Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the bar is set low on parenting for men?

145 replies

Babysitting101 · 06/09/2022 08:29

It's something I keep noticing. If a man does even the bare minimum for his child people think he's incredible. I saw one deadbeat dad referred to as a 'legend' on Facebook today for 'taking on' his daughter for 12 months whilst her mother was unable to meet her needs, he was also told that 'not many men would do what you did'

By the way, this is a man who fobbed his daughter off on his mother at every opportunity as he was living in her house. He's also a man who seldom bothers with his other small child as he has a capable and committed mother so his 'support' isn't needed the way it is with his daughter.

Still - the mere fact he remained under the same roof as his daughter for approx 12 months meant he achieved legendary status.

Another case that sprung to mind recently is my own. I had an appointment to attend during which my OH had our three children. The person I had the appointment with gushed about how wonderful he is for babysitting... yep, babysitting.

AIBU to think the parenting bar is set so low for men? Why is this a thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Topgub · 07/09/2022 16:54

@TheHideAndSeekingHill

Why would they change when they dont have to?

TheHideAndSeekingHill · 07/09/2022 14:25

It might be women PERFORMING the actions that show how low the bar is set, but it is certainly men who are mainly contributing to setting that bar low.

Literally tens of thousands of dads (at least) don't pay towards their kids. Tonnes don't see their kids at all, even many of those who live with their kids do the bare minimum. My own dad had friends who wouldn't be seen dead pushing a pram or carrying their own child. Many younger dads I know now try to wriggle out of doing anything for their kids, with probably only about a third who I'd truly say act as equal parents.

So as a PP said no wonder some women comment: "a bit like if your dog made you a bacon sandwich".

Blaming women for "setting a low bar" on this is such shit. Men have run society for just about ever and have had - and continue to mostly have - a huge interest in dodging the boring, unglamorous jobs. If men wanted to change where the bar is set, they could en masse improve and start being equal parents.

Goosygandy · 07/09/2022 12:53

Topgub · 06/09/2022 13:21

@Goosygandy

Huh.

Maybe you should take some of your own advice?

You're being very critical and belittling of me right now. (For no objective reason that I can fathom from this thread)

Seems you only want to support the sister hood when it suits you.

I cope fine with being disagreed with, I actively enjoy it. Its called debate. I dont care if people agree or don't or even if they listen to my opinion.

None of that is actually relevant to the op.

I suggest you stick to it rather than personally attacking me.

Stop being so disingenuous. You know exactly what you were doing when you said some people can't cope with being disagreed with. Nothing I have said is remotely belittling. It's just pushing back at you.

Supporting the sisterhood doesn't mean agreeing with every woman that wants to put other people down. But you know that of course.

Playing the victim isn't a good look because you don't like people disagreeing with you.

Tlolljs · 07/09/2022 12:42

If dogs could make bacon sandwiches I’d get one.
But yeah it’s the rarity value of seeing men shopping, cleaning, looking after their own kids.

5128gap · 07/09/2022 08:25

Its almost always women heaping praise on these men.
Partly its still got novelty value for some women, so a bit like if your dog made you a bacon sandwich.
Then there's the women who've learned that men tend to need praise and positive reinforcement if they want their continued contribution.
There are also some women who like to preserve the idea that childcare is a unique ability found only in women, and so any man 'having a go' will mess it up a bit, (in a really cute way, naturally) but its sweet that he's trying, bless him.

DisneyMillie · 07/09/2022 08:18

My ex-h moved his new family abroad for a better job (bearing in mind he already had a good 6 figure salary so didn’t “need to”) and practically is worshipped even by my mother for coming over and visiting our dd approx once a month (at a time that suits when he needs to be over for work anyway) and paying appropriate maintenance.

Don’t get me wrong he loves our daughter but I get a hard time for even doing part time work as “you don’t have as much time for the children / to keep on top of the house” - if I’d upped and moved as he did I’d be crucified by the same people that think he’s amazing for bothering to still be in her life.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 07/09/2022 07:37

Sad to hear this is still the case in 2022 … I had my twins 20 years ago. Went back to work part time when they were 9 months. DH did four long days at work so he could have one day off with them.

He took them to baby groups, shops, cafes etc and the comments and incredulation that he was doing this ALONE was off the scale.

Rainbowqueeen · 07/09/2022 07:31

Bar is definitely in hell.

The question is what can we do about it? The first things I can think of is be aware. I know that I am far more aware than I used to be. There was a thread on here a few months ago about a mum wanting to go away for a weekend with her girlfriends and lots of responses saying “the kids will be fine, a weekend of Tv and takeaway with dad won’t hurt them” Once upon a time I might have agreed with that. Now I think why? Why can’t the dad cook a proper meal and entertain the DC by taking them to the park and engaging with them. Why don’t we expect that?

The parent who gets to do the “slack” parenting of takeaway and tv should be the parent who does the lions share of parenting. Not the one who does less.

Now I find myself noticing it more I find myself commenting more. I agree it’s a societal thing that will take time to change. And to be honest I don’t think a lot of men want it to change. I think they’re happy doing the bare minimum and being praised to the heavens.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 07/09/2022 07:15

Oh yes. My own partner actually tried to defend his friend when I called him.a sperm donor. But that's all he is to me, he's not worthy of the title father. He doesn't see his kids, even when he lived near them he didn't and then he moved 4 hours away. I think he does now pay for them, but he didn't before because he couldn't be arsed working. He is now trying to sort himself out and fair play to him, he does actually have one child living with him now, but they are 18! Until he's done 18 actual years of parenting with her and the rest, he's not a dad and I refuse to call him that.

Miffee · 07/09/2022 07:06

What shocked me when my friends had kids with their partners (I had mine very young) wasn't the childcare as much as the responsibility. My DH took full (joint) responsibility for our DCs, we made all decisions together with both of us having veto power. This, more than child care (which my DH also took full responsibility for), was what my friends used to comment on. One friend even asked me how I got him to do this, I couldn't answer. He would no more let me make all the decisions and tell him what we were doing than I would have let him.

I do wonder if our young age when we became parents was part of it. We were both so utterly clueless so working together was the only option.

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 07/09/2022 06:57

I'm fortunate that this isn't really my experience - DH is the primary carer while I work, and I don't really hear this from friends or acquaintances apart from one or two comments from the older generation. I'm not saying it doesn't happen - I 100% believe you all, but hopefully it's a sign that there is a bit of progress! Maybe it's just that people are a bit intimidated by me and wouldn't dare... Grin

EmeraldShamrock1 · 07/09/2022 06:48

It always has been.

Thankfully the bar has been raised massively from 40/50 years ago.

It's going to take more than two generations to undo the years of conditioning on genders.

If you have a DS start training him early.

SquirrelSoShiny · 07/09/2022 06:39

YANBU. It's pathetic and I say that as someone with a DH who actually parents his DC.

Fucket · 07/09/2022 06:36

It just goes to show how many women are willing to procreate with feckless men. How many of them have grown up with absent or neglectful fathers, that even just a crumb of affection towards a child, or sharing.a domestic task for even 5 minutes from these males blows their minds.

The man in front of them is truly a god among men.

Siameasy · 07/09/2022 06:26

Women fuel this nonsense mainly by the way. My DM is a pain for it. My brother is treated like a God and it’s caused a lot of resentment from me

Siameasy · 07/09/2022 06:24

When my SIL had her DC1 my Mil said “and (Sil’s hubby) did so well”. I asked what he had done and no one could elaborate so I assume he just existed or at least he didn’t eat the baby or something

mackthepony · 07/09/2022 02:02

I wandered off somewhere, when I came back he said one woman had offered to do the shopping for him! ‘Just give me your list and I’ll run round’

^

Wtaf

mackthepony · 07/09/2022 02:00

Colleagues used to rave about one of the guys we worked with because 'he makes muffins with his kids and everything'

His wife had cooked the bloody dinner for the past twenty years but does she get a head nod?

Fuck no

Ihaveanoldiphone · 07/09/2022 01:16

*to ffs.

Ihaveanoldiphone · 07/09/2022 01:12

Yes, the bar is so low it’s a tavern in Hades.

in my community is actually still too much to expect men to do anything other than paid work. Yup. I’m actually a shit wife because I ‘make’ my Dh do stuff.

so you can imagine my mil dying when she’d see her son doing the women’s work at home, and my own mother mocking my husband for doing nappies as she’d be too embarrassed to let my brother do his own kids nappies (while other chapter). Anyway we are getting there with the mental load but I do prefer to control some aspects such as the children but he’s not the type to try weaponised incompetence with me so I’m not complaining. It depends on what you’re prepared to put up with and yes depends on the man too but sometimes I think with the culture me and Dh grew up in he would more than happily do bare minimum if i gave him permission too.

MrsAvocet · 07/09/2022 01:03

The double standards are ridiculous.
Our children are more or less grown up now and I'm retired so the dynamic has changed a lot for us recently but for most of our marriage I have been the higher earner and worked longer hours and DH has done more of the domestic/child related stuff than me, though he's also worked. To many people, sadly particularly women, that makes him some kind of super hero and me, at best, nothing, and at worst a complete villain.
His Mum once described him, in my hearing, as "having to be both Father and Mother to those children". Okaay...he takes on a few traditionally female roles and gains mother status does he? However I apparently am not worthy of the title since I don't do the school run, but I get no kudos for doing that traditionally male breadwinner thing? I was lucky that he looked after the children "for me" but nobody ever told him he was lucky to have a wife who paid the mortgage "for him" .
A few years ago I was seriously ill in hospital and the fuss that was made of DH by again largely female friends and family was quite ridiculous - bringing meals, doing laundry and ironing etc - all very kind, but stuff that he and our teenage sons were perfectly capable of doing. The minute I was home, when we actually could have done with some help as I was still needing a lot of care it stopped. "You'll be glad Avo is home, it's been tough for you having to run the house without her" said one of our neighbours as she collected her casserole dishes. Strangely nobody brought me any casseroles when DH was in hospital this year. Funny that.

Westernesse · 06/09/2022 23:38

Snargle · 06/09/2022 23:28

The language used is also very telling.

How many times do we hear of a man described as being a "hands on dad" because he changes nappies or dresses his child? Yet when was the last time anyone described a woman as being a "hands on mum"?

It's not a term that's used because we automatically assume that being a mother includes actually taking care of a child's needs. No such expectation in society for fathers.

Totally agree but it’s entirely female driven. Why they do it, I do not know.

Snargle · 06/09/2022 23:28

The language used is also very telling.

How many times do we hear of a man described as being a "hands on dad" because he changes nappies or dresses his child? Yet when was the last time anyone described a woman as being a "hands on mum"?

It's not a term that's used because we automatically assume that being a mother includes actually taking care of a child's needs. No such expectation in society for fathers.

Westernesse · 06/09/2022 23:14

“It's something I keep noticing. If a man does even the bare minimum for his child people think he's incredible. I saw one deadbeat dad referred to as a 'legend' on Facebook today for 'taking on' his daughter for 12 months whilst her mother was unable to meet her needs, he was also told that 'not many men would do what you did'”

this appalling, matronising kind of sentiment almost always comes from women.
Many women like to keep men belittled and patronised with regard to childcare for some reason.

FrangipaniBlue · 06/09/2022 23:11

DH and I have always done everything 50:50.

I was made redundant when DS was 3 and made a career move that meant I worked away a few days during the week for around 5 years.

DH did all the nursery (and then school) drop offs/pick ups when I was away - I did them when I was home and I worked from home during school holidays.

But OMG the comments about what an amazing husband I had, wasn't I lucky that he was so hands on enabling my career, not many men would do what he does BLAH FUCKIN BLAH

Yeah mate, he does what millions of MUMS all over the world do and I don't see anyone putting them on a pedestal