Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When poverty comes in the door, loves goes out the window

93 replies

Slowdaysfastyears · 06/09/2022 15:36

Do you agree?

I always remember a friend of mine telling me that her mum had said this to her when she was young and for her to make sure she settles with someone who can provide (not necessarily rich) she said that with money struggles, life is so much harder and love dies. The mum herself has been married for years to a lovely man with a nice amount of money, nice house, she’s never worked..but not rich. Her daughter, my friend has followed a similar path..my friend is lovely, but has always been materialistic and money minded..she has worked in the past and has a degree etc though, unlike her mum.
Do you agree with this view or that her mum saying this to her as a child is damaging? Her grandmother said the same to her too.
Is there any harm in hoping or advising our children to marry *Well?

OP posts:
dockspider · 07/09/2022 09:13

I would say when reality of life be it illness, responsibilities,housework, children, difficulty conceiving etc comes in the door love often goes out the window in even the strongest of couples. It is far from limited to just poverty or financial difficulty.

Agree

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 09:13

Love can be more powerful and worth so much more than material things.
I would choose a poor life with my love and be fulfilled just being together with nothing but each other rather than a rich life with someone who I didn’t truly love.
Being poor doesn’t make love die

and have you ever been generally poor then? Or have you been a mother who can't afford to feed her kids and struggle with them?>

Because whilst your advice is all well meaning, it's pretty idealistic. The reality of poverty and I mean real poverty might counteract your principles there.

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 09:10

People who say there's more to life than money are people who have enough money

this, reminds me of the threads on mn where people say they'd hate to win the lotto or that money can't bring happiness and they don't need large amounts etc. Easy to say that coming from a point of privilege.

But then this happens on all topics on mn, posters weigh in with their advice and principles when they have no experience of the topic at hand.

Etak123 · 07/09/2022 03:21

Slowdaysfastyears · 06/09/2022 15:36

Do you agree?

I always remember a friend of mine telling me that her mum had said this to her when she was young and for her to make sure she settles with someone who can provide (not necessarily rich) she said that with money struggles, life is so much harder and love dies. The mum herself has been married for years to a lovely man with a nice amount of money, nice house, she’s never worked..but not rich. Her daughter, my friend has followed a similar path..my friend is lovely, but has always been materialistic and money minded..she has worked in the past and has a degree etc though, unlike her mum.
Do you agree with this view or that her mum saying this to her as a child is damaging? Her grandmother said the same to her too.
Is there any harm in hoping or advising our children to marry *Well?

I think lack of money obviously makes life much harder and causes lots of problems and other hardships but love outweighs all of that. As long as we have food and shelter we would have everything we need when we have love. Love can be more powerful and worth so much more than material things.
I would choose a poor life with my love and be fulfilled just being together with nothing but each other rather than a rich life with someone who I didn’t truly love.
Being poor doesn’t make love die, but love dies when one or both people stop trying or listening properly and lose each other x love and relationships need effort putting in, respect for each other and the desire to learn more about the other person and adapt and grow together otherwise they fall apart.

LangClegsInSpace · 07/09/2022 02:38

Poverty is very tough and it tests the mettle of individuals and relationships. Love does not necessarily go out the window but it often does because of the incredible stress of living in poverty.

But this is completely topsy-turvy. Better advice would be:

Sometimes love goes out the window. Make sure you plan for this and don't let poverty in the door.

Marrying a lovely man with a nice amount of money and never working is a high risk strategy. What happens if love goes out the window? Will you be plunged into poverty?

dalilicios · 07/09/2022 01:59

I agree with the statement that love goes out the window when you are poor but only if you've picked the wrong person and you are doing all the legwork etc. I don't agree with marry rich to be happy though. Just be with someone who has a similar mindset to you about life and what you want to achieve in life as if you are starting from scratch with no help. Study, work hard, be smart with your finances and find someone who is similar which is way more easier than finding a rich man. Me and dh had a similar mindset and we didn't have any help from anyone. We started life from scratch and built it together. Dh is very hardworking and is a natural go getter and I'm just a hard worker but we share the same values when it comes to things like this.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/09/2022 01:27

OnlyEverAutumn · 06/09/2022 22:25

What’s the female équipe of a cocklodger?

If you're not looking for funny answers, it would be a kept woman.

