Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

an energy cap of 2500 - still double energy bills this winter?

183 replies

yih8979kh · 06/09/2022 20:39

The figure of 2500 a one possible energy cap has been doing the rounds on the media -www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-62801913. It's definitely better than 3500 but doesnt that still mean that our energy bills will be double this winter seeing as last winter's cap was 1200? We paid 180 per month last winter, will it be 360 this Dec? Yes, we get 67 pounds off or something but thats still quite a lot more per month than last year.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JS87 · 07/09/2022 13:19

How would a tiered system work? Do you need a smart meter? If you meter is only read every six months how do they calculate daily usage? What about pre-payment meters? I think unfortunately it is too difficult to implement although what be interested to see how Germany will do it.

1dayatatime · 07/09/2022 12:48

Truss economics seems to be
Spend more
Cut taxes
Increase debt

This will inevitably lead to higher inflation and higher interest rates and is economic madness.

Robin233 · 07/09/2022 12:36

Everything I've read - so far says we all get the £400'- spread oct to mar and it's free ( not ti pay back)
And there will be additional money for low income people
Unit prices will be frozen - so bills have only doubled not x 3 or x 4

  • (which is better than we could have hoped)
Businesses will get help - And there are big plans to invest in energy making us more independent (from foreign imports ) Which is the way forward
Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 12:15

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 11:10

If someone can afford to pay a lot of money to have heating on as much as they need to keep their family comfortable and Gos forbid a hot tub, then good for them. Let them cough up. This seems like total bitterness at other people’s differing fortunes. Is this what the left is becoming? Drag everyone down to our level (my level maybe?).

I think everyone being treated equally is a good thing. Everyone who cuts back pays less, everyone who can afford to use more and pay more does.

So much resentment for other people NOT being up Shit Creek is so unpleasant to read. The poorest should be helped the most, but the focus is on tearing down the rich. Crab-in-bucket-like.

Its not about "punishing" the rich or being jealous of success, since 2015, the numbers of millionaires in this country has gone from 800k to 2.5m.. and good for them but they need to pay now we are in at the very least, an economic war with Russia.

If the wealthy do not pay a larger proportion of their wealth toward energy, then the poor will be paying the difference for decades to come, both in cash terms and in poorer public services esp health and education BUT will still face a completely unaffordable doubling in energy costs.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/09/2022 11:59

I think everyone being treated equally is a good thing. Everyone who cuts back pays less, everyone who can afford to use more and pay more does.

But that isn't what is happening, everyone that can't afford it will have no choice but to cut back, those that can afford the increase continue to spunk energy wherever they pleased at a discounted rate.
The discount is paid back by everyone else, including those who are very frugal with their energy use.

If you think I'm resentful of people not being up shit creek you are wrong. I'm resentful that the nation will be paying for people's energy that are wasting it/financially sound.

Personally short term this plan will benefit me financially but long term and for the country and the majority it is fucking nuts. It is not helping where it is needed.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/09/2022 11:30

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 11:10

If someone can afford to pay a lot of money to have heating on as much as they need to keep their family comfortable and Gos forbid a hot tub, then good for them. Let them cough up. This seems like total bitterness at other people’s differing fortunes. Is this what the left is becoming? Drag everyone down to our level (my level maybe?).

I think everyone being treated equally is a good thing. Everyone who cuts back pays less, everyone who can afford to use more and pay more does.

So much resentment for other people NOT being up Shit Creek is so unpleasant to read. The poorest should be helped the most, but the focus is on tearing down the rich. Crab-in-bucket-like.

The rich are not in our bucket and never will be. The rich own the bucket.

Remember you are significantly closer to being homeless and destitute than you ever will be to becoming a billionaire or multi-millionaire. Stop glorifying our oppressors and start fighting back.

An energy system where some can afford to run hot tubs/swimming pools/wine cellars, heat their homes to 24 degrees 24/7 while others go cold and hungry because they can't afford to turn their heating or oven on is a broken system. We need to make the system and society as a whole more equitable not more equal.

That you support people wasting energy simply because they can is morally reprehensible imo.

WeepingSomnambulist · 07/09/2022 11:29

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 11:10

If someone can afford to pay a lot of money to have heating on as much as they need to keep their family comfortable and Gos forbid a hot tub, then good for them. Let them cough up. This seems like total bitterness at other people’s differing fortunes. Is this what the left is becoming? Drag everyone down to our level (my level maybe?).

I think everyone being treated equally is a good thing. Everyone who cuts back pays less, everyone who can afford to use more and pay more does.

So much resentment for other people NOT being up Shit Creek is so unpleasant to read. The poorest should be helped the most, but the focus is on tearing down the rich. Crab-in-bucket-like.

The fact is, this deal fucks the country for a long time. It costs so much and we all need to pay it back eventually through tax or austerity, public service cuts etc.

It makes no sense to have a blanket cap. Just like it makes no sense to have a blanket tax rate.

The capped price should apple to what.. the first 15 units a day (example figure pulled from nowhere but you get the point). Then any power you use after that gets paid for at the full price.

It would ease the burden for those who really need it, and discount the burden for those with larger homes and higher incomes. It saves the taxpayer from subsidising the wealthy and lowers the debt the country is getting into.

GertrudeOHara · 07/09/2022 11:10

If someone can afford to pay a lot of money to have heating on as much as they need to keep their family comfortable and Gos forbid a hot tub, then good for them. Let them cough up. This seems like total bitterness at other people’s differing fortunes. Is this what the left is becoming? Drag everyone down to our level (my level maybe?).

I think everyone being treated equally is a good thing. Everyone who cuts back pays less, everyone who can afford to use more and pay more does.

So much resentment for other people NOT being up Shit Creek is so unpleasant to read. The poorest should be helped the most, but the focus is on tearing down the rich. Crab-in-bucket-like.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/09/2022 10:56

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 10:41

See my worked example the more energy one uses the greater the subsidy as it is biased to per kWh unit price. Those who have the heating on the highest will get the biggest subsidy. It's really not difficult to understand.

This plans subsidises hot tubs, swimming pools, people who use tumble dryers when it is 30°C outside, it subsides houses that are festooned with Christmas lights, it subsidises houses that have the heating on at 25 and leave the windows open.
Does that sound like a good idea?

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 10:56

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 10:41

See my worked example the more energy one uses the greater the subsidy as it is biased to per kWh unit price. Those who have the heating on the highest will get the biggest subsidy. It's really not difficult to understand.

It still doesn't mean there's "no incentive to use less energy", does it.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 10:41

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 10:21

@FreddyHG Just to add the "No incentive to use energy efficiently" also makes no sense unless you think that the wealthy won't be paying more, too.

See my worked example the more energy one uses the greater the subsidy as it is biased to per kWh unit price. Those who have the heating on the highest will get the biggest subsidy. It's really not difficult to understand.

Aposterhasnoname · 07/09/2022 10:40

StarDolphins · 06/09/2022 21:23

Does this mean that for £208 pm we can all have our heating/dryer on all day if we want?

my current usage is £2 per day & I was offered fixed rate of £166 so this won’t benefit me. I actually don’t want to be paying £2590 per year.

tgis is only going to benefit the rich in the 5-6 bedroom houses that would’ve spent that & more anyway.

🤦‍♀️

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 10:38

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 10:19

@FreddyHG

No you seem obviously confused like many on here.

No. I'm not confused about the cap - far from it - in fact if you scroll back to last night's posts you'll see my detailed one about our new energy bill which takes into account the October cap raise.

My point was, you're talking about people being "penalised for doing the right thing".

The only context in which that would be valid is if some people didn't benefit from the cap, which is not the case.

I don't benefit I am on a long term fix I freely chose in September last year which is well below the proposed price cap I paid an early exit fee because it was so obvious what was happening to energy prices (I also brought shell shares too using money I could have used as a holiday days out fund). So far as I see it I am being made to pay in the future for something I don't benefit from all because the masses were unable to see the obvious problems coming cheered on by Martin Lewis telling people not to take out fixes.

midgetastic · 07/09/2022 10:33

They pay more but they don't notice the cost so have no incentive uk reduce usage

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 10:21

@FreddyHG Just to add the "No incentive to use energy efficiently" also makes no sense unless you think that the wealthy won't be paying more, too.

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 10:19

@FreddyHG

No you seem obviously confused like many on here.

No. I'm not confused about the cap - far from it - in fact if you scroll back to last night's posts you'll see my detailed one about our new energy bill which takes into account the October cap raise.

My point was, you're talking about people being "penalised for doing the right thing".

The only context in which that would be valid is if some people didn't benefit from the cap, which is not the case.

Robin233 · 07/09/2022 09:55

@Silverpossum

"I'm at peace with it as it could be a lot lot worse. I appreciate it will be really really rough for a lot of families though."

^^^
I agree
And we will get the £400
This way I can still help others where possible

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/09/2022 09:49

Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 09:17

FGS

Where fuck did i say that energy costs are capped at 2.5k? i'm well aware its unit cap

The point is, people at the bottom will be paying proportionately far more than the wealthy, who can afford more but are being given an inflation rising handout instead.

