Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my DC back to school with Covid?

206 replies

TheChemicalsAintGotYouBaby · 06/09/2022 11:17

DS tested positive on Sat, and was still a glaring positive last night.

He's due back at high school tomorrow. V few symptoms apart from a snotty nose, and DH and I seem to have swerved it.

He's desperate not to miss the first day of term, and I'm aware that official guidance means that you no longer have to isolate etc if you test positive, if all reasonable steps (masks, distancing etc) are taken. However, I wouldn't be confident he'd remember to do this (little scatterbrain!)

On the flipside though, I don't want to unleash a new infection that will no doubt spread through the school like wildfire.

WWYD?

YANBU - send him. Covids going nowhere and we need to carry on

YABU - keep him off until he's negative

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fizbosshoes · 08/09/2022 07:42

Although it's easy to say "of course you shouldn't send them, how selfish" it's never -even at the start of covid, and especially not now- been as black and white as that for a lot of people.

Humans are generally selfish - most, possibly all of us. In that we look after our own or our immediate family needs first. If people can't afford to take time off work, then they may well go into work with mild cold symptoms that might be covid, or send a child to school with a runny nose or sore throat that might be covid. Some work places expect people in after day 5 regardless of whether their test is positive. My sis works in a public facing role. She had covid earlier this year, and was still testing positive after day 5. She travels on public transport and is facing members if the public all day and had to go in whilst still testing positive.

worriedatthistime · 07/09/2022 23:10

@SnowqueenOfTexas but symptoms for covid can be anything really , I wouldn't stay home for a headache for example and if I took. Day off every time i had one ,I wouldn't have a job
Same with kids for years we have been encouraged to send them in, now its back to checking attendance again
I will keep mine off when they are unwell and always have , follow the 48 hrs after D&V
But i simply cannot keep them home with a headache or slight sore throat every time or when have hayfever symptoms, not can i test all the time as we cannot afford them all the time
If mine appear to have cold/ flu then i will keep home or test but its impossible to stay home for everything , I would be out if a job and fined for kids attendance
Also i know so many work places where people are now being told to go in
We try our best and if clearly unwell we do stay home but for a headache , sneezing in morning ( my son is like that every morning. , due fo allergies ) we can't stay home
One day my ds sneezes could go on all day and we only then realise its not allergies

Saynotothefishtank · 07/09/2022 21:40

Of course he shouldn’t go to school with an active covid infection. He’ll give it to the whole class, they’ll give it to their parents, their parents will have to take time off work and all the other parents will hate you for a very long time.

Why can’t you just keep him off til Monday?! It’s the obvious thing to do.

hop321 · 07/09/2022 21:19

I’m so sad. It’s incredibly painful to feel like it’s unreasonable to want my child to be safe at school. In the parents group I am in, there is an overwhelming feeling that our children are a nuisance.

I understand where you're coming from, it must be really hard in your situation.

I'm not trying to cause offence by answering your question honestly. I suspect others may not admit to choosing not to test for a minor symptom such as a runny nose. I don't know of any school parents testing that regularly since obligatory school testing and free covid tests ended.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 21:11

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:40

But surely most people are aware that even if for them a bad stomach or runny nose is fine, it might not be for others. You’re right in that we can’t test for everything, but if you’re symptomatic why wouldn’t you err on the side of caution in terms of potentially infecting vulnerable people?

And by erring on the side of caution, I mean being careful when you know that you have symptoms that could mean you’re unwell. Why wouldn’t you try and avoid making others ill? And for something as essential as school or work, is it so much to ask that you’d try your best not to make it a dangerous place for those more vulnerable?

I don’t understand what you want. I don’t understand why it’s unreasonable to ask that if you’re symptomatic, you think twice before potentially spreading something around.

Expecting people to test/miss a couple of days of school or work when they know they are unwell or contagious is far more reasonable than expecting vulnerable people to risk their lives to go to school or work.

I'm not sure most people would necessarily pick up that a headache for a couple of hours or a couple of looser than usual shits could be a risk to others no, especially as those are non-respiratory, but they could both be symptomatic covid. Especially as so many of the possible symptoms have other explanations too. A headache might be due to tiredness, menstrual cycle, having sat gawping at your phone for the last hour, or it might be due to covid, and I think it's unrealistic to expect people would always think of the latter.

But even if you do, yep I think it's completely unworkable to expect people to test every time they notice they've got a headache, particularly given the fact that, as you've acknowledged, testing in itself renders some people vulnerable due to the potential financial impact. Sure, don't send your kid into school glowing with fever or a few hours after they last threw up, if you can wfh instead of sharing your cough with the office then do so etc. You're not going to get much disagreement there. That's reasonable. Expecting people to test whenever they're a bit more tired than usual, not so much.

giveovernate · 07/09/2022 21:10

@SnowqueenOfTexas but people go out with not proper covid all time? Because they don't know?

I don't test randomly, not paying for tests, not with current cost of living rises.

So I could be going out with covid, or flu?

You're talking about "proper" flu as in when people feel very unwell so they don't go out?

What about if people don't feel unwell with covid so do go out? They wouldn't go out if they were very unwell obviously.

Your argument is very flawed and you're kidding yourself if you think people are paying for tests for covid!

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:59

giveovernate · 07/09/2022 20:57

*Okay, so as above - is it a Schrodinger's cat type of approach then? If you don’t test, as far as you’re concerned it’s not covid - even if there are symptoms?

I just can’t think of another example where this ‘if I don’t test, I don’t know’ approach would be acceptable when it potentially risks another persons wellbeing.

If for example, somebody had unprotected casual sex and later developed non-specific symptoms that could be an STD but could also be a number of other more benign things would it be okay for them to continue sleeping with other people because they don’t know they have an std? Or would that person have a responsibility to get checked out before potentially passing something on?*

Would flu be an example?

I don’t know anyone who would go out mixing with others if they had the flu. As in, the proper flu.

giveovernate · 07/09/2022 20:57

*Okay, so as above - is it a Schrodinger's cat type of approach then? If you don’t test, as far as you’re concerned it’s not covid - even if there are symptoms?

I just can’t think of another example where this ‘if I don’t test, I don’t know’ approach would be acceptable when it potentially risks another persons wellbeing.

If for example, somebody had unprotected casual sex and later developed non-specific symptoms that could be an STD but could also be a number of other more benign things would it be okay for them to continue sleeping with other people because they don’t know they have an std? Or would that person have a responsibility to get checked out before potentially passing something on?*

Would flu be an example?

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:47

hop321 · 07/09/2022 20:33

Can I ask you something please? If it was your child, for whom covid or norovirus or whatever was life threatening; would you not want people to show a little bit of consideration? Not even so they could go on a cruise or on holiday, just so that you could send them to school knowing that nobody would knowingly put them at risk?

Fair question. Honestly, I wouldn't expect school kids to do a covid test every time they have a runny nose (particularly ones that suffer from hay fever in the summer).

It's where you draw the line and, given that tests are no longer free, I'm guessing the government don't expect others to be testing for runny noses either.

I'm not trying to be heartless, I'm just answering the question honestly.

Thank you for your honesty.

Testing seems like such a small kindness given that the alternative is potentially putting a child in hospital. When my daughter caught covid in the summer, she was in hospital for a month and has been in and out since. The trauma, the fear, the disruption and loss of earnings. Having been through that and knowing that we’ll go through similar again is really, really tough.

If I could save somebody else from going through that by testing if I was sniffly, staying home if my tummy was ‘off’ etc - it feels like a no brainer.

I’m so sad. It’s incredibly painful to feel like it’s unreasonable to want my child to be safe at school. In the parents group I am in, there is an overwhelming feeling that our children are a nuisance.

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:40

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 20:22

The problem with this argument is that the value judgement you make here is based on an abstract definition of what ill is that doesn't necessarily correspond to either what covid symptoms can be or what people might identify them as. So even if I trusted that it would only be applied to people who met that standard, which I don't because that is not our lived experience of the last two and a half years is, the symptoms for covid are so wide in range and severity that people can be showing symptoms and not consider themselves ill at all. I don't think most people would consider themselves ill simply because of having a headache, an off stomach, a runny nose for a couple of hours, and yet these are all common enough symptoms of covid.

But surely most people are aware that even if for them a bad stomach or runny nose is fine, it might not be for others. You’re right in that we can’t test for everything, but if you’re symptomatic why wouldn’t you err on the side of caution in terms of potentially infecting vulnerable people?

