yes I agree.

And I bet they were banking on the fact that because everyone was so worried about bills quadrupling, now that they'll only be doubling, people are relieved and that will shut them all up for a bit....

SeptemberPumpkin · 07/09/2022 08:39

As Mrs Zelensky said we will pay in higher bills but they will also pay in causalities. Something to bear in mind when we're moaning

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 08:38

I mean… I would be either doffing my cap or tugging my forelock but ANYWAY..

i’m not entitled to the COL payments of £650 and I have no objection to that. There’s always someone richer than me in any given situation. They will proportionately pay higher costs by means of their lifestyle - bigger houses, higher bills, bigger families, huge food shop, larger cars, whopping tankfuls of petrol. They pay more vat, more income tax, if they own businesses they have no cap at all and pay tax there too plus the Employers NI for their staff.

if I were a Tory I’d have voted for Rishi, personally but he got a lot of hate just for being rich so now we have Liz Truss. He was hated for having a rich wife. An Indian wife, whose businesses are Indian who completely paid her tax in India.

I don’t hate what is perceived as this homogenous group of Rich People. Be nice if I was one but I do like their taxes rolling into the coffers.

Lemonyfuckit · 07/09/2022 08:29

Flapjacker48 · 06/09/2022 21:12

Get real - there has to be at least some reflection of the massive rises in gas prices. This rumoured package is already going to cost a fortune - time will tell if it will lead to (more) cuts to public services and tax rises.

Yeah but the other option would have been for the government not to make whole the energy companies, so rather than increasing the country's debt, I dunno, they make slightly less than their billion pounds of profit....just a thought.

Flapjacker48 · 07/09/2022 08:26

@BackT No it doesn't.

Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 08:24

the moaning seems to be that rich people can have more stuff. ‘‘Twas ever thus"

Well maybe its time to change that?

If the help was more targeted, we could borrow less and give you and others far more.

if Germany can offer more help to the less well off and for less money, despite a much larger population, then why can't we?

But instead, you re happy to doff your forelock and be thankful for the crumbs from your masters table.

cinnamonbiscuit · 07/09/2022 08:22

It was reported in a newspaper (possibly telegraph?) this morning that the £400 will remain.

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 08:17

If the price cap comes to pass at £2,500 AND we still get the £400, I’m going to be very grateful for that. I was planning a winter of no heating at all (logburner) but with this I could put it on for an hour in the mornings. The £67 pcm was already helpful. People moaned that “the rich are getting £400 too” but it was fairest to give to all. I’ve had my £150 council tax rebate which I put aside for energy bills and my boomer parents didn’t but they pay more tax than me so they should get £400 in my book.

I can’t pare my use down any more than I do already.

while some may feel that it’s too much as the £400 gives out more than the increase of the cap, it isn’t just energy bills that have risen a lot. Food and petrol have too, so any savings on energy can be diverted towards that.

the moaning seems to be that rich people can have more stuff. ‘‘Twas ever thus.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/09/2022 08:15

£2500 is still more than double the 2021 average and fuck knows how much it will cost the public in the long run.

The whole mess has been caused by tory ineptitude over energy infrastructure and security but instead of the people holding them responsible and enforcing change we'll now see many thanking them for giving them a shitty little crumb.

But it follows a classic tory strategy. Privatise a national asset for a nominal fee, allow serious under investment into infrastructure/services and shareholders to extract as much profit as possible until the point of failure, bail the now private asset out with public money (ensuring shareholders get a last hurrah), rinse and repeat.

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 08:14

@FreddyHG

The wealthy or larger energy users will be subsidized to for each unit of electricity so the largest users get more subsidy from the government. This policy is really stupid and simply penalises people who have done the right thing in preference to those who haven't.

And indeed this shows the massive flaw in this policy there is no incentive to use energy efficiently...

What are you talking about?

Have you misunderstood the energy price cap???

Luckydip1 · 07/09/2022 08:11

At the end of the day we have to pay for the increases. This way we pay part of the increases now and the rest down the road. It makes sense.

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 08:10

We’ll still reduce usage but I’m sure some will be happy to have heating on for a couple of hours rather than none at all

Plus businesses not going bust

We’ll pay just over longer - if details are confirmed

cakeorwine · 07/09/2022 08:06

We are going to have high gas prices for a long time - if you compare them to a few years ago.

I wonder how long this intervention can go on for