Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extremely rude doctor

307 replies

Picturesintheclouds08 · 06/09/2022 16:45

This is more of a vent than anything else.

In my GP practice you don't get a face to face, you get a phone call then a face to face if deemed necessary. That's fine, no issue with that.

You have to state what you are calling for to the receptionist so I stated stomach issues and period problems.

The doctor calls and asks how he can help.

I begin saying - I'm calling for Two things that may or may not be related.. one is a pain in my stomach, one is period pains.. he cuts me off right there and says .. I don't have time for a list of issues.

What's your stomach pain he asks - dull ache, coming and going, few centimeters to the right and below belly button, been going on few weeks. He says - it's just your bowels, it is very normal. I question that - I'm 36, never had this pain before.

Then I say - about my period - he goes - I don't have time to be talking about periods and all that, quickly give me the highlights. I could not believe the rudeness of him. Highlights - 12 days between a period, sometimes 7 weeks, extremely painful through to my back and bum - cannot physically move, blood clots, very heavy, would consider a hysterectomy it is that bad. (Took me about 30 seconds to give him that run down) Ok he says, i dont have time to deal with this today and you need to call back another day for a new appointment and request a female doctor.

I was gobsmacked at his rudeness. The phone call lasted under 5 mins. I understand they are under alot of pressure but his rudeness was terrible. I didn't realise you couldn't talk about 2 issues (that may be related) at the same appointment.

OP posts:
Percypigfanatic · 07/09/2022 06:45

Previous, not precious 😊

Percypigfanatic · 07/09/2022 06:44

Op I don’t think you need a female doctor, my precious female doctor was very dismissive of any ailment I had (including periods) and made me reluctant to tell her anything. You just need a doctor (of any gender) who will listen. Complain to your gp practice and ask to see someone who will listen rather than dismiss - whoever they arrange for you to talk to will be told of your experience beforehand as they won’t want any issues.

AgeingDoc · 06/09/2022 23:10

Not my field, and I appreciate that GPs work differently and have different pressures that I haven't experienced, but I don't think this sounds acceptable.
If, after initial triage, the doctor thought another colleague was more suitable to see you then fair enough but it could have been handled so much better. If he'd said something like "Dr Bloggs is one of my colleagues with an interest in gynaecological issues so please ring Reception and tell them I've recommended you make an appointment to see her" that would have been ok I think. The same outcome could have been reached in a much better way.
I also completely understand the policy of one issue per appointment, but it's designed to prevent people coming in with a long list of unrelated issues which can't realistically be dealt with in one consultation, not situations like this. I don't think you were at all unreasonable to wonder if the issues are connected and to bring them up together.
I would make an appointment with a female doctor as suggested but I also think it would be perfectly reasonable of you to complain. There should be a complaints process outlined on the practice website letting you know how to do it.
My only experience with complaints processes is in hospital so it might be different in General Practice but my advice would be to send emails if possible rather than write or phone. Keep a copy if you write on paper though. Keep things fairly concise and factual - bullet points are good. I used to deal with complaints when I was head of dept and actually I used to appreciate reasonable complaints as they can help bring about real change.
I hope you get a satisfactory outcome, both with the complaint and your health.

MibsXX · 06/09/2022 23:06

Picturesintheclouds08 · 06/09/2022 16:45

This is more of a vent than anything else.

In my GP practice you don't get a face to face, you get a phone call then a face to face if deemed necessary. That's fine, no issue with that.

You have to state what you are calling for to the receptionist so I stated stomach issues and period problems.

The doctor calls and asks how he can help.

I begin saying - I'm calling for Two things that may or may not be related.. one is a pain in my stomach, one is period pains.. he cuts me off right there and says .. I don't have time for a list of issues.

What's your stomach pain he asks - dull ache, coming and going, few centimeters to the right and below belly button, been going on few weeks. He says - it's just your bowels, it is very normal. I question that - I'm 36, never had this pain before.

Then I say - about my period - he goes - I don't have time to be talking about periods and all that, quickly give me the highlights. I could not believe the rudeness of him. Highlights - 12 days between a period, sometimes 7 weeks, extremely painful through to my back and bum - cannot physically move, blood clots, very heavy, would consider a hysterectomy it is that bad. (Took me about 30 seconds to give him that run down) Ok he says, i dont have time to deal with this today and you need to call back another day for a new appointment and request a female doctor.

