Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's the obsession with private school parents & sports? Seems to be a deal breaker in choosing a school..

134 replies

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 12:40

We know many parents with girls & boys ar private schools. They are all obsessed with their kids sport & the school sports facilities, teams etc.. Cross Country, athletics, rugby, football, netball, hockey even yoga gets touted... These schools also provide lots of homework... State school parents aren't nearly as bothered by school sport or aibu..

OP posts:
GreenGreenGrassBlue · 06/09/2022 14:56

Snipdog · 06/09/2022 14:32

And regarding my post I am based in London.

Wales - thank god - actually are more inclusive with rugby. It gives me hope.

But for state schools it is unfair. That is the issue with private schools. I get you can pay for what you want. You can pay for the entrenched privilege while others don't get the opportunity.

But we are talking children here. Why should not sports and arts provision be something that is core to the lives of children whatever their parents background?

It is deeply unfair.

That’s life though isn’t it. You could say why are there children living under railways in Mumbai? It’s what people can pay for and they’ll do the best for their kids. Privilege & the rich/poor gap will only become wider with our consecutive Tory governments. There are limited opportunities for poor kids to see examples of or be inspired by success.

it’s more than likely privilege will have to be bought. I can’t see the world changing.

CaptainBarbosa · 06/09/2022 14:55

Snipdog · 06/09/2022 14:32

And regarding my post I am based in London.

Wales - thank god - actually are more inclusive with rugby. It gives me hope.

But for state schools it is unfair. That is the issue with private schools. I get you can pay for what you want. You can pay for the entrenched privilege while others don't get the opportunity.

But we are talking children here. Why should not sports and arts provision be something that is core to the lives of children whatever their parents background?

It is deeply unfair.

Yes rugby in Wales is very much seen as a sport for all. Women's rugby is also really picking up, with female grass roots teams and professional female players now getting full time contracts like the male national team. (Unsure on the pay scales though, probably more work needed as always.)

We do say "only posh boys play rugby in England" 😳 Meanwhile in Wales you could have the child of a consultant surgeon or Barrister on the same team as the local Police Officers kid or the single mum.

Sport should be accessible to all children regardless of background.

GreenGreenGrassBlue · 06/09/2022 14:54

As PPs it’s an all rounder thing. But also because life is more than education. Plus when you go to Uni you can get involved in sports there too. It’s a lifelong passion/hobby: adding to quality of life.

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 14:52

One of the mums in the group suddenly became sporty once her dd stared reception in a well know private... She started tennis lessons so she could fit in with some of the mums, also hiking & sea swimming.. She honestly was the most unsporty person I know, now she's obsessed with the school's sport...

OP posts:
Technosaurus · 06/09/2022 14:33

(to clarify, my post was in response to OP's remark about the parents being pushy - I don't disagree with anything you've said @Snipdog !)

Snipdog · 06/09/2022 14:32

And regarding my post I am based in London.

Wales - thank god - actually are more inclusive with rugby. It gives me hope.

But for state schools it is unfair. That is the issue with private schools. I get you can pay for what you want. You can pay for the entrenched privilege while others don't get the opportunity.

But we are talking children here. Why should not sports and arts provision be something that is core to the lives of children whatever their parents background?

It is deeply unfair.

Technosaurus · 06/09/2022 14:23

Yeah but that's up them really. It may also simply be a pragmatic case of whichever sports are on offer after school on certain days so you need them to do 'something' until 5pm on a certain day.

Private schools rarely charge for after-school/extra-curricular stuff so if you can't do a 4pm pick up on say Weds & Thurs, and there's a certain club on those nights until 5pm that would make your life easy, you can "gently" lean them into it at no extra cost - whether it's trampolining, badminton, bee-keeping or drama, whatever it is might just make the parents' life easy.

It only dawned on me relatively recently as to why my Mum suggested I join Bridge club after school on Fridays, because she worked late that day! She was probably relieved when I got a bit older and played a musical instrument as the Jazz Band practice (where you had to be a certain level of ability) was also after school on Friday!

Snipdog · 06/09/2022 14:19

if you want to play rugby and cricket to a high level in the UK you really need to go to a private school. Anyone know any state schools helping women play cricket and getting them into the hundred for example?

The state schools I know of either can't complete or if they do tremendously well then that often is not maintained. They can't keep winning championship year after year. They simply don't have the resources.

There is a reason private schools are often so good at what they do as they entrench privilege for a select few. Is it not 7 percent going to private school? The private school can employ a specific coach the state school may have a sports teacher teaching or coaching lots of different sports.

if you want say excellent coaching you generally will get that at a private school. You may also have a private school more willing to accommodate timetable changes. You may have indoor nets whereas the state school is likely to have a poorly maintained outdoor net and lack of all weather pitches. Need to go to an extra tennis camp in Spain and need some cornpressed lessons? Yes, then a private school will accommodate that.