As for the argument on inflation, thats rubbish, the £ is and will fall on the back of unaffordable borrowing, that means imported inflation and what happens when in 18 months time, gas is still super hi? what then?

The markets have no faith in this policy and its not one any european country is doing, plus we need extra spending on health and defence due to the UK having the highest inflation in the G7.

I did chuckle about Lincs calling you thick.

Price cap on all units regardless of how many you use is, as another poster put, 'Gordon Brown policy on speed.'

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 07/09/2022 09:38

I think that it has to be high to ensure people cut their usage. Too many people think it is ok to wear t-shirts at home and have the heating on full.

Hopefully, the people who really need it will get targeted help as well.

Mumtofourandnomore · 07/09/2022 09:30

The new price cap comes in on 1 October - that’s just over three weeks away. The new government policy has to be really straightforward in order to implement it so quickly - hence a one size fits all ‘freeze’ (at least for customers on a capped tariff, business is more complicated I suspect as there isn’t a capped tariff already).

I agree that some kind of tiered tariff would be fairer, but given that the £400 scheme is horrendously complicated for suppliers to implement and has taken months, a much larger scheme needs, at this point in time, to be ‘simple’ in order to benefit people quickly.

I guess the structure and the standing charges will be reviewed in due course.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 09:23

If they just subsidised the standing charge and kept the unit rate the same as the market rate I would be happier but it seems from the maths the subsidy is more tilted towards higher usage houses

But unless you use pretty much no energy at all, the standing charge is a small percentage of the annual bill. At the current price cap, it's a little over 10%.

If they did what you're suggesting, then it would knock a couple of hundred pounds at most off a £5k pa+ bill that would still destroy the finances of average income households in 2-3 bed properties using a typical amount of energy.

On the matter of profit, this is due to increased global demand for a finite and reducing supply of energy. The companies who we as householders buy our energy from are not making much, if any profit at all, it's under £50 a year. They could sell us energy at cost, and it would barely change the size of our bills.

They do need a windfall tax on the global mega corps who extract and produce the energy, but that's a separate issue.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 09:17

Leftbutcameback · 07/09/2022 09:13

Looks like details will be announced tomorrow so the most sensible thing to do is calculate your annual usage, and winter months usage, so you can do the maths when the actual unit and standing costs are announced (I expect the energy company websites will all go down with too many people looking to use the cost tools).

Personally I would prefer the standing charge to be reduced as this is effectively a tax - everyone pays it regardless of how poor they are and there is no opportunity for anyone to reduce it. As I understand it one reason it's gone up is because of the cost of failing companies which makes me furious - the regulator should have prevented that.

Indeed about the regulator people cheered these non big size challenger companies when they came out but their business model was nuts. People like Martin Lewis need to take the blame here for how they pressured in my opinion the regulator to allow these companies to enter the market in the first place.

Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 09:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FGS

Where fuck did i say that energy costs are capped at 2.5k? i'm well aware its unit cap

The point is, people at the bottom will be paying proportionately far more than the wealthy, who can afford more but are being given an inflation rising handout instead.

As for the argument on inflation, thats rubbish, the £ is and will fall on the back of unaffordable borrowing, that means imported inflation and what happens when in 18 months time, gas is still super hi? what then?

The markets have no faith in this policy and its not one any european country is doing, plus we need extra spending on health and defence due to the UK having the highest inflation in the G7.

Bunnyfuller · 07/09/2022 09:15

This strategy protects the shareholder. Liz should be piling into the record profits of the energy companies, and getting the help for the householder from there, and not just borrowing from our money to keep them raking in profits

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 09:14

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 08:14

@FreddyHG

The wealthy or larger energy users will be subsidized to for each unit of electricity so the largest users get more subsidy from the government. This policy is really stupid and simply penalises people who have done the right thing in preference to those who haven't.

And indeed this shows the massive flaw in this policy there is no incentive to use energy efficiently...

What are you talking about?

Have you misunderstood the energy price cap???

No you seem obviously confused like many on here. The cap isn't a cap it is a average household price should not exceed given an average use of units. Each unit is being subsidised so if wholesale costs are 60p and the unit rate I pay is 40p then each unit the government pays 20p to subsidise. Someone who uses 4000 units a year gets a £800 subsidy someone who uses 16000 units a year gets £3200 subsidy. If they just subsidised the standing charge and kept the unit rate the same as the market rate I would be happier but it seems from the maths the subsidy is more tilted towards higher usage houses.