Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of Mumsnet do not understand libel?

87 replies

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 09:24

It is really common on here now to see an accusation that what an MNer said is libellous. It rarely is.
Libel is not a criminal offence, it is a civil wrong. Someone has to take you to court.

Libel refers to damaging someone's reputation and character and is based on stating as fact, things that are untrue.
So if I said someone famous who is known to be in a happy marriage was having an affair with someone else, and that was false and I said it maliciously, it would probably be potentially libellous i.e. that famous person could take me to court. Although unless you have an online following, that is very unlikely to happen.

But if I said the famous person was sleazy and I would not trust them, they seem the kind to pretend to have a happy marriage in public while having multiple affairs, that is unlikely to be libellous. It is my opinion and is not presented as a fact. It is the second kind of statement that some MNers keep saying is libellous.

You can say legally that you consider a named politician or famous person to be untrustworthy, sleazy, a bit thick, etc. It is opinion.

So please stop telling people that what they have said is libellous. The only potentially libellous comments I have ever seen on MN (rare) are deleted when reported. The matter is just an opinion that you may or may not agree with.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
limitededitionbarbie · 07/09/2022 22:09

Was that libel?

limitededitionbarbie · 07/09/2022 21:55

Op what were your thoughts on the Collen Rooney vs Rebecca thingy trial

Erictheavocado · 07/09/2022 20:29

Many years ago I was a member of the jury on a high profile libel case. During his summing up the judge instructed us that libel was the deliberate act of lying about someone (in print) with the intention to make others think the worst of that person. I accept that the law may have changed since then, but at that time the intention to damage a person's reputation was very much a consideration.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 20:11

Cam22 · 07/09/2022 17:07

Proving your point? 😆

Yes. The point that that distinction is largely irrelevant to this discussion - since the lack of understanding of defamation goes far beyond the largely trivial differences between slander and libel.

Cam22 · 07/09/2022 17:07

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:19

Most school kids are aware? But you felt the need to point it out to a group of adults.

Sort of proving my point.

Proving your point? 😆

Cam22 · 07/09/2022 17:06

I know there are posters here - presumably adult - who use “chest of draws” or who will be unfamiliar with many idioms etc. The likelihood of those posters being able to differentiate between slander and libel is very low.

Therefore, if kids at secondary school are generally au fait with the terms, maybe it’s time adults on fora got to grips with basic language knowledge.🙄

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:19

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 23:38

I’m not invested in the ins and outs of your tedious, long winded posts. Trying to sound clever? Most school kids are aware of the difference between spoken and written defamation so it’s hardly “clever” - though people here might think that, of course. Lol

Most school kids are aware? But you felt the need to point it out to a group of adults.

Sort of proving my point.

Leftbutcameback · 07/09/2022 11:39

Ah! Is that what happened there? I knew the result but not why.

Mummyford · 07/09/2022 11:31

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:28

If you had good reason to believe it was true you could use honest opinion or public interest as a defence. Neither of those require the facts to be actually true.

A case that better illustrates defamation is the one against Elon Musk a few years ago.

For no sensible reason he called a man on Twitter, “pedo guy” and wouldn’t apologise.

The man sued & on the face of it had a good case since there was no evidence at all he was a “pedo” and Musk had no reason to suppose he was. But he lost the case….because he couldn’t show that he’d been “defamed” or had suffered undue harm as a result even though the allegation was clearly untrue.

I’ve always thought Musk behaved despicably over this. He should just have said sorry and bumged the man a few hundred grand not forced him into court action.

Yes, and Banks v Cadwalladr came down to public interest in the end, which Banks clearly hadn't factored in heavily enough.

JumpingPiglets · 07/09/2022 02:49

Malice as a concept only has a limited role im English libel law for certain defences.

JumpingPiglets · 07/09/2022 02:48

I expect that Mumsnet relies (as many social media sites would) on s5 Defamation Act 2013, which limits the exent to which it can be sued provided it complies with certain processes.

Also you can be sued successfully for expressing an opinion. An opinion operates as a defence only when the requirements of s3 Defamation Act 2013 are met. The line between opinion and fact is not always an easy one.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 00:01

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:10

I know pedantic people like me are annoying, but you said “maliciously”, not “with malice”.

”With malice’ just means you know you’re doing something wrong - or don’t care either way - which is always relevant in any legal proceeding. So you’re right on that front.

Lots of people have been going on about “actual malice’ since Depp v Heard without knowing what it means, so I was just clarifying that wasn’t the case here.

No that was not the case here.

OP posts:
Cam22 · 06/09/2022 23:38

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 17:18

Sure but the distinction is largely irrelevant, since for most relevant purposes there is no practical distinction between the law on slander and on libel. There are some but much smaller than in the past.

Most people posting definitions of libel and slander tend to want to sound clever but without adding much of relevance.

I’m not invested in the ins and outs of your tedious, long winded posts. Trying to sound clever? Most school kids are aware of the difference between spoken and written defamation so it’s hardly “clever” - though people here might think that, of course. Lol

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 18:54

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:28

If you had good reason to believe it was true you could use honest opinion or public interest as a defence. Neither of those require the facts to be actually true.

A case that better illustrates defamation is the one against Elon Musk a few years ago.

For no sensible reason he called a man on Twitter, “pedo guy” and wouldn’t apologise.

The man sued & on the face of it had a good case since there was no evidence at all he was a “pedo” and Musk had no reason to suppose he was. But he lost the case….because he couldn’t show that he’d been “defamed” or had suffered undue harm as a result even though the allegation was clearly untrue.

I’ve always thought Musk behaved despicably over this. He should just have said sorry and bumged the man a few hundred grand not forced him into court action.

And wasn't it one of the divers involved in the thai cave rescue? He's such an idiot (musk that is)

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 18:40

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:28

If you had good reason to believe it was true you could use honest opinion or public interest as a defence. Neither of those require the facts to be actually true.

A case that better illustrates defamation is the one against Elon Musk a few years ago.

For no sensible reason he called a man on Twitter, “pedo guy” and wouldn’t apologise.

The man sued & on the face of it had a good case since there was no evidence at all he was a “pedo” and Musk had no reason to suppose he was. But he lost the case….because he couldn’t show that he’d been “defamed” or had suffered undue harm as a result even though the allegation was clearly untrue.

I’ve always thought Musk behaved despicably over this. He should just have said sorry and bumged the man a few hundred grand not forced him into court action.

There would certainly have been a different outcome in England. A claiming doesn’t need to demonstrate actual harm (unless the claimant is a business in which case financial harm must be demonstrated). Just probable harm using the reasonable person test.

So he wouldn’t need to demonstrate that anyone actually thought less of him or that it caused any material harm - just that a reasonable person probably would think less of him if they heard him called ‘Pedo Man’ which is a much easier threshold to reach.

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:28

If you had good reason to believe it was true you could use honest opinion or public interest as a defence. Neither of those require the facts to be actually true.

A case that better illustrates defamation is the one against Elon Musk a few years ago.

For no sensible reason he called a man on Twitter, “pedo guy” and wouldn’t apologise.

The man sued & on the face of it had a good case since there was no evidence at all he was a “pedo” and Musk had no reason to suppose he was. But he lost the case….because he couldn’t show that he’d been “defamed” or had suffered undue harm as a result even though the allegation was clearly untrue.

I’ve always thought Musk behaved despicably over this. He should just have said sorry and bumged the man a few hundred grand not forced him into court action.

DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 18:10

I know pedantic people like me are annoying, but you said “maliciously”, not “with malice”.

”With malice’ just means you know you’re doing something wrong - or don’t care either way - which is always relevant in any legal proceeding. So you’re right on that front.

Lots of people have been going on about “actual malice’ since Depp v Heard without knowing what it means, so I was just clarifying that wasn’t the case here.

balalake · 06/09/2022 17:38

I think OP you raise a valid point about the understanding of libel laws. The cost of bringing a libel action makes it a rich person's option only. It also seems to me a way rich people can bully others into silence, Robert Maxwell being an example of someone who used libel laws thus.

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 17:23

I think OPs point about people slinging accusations about is a good one. I was on another SM platform recently and someone (who is often quick to be offended) said a poster had defamed them. I read the relevant post several times and there was nothing in it even capable of being defamatory!

TeaKlaxon · 06/09/2022 17:18

Cam22 · 06/09/2022 15:51

My list provided a general definition for the benefit of people who clearly do not know.

This forum is not the centre of the universe, incidentally…

Sure but the distinction is largely irrelevant, since for most relevant purposes there is no practical distinction between the law on slander and on libel. There are some but much smaller than in the past.

Most people posting definitions of libel and slander tend to want to sound clever but without adding much of relevance.

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 17:17

The defence us that it is substantially true (s2(1)). Not that you believe it is true. There are of course other defences. But that was, for example, what Coleen Rooney relied on. That Rebecca Vardy did, in fact, leak the stories. And why she won. Terrible waste of money, great example case for us to look at!

Leftbutcameback · 06/09/2022 17:11

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 12:47

The damaging people's opinion is an interesting one. I can remember vaguely a famous libel case that was dismissed by the court. Although the court found no evidence to support the allegations being made, they also said the public's view of the individual was so poor that the allegation did not damage people's opinions of them as it was already so poor.

Wow! That's really interesting. I had assumed it wouldn't be a relative thing, but it does make sense

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 17:08

@DaisyMcTitface I accept your point. But as I explained I did not mean maliciousness. That is not what with malice means.

OP posts:
DaisyMcTitface · 06/09/2022 16:50

There’s not really any need to specify “with malice” or “maliciously” - that’s already factored in.

If a court finds that someone has been defamed and that the defendant/s either knew they were lying or (more likely and more common) had absolutely no good reason to believe that what they said was true (and it turned out not to be) then there’s no need to investigate their motivation further…which deciding on the level of “maliciousness” would require. If the claimant has specific evidence of malicious intent then that’s a good thing to put before the court, but “with malice” isn’t a necessary finding.

antelopevalley · 06/09/2022 16:35

I understand the difference between libel and slander, but I was posting about Mumsnet so libel is the relevant issue.

@DaisyMcTitface I had understood the with malice to mean deliberately. So the person knew what they were saying was false, or they were reckless about the truth of the issue.
But I am not a lawyer.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread