Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of Mumsnet do not understand libel?

87 replies

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

OP posts:
MayThe4th · 06/09/2022 10:19

If you say you believe someone is sleazy then they could very much take you to court for defamation as this could be damaging to their reputation and you would need to back it up with fact. There’s a difference between thinking something and putting it in writing.
I voiced the belief that someone was disingenuous a couple of years ago. I can’t go into further detail, but he pursued me for over a year, demanded copies of my income etc to prove I couldn’t pay him compensation. Sent a letter suggesting I pay him £7000 in damages.

Some of it was bluster on his part but he was a lawyer so I had no option but to seek legal advice which put me out of pocket anyway.

As it turned out I was right and his downfall came after his year to take me to court was up.

But after that I would always caution anyone against saying anything derogatory online because once you’ve written it it’s out there forever.

justaladyLOL · 06/09/2022 10:11

Libel is an opinion that is why court cases are so long and expensive

ShirleyPhallus · 06/09/2022 10:10

About 90% of what’s spouted on here is nonsense though isn’t it

You only need to look at the threads on asking for management advice for a staff issue to see all the people saying “well I’d fire them / whatever” to see that people rarely have the correct experience or qualifications to give the advice they’re suggesting

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 06/09/2022 10:08

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:59

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow I said probably on purpose. Sally Bercow was clearly implying as fact a sexual abuse allegation. Simply because you do not say, x did this, but imply it through words, is not necessarily enough to protect you against libel.

Are you a lawyer, OP? Because you sound like someone who doesn't know a lot about defamation, with an overly simplistic view of the Law. You may think that saying someone is sleazy is not defamatory. Good luck proving that that is an honest opinion, and not a statement of fact.

Hope that first year law essay goes well. It's nice that you're keen.

Dotjones · 06/09/2022 10:06

You're wrong to assume that an opinion is not defamatory because you have the right to hold it. Libel would require you to have published your view, and publishing an opinion is not protected in the same way as holding an opinion is.

Eg I can think that Ms XYZ is a thieving scumbag, but if I publish it in a social media post I am at risk of losing legal action if I can't back up my view with facts. (For the avoidance of doubt, Ms XYZ here is a fictional character, any similarity with any real person living or dead is entirely coincidental.)

Pruella · 06/09/2022 10:05

It’s correct to say that people don’t understand libel particularly well which is fair enough if they aren’t lawyers. I don’t think you’ve got a great grasp either though, calling someone sleazy could be libellous in certain circumstances.

Discovereads · 06/09/2022 10:03

@antelopevalley
This is all too common that people don’t know the definitions of terms they toss into their word salads.

JaniceBattersby · 06/09/2022 09:59

Key to defending a libel claim is not just that what you said is true, but that you can prove in court, on the balance of probabilities, that what you said it true. And also that you have a ton of money in order to be able to defend that claim, because there’s no legal aid in the civil court.

I work as a journalist and see things on here every day that are defamatory, things that I’d be ripped
to pieces for it I stuck them in a newspaper (despite the fact the newspaper I work for likely gets lower PVs than MN)

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:59

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow I said probably on purpose. Sally Bercow was clearly implying as fact a sexual abuse allegation. Simply because you do not say, x did this, but imply it through words, is not necessarily enough to protect you against libel.

OP posts:
wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 06/09/2022 09:56

I'm with you there @sst1234

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 06/09/2022 09:54

OK but what's your point?

All sorts of words have a technical meaning that is different from their use in everyday conversation. Have you ever talked about your stomach, when you actually mean your abdomen, for example? Or about someone suffering from shock, medically, when you actually mean they are psychologically distressed? (shock has a very specific medical meaning that has nothing to do with feeling upset)

Also, your explanation of defamation is pretty simplistic and actually sounds more like defamation in the US. Because of the strong legal protections of free speech, opinion in the US can rarely be defamatory. It is not as clear cut in the UK, as Sally Bercow and others have found out, to their cost.

sst1234 · 06/09/2022 09:42

People on MN especially use a lot of words they don’t understand. Probably because they have heard them and would like to shoehorn them into the conversation. Narcissist, gaslighting and anxiety for example.