I was gobsmacked at his rudeness. The phone call lasted under 5 mins. I understand they are under alot of pressure but his rudeness was terrible. I didn't realise you couldn't talk about 2 issues (that may be related) at the same appointment.

My mum died of bowel cancer because the docs downplayed her symptoms...

eastegg · 06/09/2022 23:02

Zebedee999 · 06/09/2022 17:17

I've heard several times that doctors don't like people turning up with a list of issues. I do this myself as I have various grumbles but don't want to waste their time. It seems more time efficient if I can rattle through my issues quickly in one go than having multiple slots. I still stick with the 4 minute window or whatever it is you get as I rattle through them quickly.

is this a thing that you shouldn't cover more than one thing in an appointment?

It is a thing, but obviously any GP who isn’t a total idiot will not use it as a blunt instrument and effectively say ‘now quickly tell me about this pain but without telling me about any other painful issue you’re having in the same general part of your body unless it’s definitely connected to the first’.

How awful OP.

Percypigfanatic · 06/09/2022 22:47

@Picturesintheclouds08 I am in the same boat where I’m considering hysterectomy. I was put on progesterone only pills after the birth of my daughter to stop periods completely but the doctor explained over the phone that sometimes if you don’t have periods at all the membrane can build up and attach to your organs (sorry if TMI) and that’s what he wants to investigate. My last doctor told me I didn’t need periods at all and the pills should stop all the pain but I don’t think it’s resolved the issue just masked it !?! Almost feels like whatever it is is pressing on my other organs so it’s hurts when I go to the toilet. He agreed it can be all connected.

Hope you get taken seriously asap I feel for you and agree the pain sometimes is horrendous. I said to my doctor I’m fed up with having to spend days in bed if I have a period. I also don’t want to mask the issue, I would like to know what’s going on so we can sort it out. Good luck OP keep us updated

Cupofteaonesugar · 06/09/2022 22:41

That sounds absolutely horrendous.
I'm not interested in "the nhs is in its knees" "health care is stressed" "doctors are tired" excuses. We are all people and in and out of work know fine well how to speak respectfully and empathetically. If this doctor cannot do that then they need their employment looking at!
Please register this as a complaint. If my mum for example had had this service she would be so devastated and it would have a massive effect on her. There will be many more liek my mum who no doubt spoke to this gp too!
Hope you're ok after that appointment! Absolutely not ok!!!

TabithaTittlemouse · 06/09/2022 22:36

RatherBeRiding · 06/09/2022 16:49

That does sound extremely rude and dismissive. However, with GP services being stretched to the absolute limit I doubt a complaint to the practice would achieve very much. I'd be inclined to book another appointment with a different doctor, and if you don't get any joy with that, look at changing to a different practice.

All services are overstretched, some of us try to remain polite and caring.
I might start telling my patients that they can only have one delusional belief a day because I don’t have time for all of them.
They can be stressed or depressed but not both.

Judijudi · 06/09/2022 22:29

Our practice is one issue per appointment too. Not ideal but understandable seeing as they are allocated about 5 mins per appointment. He sounds like an arse but don’t waste your energy on him!

Qwertyyui · 06/09/2022 22:29

I have the same symptoms with my bowel area. It's been 8 weeks now. After 3 I saw my doctor. She thought maybe my apendix so off to a&e with a letter. Was scanned and bloods done. Was assured not my appendix and was told some fluid in my abdomen they are not sure where it has come from though as no sign of cysts. Was told to wait a few weeks as it might go away. Last week it was still there. My doctor ordered a fit poop test to check for blood and a repeat scan. Then my doctors texted to say there is another test they want to do and to drop off another sample. Once the results are back they will book me in and see where they go from there. I have a history of bowel issues in my family and I won't be fobbed off. I will push for every test and to be fair they are supportive of that. I am 37 I cannot spend every day feeling sick when I eat and in pain when I move too much! Push for everything life is too precious to take them saying no!

Ireolu · 06/09/2022 22:20

Phonecalls* even

Ireolu · 06/09/2022 22:20

Phonecards r recorded and so there will be proof of this interaction. You shd complain. Practice Manager will listen to the call and determine what to do next.

