Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be very pissed off with school

215 replies

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 11:37

First day back at school today - school is round the corner from my house. My son is year 6 and walks to school himself ( he’s done this all last year no issues). He went to school as normal this morning and at 9.30 I revived this text from the school.
“ CHILD1 has not turned up at school today, please could you call the school immediately to update us.”
This immediate made me panic and think the worst! He’s very responsible and wouldn’t skip school so all the worst case scenario’s we’re going through my head!
Rang school in a panic shoes on ready to run over! They asked me to hold while the called his class and he was there all along but had been missed off the register! They said he must have “snuck” in past the teacher! He didn’t sneak we just went to school as normal!
anyway I know people are human and errors can happen but surely they should check before causing such alarm! I’m shocked that this isn’t standard procedure and more shocked that if he had actually been missing it would have taken them 30 mins to inform me. Spoke to head teacher and she was awful and so insincere in her apology and just came across very defensive! I want to take it further as I’m unhappy about the whole situation.
AINU to feel so angry with the school or am I being ott? Thanks!

OP posts:
MajorCarolDanvers · 07/09/2022 18:00

It happens at our school all the time since they went electronic with the register

I panicked the first time too.

Now I just get pissed off having to come out of work meetings to call and wait for them to confirm my child is in class.

threatmatrix · 07/09/2022 17:57

Doesn’t anyone on here think six is way to young to travel on their own.

Jalepenojello · 06/09/2022 22:42

Why? Unfortunately parents forget to call in sick all the time. Everyday. It’s far more likely than a child being forgotten on a register. It’s demeaning to the teachers to ask for them to double check for every absent child after they have done a register. Your issue was resolved quickly.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 22:35

Where are you getting this from? Did you read the thread? He was on time the teacher missed him off in error…..nothing to do with lateness or me being irresponsible…

OP posts:
Jalepenojello · 06/09/2022 22:33

YABU. It’s your responsibility to make sure he is at school on time. It likely took 30 minutes for the class to get settle, do registration and then pass all info onto the office who then worked through a list of none attendances who has not called in sick. Was he late and snuck in? Did he miss register? He should be making it known he is present during registration. What actually happened?

Navigatingnewwaters · 06/09/2022 22:26

Confusion101 · 06/09/2022 16:46

The texts are sent automatically! It's not like the receptionist went and physically got your number and sent the text. Attendance called, input to comp, comp sends text automatically to the number in the system for your son. Human error or comp error is possible.

So what u want to happen is...
Teacher calls roll
Teacher inputs roll to system
Receptionist views the roll
Receptionist rings teacher, "just checking that Tom, Dick and Harry are the people that are absent"
Teacher must then call the roll again??
Receptionist then rings the next classroom?

Receptionists are probably the most busy staff member in our school. And teachers have 30 odd kids to be dealing with? In an ideal world they could do that but in an ideal world the human error would have happened in the first place.

I said in a previous post it can easily happen, but in my 7 years I have done it once and I input 6 rolls a day to the system! Tom was absent, I accidentally marked Harry as absent who was next on the roll! Text was automatically sent, it had nothing to do with the receptionist.

What system do you have that sends the texts automatically?? It is usually done manually by the attendance officer or the school office. It is 99.9% usually teacher error.

Spudina · 06/09/2022 22:04

Massive over reaction on your part.

Tinkerbell1980 · 06/09/2022 22:01

I'd rather get a message in error, when my child is safe on school! Checking every absentee against sickness/appointment/running late/on holiday messages is time consuming Often, support staff sending the messages have to rely entirely on the register being correct - which doesn't always happen due to many reasons - child was late, in the toilet, daydreaming, just didn't answer their name...etc.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/09/2022 21:17

modgepodge · 06/09/2022 20:34

Well yes, in your particular case that’s how the conversation would have gone, but the vast majority of the time children marked absent are in fact absent. I don’t think I have ever marked a child absent who was in fact present. So the conversation would go ‘hello? Yes, I marked him as absent and he is absent. Yes and also the other one I marked as absent is absent.’ ie, a pointless conversation most of the time. I understand that it must have been really scary for you, but your son has sat through over 1000 registers in his life and this is presumably the first time he’s been recorded incorrectly so checking every absence is not necessary. The bigger risk, actually, is children being marked present when they aren’t, and office staff don’t double check all of those.

Don't forget about the complaint via SLT saying the admin person disturbing their lesson and publicly questioning their register was extremely unprofessional and embarrassing for the teacher.

felineweird · 06/09/2022 20:39

God where to start...we do not have phones in classrooms in my school, most parents do not necessarily let me know their child is absent, we do have teachers that fuck up the register (for the record if a child who is at school is deemed absent it is FAR more likely the teacher's fault than office staff), we do not have an automated system and have to call parents in this situation and by the time the incoming phone has gone 20 times, and the buzzer 10 times, you can't always get attendance done mega early. School Office staff get a bad rap sometimes and our pay is hardly great

modgepodge · 06/09/2022 20:34

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 20:06

I hear what your saying but they would only need to check on the kids who’s parents hadn’t already contacted the school which would be rare instances. Additionally would that that conversation not have gone more like…..ah yes I marked X as absent but I can see he’s here so please change that as it’s incorrect. Thanks for checking?