OnlyEverAutumn · 06/09/2022 22:25

What’s the female équipe of a cocklodger?

mycatisannoying · 06/09/2022 22:25

Ooh, interesting. I saw it from a childhood/parenting POV, and others are seeing it from a partner POV.

mycatisannoying · 06/09/2022 22:24

I agree with it. A working-class Glaswegian childhood in the 70s/80s would generally support the view!

hattie43 · 06/09/2022 22:23

The saying is probably quite true . Poverty brings stress to a relationship. However I think it's really old fashioned to think women have to rely on a man's income as we are perfectly capable of earning our own .

Fairislefandango · 06/09/2022 22:22

Marry a person who respects you, considers you their equal, and has a sensible and responsible attitude to work and money. You can't really guarantee you won't end up poor, but you can avoid marrying somebody whose attitude to life makes it more likely!

limitededitionbarbie · 06/09/2022 22:14

I'm Not saying I agree with it I've been lucky enough to be self sufficient but it's come at its own cost.

If men were held accountable for csa etc and Childcare was seen as a joint responsibility after splitting rather than usually just for the women to sort out in order to be able to afford to go back to work full time then this advice wouldnt be needed at all.

We still have a long way to go.

NovaDeltas · 06/09/2022 22:14

Agree with @VatofTea , it's about values. Don't spend any effort on a partner who doesn't work and doesn't want to work. Ignore the unambitious. Date and settle down with intelligent, driven, successful people. Don't have a kid with Billy NoGCSEs who lives in his car and wonder why your life went wrong.

limitededitionbarbie · 06/09/2022 22:09

I think this advice will apply until the gender pay gap has been eliminated.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 21:17

Summerfun54321 · 06/09/2022 17:57

If you’ve experienced true poverty growing up then of course you’ll guide your children away from it.

I have experienced true poverty. Having to rely on a man not to be in poverty is not a good way out.

dementedma · 06/09/2022 20:34

People who say there's more to life than money are people who have enough money. Yes you can be miserable in any life but I'd rather be miserable in my holiday villa in France than in my damp bedsit in Glasgow

felulageller · 06/09/2022 20:27

A DH will most certainly be due half of a house gifted by the spouses parents as a marital asset.

Wealthy women need to be more aware of the risks of marriage.

Ie don't do it if you have more £££ than him!

SurfBox · 06/09/2022 19:00

Why is it sexist crap? Money problems affect both halves of a partnership and are a well known factor in relationship breakdown. There’s nothing sexist about it

this, there is an assumption on mn that all men are comfortable and in well paid jobs, so not true. I know many marriages where the women's earnings carry the family.

WitchyPooPoo · 06/09/2022 18:36

When I was young, mum, comparing herself to my aunt, said she would always marry for love and not money. Years later mum and dad were completely miserable and ended in divorce. They both worked very hard but they constantly scraped by financially when we were children and they drifted apart. Wealthy aunty and uncle work as a team and are still genuinely happy and in love.

My hubs is a high earner for our area. We both worked and had ambition when we met, didn’t know his career would take off but I wouldn’t have dated someone without a job, prospects or motivation. Like pp’s have said, for some people it’s not about money per se but having similar goals and work ethic etc.

Some randomer on holiday commented our teen daughter wouldn’t struggle to find a ‘rich bloke’. I quickly corrected them and said DD will make her own money. I hope our children are happy, motivated and meet likeminded people.

newnamethanks · 06/09/2022 18:36

I haven't heard that phrase since my dad died, many years ago, together with always have your own money, don't rely on anyone to keep you.

Maybebabyno2 · 06/09/2022 18:35

I always knew this saying as 'when debt comes through the door, love goes out the window' which I do completely agree with

DarkShade · 06/09/2022 18:28

A feminist twist on this message: girls, and what's why it's important for you to work hard and make your own money, so that whether poverty (and love) fly in or out the window is not purely at the mercy of your partner....

Honestly my parents gave me typical advice for middle class parents of their age, and it was terrible advice. It was that money does not matter. Don't choose a partner based on how much they are capable of earning, don't choose a job based on wages but passion. No surprise both me and my sister have no money! I wish I had been guided to think through the implications of my own career choices. If you earn a good wage you can marry someone who earns less and not worry about being poor.

Blossomtoes · 06/09/2022 18:18

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 16:08

I disagree with this and if anyone tried to say similar to my daughters they'd be getting it in the ear from me

Sexist crap

Girls should be empowered to create their own financial security

Not rely on others for that

Why is it sexist crap? Money problems affect both halves of a partnership and are a well known factor in relationship breakdown. There’s nothing sexist about it.

Thinkingblonde · 06/09/2022 18:08

My mother said this too, but not in a materialistic way.
Another of her sayings was “Better to be an old man’s darling than a young man’s slave.”