Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in not tipping?

136 replies

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 08:25

Here in the UK we have the national minimum wage laws so anyone working in a restaurant should be paid at least that. I get that it's not a lot of money (I'm not on much more myself) however I could go into a retail store, let's say Primark and a shop assistant could give me absolutely amazing customer service but I'm not allowed to tip her. That Primark staff member could be paid the same wage as a waitress serving me in a restaurant whose service is very basic i.e. taking a food/drink order and bringing the food to the table without a smile or any friendly chat, yet they expect a tip?

Years ago dining out used to be an experience, waiters/waitresses made chat with you, told jokes etc, really made your experience something extra special so I could maybe understand wanting to tip someone in those circumstances but there isn't a lot of that anymore. Most dining out in recent years is just someone taking your order and bringing it to your table (i.e. doing their job in which their employer pays them a wage).

I was having a chat with a colleague the other day and they said it's stingy not to tip but I just feel it's not necessary in the UK. In America a lot of states don't have any minimum wage requirements and so some American staff work solely on tips so tipping is sort of built into ther culture.

But in the UK there are loads of roles where people are paid the national minimum wage or just above but those specifically working in hospitality seem to expect tips.

AIBU in not wanting to pay tips?

OP posts:
Dotjones · 06/09/2022 11:44

If you choose not to then that's your choice, but trust me, they are judging you for it.

I'm happy not to tip people who are judgemental.

Danielle9891 · 06/09/2022 11:41

You are being unreasonable, but English people are know for not tipping all over the world. (I'm originally from England and have worked in Australia, new Zealand, America, Spain and Ireland)

I work in a restaurant in N.Ireland and make around £5-20 in tips a day. I wouldn't be able to continuing working in the restaurant trade without them.

We work fewer shifts in the winter and split shifts is normal for us, such as 11-2 for lunch and 5-9 ect. It's not a normal 9-5 job.

I would work around 30/40 hours during the summer and I'm lucky if I get 10 hours in October - November and January - April.

Because of people getting less and less hours now people aren't going out as much the restaurant I work at will be closing monday-wednesday starting next week.

Not sure what I'm going to do as public transport is really bad where I live and I don't drive.

pawkins · 06/09/2022 11:38

Such emotive language is being used - you will be judged/embarrassed for you etc. A service is a business transaction. People pay the set charge for the service required. End of.

Dreamstate · 06/09/2022 11:30

After a few trips to some restaurants (not chains) post pandemic I have just stopped going out and eating, service is shockingly bad/ slow and food mediocre.

And I for one do not care if you judge me for not tipped - who even knows other than the waitress/ hairdresser that you don't tip and I for one do not care what other people who are effectively strangers to me think of me

JasonWaterfalls · 06/09/2022 11:27

So many places like restaurants add ten percent service charge anyway I tend not to tip those and tip non-service charge bills when the service has been good, don’t know if I’ve misunderstood service charge now, I thought that was a tip!!?

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 11:25

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 11:18

It's not cheeky, it is what it is. You tip in a restaurant. It's good social etiquette. If you choose not to then that's your choice, but trust me, they are judging you for it.

@Lyla82 they can judge me if they want but if they're not coming to my work to tip me then I don't really see why I should care...

OP posts:
latetothefisting · 06/09/2022 11:24

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 11:15

As I said before, it's only the minority of tight people who are happy to embarrass themselves and not tip. Most people do tip, contrary to MN!

And you are basing this conclusion on your exhaustive survey of all 70million people in the UK?
Or perhaps actually on your very limited experience.....

GlitteryGreen · 06/09/2022 11:19

I usually tip in restaurants unless the service has been really bad or slow, but this is usually dependent on whether we actually have any cash with us.

I'd usually always include a tip on the card machine if given the option but so many just skip past that - I guess either through embarrassment or preferring cash - and it leaves us in a position where we don't have anything to leave.

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 11:18

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 10:47

@Lyla82 people work antisocial hours in retail i.e. evenings/weekends (some even open on Christmas day i.e. retailers at petrol stations) and they have no option for tips? It would be very cheeky to assume being a waiter/waitress and following your job description without going above and beyond would earn you a tip...

It's not cheeky, it is what it is. You tip in a restaurant. It's good social etiquette. If you choose not to then that's your choice, but trust me, they are judging you for it.

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 11:15

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 10:46

@Lyla82

"They choose to be waiting staff despite antisocial hours and physical demands because they will get tips"

No, they might get tips

If people have made a career choice based on tips that's a bit silly

As I said before, it's only the minority of tight people who are happy to embarrass themselves and not tip. Most people do tip, contrary to MN!

caringcarer · 06/09/2022 10:57

I tip postman, bin men and dog groomer at Xmas. I don't go hair dresser for hair trim often but leave £2-3 extra. I tip in restaurants £5 on a £30 meal. I don't tip in Witherspoon's as pay on app. I don't tip in taxis if drivers go deliberately a long way round or drive very slowly for no reason other than making meter go higher. They infuriate me.

pawkins · 06/09/2022 10:52

I stopped tipping a few years ago.
If I (and other non tippers) didn’t do business in the restaurants/hairdressers, the people working there wouldn’t have jobs. If they aren’t happy with the wages, don’t work there. If the employers don’t want to pay them more, let the businesses shut down.
It really isn’t up to customers to throw cash at other people’s employees. If I was so eager to want to pay oriole’s wages, I’d open my own restaurant.

It really is that simple and Ive worked in many minimum wage jobs myself.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 06/09/2022 10:51

I'm old school - I tip in restaurants, cabs, hairdressers, delivery drivers, buy a drink for bar staff and every year our bin men know they'll get £20 and a crate of beer.

VictoriaConcordiaCrescit · 06/09/2022 10:47

It's very rare for us to tip

They are paid to do the job anyway

I don't tip the person on the checkout at Tesco either

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 10:47

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 10:44

See my earlier response to Nutella. They choose to be waiting staff despite antisocial hours and physical demands because they will get tips. Most people would not choose to work evenings/weekends/Christmas day for minimum wage, they do it for their tips.
You can try to justify your view all you like, but tipping is the accepted social etiquette and by not doing so, you look tight.

@Lyla82 people work antisocial hours in retail i.e. evenings/weekends (some even open on Christmas day i.e. retailers at petrol stations) and they have no option for tips? It would be very cheeky to assume being a waiter/waitress and following your job description without going above and beyond would earn you a tip...

OP posts:
nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 10:46

@Lyla82

"They choose to be waiting staff despite antisocial hours and physical demands because they will get tips"

No, they might get tips

If people have made a career choice based on tips that's a bit silly

MintyGreenDreams · 06/09/2022 10:46

I don't tip in this country but I will on holiday.
We went to Egypt this year and the guy who worked in the pool area worked 12 hour shifts 7 days a week and only saw his family for a few days every 10 weeks.He worked so hard and was so friendly.
He deserved to be tipped.

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 10:45

undernotover · 06/09/2022 10:42

I will say though - I know a lot of people in hospitality (&worked as a server myself through university) who would not work if it wasn’t for the tips. So while yes they are minimum wage earners, most wouldn’t consider the job if that’s all they were receiving.

Hospitality is crying out for staff and not getting many responses because the effort isn’t worth the reward, so tips go a good way to keeping the nice places running.

This hits the nail on the head for me. At university I worked in hospitality rather than a supermarket/shop because of the tips. You think I wanted the 2/3am finishes, dealing with clearing up peoples gross half eaten food/drink (which always inevitably ended up on the floor/table/seats), heavy lifting, coming home sticky covered in cocktail ingredients every night? The list of gross tasks goes on. I did it for the extra tips (and specifically chose a bar/restaurant that was independent and slightly higher end rather than a bog standard pizza express so I'd get them). If people had consistently not tipped I and the other staff all would've left.

And it was always consistently the people who didn't tip who were also the most demanding, made the most mess, spoke to me like I was less than them, and acted like any task (including picking up things they'd knocked over so I could clean the remaining mess) was below them. So yes, I did judge 99% of the non tippers. Because it seemed to come from a place of superiority and contempt for me.

100% this!

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 10:44

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 10:35

@Lyla82 what about others who earn the same base salary/hourly rate as waiting staff and who have no opportunity to get tips? Do waiting staff expect tips just for doing their job?

See my earlier response to Nutella. They choose to be waiting staff despite antisocial hours and physical demands because they will get tips. Most people would not choose to work evenings/weekends/Christmas day for minimum wage, they do it for their tips.
You can try to justify your view all you like, but tipping is the accepted social etiquette and by not doing so, you look tight.

undernotover · 06/09/2022 10:42

I will say though - I know a lot of people in hospitality (&worked as a server myself through university) who would not work if it wasn’t for the tips. So while yes they are minimum wage earners, most wouldn’t consider the job if that’s all they were receiving.

Hospitality is crying out for staff and not getting many responses because the effort isn’t worth the reward, so tips go a good way to keeping the nice places running.

This hits the nail on the head for me. At university I worked in hospitality rather than a supermarket/shop because of the tips. You think I wanted the 2/3am finishes, dealing with clearing up peoples gross half eaten food/drink (which always inevitably ended up on the floor/table/seats), heavy lifting, coming home sticky covered in cocktail ingredients every night? The list of gross tasks goes on. I did it for the extra tips (and specifically chose a bar/restaurant that was independent and slightly higher end rather than a bog standard pizza express so I'd get them). If people had consistently not tipped I and the other staff all would've left.

And it was always consistently the people who didn't tip who were also the most demanding, made the most mess, spoke to me like I was less than them, and acted like any task (including picking up things they'd knocked over so I could clean the remaining mess) was below them. So yes, I did judge 99% of the non tippers. Because it seemed to come from a place of superiority and contempt for me.

Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 10:37

KatherineJaneway · 06/09/2022 09:52

I would only not tip if the service was very poor.

@Thecarpetisbeige Do you ask for the service charge that is automatically added at some restaurants to be removed?

@KatherineJaneway luckily I haven't come across this at any of the restaurants I've been to. I would find that really rude and presumptious of the owner/company to assume their staff are going above and beyond normal duties, it would be for the customer to decide that surely?

OP posts:
Thecarpetisbeige · 06/09/2022 10:35

Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 09:57

You should always tip in a restaurant unless the service has been horrendous. Waiting staff in the UK rely on their tips.

@Lyla82 what about others who earn the same base salary/hourly rate as waiting staff and who have no opportunity to get tips? Do waiting staff expect tips just for doing their job?

OP posts:
Lyla82 · 06/09/2022 10:30

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 10:26

@Lyla82

More fool them then for choosing a job for a non guaranteed tip

I think you'll find that the majority of people do tip. It's a minority of tight people that are happy to embarrass themselves by having a nice meal and walking out that restaurant without leaving a penny.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/09/2022 10:28

When people tip automatically with no thought to the level of service they have received, they are undermining those workers that make the effort to provide good service.

A tip should be in recognition of someone going above and beyond, not something that is given or expected just for doing the basics.

nutellachurro · 06/09/2022 10:26

@Lyla82

More fool them then for choosing a job for a non guaranteed tip