I heard if a private school who allocated a teacher to travel with their sports scholarship student when they did an international event so the child would not have their schooling interrupted - how would that happen at a state school?

As a private school student you get more holidays and recovery time of playing sport - but you tend to play way more matches so guess what you get better at what you do. It is not rocket science.

Some intensive holiday coaching and music courses only happen when the private schools are on holiday.

Yes, as a state school student, you can say join a rugby or cricket club but what I have found is that the private school children who go to secondary drop out as their facilities are better and they have more resources such as coaches to matches etc whereas remaining state school kids are scrambling to fit stuff in.

Ofcourse private schools also crème off the top talent with scholarship courses.

The rugby and cricket authorities need to reach out to private schools and get them to run some programmes in state schools. They are supposed to be charities after all.

Then there are a whole host of sports and pe that you may not ever get exposed to at your state school - maybe like swimming ( I am not talking like water safety) but proper competitive or team swimming, hockey, lacrosse, rugby, cricket, fencing, horse riding, I could go on and on and on ...

Also the multiple teams are important too - some private schools have like 12 teams in a year whereas the state school may field only 1.

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 14:13

Yes but these three families were only waxing lyrically about sports & one family pushing their unsporty daughter into two after school sports when they're so much more on offer is a bit bizarre imo

OP posts:
Mumspair1 · 06/09/2022 14:10

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 14:02

I found it very interesting.. If my dc were at a private I'd be encouraging the baking club, yoga, drama & possibly athletics.. It was just with all the possibilities sports were the be all & end all.. This is just after school btw, sport seems to be heavily incorporated into the actual school day also...

The private schools do offer this though. My ds school offers a whole range of other activities not just sports. It really covers a whole range of extra curricular in addition to academics.

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 14:07

Actually chatted to my mum about the meet up this morning.. Her reply was "What do you expect, sure didn't the Middleton sisters play every sport under the sun according to the press & it did them no harm" 🤣

OP posts:
TaraRhu · 06/09/2022 14:03

These are the things that give you life skills and entry into social circles etc that you unfortunately need in this country to get ahead.

We live in a classist society where your ability to play sport, understand culture and talk in a certain way still dictates how far you will go. If you don't do your homework, you will not pass your exams, you won't get into uni and won't have the key to the door.

It's pretty obvious.. why wouldn't you want your kids to have the chance to try all those things? The state system is terrible by the time I pay for my son to learn football, tennis , swimming I might as well send him to a private school.

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 14:02

I found it very interesting.. If my dc were at a private I'd be encouraging the baking club, yoga, drama & possibly athletics.. It was just with all the possibilities sports were the be all & end all.. This is just after school btw, sport seems to be heavily incorporated into the actual school day also...

OP posts:
GroggyLegs · 06/09/2022 14:00

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 13:52

It was just an interesting observation, DH was with me & we both thought the same, when we meet up with friends with kids in state the chats are completely different.. Actually school is rarely discussed!

DH went to private & I know it became a huge part of the ILs identity as well as my DHs. School events were where they socialised etc.

I think when it's as all encompassing as it sounds DH school was (Saturdays and every other Sunday) it became a lifestyle for all of them, not just 'school'.

365sleepstogo · 06/09/2022 14:00

Technosaurus · 06/09/2022 13:46

I went to a private school. It wasn't necessarily whether the children were sporty or my parents wanted me to be an Olympian, it was the fact that if they happened to be there were loads of opportunities to develop it, without it impacting on our parents or our educations.

Good at swimming? Excellent, we had our own pool and pre-school swimming club for those interested. Hockey? There's a floodlit pitch, training is after school every Tuesday. Cricket? Yes, we happened to have our own pitch and nets. This is before you get to the really niche stuff - Fencing club after school on Monday anyone? Even for non-sporty types, there was a blizzard of available options. PS Latin wasn't 'extra-curricular', it was mandatory until 14!

My DS goes to a state school and there's none of these options, if he shows an interest we have to find a club for evening/weekend training. Whereas if he was at private, it would all be taken care of between 8 and 5, leaving evenings/weekends to be spent as proper family time. If he happened to demonstrate elite-level ability, that's different, but for 'average' kids there are just more opportunities at private schools. There's a myriad of reasons why state schools don't/can't offer such things, which is a real tragedy for the UK.

Yes, lots of sports clubs for all skills sets- trampolining, karate, basketball, table tennis, bouldering, rock climbing, yoga, gymnastics, dance.

Also very important for a school to have multiple teams e.g. A-D so there are match opportunities for all and the enjoyment of sport continues as you play with/against those of a similar level without feeling intimidated or rubbish.

CaptainBarbosa · 06/09/2022 13:56

Sport is important. Sport teaches valuable lessons such as team work, physical health, some psychology such as competition, achievement and loss, commitment, perseverance and determination. Sport also keeps many a kid out of trouble, it's a place to put energy into something positive and not negative.

DS is not private he's state, and I'm a low income, lone parent. We are in Wales where rugby is everywhere, clubs are heavily subsidised by the WRU, community grants, help with uniform, tog exchanges are widely done.

DS goes to rugby, I purposely wanted him to do a sport so he can learn life skills, have fun, excercise and be a member of a team.

Those parents for the private school are just looking for something similar that's all.

365sleepstogo · 06/09/2022 13:53

Sport is so important and is often the case that if it doesn’t become habit at a very young age then it becomes difficult to instill once older.
DD has done a lot of sport in a her pre prep/prep - she is not necessarily that good (c team level) but she loves it. Once she moved to secondary, she wanted to try out for many different sports teams knowing she wouldn’t be in the a-team but would get to train and play matches in lower echelons.

I didn’t have any sports opportunities at primary school. Once at secondary, going through puberty etc, it wasn’t something I was used to doing or felt I had the ability to do and so I didn’t enjoy.

I would love it if when DD is an adult she felt comfortable to join a community netball team, local tennis club etc and just enjoy herself. And stay fit and healthy.
She may, of course, decide never to do that but that’s her choice.

Same goes for music.

Ewetoo · 06/09/2022 13:52

It was just an interesting observation, DH was with me & we both thought the same, when we meet up with friends with kids in state the chats are completely different.. Actually school is rarely discussed!

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 06/09/2022 13:52

My dd is pretty sporty. She is also at selective private secondary. She is not going to the most renowned private school in the area for sport as she didn’t want to go to a single sex school. One of her classmates changed to the corresponding boy’s school to follow his sport. Dd enjoys sport at school but isn’t obsessed and also has sporting hobbies outside of school. I am not pushing her to do sport but it is very beneficial for her and she wants to be always on the go. She’s not so interested in going to the park anymore and rather be doing activities than hanging around town and so forth.

GroggyLegs · 06/09/2022 13:49

I'd imagine families who can afford private education are also the families who can also afford the extra curricular activities (and the bikes, the boots, the hockey sticks, the cricket bats as well as the time & transport to shuffle it all around) that create a sporty kid?

So then it becomes even more important when searching for a school.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/09/2022 13:47

I'm quite apprehensive about this tbh.

My DD has just started at a private school.

I'm worried that sport will be an all-encompassing obsession which I would find quite tiresome and intimidating. I'm by no means anti sport: I run and swim a lot and I really understand the benefits of team sports for children. But I find the idea of a culture which values sporting prowess over everything else a bit threatening. I find people who judge others on the basis of their sporting prowess judgemental and often quite limited.

Obviously I chose a school which I didn't think had a mania for sports but one of the things which put me off a lot of private schools was the idea of my daughter being forced to rub shoulders with a lot of kids whose parents bully them to be in the first team for everything and the whole "sport is all" culture which breeds rugger buggers and football obsessives. I find people like this a bit scary.

Oh well... the die is cast.

Technosaurus · 06/09/2022 13:46

I went to a private school. It wasn't necessarily whether the children were sporty or my parents wanted me to be an Olympian, it was the fact that if they happened to be there were loads of opportunities to develop it, without it impacting on our parents or our educations.

Good at swimming? Excellent, we had our own pool and pre-school swimming club for those interested. Hockey? There's a floodlit pitch, training is after school every Tuesday. Cricket? Yes, we happened to have our own pitch and nets. This is before you get to the really niche stuff - Fencing club after school on Monday anyone? Even for non-sporty types, there was a blizzard of available options. PS Latin wasn't 'extra-curricular', it was mandatory until 14!

My DS goes to a state school and there's none of these options, if he shows an interest we have to find a club for evening/weekend training. Whereas if he was at private, it would all be taken care of between 8 and 5, leaving evenings/weekends to be spent as proper family time. If he happened to demonstrate elite-level ability, that's different, but for 'average' kids there are just more opportunities at private schools. There's a myriad of reasons why state schools don't/can't offer such things, which is a real tragedy for the UK.

justaladyLOL · 06/09/2022 13:43

Sport also teaches kids that life is hideously competitive which is a good lesson to go into the workplace with

purpleboy · 06/09/2022 13:42

Sports is so important for us, it provides so much for DC on top of the obvious physical health benefits. It wasn't a factor in choosing our DCs actual school as all the private schools offered similar sporting provision, but was a factor in choosing private over state.

5foot5 · 06/09/2022 13:42

TBH if I was going to choose an independent school over a state school then music provision would be more likely to be a deciding factor than sport. Most state schools will have at least some sport on the curriculum but the music is often woeful these days.