Well yes, in your particular case that’s how the conversation would have gone, but the vast majority of the time children marked absent are in fact absent. I don’t think I have ever marked a child absent who was in fact present. So the conversation would go ‘hello? Yes, I marked him as absent and he is absent. Yes and also the other one I marked as absent is absent.’ ie, a pointless conversation most of the time. I understand that it must have been really scary for you, but your son has sat through over 1000 registers in his life and this is presumably the first time he’s been recorded incorrectly so checking every absence is not necessary. The bigger risk, actually, is children being marked present when they aren’t, and office staff don’t double check all of those.

user1471452428 · 06/09/2022 20:28

This happened to me too, except the school secretary said she would call me back within an hour. In that time I drove to the school like a maniac and found her myself (in the playground.) It is horrible and I aged about 5 years in 5 minutes but these things happen. I'm glad he is safe and well and good for him walking to school!

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 20:20

He didn’t know - he was on time and though he was just checked off? Teacher must have just missed him

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 06/09/2022 20:14

Has your son explained how he missed the register @AlbertaAnnie

Christmasiscominghohoho · 06/09/2022 20:07

Oh ffs. Chill out.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 20:06

I hear what your saying but they would only need to check on the kids who’s parents hadn’t already contacted the school which would be rare instances. Additionally would that that conversation not have gone more like…..ah yes I marked X as absent but I can see he’s here so please change that as it’s incorrect. Thanks for checking?

OP posts:
modgepodge · 06/09/2022 19:38

As a teacher with a phone in the classroom, it’s really distracting to answer it when teaching. The teachers morning would look like this almost every day:

register, submit
start teaching
phone rings
answer phone
confirm that yes, x y and z are missing, as I just filled in on the register 5 minutes ago
go back to teaching by which point you’ve lost the flow and the kids concentration.

i get that for you today this would have saved you the worry but 95% of the time it is unnecessary as registers are completed correctly. even in a small school there’s possibly someone missing in every class so that’s 7 phone calls for the busy receptionist to make, to confirm what they have already been told.

it is better you had a few minutes of worry than children who actually were absent (abducted on the way to school, harmed by parents overnight, something had happened to single parent overnight and young child is locked in at home unsupervised with no one to help them or the parent….etc etc) were not followed up.

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 19:24

Thank you for your point of view - it’s good to see it from different sides, I wish you were the head at my kids school, they have been a contributing factor to making it worse!

OP posts:
Magnanimouse · 06/09/2022 19:20

From a headteacher's perspective:

There are two competing pressures here, as in the thread.

Most register systems allow a bulk text to all the parents of absent children asking them to notify the reason for absence. Sending that means it can be done quickly as soon as all registers have been completed (often by 9.10 or 9.15 realistically) and therefore if a child were missing, that becomes clear very quickly. Tracking down each and every child to check they really weren't in school would delay this massively - you wouldn't get to the end of the list before 10am in a school of any reasonable size.

Obviously, the other side is that we shouldn't be telling parents their child is missing when they are safely in school - that is about as stressful as it gets.

So schools have to make the judgment call as to whether to verify every absence and therefore it may be later when a child who really is missing gets noticed; or potentially cause a parent to become extremely distressed thinking something is wrong when it isn't. The first is potentially a life threatening situation, so takes precedence.

However, you are completely right to be annoyed and expect the school to be apologising profusely if this is a one-off (it's happened once to us, and I called them myself to apologise). If it's regular, then the teacher isn't doing the register properly.

Talipesmum · 06/09/2022 19:04

Topseyt123 · 06/09/2022 19:01

Nowhere has OP said that she can't trust her son to walk to school alone! You've plucked that from thin air.

With regard to phones in classrooms for emergency use by staff, surely it is about time. Glad to hear it is happening. It has to be much more efficient than sending a child down to the school office with a written message, or worse still the teacher having to leave the entire class unattended in order to go themselves.

Ah that makes more sense, thinking of the phone as something the teacher would use to call the office / reception with, rather than vice versa.

Topseyt123 · 06/09/2022 19:01

RedHelenB · 06/09/2022 17:26

You often get them in mobiles where you're mire isolated. They d only be used in real emergencies so yes a teacher would answer straight away.
As to the OP, if she can't trust her son to walk to school aline then he shouldn't be doing it. That's school protocol, wait for the registers to be sent in and then notify parents of any unauthorised absence.

Nowhere has OP said that she can't trust her son to walk to school alone! You've plucked that from thin air.

With regard to phones in classrooms for emergency use by staff, surely it is about time. Glad to hear it is happening. It has to be much more efficient than sending a child down to the school office with a written message, or worse still the teacher having to leave the entire class unattended in order to go themselves.

Navigatingnewwaters · 06/09/2022 18:29

Now THAT is outrageous

AlbertaAnnie · 06/09/2022 17:42

I completely trust my son to walk to school? Not sure where you even got the idea from that him walking to school was a issue?

OP posts:
cansu · 06/09/2022 17:28

How are you going to take it further? This kind of thing happens. Kids go to sort out their pe kit or stop to chat and don't get registered. They then might slip into class after the register has been taken. You have already complained to the head. The next stage would be the governors. All you will get is an apology and an explanation that they made a mistake and these things happen which is exactly the same as you have already had. Let it go.

RedHelenB · 06/09/2022 17:26

Talipesmum · 06/09/2022 17:16

I’m intrigued by this “phone in the classroom” thing. Who answers it - is one of the kids on duty? Can’t imagine the teacher would be wanting to break off mid-announcement to the class to answer the phone.

You often get them in mobiles where you're mire isolated. They d only be used in real emergencies so yes a teacher would answer straight away.
As to the OP, if she can't trust her son to walk to school aline then he shouldn't be doing it. That's school protocol, wait for the registers to be sent in and then notify parents of any unauthorised absence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread