Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of Mumsnet do not understand libel?

87 replies

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

OP posts:
StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:36

I think it would depend on the country and whether they have criminal laws against libel and defamation, or whether libel is a civil matter; what's posted; the poster's nationality.

There have been cases of countries extraditing people over online posts that broke that country's laws, but only where the poster is a citizen of that country, and all the cases I know about involved breaking hate crime laws, not libel laws.

The UK actually extradited some British Neo Nazis who had fled to the US because they were facing arrest here for breaking hate crime laws. The made sure their Neo Nazi site was hosted in California because they believed that would protect them, since US law does not criminalise what they were posting. However because they were British and committed something that's a criminal offence in the UK while on UK soil, they were still under UK law, regardless of the fact the website was hosted abroad. The dumbasses actually approached a police officer when they arrived in LA to say they were fleeing criminal charges in Britain and would like to apply for political asylum in America!

If someone wanted to bring a libel suit over something said on MN then their legal action would be against Mumsnet for disseminating the libellous post, and it would be up to MN to decide whether to hand over the poster's IP address - MN couldn't be forced to do so without a warrant.

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 13:36

YANBU to think most people don't understand defamation.

YABU to pretend that you do understand it.

For example, your claim that calling someone sleazy wouldn't be defamatory is simplistic at best.

You didn't point out, for example, that the burden of proof shifts from the claimant to the defendant once they establish that the published material is prima facie defamatory. So if you called X sleazy, X would need to prove that (a) you called them sleazy; (b) you did so in a way that falls within the meaning of 'published'; and (c) that sleazy would diminish their reputation in the eyes of the reasonable person. It is very easy to prove all three of those things.

There are, of course, defences. Truth is the most obvious one. Honest opinion is the one you'd need to rely on in this example. But saying 'X is sleazy' isn't immediately obviously just an opinion. It implies some basis in fact (and indeed, a requirement of the defence is that an honest person could hold that opinion).

Saying 'X is sleazy' almost certainty doesn't constitute honest opinion. Saying 'X is sleazy because he is dating a woman 25 years younger than him' might count as honest opinion (assuming the fact he is dating the woman is true), since you might reasonable conclude from that an honest opinion that dating someone 25 years younger is 'sleazy'. So it very much depends on the circumstances.

But something just being an opinion doesn't transform a defamatory comment into a legally sound and safe comment. It would be for the defendant to prove that the defence of honest opinion applies, and it is much trickier than OP makes out.

Pruella · 06/09/2022 13:35

You can say whatever you like about Jimmy as you can’t defame the dead.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 13:32

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 13:15

The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may.

Is calling someone a paedophile or a rapist when there hasn't even been a charge against them, never mind a conviction, libellous?

Potentially.
I say potentially because if you say Jimmy Saville was a paedophile then you will be fine, even though he was never even charged,

OP posts:
Boreded · 06/09/2022 13:28

sst1234 · 06/09/2022 09:42

People on MN especially use a lot of words they don’t understand. Probably because they have heard them and would like to shoehorn them into the conversation. Narcissist, gaslighting and anxiety for example.

And almost anything to do with economics lol

Fladdermus · 06/09/2022 13:17

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:13

Iirc the country the site is hosted in. So UK for Mumsnet.

Some sites that host contentious content deliberately use web hosting companies and web servers based in countries with lax libel laws (when the owners of the site are not in those countries), to avoid being sued.

So how would someone take action in the UK against someone who isn't in the UK? Especially if what they've said doesn't break any laws in their own country. Nobody's going to extradict us to the UK for posting shite on Mumsnet.

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 13:15

The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may.

Is calling someone a paedophile or a rapist when there hasn't even been a charge against them, never mind a conviction, libellous?

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:13

Iirc the country the site is hosted in. So UK for Mumsnet.

Some sites that host contentious content deliberately use web hosting companies and web servers based in countries with lax libel laws (when the owners of the site are not in those countries), to avoid being sued.

Fladdermus · 06/09/2022 13:09

I wonder how it works on an internet forum with posters all over the world. Which defamation rules apply?

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:02

The funniest thing that ever happened to me on MN was someone posting to say they'd phoned the police about me, because I'd mentioned something that had actually been court testimony but was obviously according to this poster wicked lies and perjury to defame the virginal mother-of-three Kate Middleton (French magazine editor testifying in the topless photo case - apparently it was libel and a crime to mention that the editor had testified in court that he had unpublished photos of Kate giving her husband a blowie, because heaven forfend a married couple enjoy each other sexually).

