Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be very pissed off with school

215 replies

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 11:37

First day back at school today - school is round the corner from my house. My son is year 6 and walks to school himself ( he’s done this all last year no issues). He went to school as normal this morning and at 9.30 I revived this text from the school.
“ CHILD1 has not turned up at school today, please could you call the school immediately to update us.”
This immediate made me panic and think the worst! He’s very responsible and wouldn’t skip school so all the worst case scenario’s we’re going through my head!
Rang school in a panic shoes on ready to run over! They asked me to hold while the called his class and he was there all along but had been missed off the register! They said he must have “snuck” in past the teacher! He didn’t sneak we just went to school as normal!
anyway I know people are human and errors can happen but surely they should check before causing such alarm! I’m shocked that this isn’t standard procedure and more shocked that if he had actually been missing it would have taken them 30 mins to inform me. Spoke to head teacher and she was awful and so insincere in her apology and just came across very defensive! I want to take it further as I’m unhappy about the whole situation.
AINU to feel so angry with the school or am I being ott? Thanks!

OP posts:
Snowpatrolling · 06/09/2022 17:22

This happened to me with my daughter, who just so happens to be in a special Ed school and is a flight risk!
I was at work and panicked but she was in class.
the week after she did actually go missing but no one noticed until I got a phone call at 2.30 asking where she was!
so missing for 5 and a half hours by this point! 🤦‍♀️

Navigatingnewwaters · 06/09/2022 17:20

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 16:54

Nope that’s not want I want to happen.
i would obviously not want them to check on every absentee - however as errors do happen I would expect them to check on any absentee child where the parents had not already contacted the school to say they hadn’t been in before worrying the parents - this number for the size of my sons school would be extremely small and easy to call the class prior to texts being sent and causing stress for no reason

Call the class?

Navigatingnewwaters · 06/09/2022 17:19

DixonD · 06/09/2022 17:00

It’s not practical to double-check every child that is deemed absent. If they have not been checked on the register, they are assumed to be absent. You can’t double check every class “just to make sure.” This would certainly mean parents of genuinely missing children would be notified even later than 9.30am.

We all have moments in life which frighten us or make us anxious. You just have to accept it.

Or walk your kid to school.

🙌

Talipesmum · 06/09/2022 17:16

I’m intrigued by this “phone in the classroom” thing. Who answers it - is one of the kids on duty? Can’t imagine the teacher would be wanting to break off mid-announcement to the class to answer the phone.

Navigatingnewwaters · 06/09/2022 17:13

30 minutes is quite good really, how quickly do you expect the office to receive all the registers and then message all the parents of students the teacher have marked absent?

DixonD · 06/09/2022 17:01

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 16:54

Nope that’s not want I want to happen.
i would obviously not want them to check on every absentee - however as errors do happen I would expect them to check on any absentee child where the parents had not already contacted the school to say they hadn’t been in before worrying the parents - this number for the size of my sons school would be extremely small and easy to call the class prior to texts being sent and causing stress for no reason

It’s not reasonable and a waste of resources just to save your emotions. It’s far quicker to check with the parent themselves.

DixonD · 06/09/2022 17:00

It’s not practical to double-check every child that is deemed absent. If they have not been checked on the register, they are assumed to be absent. You can’t double check every class “just to make sure.” This would certainly mean parents of genuinely missing children would be notified even later than 9.30am.

We all have moments in life which frighten us or make us anxious. You just have to accept it.

Or walk your kid to school.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 16:54

Nope that’s not want I want to happen.
i would obviously not want them to check on every absentee - however as errors do happen I would expect them to check on any absentee child where the parents had not already contacted the school to say they hadn’t been in before worrying the parents - this number for the size of my sons school would be extremely small and easy to call the class prior to texts being sent and causing stress for no reason

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 06/09/2022 16:46

The texts are sent automatically! It's not like the receptionist went and physically got your number and sent the text. Attendance called, input to comp, comp sends text automatically to the number in the system for your son. Human error or comp error is possible.

So what u want to happen is...
Teacher calls roll
Teacher inputs roll to system
Receptionist views the roll
Receptionist rings teacher, "just checking that Tom, Dick and Harry are the people that are absent"
Teacher must then call the roll again??
Receptionist then rings the next classroom?

Receptionists are probably the most busy staff member in our school. And teachers have 30 odd kids to be dealing with? In an ideal world they could do that but in an ideal world the human error would have happened in the first place.

I said in a previous post it can easily happen, but in my 7 years I have done it once and I input 6 rolls a day to the system! Tom was absent, I accidentally marked Harry as absent who was next on the roll! Text was automatically sent, it had nothing to do with the receptionist.

BlackeyedSusan · 06/09/2022 15:59

Yes annoying but better that than your child actually going missing bogging off home it's useful. bloody kids

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/09/2022 15:57

Cookie79 · 06/09/2022 13:42

@NeverDropYourMooncup oh her new school has and it was a total nightmare for them to get anything out of the old school. I know all well from the LA perspective.

I did get that heart drop moment though before I realised it was the old school. Rolled my eyes and sent a polite but blunt reply.

It’s a horrible feeling Op no matter how fleeting.

That's pretty good going, considering that they aren't legally allowed to remove them until the first day the kid is physically in the new school and that new school then sends the confirmation. And the old school will also be dealing with the new intake at Y7 and L6 enrolment and retakes - for the new one to do all that in one day and expect the old school to not have anybody else to deal with, well, it would be a little unfair.

FacebookPhotos · 06/09/2022 15:52

If my son had been kidnapped outside of school it would obviously not be the schools fault

If your son had been kidnapped (or more likely injured) on the way in to school and they hadn't picked up on him being missing in a timely manner they would be rightly held accountable. When youngish children are missing or injured minutes do manner. And for most primaries that means sending the text around 9.30am (half an hour late). In the majority of cases it will be that the parent forgot to inform school of something. In some (hopefully very few) cases it will be that the child has arrived in school but nobody knows and the parent will worry unnecessarily. Very occasionally something bad will have happened and the school, parent and any other services can work together to find and help the child.

It is not possible to have a system whereby no parent is worried unnecessarily AND there is no delay in identifying a missing child. It is a balancing act.

Cats23 · 06/09/2022 15:25

I had this once.
My Ds was 6 at the time dropped him to the gate as I always did.
2hrs later, I got a call ' Ds isnt in today is he ok?'
I panicked, I was 8months pregnant and 1hr from the school.
When the receptionist camr back and saif ' Oh dont worry, he is there just wasnt ticked off ' she then laughed.
I told her I didnt think it was funny at all and it was 2hrs after school had started they even noticed he 'wasnt in', I asked if she thought it was an acceptable amount of time to have contacted me- she thought it was'🤦‍♀️
I put a complaint in.

SallyWD · 06/09/2022 15:03

I'd have been panicking too but it was only for a few minutes. They've apologised. What more can be done? It was a mistake and next time I'm sure they'll check more thoroughly.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 15:02

If my son had been kidnapped outside of school it would obviously not be the schools fault - this however was not the case

OP posts:
AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 15:01

Mine are never late - same system here that we have to give permission for them to walk alone from year 5 but in my area that is the norm - almost all his class walk with the exception of a few who live too far and their parents drop them off so not unusual or irresponsible in my opinion for him to safely walk round the corner ( no busy roads) my sons school is smaller than the one you have described and they wound need to check all kids just the unauthorised absentees which would be a small number and quickly done given there are phones in each classroom

OP posts:
AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 14:57

Yes the school know is well very rare for my kids to be ill and never been late….

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 06/09/2022 14:55

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 14:40

Thank you for the message, glad you were all ok - it’s alright to say it ended well but it still a shock at the time - especially if you have never received a message like that 😘

Yes, it worries you first time.

You can become almost immune to it when it more often happens throughout secondary school, as a couple of us have said. I took to usually just messaging my children myself whenever I received these, and finding that the problem had normally already been resolved. Only rarely was action needed, and that would be something as simple as just phoning school to point out that the bus was routinely turning up late every morning etc.

It is something you may have to get used to. It means that the system works as intended in most cases.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 14:54

Well I’m sure he normally does - this hasn’t happens before so I’m assuming he’s always made his presence known somehow

OP posts:
mam0918 · 06/09/2022 14:54

Kids are late all the time, 30 minutes is not that long at all.

They have to get kids in, wait a reasonable time for kids running a bit late, take register, submit register then register needs to be checked then each missing child (sickness, appointments, slept in, stuck in traffic etc...) needs to be chased up.

There are 8 year groups in my DS school with approx 30 kids per class so 240 kids to varify... your kid isnt the only one and 30 minutes is very fast to turn that around.

If your worried then dont send your kid alone, in all the years my oldest (now a teen at another school) attended only 1 kid walked themselves too and from school alone, the parents had to give the school permission (or children are not allowed to leave school without an approved gardian) so that the school has no responsability for what happens on the parents (lack of) watch.

tttigress · 06/09/2022 14:50

Ok, but surely it is also your kids responsibility to make his presence known at register?

felineweird · 06/09/2022 14:49

I am a school secretary and youd be surprised how often teachers cock up the register. If it's someone who we would normally hear from I physically go to their classroom and check.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 14:45

Yes I agree, no system is perfect and mistakes to happen but these ones are easily sorted out it seems

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 06/09/2022 14:43

If it is a small school the admin person may have a number of duties. There will be a time that they have to notify parents. If there is only one person in the office they may have got caught up with something else so not had time to check whether the child was in school before the automated text went out

I would rather a text went out (even if it resulted in me getting a few grey hairs) than they didn't get round to doing it until an hour later and there was an issue with a child

Bubbleguppette · 06/09/2022 14:42

I'm not sure that a system which prevents your situation would be better overall. It is upsetting and of course very stressful when you incorrectly receive the "missing child" message. But there is a balance between worrying parents unnecessarily and taking a longer time to identify actually missing children.

I* *agree, but in this and many cases mentioned above it seems the teacher just needs to be a bit more careful when filling out the register. To double-check that any children they record as absent are indeed missing from the room shouldn't take up too much time? It's when another admin person has to go around checking that time would be wasted. A bit more care could save a lot of trouble.

Maybe OP's school rarely gets things wrong, but some teachers upthread have said mistakes happen very easily. They shouldn't happen easily and something is wrong if they do.