And by erring on the side of caution, I mean being careful when you know that you have symptoms that could mean you’re unwell. Why wouldn’t you try and avoid making others ill? And for something as essential as school or work, is it so much to ask that you’d try your best not to make it a dangerous place for those more vulnerable?

I don’t understand what you want. I don’t understand why it’s unreasonable to ask that if you’re symptomatic, you think twice before potentially spreading something around.

Expecting people to test/miss a couple of days of school or work when they know they are unwell or contagious is far more reasonable than expecting vulnerable people to risk their lives to go to school or work.

hop321 · 07/09/2022 20:33

Can I ask you something please? If it was your child, for whom covid or norovirus or whatever was life threatening; would you not want people to show a little bit of consideration? Not even so they could go on a cruise or on holiday, just so that you could send them to school knowing that nobody would knowingly put them at risk?

Fair question. Honestly, I wouldn't expect school kids to do a covid test every time they have a runny nose (particularly ones that suffer from hay fever in the summer).

It's where you draw the line and, given that tests are no longer free, I'm guessing the government don't expect others to be testing for runny noses either.

I'm not trying to be heartless, I'm just answering the question honestly.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 20:22

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:59

It’s also sufficiently dangerous to expect that a certain demographic must choose between risking their lives or going to school/work. That’s far more sinister than asking people to stay at home when they know that they are ill.

The problem with this argument is that the value judgement you make here is based on an abstract definition of what ill is that doesn't necessarily correspond to either what covid symptoms can be or what people might identify them as. So even if I trusted that it would only be applied to people who met that standard, which I don't because that is not our lived experience of the last two and a half years is, the symptoms for covid are so wide in range and severity that people can be showing symptoms and not consider themselves ill at all. I don't think most people would consider themselves ill simply because of having a headache, an off stomach, a runny nose for a couple of hours, and yet these are all common enough symptoms of covid.

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:19

worriedatthistime · 07/09/2022 20:08

@SnowqueenOfTexas colds and flu risk some peoples lifes , people only stay home when actually sick
Have you never gone out or to work with a sniffle or sore throat or cough ? Because technically that is a risk to someone you unknowingly may have come into contact with
I think most people are just only staying home if actually unwell as before now

I’m aware. My daughter is vulnerable to colds and flu too, so we try our best to limit our exposure to these things and thankfully our friends & family are careful. So as you can imagine, things are already very difficult and we have to think carefully before attending crowded indoor events depending on her bloods and the time of year.

But for school, for work - I would hope that given how essential these things are and that it’s not as easy to simply opt out if we don’t want to put her at risk, yeah - I’d hope that people would be more considerate.

Foolishly, I thought that the pandemic might have actually made people more considerate towards others and the impact illness can have on vulnerable people.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 20:13

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:53

I’m talking about the people who show symptoms of covid and don’t test or those who know they have it and still mix with vulnerable people.

I’m not suggesting that everyone tests every day forever, that’s pointless. You’d never be able to test for every condition and knowing there’s a risk is part of life.

But people knowing or suspecting they have something and going ahead anyway? That’s different.

Ok, in that case what you said before about only wanting people to stay at home if they're potentially infectious isn't accurate. Because that is literally everyone. You are of course free to make a moral distinction between people who have a certain level of observed symptoms and people are asymptomatic/don't identify any symptom as possible covid, but this is a quite separate point from potential to infect.

worriedatthistime · 07/09/2022 20:12

@dockspider but it does sometimes happen with what we would consider a routine illness, it happens more than we know we just don't always hear about it

worriedatthistime · 07/09/2022 20:08

@SnowqueenOfTexas colds and flu risk some peoples lifes , people only stay home when actually sick
Have you never gone out or to work with a sniffle or sore throat or cough ? Because technically that is a risk to someone you unknowingly may have come into contact with
I think most people are just only staying home if actually unwell as before now

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 07/09/2022 20:05

But surely you can see my point then?! You test because your mum has blood cancer and presumably you’d hope that anyone visiting your mum would do the same.

Well I test because I'm staying with her and I would hate to give it to her but she certainly doesn't expect me to and certainly doesn't expect others visiting her to. If she's fine with that so am I. I offer to do shopping for her when I'm there but she likes to come with me after all the shielding. She wears a mask and has had all her vaccs but figures life has to go on.