People are barking.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 12:47

The damaging people's opinion is an interesting one. I can remember vaguely a famous libel case that was dismissed by the court. Although the court found no evidence to support the allegations being made, they also said the public's view of the individual was so poor that the allegation did not damage people's opinions of them as it was already so poor.

OP posts:
Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 12:34

Worth remembering that (substantial) truth is a defence to defamation, and also the statement has to be one that damages people's opinion of the claimant.

I always think the most interesting point is that MPs in parliament have privilege so they can say whatever they want, with no fear, which I always find a bit strange. Would be interested to know why that is and the historical reason behind it.

Comefromaway · 06/09/2022 11:04

Yes. I had someone online threaten to sue me for libel because someone had asked for advice on where to study a particular subject and I said I personally would would not trust a certain unaccredited college, who made up their own diplomas with a bargepole.

That was my opinion and I stood by it. It was not libel.

Hawkins001 · 06/09/2022 11:03

Reading with intrigue

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 11:01

I wouldn't say being disingenuous was exactly the same as lying. It's more when you use things out of context or use weasel words so to twist the meaning.

For example there was a thread on here about somebody who had unfortunately died during an activity, and a poster said that because they had been 1000 people who did the activity at at that location , and one person had died, the chance of dying during the activity was 1 in 1000.

That might be a defensible point but it was disingenuous because there hadn't been enough people doing it, and enough people who died, for that to be statistically meaningful by itself.

HotWashCycle · 06/09/2022 10:44

I don't think you are fully up to speed on defamation, OP. For one thing libel has to be written or otherwise published (including on social media). Your post repeats several times that you can "say" something derogatory that would be libel, but that is not the case - it would be slander if spoken in real life (not on social media). Also you can say or publish anything at all, even if derogatory and damaging to someone's reputation if you can prove that it is true. This would apply equally to anyone repeating or publishing a false allegation, including retweeting it. They would need to be prepared to prove it was true. Best not to risk having a defamation suit against you to sort it out in court.

PurpleWisteria · 06/09/2022 10:42

The board police have spoken.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:42

@GhostFromTheOtherSide Anyone can threaten libel. Just as anyone can pay a solicitor to write a letter threatening court action. Some people do this all the time as it can be successful. Some people simply do not want the hassle of dealing with these kind of people.
But that does not mean it is actually libel.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:37

@hewouldwouldnthe I can't think of anyone cleared who people still say has got away with what they were accused of. I do know famous people who members of the public say they have been cleared, when in reality they have not been. The allegation has been dropped because of a lack of evidence, or even suspected government involvement.
Jimmy Saville was never charged for his crimes. Not being prosecuted means nothing.

OP posts:
GhostFromTheOtherSide · 06/09/2022 10:37

The thing is that some things are clearly not intended as they are written and yet MN has been threatened with legal action.

E.g. some of the things said about Gina Ford could have been considered as libellous, but they were so ridiculous that presumably nobody would really have taken them seriously. Except her legal team did, and mn were threatened with legal action because people opposed to her methods of doing things.

For years Gina ford was not allowed to be discussed on here for fear of reprisal. And a lot of those posts were based on opinion only.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:33

ShirleyPhallus · 06/09/2022 10:31

Are working class people not allowed to use big words?

I am working class. I had never heard anyone use the word disingenuous until MN. In my world people just say you are lying.

OP posts:
hewouldwouldnthe · 06/09/2022 10:31

I reported a post on a thread about the false allegations about our 'national treasures'. The post was genuinely libellous as it said the people involved (and cleared) had got away with what they were accused of. MN HQ didn't take it down, which really surprised me.

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 10:31

YANBU

Although the list of things many MN users get 100% wrong is endless

ShirleyPhallus · 06/09/2022 10:31

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:27

Disingenuous is a middle-class way of saying you are a liar.
@JaniceBattersby Our libel laws are far too harsh. I know you have to be able to prove it is true in court. But on MN people generally do this by posting a link to already published news articles. And MNHQ tend to accept that.

Are working class people not allowed to use big words?

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:27

Disingenuous is a middle-class way of saying you are a liar.
@JaniceBattersby Our libel laws are far too harsh. I know you have to be able to prove it is true in court. But on MN people generally do this by posting a link to already published news articles. And MNHQ tend to accept that.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread