Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When poverty comes in the door, loves goes out the window

93 replies

Slowdaysfastyears · 06/09/2022 15:36

Do you agree?

I always remember a friend of mine telling me that her mum had said this to her when she was young and for her to make sure she settles with someone who can provide (not necessarily rich) she said that with money struggles, life is so much harder and love dies. The mum herself has been married for years to a lovely man with a nice amount of money, nice house, she’s never worked..but not rich. Her daughter, my friend has followed a similar path..my friend is lovely, but has always been materialistic and money minded..she has worked in the past and has a degree etc though, unlike her mum.
Do you agree with this view or that her mum saying this to her as a child is damaging? Her grandmother said the same to her too.
Is there any harm in hoping or advising our children to marry *Well?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SurfBox · 07/09/2022 21:24

Some couples do still like and love each other. I love my husband very much. He is still my favourite adult throughout all the good and hard times

ofcourse they do, I never said all.

dockspider · 07/09/2022 17:40

I don’t disagree with you @SurfBox. Shit happens in life. It makes some couples stronger. It splits some couples up. It makes some
couples not like each other much but not want to split up. But it’s not purely financial shit, that’s all that I and the other poster were saying.

54isanopendoor · 07/09/2022 17:36

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/09/2022 15:46

The saying is probably accurate. The sentiment (to marry a man with money) is all wrong.

Work hard at school, get and keep a decent job, live within your means, don't marry a cocklodger.

Exactly as @MrsTerryPratchett says!
the sentiment is correct.
Love for a partner, hope, self esteem are all harder to maintain in poverty.
So, don't 'marry a rich man' but try to ensure that you don't get trapped by poverty
Not that the Govt is much help here.
£170m profit by energy companies & it seems the govt will borrow taxpayers money so we can 'bail ourselves out'. Sorry to bring politics into it but, sheesh...

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:28

@SurfBox Some couples do still like and love each other. I love my husband very much. He is still my favourite adult throughout all the good and hard times.

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 15:21

Oh, absolutely. In the same way that poverty won't break up every couple, nor will other life stressors. Many couples will be strong enough to weather the storms - and crises can of course strengthen relationships, too. But I guess the point is that any life stressors can and do contribute to the breakdown of (less strong) relationships, not just financial ones

and as I said in another post it doesn't take a break up to show that the love is gone, many couples stay together as break ups can be so messy.

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 15:19

*I would say when reality of life be it illness, responsibilities,housework, children, difficulty conceiving etc comes in the door love often goes out the window in even the strongest of couples. It is far from limited to just poverty or financial difficulty.

Agree

But this is why you need a really strong relationship because shit happens to most people.
We have had some really big shit times. And I am not sure how I would have got through it without my partner*

But many relationships/marriages stay together until the end but it doesn't mean love or affection remains after shit storms or the general realities of lives erode love. Just because a couple stay together doesn't mean they love each other or even like each other.

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 15:14

I suppose I'm gonna come across as a snob, but I was brought up with quite well off parents (not mega rich, but we NEVER went without) I honestly don't think I could be with someone that was really struggling for money and living on a month to month basis. I appreciate that makes me horrible and that's fair enough but I just wouldn't want that for myself

that doesn't make you horrible, it makes you sensible

Suetwo · 07/09/2022 14:26

But I’m sure the opposite is true. I mean, there must be women who’ve married just for money who also ended up miserable. You’d have to be incredibly shallow and insensitive to live with (and have regular sex with) a man you didn’t like just so you could have holidays in Tuscany and a big conservatory. Even a sex worker only has to spend an hour with her client.

dockspider · 07/09/2022 14:14

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 11:36

But this is why you need a really strong relationship because shit happens to most people.
We have had some really big shit times. And I am not sure how I would have got through it without my partner.

Oh, absolutely. In the same way that poverty won't break up every couple, nor will other life stressors. Many couples will be strong enough to weather the storms - and crises can of course strengthen relationships, too. But I guess the point is that any life stressors can and do contribute to the breakdown of (less strong) relationships, not just financial ones.

OhamIreally · 07/09/2022 13:55

My grandmother used to say this. I always understood it to mean that poverty would make life hard and it's difficult for a relationship to withstand it.
I never understood it to be an edict to marry a rich man.

MilliwaysUniverse · 07/09/2022 13:44

I disagree. Me and DH were skint when we first got married, to the extent we had to choose between the mortgage (cheaper than rent) and the council tax. We would visit my gran and raid her fridge and cupboards - she bought extra so we could do that without feeling bad. We didn't use the heating and had a really frugal lifestyle. We weren't on the bones of our arses, but close. We weren't strained with each other though, we pulled together as a team, so it's not inevitable. It depends on your situation and your relationship.

honeylulu · 07/09/2022 13:40

Poverty brings misery and stress. Being rich won't make you happy but being able to manage comfortably makes a huge difference. My parents bang on about money not being important but it's easy for them to say that in their big detached house by the sea! I've been extremely poor in the past, real "I don't know how I'll pay the bills" poor and it's horrendous. I worried about money all the time. It kept me awake at night

But I don't agree women should aim to be provided for. Earn money yourself, manage it wisely and aim to marry someone who feels the same.

WeAreThePigs · 07/09/2022 12:59

Completely true, sadly.

we don’t fight because we have no financial stresses but also enough space to get away from each other so no tensions ever really builds up. I suspect we would not be so rosy if we had the worries that many have.

user1471538283 · 07/09/2022 12:57

I do believe in this but I also believe in being independent.

I know from experience that when money was tight my ex thought it all belonged to him. He would have seen us starve so he had enough.

Poverty causes so much stress anyway. You need to be with someone with the same financial values as you and have your own money (and they need their own as well). I am not supported a grown man.

Minimalme · 07/09/2022 12:46

We married for love, both worked, saved and progressed until we had two disabled children.

I had to give up my job and we lost our home.

Because we are so in love 20 years on, we have been able to make it through the really bad times.

We are rebuilding our lives together with no regrets.

worriedmammaofone · 07/09/2022 11:41

@antelopevalley absolutely I agree with providing for yourself but I would also want the other person to be able to do the same. I'm not talking being really rich but enough to be comfortable. It definitely makes life a whole lot easier if money or lack there of isn't a major factor in everyday decision making. For example I wanted to have the wiggle room to take a few years off when my twins were born and my eldest was a toddler. Having a DH that could provide during this time me both our lives easier. I now work full time again in a job that I love.

ReneBumsWombats · 07/09/2022 11:39

worriedmammaofone · 07/09/2022 11:31

I suppose I'm gonna come across as a snob, but I was brought up with quite well off parents (not mega rich, but we NEVER went without) I honestly don't think I could be with someone that was really struggling for money and living on a month to month basis. I appreciate that makes me horrible and that's fair enough but I just wouldn't want that for myself

Why does not wanting a subsistence existence make you horrible?

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 11:36

dockspider · 07/09/2022 09:13

I would say when reality of life be it illness, responsibilities,housework, children, difficulty conceiving etc comes in the door love often goes out the window in even the strongest of couples. It is far from limited to just poverty or financial difficulty.

Agree

But this is why you need a really strong relationship because shit happens to most people.
We have had some really big shit times. And I am not sure how I would have got through it without my partner.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 11:34

You need to be able to support yourself.
I find it strange that it is seen by some as a good situation, to only be able to avoid poverty by being with a well-off/rich man.
I want to be in a relationship because I want to be with that person. Not because I need their money. I would never want to be in the position of not leaving a partner because to do so would plunge me into poverty.

worriedmammaofone · 07/09/2022 11:31

I suppose I'm gonna come across as a snob, but I was brought up with quite well off parents (not mega rich, but we NEVER went without) I honestly don't think I could be with someone that was really struggling for money and living on a month to month basis. I appreciate that makes me horrible and that's fair enough but I just wouldn't want that for myself

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 11:11

Disagree. I am disabled, my husband is my carer. We live in poverty and we love each other fiercely and try to live within our means

do you have kids though? It's easier for a couple to love in poverty than when kids come along.

SwordToFlamethrower · 07/09/2022 09:38

Disagree. I am disabled, my husband is my carer. We live in poverty and we love each other fiercely and try to live within our means.

We have also had terrible infertility issues and our love has never faltered.

Money has never been a reason we have argued, we have always sat down together and planned our available money.

I have had rich men try to buy my love and affection in the past and that is such a massive turn off for me. I'd rather live in a tent with my husband than in a mansion with a man I didn't love.

MercurialMonday · 07/09/2022 09:31

I wasn't given any of this advice.

My GPs were born into poverty and GM both worked full time when they could - my DP were both latch key kids. DP wanted one of them around when we got home so DMum work p/t sometimes 3 jobs but was always there - and money was often tight in my childhood eased a bit in my teens.

I did marry someone with similarity values - money wise I think we balance each other out - I'd probably save much more but enjoy life less and he's slightly opposite and we find that happy medium.

We did have a period with very young kid just after buying our first house when money was devastatingly tight - which went on for years things would easy and next blow would happen. I put off getting prescriptions for me filled and getting shoes with no holes but kids were fed and mortgage paid - though we had real worries when DH was made redundant at being able to do that. I do now wonder if lack of heating contributed to my lung issues and older DC. Love didn't die - but fun was rarer and more focused round our young kids. Moving massively improved our finances and life was much easier.

Interestingly DSis had massive money worries - bailed out by DP - and both of us are worried our kids don't get the value of money - wonder if we protected them too well - something I think our parents couldn't do.

ByTheSea · 07/09/2022 09:23

My (now 85-year-old) mother used to say both
"It's just as easy to fall in love with a rich man as a poor one" and
"Make sure you're never financially dependent on any man".

SurfBox · 07/09/2022 09:22

As long as we have food and shelter we would have everything we need when we have love

if we have these though it's not really poverty. It's when we can't access these we are in poverty. I think people here don't get it. Also shelter is not enough, if you can't afford to put the heat on and the house starts getting mould and dampness and people get sick that's poverty too or if the house is not proper ventilated and droughts get it it also can cause illness.
Simply having a roof over your head is not always enough, you might want to say having adequate food and adequate shelter. Likewise only being able to afford beans and toast for the kids and the kids and you being hungry and malnourished is an example of getting food but not adequate amounts of food.

Many people on mn, myself included, have no proper experience of poverty so we shouldn't preach to those who do. Whilst I have no experience of it though I am still well aware of the realities of it.