AchatAVendre · 06/09/2022 22:09

One issue per appointment, or on symptom? How is a patient meant to distinguish between an issue or a symptom, without self diagnosing their issue first?

A crazy policy which potentially rules out just about every medical condition in existence.

Can you imagine trying to describe your Covid symptoms? "Well, doctor, I have a headache and ---" GP: "I'll have to stop you right there. One issue per appointment".

Obviously, doctors use common sense but for the few that don't, the potential for mistakes is high.

warriorathena · 06/09/2022 22:03

There are arseholes in all walks of life. Medicine is no exception. His blatant misogyny is baffling and needs reporting. His request for one issue per appointment isn't unusual though. Agree with others that it is difficult for patients to know which symptoms are related or not. Either way, the right thing to do is to complain to the practice manager in the hope he will treat future patients in a more professional manner.

AnnaMagnani · 06/09/2022 22:00

@BlodynGwyn are you not in the UK?

Because here nobody (unless paying privately) has their own personal gynaecologist they go direct to for any female health issue.

You start with your GP.

bringincrazyback · 06/09/2022 21:54

BlodynGwyn · 06/09/2022 21:41

You should see your gynecologist for women's reproductive issues. I'd never ever talk to my GP about something like that.

@BlodynGwyn You're on a wind-up, right? Why on earth wouldn't you talk to a GP about this??

OP, he sounds shocking, not rtft but I think I read that you were going to report him - good. He sounds awful, very much like a rude male GP at the practice I attend, unfortunately.

Lovvy67 · 06/09/2022 21:45

It really fucks me off when women get fobbed off about issues relating to our period.

"It's just periods, nothing to worry about"

Yes, we know what a period is thanks, we've been having them most of our lives, therefore we're perfectly capable of realising when something isn't right with the cycles we've been having again, most of our lives.

My period went biserk after my last baby, previously non existent PMS developed into PMDD, feeling a bit grumpy on the first day of my period morphed into feeling physically ill for two weeks out of every 4.

"Just periods" oh sod off.

I'm really sorry you were treat this way OP. Please do make a formal complaint. He shouldn't be in the job with an attitude like that and such disdain for his patients.

Picturesintheclouds08 · 06/09/2022 21:44

BlodynGwyn · 06/09/2022 21:41

You should see your gynecologist for women's reproductive issues. I'd never ever talk to my GP about something like that.

@BlodynGwyn My gynecologist?? I don't have a personal gynecologist.. 😕 You go to the GP who then refers you, if they don't dismiss you that is.

OP posts:
Lipsandlashes · 06/09/2022 21:43

BlodynGwyn · 06/09/2022 21:41

You should see your gynecologist for women's reproductive issues. I'd never ever talk to my GP about something like that.

Are you bloody serious?

BlodynGwyn · 06/09/2022 21:41

You should see your gynecologist for women's reproductive issues. I'd never ever talk to my GP about something like that.

Slicacakeandacuppatea · 06/09/2022 21:41

Just to add- I don’t think it is necessarily 2 problems. Causes of stomach pain in a woman could be related to periods and especially if irregular should be asked assessed as part of the original problem!

I don’t think it’s unreasonable at all to discuss both in one session.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 06/09/2022 21:37

BakersYeast · 06/09/2022 20:26

It is standard that you do not discuss more than one appointment in one slot. You are told to book two.

Not at my practice. What an outrageous waste of time and NHS money!

Facecream · 06/09/2022 21:35

Whatever you do don’t waste your time with the GMC… utter waste of space

Slicacakeandacuppatea · 06/09/2022 21:35

Irregular, heavy periods with abdominal pain should have a minimum of bloods (including full blood count to rule out anaemia and hormone levels to look for polycystic ovaries) and an ultrasound to look for eg fibroids

it makes me so angry when male doctors dismiss period problems and let people suffer. This guy just sounds like an all round dick but please do advocate for yourself at your next appointment.

and I agree… you should complain so he’s held to account (I would be requesting at the least an apology, how dare he be so dismissive?!)

Picturesintheclouds08 · 06/09/2022 21:33

BakersYeast · 06/09/2022 21:25

You are complaining about them asking how they can "help"?

@BakersYeast God out of the whole thread that's the bit you pick out - my answer to a pp based on their dislike. It's a dislike, not a complaint.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread