Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When poverty comes in the door, loves goes out the window

93 replies

Slowdaysfastyears · 06/09/2022 15:36

Do you agree?

I always remember a friend of mine telling me that her mum had said this to her when she was young and for her to make sure she settles with someone who can provide (not necessarily rich) she said that with money struggles, life is so much harder and love dies. The mum herself has been married for years to a lovely man with a nice amount of money, nice house, she’s never worked..but not rich. Her daughter, my friend has followed a similar path..my friend is lovely, but has always been materialistic and money minded..she has worked in the past and has a degree etc though, unlike her mum.
Do you agree with this view or that her mum saying this to her as a child is damaging? Her grandmother said the same to her too.
Is there any harm in hoping or advising our children to marry *Well?

OP posts:
Ilovelindor · 06/09/2022 18:05

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 16:08

I disagree with this and if anyone tried to say similar to my daughters they'd be getting it in the ear from me

Sexist crap

Girls should be empowered to create their own financial security

Not rely on others for that

Exactly what I was going to say.

onthefencesitter · 06/09/2022 18:02

felulageller · 06/09/2022 17:42

I was going to also mention looking at their family and the likelihood of help for deposits/ private school fees but my post was already quite long!

All the women in my family, for generations have 'married down'.

It's been disastrous. Family money squandered by alcoholics, cocklodgers, the workshy, etc.

Yes encourage women to be independent. But not many women will ever earn enough to always work full time, pay full time childcare and have their own mortgage on a decent house in a decent area. It's not a very realistic plan unless the family already has money.

Picking a life partner who can pay their own way, not run up debts, contribute fairly to the family budget etc is the most important decision of a person's life.

I fu**ed up and I'd do anything to shake some sense into me as a young adult.

well I hope my DH wasn't looking at my family's money when he married me.

I love my DH but I would be so embarrassed if something happened down the line and the house my parents bought for me outright became classed as 'marital assets' in a divorce and he walked away with half! My parents would be really really angry if that happened. at least now our flat was bought with our joint savings so if anything happens; well we saved it together (albeit with 3 years of rent free living with his mum, but its not as easy to quantify that; plus we will probably support her in her old age) !

So have to add in parents who are ok with giving house deposits even if at least half of it may end up in the spouse's pocket. quite a lot of British parents seem fine with it but you may marry into a family who wouldn't be.

Summerfun54321 · 06/09/2022 17:57

If you’ve experienced true poverty growing up then of course you’ll guide your children away from it.

Oysterbabe · 06/09/2022 17:49

I wouldn't have married someone skint with no career prospects. I carried an ex financially and it was awful. I was definitely on the look out for someone on an equal footing.

latetothefisting · 06/09/2022 17:46

Depends what rich and poor mean - back x amount of years ago when poverty meant actual grinding horrendous whole family in 1 room with rickets, unable to feed your kids then yes, I think anyone would struggle to be happy in those conditions even if you had married for love. If, often, nowadays, it means married to someone you don't like but able to buy designer stuff and go on foreign holidays versus in love but counting the pennies, I'd go for the second.

Plus these sayings originated and were popular in a time where woman had no real option to be financially secure other than to marry, so who you married, and their financial status was literally the most important decision you would ever make in your life, and, once made, you'd struggle to get out of. So they are generally irrelevant now where the stress should be on being able to financially support yourself in order to be happy/comfortable. In which case the advice should centre more on getting qualifications and choosing a job that will allow you to live comfortably rather than a career you love but pays badly.

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 17:43

My mum always told me not to rely on a man for money. Happy with that advice. I would have a different lifestyle if single (so would OH) but my money, my choice. I wouldn't ever want to feel I had to stay with someone for any reason, including their money, or ask anyone for permission to spend money.

felulageller · 06/09/2022 17:42

I was going to also mention looking at their family and the likelihood of help for deposits/ private school fees but my post was already quite long!

All the women in my family, for generations have 'married down'.

It's been disastrous. Family money squandered by alcoholics, cocklodgers, the workshy, etc.

Yes encourage women to be independent. But not many women will ever earn enough to always work full time, pay full time childcare and have their own mortgage on a decent house in a decent area. It's not a very realistic plan unless the family already has money.

Picking a life partner who can pay their own way, not run up debts, contribute fairly to the family budget etc is the most important decision of a person's life.

I fu**ed up and I'd do anything to shake some sense into me as a young adult.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 17:23

I disagree. Any able-bodied adult should make sure they can provide for themselves. Plus that if they marry someone they have similar attitudes towards money.

EveningOverRooftops · 06/09/2022 17:22

I think you need to find someone who matches your attitude to spending.

if you’re thrifty a spender might see you as tight etc.

you have to match on the important things

food, money, alcohol/drugs, attitudes to family life, parenting and sex.

everything else imo can be negotiated.

Nidan2Sandan · 06/09/2022 17:17

I grew up in severe poverty, and my parents marriage couldnt survive it.

DH have lived together through times of poverty and times of affluence and still madly in love. It's tough to be happy when money is tight, and DH has a tendency to be lax with money where as I am more controlled, but our love has always remained strong.

abovedecknotbelow · 06/09/2022 17:17

Being self sufficient is a hard lesson I learnt from my mother, who wasn't, and something I teach my daughters every day.

dworky · 06/09/2022 17:13

Well, that's clearly bullshit otherwise the rich would all be married or n a relationship for life & the poor would all be single.

onthefencesitter · 06/09/2022 17:07

ReneBumsWombats · 06/09/2022 16:49

Well surely it's always better to be happy than miserable! But it's easier to cry in a mansion etc etc....

I think there is some truth to the OP's statement in the sense that money worries put enormous stress on couples and can indeed cause things to end, even if they do love each other. I haven't had money worries since marrying my husband but I had them at one point in my life and it's not something you forget.

It depends also on when you have the money worries. I married at 22 and we had little money then (but never went hungry). But I knew at the back of my head it was temporary so we were still very happy. I was young enough to be optimistic!

I am in my late 20s but I know I will experience future recessions in my lifetime. the government is probably going to bail us out by freezing bills but for a few weeks, I was preparing myself to pay £10k energy bills. However, we may not be so lucky every time so I think going into marriage even with someone who is financially stable with the illusion that there would be zero money worries is a bit naive. If you look at many of the well paid professions, they often don't do well in recessions.

Lawyer- a lot of top law firms shed staff during recessions when there isn't as much commercial activity. A lot of high street firms also do the same due to higher overheads

IT developer- if you work for a startup, funding can dry up during a recession

Small business owner- energy bills are likely to be frozen for 6 months but if they weren't, a lot of businesses would have gone bust.

Banker/City worker- Banks often do retrench during recessions.

People with good salaries have savings but that doesn't mean an absence of money worries unless of course the man in question is independently wealthy (and even then he can be disinherited).

mackthepony · 06/09/2022 17:05

You could be absolutely stunningly beautiful, work hard at school but still only be on NMW for 40 years.

Or you could meet and marry a rich fella and never work

Thinkbiglittleone · 06/09/2022 17:01

I was taught to respect myself and only ever marry a man who respects and loves me.

But I do believe that when poverty strikes, the stress and sadness it brings is hard to survive, even with the strongest of couples.

I had also been advised my family
Always marry someone who loves you more than you love them Confused

Never marry a drinker or gambler - goes without saying

Always have your bus fare home - enough to get your own place if you want to Just walk.

pawkins · 06/09/2022 16:54

Crunchingleaf · 06/09/2022 16:14

The stress of poverty cannot be underestimated. It’s relentless and leaves no aspect of your life untouched. I don’t think love can survive it.
I would agree that marrying well is important, but what I mean by well is someone who respects money and savings. A big earner and spender who accumulated debts would be as bad to me as a lazy person who doesn’t bother work hard to bring home an income.

This.

ScurryfungeMaster · 06/09/2022 16:53

I think financial worries can have a negative impact on happiness and on relationships because money worries tend to bring with them a lot of stress and it's hard to focus on your relationship when you're riddled with stress and anxiety. I've been married for 10 years and there have been times in my marriage when we were completely broke and it was very stressful, but we became closer in those times and worked together to get through it.

At the moment things are relatively comfortable for us financially but we're not ''well off'' by any means. We share similar work ethics and values and I think that's the most important thing (for me). I wouldn't swap the love and support that my husband offers me in exchange for money but I can see why some people would look for a partner who is financially stable or even wealthy.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/09/2022 16:49

Justcallmebebes · 06/09/2022 15:44

My mother and grandmother both said this. They also said, "better to marry a rich man and be miserable in comfort than a poor man and be happy in poverty"

Not too sure I agree as I believe it's better to be financially independent, plough your own furrow and not have to depend on any man, rich or poor

Well surely it's always better to be happy than miserable! But it's easier to cry in a mansion etc etc....

I think there is some truth to the OP's statement in the sense that money worries put enormous stress on couples and can indeed cause things to end, even if they do love each other. I haven't had money worries since marrying my husband but I had them at one point in my life and it's not something you forget.

MsTSwift · 06/09/2022 16:49

Was never taught anything like that whatsoever - sounds dreadful. But then one of my grandmothers was the main breadwinner and did all the driving which in those days (they were born 1909) was seen as shocking!

We had it drummed into us that you marry someone who is kind clever and decent and then you are a team and you both help each other on. That’s what my parents and both sets of grandparents did and it’s the best way.

Crikeyblimey · 06/09/2022 16:46

My grandad always said ‘marry for love not money, but mind you love where there’s money’.

So pretty much translates as ‘don’t marry a cocklodger’.
we (many female siblings and I) were brought up to be self sufficient and always work / earn but also to be mindful not to throw our lot in with someone who wasn’t those things.

Mfsf · 06/09/2022 16:44

My reply to that is , when love goes away poverty arrives !
I will teach my kids to be independent. Teaching my daughter to depend on a partner is the worse advice I can think of .
I will teach her to stand on her own 2 feet so if she is ever in a relationship where she needs to leave or is left she is financially stable .
I can proudly say that if my partner left tomorrow all bills would be paid and I would be heartbroken but my kids would not need to go without . This should be a priority imo

allinatizzy · 06/09/2022 16:39

I chose a man I loved, one who came from a similar background (as far as family finances are concerned) and who shared my views of money management.

I'd advise people not to marry someone who is poorer than they are willing to be. Don't expect riches, but yes, it's okay to want a decent standard of living. If you choose someone and they experience financial difficulty through no fault of their own, that's life, and you should stick with them and make the best of it, but I wouldn't actively choose someone who was living in poverty or was too poor to have what I consider a normal life.

Money's not the most important thing or the only important thing, but it's important.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 06/09/2022 16:38

I say something similar to my daughter but I also tell her to get a good job herself so she has money but to try and marry someone that also has money as no one likes to be poor.

MoistBandana · 06/09/2022 16:30

I'd like to think that money wouldn't matter to me if I met the right person... But I don't think that's realistic.
Let's face it, a lot of women still expect men to pay for everything on dates and stuff and if he doesn't, they're told to dump him as he's cheap etc.

I don't think it's necessarily shallow for an adult to want someone stable and earning their way in life as a partner.
When you're a kid, a guy just needs nice trainers..or to upset your mum... 😂

SurfBox · 06/09/2022 16:26

If you read the post the advice was 'to settle for someone who can provide

Yes I did but that can be read as ensuring the partner earns enough, doesn't mean the woman can just give up work and live off him. She might have to work too.

Whilst people here might say marrying for money terrible advice I would agree to an extent but then my mind is swayed because I've seen umpteen threads on mn on this topic over the years. And many women who are middle aged and older said they wished they had married for money over love as they'd struggled for years financially, had no pensions, missed their kids childhoods as they always had to work etc and warned us never to marry for love...

I think it's all to easy here to diss out advice but unless you experienced the realities of poverty,financial hardships or excess workloads in a profession you detest we truly cannot understand why people say never marry for love.