Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect the current GCSE / Y11 cohort to get concessions too?

80 replies

andyetanotherschoolyear · 06/09/2022 13:21

Due to the (negative) impact of the pandemic on learning, each cohort so far have been given concessions to try to make up for this (e.g. not sitting exams - 2 years; being provided with advance info - last year) and I don't think it's unreasonable to expect the current Y11s should be provided with some sort of adjustment too. They did, after all, lose out on class room learning for a significant part of their GCSE courses too.

Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PugInTheHouse · 08/09/2022 12:00

I have a DS who took GCSEs this summer, there were no real concessions, they missed a huge amount of school, even in Y11 there were huge periods of learning they missed due to isolation and also many supply teachers. The GCSE grades last year from what I know of (obv only in my circle of friends, although various schools) seem to reflect what the children were predicted and were expecting over the last few years. There will obviously be exceptions. In comparison to last year it seemed almost reasonable, last years results were a bit of a joke, I know people predicted 4/5s who got 7-9s and at A level predicted D/Cs and got A/A*s.

It needs to be back to normal next year (which is basically was this year anyway) however I do feel there should have been an overhaul as I don't think the exams are particularly fit for purpose.

Anothernamechangeplease · 08/09/2022 09:48

gatehouseoffleet · 08/09/2022 09:27

I don't think exams should go back to "normal" at all. We had a chance to change the system and go with open book exams. At the moment, exams are just a memory test. They don't show who will do well in the workplace at all.

There should be numeracy and literacy tests at 16 and that's it.

A levels should be open book exams. You still need to know the stuff but I don't know for example why you need to learn poems off by heart so you can quote from them, or formulae that you could look up in the workplace (and presumably if they were essential to your job you'd soon learn them off by heart).

I think there are certainly arguments for reforming exams, at all levels. That wasn't really my point, though.

My point was that there do not need to be further special concessions for the current year 13s because of the pandemic. Yes, their education has been affected by the pandemic, as has the education of the 10 or so cohorts below them, but we can't keep applying "special" concessions forever.

Long term reform of exams and assessments wouldn't just be a special arrangement for the current exam cohort - any reformed system would presumably be retained for future cohorts as well. That's a different argument entirely!!

gatehouseoffleet · 08/09/2022 09:27

I don't think exams should go back to "normal" at all. We had a chance to change the system and go with open book exams. At the moment, exams are just a memory test. They don't show who will do well in the workplace at all.

There should be numeracy and literacy tests at 16 and that's it.

A levels should be open book exams. You still need to know the stuff but I don't know for example why you need to learn poems off by heart so you can quote from them, or formulae that you could look up in the workplace (and presumably if they were essential to your job you'd soon learn them off by heart).

Anothernamechangeplease · 08/09/2022 09:13

cptartapp · 08/09/2022 08:41

This. This GCSE years for current year 13's were shambolic. Unfinished syllabuses. Remote learning. Starting A levels in year 12 on the back foot with gaps in knowledge.And they've never sat an external exam.
A line does have to be drawn. After the summer exams of 2023.

I don't agree. There is no particular reason for the line to be drawn after summer 2023. There will then be another argument for the next cohort, and the one after that. Where does it end?

The exams should go back to normal in 2023. It's the fairest option. Kids who have been disproportionately affected by the pandemic should be able to apply for mitigating circumstances. The rest of them are all in the same boat together.

cptartapp · 08/09/2022 08:41

CrapBucket · 06/09/2022 17:15

I have a Y11 and a Y13. The Y13 has bore much more of the brunt than the Y11.

With GCSEs its just about getting into your next stage of education, however, my Y13 missed so much in his GCSE years it has meant a huge jump to A Levels. Not sure if they will do well enough for university but I'm sure without covid they would have.

This. This GCSE years for current year 13's were shambolic. Unfinished syllabuses. Remote learning. Starting A levels in year 12 on the back foot with gaps in knowledge.And they've never sat an external exam.
A line does have to be drawn. After the summer exams of 2023.

CrapBucket · 07/09/2022 15:40

Surely 3 year v 2 year GCSE course just means the kids get to drop their most hated subject a year earlier? They are still going to spend Y9 learning whatever maths is on the Y9 national curriculum. Its not like they do Y8, then skip Y9 and start GCSE, because GCSEs have to build on KS3 knowledge.

BettySundaes · 06/09/2022 21:37

There are plenty of schools still following a 3 year GCSE programme - those where "exam results" are a real focus - as I understand it though they mostly cover the curriculum in years 9 & 10 and year 11 is all repeat and revision and drill.

CloudsandTeacups · 06/09/2022 20:43

A GCSE is a two year course. If schools chose to start it earlier that's their decision. So the exam boards will say this cohort have not lost learning time due to lockdowns. I don't think concessions will be needed or appropriate.

Chakraleaf · 06/09/2022 20:31

No. I think it is OK now.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/09/2022 20:29

YABU, most kids don’t start GCSE courses in year 9 - my dd is in year 9 and only starting one of her GCSE courses this year (German).

Theyve got to stop giving concessions at some point.

But also, haven’t the kids who were in yr 9 in Mar 2020 just done their GCSEs? Everyone is three years up from where they were at that time.

HotelKettle · 06/09/2022 20:11

They are getting concessions- their grades will be higher but not as high as last year.
Last year’s cohort had both of their GCSE years badly affected by COVID.
This year’s cohort will have had last academic year affected but hopefully this year will be ok.

Aworldofmyown · 06/09/2022 20:07

This year's 'concessions' were a bit of a shit show in my opinion.
I think this year group are going to have real problems if they went on to A levels - they have huge gaps in learning.
I feel really sorry for the cohort who have just done A Levels, the whole thing has just been a nightmare for a huge group of kids.

Darbs76 · 06/09/2022 18:24

Schools are not supposed to do 3yr courses - so no

MrsHamlet · 06/09/2022 18:21

Key stage 3 is years 7-9. Ofsted have a (legitimate, I think) dislike of that being reduced to two years in favour of a three year GCSE course.

Anothernamechangeplease · 06/09/2022 17:50

AntlerRose · 06/09/2022 17:36

At one point more than half of schools were doing 3 year GCSE and this year 11 are part of that. Lots of schools are moving away from it because it was hard to prove a broad and balanced curriculum (eg arts and music) in years 7, 8 and 9. I dont know if its spefically banned - it might be, but there are a lot of current year 11s who had started their gcses in year 9.

That may well be the case, but the fact is, many schools have always covered the course in 2 years, so it is possible to do so. The ones who started in their disrupted Year 9 just have slightly less of a head start than they would have done.

AntlerRose · 06/09/2022 17:36

Nadal · 06/09/2022 17:24

How come some do? How do they allow this?

At one point more than half of schools were doing 3 year GCSE and this year 11 are part of that. Lots of schools are moving away from it because it was hard to prove a broad and balanced curriculum (eg arts and music) in years 7, 8 and 9. I dont know if its spefically banned - it might be, but there are a lot of current year 11s who had started their gcses in year 9.

balalake · 06/09/2022 17:27

There is the possibility that if you have yet another year of some form of concession the value and recognition of GCSEs will be devalued yet more. It will also increase the jump to A levels.

So I think that whilst not nice, it should not continue.

Nadal · 06/09/2022 17:24

MrsHamlet · 06/09/2022 16:36

Schools are not supposed to start GCSEs in year 9

How come some do? How do they allow this?

ShaunaTheSheep · 06/09/2022 17:20

The 'advance information' for the most recent A level cohort was a waste of paper. They have been shafted royally by Covid AND the exam boards for the last 3 years.

CrapBucket · 06/09/2022 17:15

I have a Y11 and a Y13. The Y13 has bore much more of the brunt than the Y11.

With GCSEs its just about getting into your next stage of education, however, my Y13 missed so much in his GCSE years it has meant a huge jump to A Levels. Not sure if they will do well enough for university but I'm sure without covid they would have.

Anothernamechangeplease · 06/09/2022 17:13

andyetanotherschoolyear · 06/09/2022 16:41

Totally agree with this. Due to testing, even those children/teachers who were not particularly symptomatic, had to take time out which would have been affecting the outcomes.

The easiest would be to let this year have some concessions. Not as much as last (2022) year's cohort but some.

But on what basis?

They will have been in school for the whole 2-year course.

Yes, some will have missed excessive amounts of school due to covid or other illnesses. Yes, some will have had teachers miss excessive amounts of school due to covid or other illnesses. Consideration should be given to individual mitigating circumstances as in any other year.

Concessions for the whole year group are not necessary as they will have had 2 full years in school which is what most schools have to cover the whole gcse course. And yes, they have missed out on prior learning but so have the 9 or 10 cohorts below them. You have to draw the line somewhere.

The fact that some schools start the gcse course earlier than they're supposed to isn't relevant.

It's actually much better for the dc to do exams as usual. Nobody wants to feel that they have only done as well as they have because special concessions have been made.

Permanentlyexhausted · 06/09/2022 17:08

The easiest would be to let this year have some concessions. Not as much as last (2022) year's cohort but some.

The whole point of the concessions was to level the playing field within the cohort, not between cohorts. To recognise that some schools had been more adversely affected than others in terms of lockdowns and their ability to provide online adequate online teaching.

Last year's cohort were told around February, with around 6-8 weeks of teaching left, which topics should and should not have questions (for info, a very tiny proportion of topics were dropped completely). They were still, in some cases, examined on those topics anyway. They had to sit two full rounds of mock exams between November and early March.

And you want concessions that aren't as good as that for this year's Y11s?

SilverGlitterBaubles · 06/09/2022 17:05

The concessions this year caused more harm than good in some subjects/ exam boards due to confusion and misinterpretation. Also the information was provided quite late so it meant some students and teachers delayed learning things or had covered things unnecessarily while waiting for confirmation of this. It's just not always as good as it seems.

BetsyBigNose · 06/09/2022 17:02

@Catch21 - agreed, but it does mean that some pupils have been unfairly disadvantaged, so it would seem that they should be entitled to some sort of concession, but I understand that others might feel it was unfair. As I said, I am biased as I have a DD who will be taking her GCSEs this year, whose GCSE courses were partly taught over remote learning during the Covid disruption. I can't see that there's an answer that will make everyone happy here!

TeenDivided · 06/09/2022 16:59

andyetanotherschoolyear · 06/09/2022 16:42

Yes, let's hope so.

GCSEs are graded on a curve. So to some extent if standards go up or down the same % are meant to get 7s or 4s. It is inbuilt into the system. The 2023 cohort are meant I think to get the same grades as the 2019 regardless of their standard. That is a concession if you think the overall standard will be lower due to disruption.

Swipe left for the next trending thread