Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of Mumsnet do not understand libel?

87 replies

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

OP posts:
Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:51

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 15:42

The slander and libel distinction is largely irrelevant here since anything posted on a website is by definition libel. The practical distinction is pretty limited though.

The bigger issue is that OP started a thread about how people don’t understand libel while demonstrating that she has no real understanding about, for example, the defence of honest opinion.

Which of course is dangerous - if someone followed her claims and acted accordingly they could well find themselves in a legally precarious position.

My list provided a general definition for the benefit of people who clearly do not know.

This forum is not the centre of the universe, incidentally…

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 15:42

The slander and libel distinction is largely irrelevant here since anything posted on a website is by definition libel. The practical distinction is pretty limited though.

The bigger issue is that OP started a thread about how people don’t understand libel while demonstrating that she has no real understanding about, for example, the defence of honest opinion.

Which of course is dangerous - if someone followed her claims and acted accordingly they could well find themselves in a legally precarious position.

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 15:40

Ironic that most (not all) posters - including the OP - don’t understand libel & slander in the UK at all.

You can’t sue anyone for libel or slander here. People tell lies about others all the time…that’s just life and free speech is more protective than people realise. You can only sue if you’ve been actively defamed - and you would need to prove it.

Defamation occurs when you’ve suffered harm because of something that’s been said or published about you. That harm could be financial - you’ve lost work or been sacked - or your reputation has been so damaged that it’s impossible for you to live happily or peacefully in the same way as before - injury to feelings. If either if these things have occured, you’re entitled to claim compensation through the courts (and other potential remedy such as
retraction).

The burden is on you to prove defamation, you don’t actually have to prove that you’ve been lied about. The defence need to try and show (in the first instance) either that you haven’t been defamed to any serious degree or, if you have, it was justified.

Once it’s been established that you have been defamed, then the burden shifts to the defence to,prove either that what they said or published was the truth or that they had very good reasons to believe it was. You’ll obviously be able to challenge their evidence with your own arguments or witnesses.

OP - I’m not sure why you brought up “malice”. I suspect you’ve been watching Depp v Heard and have misunderstood “actual malice”, which is a legal burden in the US for public figures to clamber over if they sue for defamation. It has nothing to do with maliciousness in the every day sense of the word, but means “with knowledge”.

Calling someone “sleazy” is unlikely to be defamatory in and of itself. You’d need to qualify it with a specific reason for why you think that….”I think Joe is sleazy” is opinion usually. “I think Joe is sleazy because he’s a rapist” could be defamatory.

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:32

Let’s keep it nice and simple:

“Defamation is split into two legal bases that a person can sue for: slander and libel. Slander is defamation of a person through a transient form of communication, generally speech. Libel is defamation of a person through a permanent form of communication, mostly the written word.”
(6 Nov 2019)

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:31

Let’s keep it nice and simple:

Defamation is split into two legal bases that a person can sue for: slander and libel. Slander is defamation of a person through a transient form of communication, generally speech. Libel is defamation of a person through a permanent form of communication, mostly the written word.”
(6 Nov 2019)

MayThe4th · 06/09/2022 15:29

Calling Jimmy Saville a paedophile would not be damaging his reputation even if he was alive. Because he has no reputation left to damage. you’re wrong.

If JS had had no reputation to protect he wouldn’t have been laid in state, had the funeral he did, had hundreds and hundreds of people filing past his coffin.

Incidentally after his death there were several threads on here voicing people’s thoughts about him and they were all removed as being disrespectful.

Whatever you or others may have believed or known about him, the fact is he did still have a reputation which could be damaged had these allegations simply been made on an online platform while he was still alive.

I’m intrigued though about why you have such a bee in your bonnet about this. Have you recently had a post deleted per chance?

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:27

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

Actually, I’m not sure you understand.

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:24

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

Surely the confusion is between slander and libel. But then if some people think there is a piece of furniture called “a chest of DRAWS” or even “a CHESTER DRAWS”, it’s unlikely they are going to be able to differentiate between words or terms.

🤷🏻‍♀️

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 15:22

newtb · 06/09/2022 15:00

It's also a defence if you believe it to be true.

I've read this and I'm interested in how this works in practice.

Say I work in a PR company and I hear someone say Harry Styles is a rapist. So I then repeat or write that Harry Styles is a rapist. But it turns out that I misheard and they were actually talking about Harry Secombe, have I then committed slander or libel or am I protected and an apology is enough, even if Harry Styles suffered financial loss or had a damaged reputation.

For clarity, neither Harry Styles nor Harry Secombe (whom I loved) is/was a rapist. I'm just using them as an example.

But actually say someone read the post wrong and actually believed that HS was a rapist, could they be sued? I've read posters on MN calling famous people rapists and paedophiles and they genuinely believe they are based on things other people have said. Are they protected too?

EarringsandLipstick · 06/09/2022 15:12

newtb · 06/09/2022 15:00

It's also a defence if you believe it to be true.

With evidence to support that belief.

EarringsandLipstick · 06/09/2022 15:12

Calling Jimmy Saville a paedophile would not be damaging his reputation even if he was alive. Because he has no reputation left to damage.

You are so wrong it's unbelievable.

As PP have said, it's about being prepared to back up your claims with evidence.

You may well think JS reputation (if alive) would be unaffected by allegations of paedophilia - you have no certainty that the courts would share that belief. Whatever about his wider reputation, calling someone a particular term with such seriously negative connotations is unlikely to be blithely accepted as fine to do.

You haven't a clue

EarringsandLipstick · 06/09/2022 15:07

I am working class. I had never heard anyone use the word disingenuous until MN. In my world people just say you are lying.

I can't actually believe you typed this, and let it stand.

You hadn't heard the word; it's offensive to link that with the fact you are working-class. I'm perfectly sure other working class people may have heard the word & some middle class people may not have.

newtb · 06/09/2022 15:00

It's also a defence if you believe it to be true.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 14:40

@Mummyford A particular type of lying.
But the accusation is often used on MN to simply shut someone up people disagree with. A kind of - how can you be so stupid as to not know this?

OP posts:
Wallaw · 06/09/2022 14:39

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:36

I think it would depend on the country and whether they have criminal laws against libel and defamation, or whether libel is a civil matter; what's posted; the poster's nationality.

There have been cases of countries extraditing people over online posts that broke that country's laws, but only where the poster is a citizen of that country, and all the cases I know about involved breaking hate crime laws, not libel laws.

The UK actually extradited some British Neo Nazis who had fled to the US because they were facing arrest here for breaking hate crime laws. The made sure their Neo Nazi site was hosted in California because they believed that would protect them, since US law does not criminalise what they were posting. However because they were British and committed something that's a criminal offence in the UK while on UK soil, they were still under UK law, regardless of the fact the website was hosted abroad. The dumbasses actually approached a police officer when they arrived in LA to say they were fleeing criminal charges in Britain and would like to apply for political asylum in America!

If someone wanted to bring a libel suit over something said on MN then their legal action would be against Mumsnet for disseminating the libellous post, and it would be up to MN to decide whether to hand over the poster's IP address - MN couldn't be forced to do so without a warrant.

Yes, they would need a warrant.

I do know an American journalist who was sued in the UK because of the more draconian libel laws here.

www.politico.com/news/2022/04/01/trump-russia-writer-facing-libel-suit-in-u-k-turns-to-u-s-court-for-help-00022484

Mummyford · 06/09/2022 14:33

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 10:27

Disingenuous is a middle-class way of saying you are a liar.
@JaniceBattersby Our libel laws are far too harsh. I know you have to be able to prove it is true in court. But on MN people generally do this by posting a link to already published news articles. And MNHQ tend to accept that.

Since we're being pedantic.

Disingenuous doesn't really mean lying. It's more subtle with a calculating aspect, like being insincere while trying to give an impression of being very blunt or frank, often in the direction of pretending to be naive or know less about a topic than you actually do.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 14:27

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 13:44

Well, he's dead so I don't see who would sue. But what about someone who is alive, has never been charged so never convicted? Can you call them a rapist and a paedophile with impunity? Or is it libel? Because I don't see MN deleting posts like that. And in fact MN has a policy of always believing the woman so they actively support calling men rapists when there's no charge or conviction.

Jimmy Saville is dead, but the point is that the allegations are now widely accepted as true. Calling Jimmy Saville a paedophile would not be damaging his reputation even if he was alive. Because he has no reputation left to damage.
However, it is only the fact he is dead that has allowed people to publicly tell the truth about him.
There have been allegations against other celebrities that have gone nowhere, and some of those will be true. And some MNers may know personally they are true or suspect strongly they are from first-hand experience.
For example, I saw Gary Glitter perform years ago. The way he openly flirted with very young teenage girls made it clear where his interests lay. So although I had no proof, I was not at all surprised by his subsequent conviction. I would not have said on MN that he was a paedophile before his conviction, but I would have said that he was very flirty and friendly with very young teenage girls.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 14:21

MayThe4th · 06/09/2022 13:59

Yes it’s libel, and IMO mn is often treading on dangerous ground to let certain posts stand where men are branded abusers, paedophiles etc.

In many cases though a poster might post that their father raped them or that they were sexually abused by a family member, and in that case it’s someone with a nickname posting about an unnamed person, which is different to posting that <insert celebrity name> is a paedophile.

But when celebrities are named, it is always individuals that have been charged. So the opinion part is whether you think they are guilty or not.
I have seen comments saying people find an individual celebrity creepy and would not be surprised if they were exposed as a paedophile.

OP posts:
Fladdermus · 06/09/2022 14:14

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:41

I googled because I was bored and find it interesting:

"Jurisdiction refers to the power of the foreign court to hear the case and exert power over you. In some countries, the fact that the material at issue is posted on the Internet and available worldwide—including in the country in question—is enough for the courts of that country to have jurisdiction over a case, at least according to that country's laws.

For example, in 2002 the Australia Supreme Court held that an American company, Dow Jones, Inc., could be sued in Australia over an article that appeared in the printed version and on the web site of its publication Barron's, which was accessible online in Australia. In 2010, Germany's highest court overruled two lower courts to hold that The New York Times could be sued in that country by a German citizen over a 2001 article available online, citing the article's references to Germany and the 14,484 registered users of the Times website with German addresses.

As an example of how complicated this can get, in August 2009 an American-based computer game company sued a British blogger in an Australian court.
A judgment against you in a foreign country could remain dormant unless you enter the country at a later time, for whatever reason."

So if I post that Putin is a peadophile I may well be at risk of being deported to Moscow. Yikes!

MayThe4th · 06/09/2022 13:59

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 13:44

Well, he's dead so I don't see who would sue. But what about someone who is alive, has never been charged so never convicted? Can you call them a rapist and a paedophile with impunity? Or is it libel? Because I don't see MN deleting posts like that. And in fact MN has a policy of always believing the woman so they actively support calling men rapists when there's no charge or conviction.

Yes it’s libel, and IMO mn is often treading on dangerous ground to let certain posts stand where men are branded abusers, paedophiles etc.

In many cases though a poster might post that their father raped them or that they were sexually abused by a family member, and in that case it’s someone with a nickname posting about an unnamed person, which is different to posting that <insert celebrity name> is a paedophile.

Oblomov22 · 06/09/2022 13:44

Nope. I disagree. I understand the difference between say libel and slander. Most MN'ers seem to know the difference.

MarshaMelrose · 06/09/2022 13:44

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 13:32

Potentially.
I say potentially because if you say Jimmy Saville was a paedophile then you will be fine, even though he was never even charged,

Well, he's dead so I don't see who would sue. But what about someone who is alive, has never been charged so never convicted? Can you call them a rapist and a paedophile with impunity? Or is it libel? Because I don't see MN deleting posts like that. And in fact MN has a policy of always believing the woman so they actively support calling men rapists when there's no charge or conviction.

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 13:42

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 13:32

Potentially.
I say potentially because if you say Jimmy Saville was a paedophile then you will be fine, even though he was never even charged,

You can't defame the dead.

Saying that a living person is a rapist or paedophile without being able to prove the truthfulness would certainly be defamatory.

The exception, of course, would be an alleged victim reporting a crime. The reporting to police, witness statements, court proceedings etc would be protected from defamation.

StolenWillowTree · 06/09/2022 13:41

I googled because I was bored and find it interesting:

"Jurisdiction refers to the power of the foreign court to hear the case and exert power over you. In some countries, the fact that the material at issue is posted on the Internet and available worldwide—including in the country in question—is enough for the courts of that country to have jurisdiction over a case, at least according to that country's laws.

For example, in 2002 the Australia Supreme Court held that an American company, Dow Jones, Inc., could be sued in Australia over an article that appeared in the printed version and on the web site of its publication Barron's, which was accessible online in Australia. In 2010, Germany's highest court overruled two lower courts to hold that The New York Times could be sued in that country by a German citizen over a 2001 article available online, citing the article's references to Germany and the 14,484 registered users of the Times website with German addresses.

As an example of how complicated this can get, in August 2009 an American-based computer game company sued a British blogger in an Australian court.
A judgment against you in a foreign country could remain dormant unless you enter the country at a later time, for whatever reason."

MayThe4th · 06/09/2022 13:37

Is calling someone a paedophile or a rapist when there hasn't even been a charge against them, never mind a conviction, libellous? yes. Incidentally, the word paedophile is overused on MN as well.

A paedophile is someone with an interest in prepubescent children, but anyone having sex with under 16’s is branded a paedophile on mn. Not that sleeping with under 16’s is any less reprehensible, but it doesn’t make them a paedophile.