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 20:05

hop321 · 07/09/2022 19:59

But you said you wouldn’t send a child in if you knew they had covid. If they have a sniffle or whatever, how do you know they don’t have it?

I don't. But I don't think testing for a sniffle is a reasonable benchmark. We tested on holiday as we were on a cruise and all had coughs (we were negative).

Honestly, I don't think we're alone in not testing for every possible symptom. For one thing, we'd get through multiple tests a week if we tested for every runny nose.

Clearly you’re far from the only ones.

I can’t pretend to get it, though.

Can I ask you something please? If it was your child, for whom covid or norovirus or whatever was life threatening; would you not want people to show a little bit of consideration? Not even so they could go on a cruise or on holiday, just so that you could send them to school knowing that nobody would knowingly put them at risk?

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:59

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 19:48

The idea that a person has a moral obligation to test before merely existing in public is a sufficiently dangerous one that it needs to be resisted. Because given that everyone who interacts with other human beings is potentially contagious and that there's no guarantee any test will pick an infection up in time even with the usual caveats about a person having access to them etc, that's what it means.

It’s also sufficiently dangerous to expect that a certain demographic must choose between risking their lives or going to school/work. That’s far more sinister than asking people to stay at home when they know that they are ill.

hop321 · 07/09/2022 19:59

But you said you wouldn’t send a child in if you knew they had covid. If they have a sniffle or whatever, how do you know they don’t have it?

I don't. But I don't think testing for a sniffle is a reasonable benchmark. We tested on holiday as we were on a cruise and all had coughs (we were negative).

Honestly, I don't think we're alone in not testing for every possible symptom. For one thing, we'd get through multiple tests a week if we tested for every runny nose.

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:57

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 07/09/2022 19:50

But most people probably no longer have free tests at home and at the moment have other priorities for their money. I only have tests (that I bought) because of visiting care homes and my mum who has a blood cancer.

With regards to DD and school I'll keep her home if she feels ill Covid or not but as far as her school is concerned, if she feels OK, she should go in.

But surely you can see my point then?! You test because your mum has blood cancer and presumably you’d hope that anyone visiting your mum would do the same.

I feel that same way about my daughter. Surely - given your mum and your job - you’d know better than to put others at risk? Given you can’t possibly be sure nobody at your daughters school is vulnerable?

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:53

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 19:48

The idea that a person has a moral obligation to test before merely existing in public is a sufficiently dangerous one that it needs to be resisted. Because given that everyone who interacts with other human beings is potentially contagious and that there's no guarantee any test will pick an infection up in time even with the usual caveats about a person having access to them etc, that's what it means.

I’m talking about the people who show symptoms of covid and don’t test or those who know they have it and still mix with vulnerable people.

I’m not suggesting that everyone tests every day forever, that’s pointless. You’d never be able to test for every condition and knowing there’s a risk is part of life.

But people knowing or suspecting they have something and going ahead anyway? That’s different.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 07/09/2022 19:50

But most people probably no longer have free tests at home and at the moment have other priorities for their money. I only have tests (that I bought) because of visiting care homes and my mum who has a blood cancer.

With regards to DD and school I'll keep her home if she feels ill Covid or not but as far as her school is concerned, if she feels OK, she should go in.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 19:48

The idea that a person has a moral obligation to test before merely existing in public is a sufficiently dangerous one that it needs to be resisted. Because given that everyone who interacts with other human beings is potentially contagious and that there's no guarantee any test will pick an infection up in time even with the usual caveats about a person having access to them etc, that's what it means.

SnowqueenOfTexas · 07/09/2022 19:29

giveovernate · 07/09/2022 19:22

Cannot remember the last time I tested, why would you be testing 50% of the time...

Batshit crazy imo!

Okay, so as above - is it a Schrodinger's cat type of approach then? If you don’t test, as far as you’re concerned it’s not covid - even if there are symptoms?

I just can’t think of another example where this ‘if I don’t test, I don’t know’ approach would be acceptable when it potentially risks another persons wellbeing.

If for example, somebody had unprotected casual sex and later developed non-specific symptoms that could be an STD but could also be a number of other more benign things would it be okay for them to continue sleeping with other people because they don’t know they have an std? Or would that person have a responsibility to get checked out before potentially passing something on?