Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in not tipping?

136 replies

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 08:25

Here in the UK we have the national minimum wage laws so anyone working in a restaurant should be paid at least that. I get that it's not a lot of money (I'm not on much more myself) however I could go into a retail store, let's say Primark and a shop assistant could give me absolutely amazing customer service but I'm not allowed to tip her. That Primark staff member could be paid the same wage as a waitress serving me in a restaurant whose service is very basic i.e. taking a food/drink order and bringing the food to the table without a smile or any friendly chat, yet they expect a tip?

Years ago dining out used to be an experience, waiters/waitresses made chat with you, told jokes etc, really made your experience something extra special so I could maybe understand wanting to tip someone in those circumstances but there isn't a lot of that anymore. Most dining out in recent years is just someone taking your order and bringing it to your table (i.e. doing their job in which their employer pays them a wage).

I was having a chat with a colleague the other day and they said it's stingy not to tip but I just feel it's not necessary in the UK. In America a lot of states don't have any minimum wage requirements and so some American staff work solely on tips so tipping is sort of built into ther culture.

But in the UK there are loads of roles where people are paid the national minimum wage or just above but those specifically working in hospitality seem to expect tips.

AIBU in not wanting to pay tips?

OP posts:
Ragwort · 06/09/2022 09:30

I think (sadly) a lot of people don't understand what really good customer service in hospitality is ... it's absolutely not just 'taking your order and delivering the food'. I trained in customer service as part of a Hospitality Course over 40 years ago Grin - yes I know that makes me a dinosaur! I loathe going out to eat and being 'served' (if you can call it that ) by someone who's opening line is 'are you all right there?', has no idea of the menu etc etc. I am very happy to tip when I receive great service ... but I rarely eat out these days as so few places offer good service (Cote Brassiere - at least the one near me - does seem to consistently offer outstanding service).

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 06/09/2022 09:28

I tip wherever I receive a personal service. If the level of service is shit, I don't tip. Someone serving me at the till isn't providing me with a personal service, but a personal shopper would be. Someone who serves me at the counter at Costa isn't providing a personal service but a waiter who seats me, talks me through the menu, takes my coat, makes recommendations, checks in to see if there's anything I need and brings my order has provided a personal service.

That's how I make the distinction.

I'd think low of somebody who didn't tip in a restaurant unless the experience was bad.

FuncaMunca · 06/09/2022 09:27

I happily tip for good service, which I value.

But in my experience, not all establishments in the UK expect significant (or any) tips as a matter of course. One pub owner confessed to me that he was embarrassed about asking for tips..

Whereas in America/Canada obviously there is a universal expectation that you will tip at least 15-20% and if you don't, they will challenge you. I was once chased out the door by a staff member as I left a restaurant having forgotten to tip on the bill, as if it were akin to stealing...

LumpyandBumps · 06/09/2022 09:22

I nearly always tip unless service has been poor, but accept it is mostly a matter of habit.

In a restaurant for example the experience can be really enhanced by pleasant waiting staff, as opposed to just taking an order and plonking down plates of food.

I now avoid places where a ‘discretionary’ service charge is routinely applied.

If the restaurant thinks it’s staff should be paid a 10-15% surcharge it should amend the prices and deal with any loss of custom.

Yes I know I can ask for this sort of charge to be removed, but I just don’t want that sort of interaction after what is meant to be a pleasant experience.

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 09:22

OneTC · 06/09/2022 09:18

Why do people think you aren't allowed to tip people in shops? It's a fairly regular occurrence in ours.

We always put it in the charity box though

Agree with @DobbyHasASock comment further up, I worked in a few retail places and it was a sackable offence to accept a tip. My brother still works in retail and it is the same with his employer too. Maybe it's different for small independent shops as opposed to big retail giants?

OP posts:
Mybeautifulfriend22 · 06/09/2022 09:22

Sometimes I tip sometimes I don’t. I don’t really overthink it but if someone is giving genuinely good service I’m more likely to

To be honest I’d rather not have staff trying to tell me jokes and be over friendly when I’m out for meals anyway. It feels fake and when it’s forced you can tell! Polite, helpful and natural service with a smile that will do!

SanFranBear · 06/09/2022 09:19

Also ex- bar staff and I often buy people serving me in pubs, a drink... I used to love finishing my shift and having a 'free' drink with which to end my day and I think tipping with money in bars is a little odd.

OneTC · 06/09/2022 09:18

Why do people think you aren't allowed to tip people in shops? It's a fairly regular occurrence in ours.

We always put it in the charity box though

DobbyHasASock · 06/09/2022 09:16

SavingsThreads · 06/09/2022 09:10

I don't tip anyone, but OP of course you're 'allowed' to tip in primark/retail!

It was a sackable action to accept a tip when I worked in retail I doubt it has change.
And yes op, tipping is unfair on other minimum wage workers like me, and encourages employ3rs not to pay staff properly.

SanFranBear · 06/09/2022 09:16

I tip everyone - always in restaurants (ex-waitress), usually on delivery apps, my hairdresser, taxi drivers...

Not sure why but I like to make people feel a bit happier, I guess, and a tip is just another way to say thank you. And given its not as common these days, it's also sometimes a nice surprise for them?

I'm not loaded by any stretch of the imagination and eating out, Ubers and my hair are treats for me so I always factor a tip in as part of the overall cost. Its never megabucks either.

Each to their own and there are lots of valid reasons why not to tip, but I just like it.

Shoxfordian · 06/09/2022 09:11

I always tip in restaurants unless service has been horrendously bad

I would think anyone not tipping was cheap tbh

Llamadrama2 · 06/09/2022 09:11

To clarify, it was a computer cable I was buying.

SavingsThreads · 06/09/2022 09:10

I don't tip anyone, but OP of course you're 'allowed' to tip in primark/retail!

Llamadrama2 · 06/09/2022 09:09

I was asked if I wanted to tip the staff when I ordered on the internet! Um...no, why would that be an option?

Yogagrandmum · 06/09/2022 09:00

I don’t tip my hairdresser as she owns the salon, therefore she should pay herself properly.
I used to ‘fly’ and would have loved all the passengers to have tipped….

Yogagrandmum · 06/09/2022 08:59

I don’t tip my hairdresser as she owns the salon, therefore she should pay herself properly.
I used to ‘fly’ and would have loved all the passengers to have tipped….

CanThisBe · 06/09/2022 08:56

I don't tip anyone any more. My haircut costs £53 for about 30 mins work. If the hairdresser isn't adequately paid, that's the employer's issue to fix.

The same with restaurants. A fairly ordinary meal for 4 people will cost £100 and you occupy the table for c. 1.5 hours. If everyone tips the "required" 10% they'll be on a huge hourly rate. Obviously not everyone does, but that's OK IMO.

I've also never understood why typing is normal for some staff and not others. What's the difference between a waiter and a shop assistant or a hairdresser and a HCP or a taxi driver and a bus driver?

latetothefisting · 06/09/2022 08:55

Qwerkie · 06/09/2022 08:35

i tip when the service has been good. You aren’t obligated to tip but the generally accepted view is you’re tight if you don’t. The salesperson in primark only has to put up with customers for a couple of minutes at a time, serving staff have to put up with them for several hours each.

Not if they're on the tills, the sales person has 8-10 hours of constant customer contact then.

I agree op it's illogical. Most waiting staff, hairdressers, taxi drivers don't work any harder than shop assistants, hcps, carers, call centre staff etc so I've never seen the logic in tipping one and not the other. I would tip if someone goes genuinely above and beyond, and if that person was in a role where they couldn't accept tips always try to email in to give good feedback instead, but tbh most people rarely go out of their way to give any sort of outstanding service that warrants paying above their actual wage.

icelollycraving · 06/09/2022 08:53

I tip at the hairdresser but rarely go anymore. I tip a cab driver if they are particularly nice or help me with bags. I usually tip in restaurants unless the service is not good. I went to Zizzi last week, service ok but then paid by app and didn’t tip.

999caffeineplease · 06/09/2022 08:52

I tip if I’ve had good service but generally only seem to go to places with better service - smaller, independent places over big chains.

I will say though - I know a lot of people in hospitality (&worked as a server myself through university) who would not work if it wasn’t for the tips. So while yes they are minimum wage earners, most wouldn’t consider the job if that’s all they were receiving.

Hospitality is crying out for staff and not getting many responses because the effort isn’t worth the reward, so tips go a good way to keeping the nice places running.

badbaduncle · 06/09/2022 08:52

I usually tip. I've had some bad experiences recently though. One restaurant I London added a 20% service charge, which I questioned and the waiter told me he didn't get it anyway. I left about 10% in cash and the manager followed me into the street to argue with me 🤷‍♀️
I asked him if it was compulsory abs when he said no I took my cash tip back. Outrageous. The service had been shit!

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 08:50

2pinkginsplease · 06/09/2022 08:42

If I’ve had good service then I’ll tip. If I haven’t then I don’t. I worked in hospitality for 18years so have high standards for good customer service, a huge bugbear of mine is sloppy service,

I do however ask if the server gets to keep most of their tips (eg half to them,half to kitchen staff) then I tip well but if it’s all pulled and split at end of the month then I don’t tip much,

I want the people actually serving and making my food to get my tips.

the difference is the primark server only has each customer for a max of 3 mins whereas the the person working in the restaurant has to seat the customer, take drinks, give menus, tell them the specials, deliver drinks, take food order, set the table, deliver food, deal with any complaints, clear plates, try and upsell on sides and desserts while maintaining a happy smiley face for approx 60-90 minutes of service for each table.

Ive worked in both environments and hospitality is much harder to keep customers happy,

@2pinkginsplease what you outline above for the restaurant staff member i.e. seating customers, giving menus, delivering food/drink, would be in their job description, so they expect a tip just for doing the general duties of the role in which their employer gives them a wage?

OP posts:
Soproudoflionesses · 06/09/2022 08:49

I am on tue fence with this - agree you shouldn't have to and l hate being told how much l should tip plus eating g out is so much more expensive that it used to be - bit if l don't tup, l feel mean.
Since covid, l use card more than cash and always check with the waiting staff that they get the money if l tip on card and if not, l don't leave one.

beeswaxbonnie · 06/09/2022 08:43

I don't tip at all for all the reasons you said, I'm not even remotely ashamed of it

2pinkginsplease · 06/09/2022 08:42

If I’ve had good service then I’ll tip. If I haven’t then I don’t. I worked in hospitality for 18years so have high standards for good customer service, a huge bugbear of mine is sloppy service,

I do however ask if the server gets to keep most of their tips (eg half to them,half to kitchen staff) then I tip well but if it’s all pulled and split at end of the month then I don’t tip much,

I want the people actually serving and making my food to get my tips.

the difference is the primark server only has each customer for a max of 3 mins whereas the the person working in the restaurant has to seat the customer, take drinks, give menus, tell them the specials, deliver drinks, take food order, set the table, deliver food, deal with any complaints, clear plates, try and upsell on sides and desserts while maintaining a happy smiley face for approx 60-90 minutes of service for each table.

Ive worked in both environments and hospitality is much harder to keep customers happy,

Swipe left for the next trending thread