Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be struggling to survive on 65k household income

581 replies

Soddinghell · 05/09/2022 20:38

By the time we have paid mortgage, phone bills, bills car insurance, kids activities etc we barely have anything left. I don’t know what’s going on. DH earns 50k and I earn 15k part time. Please somebody help me I am thinking of going full time to stay afloat, I don’t know where we are going wrong, we are not in London or an expensive area, just outside manchester and people keep telling us we should be fine. We are not though!

OP posts:
JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:18

@andymary Seriously, you need some good financial advice.

You ought not to be paying off £200 pm in debts owed (which you have ramped up) while saving for things like holidays and Xmas presents.

Your debts are presumably credit cards so you are spending yet paying interest, but at the same time putting money away for things like holidays and presents.

Your spending on non-essentials is very high.

Your 'entertainment' costs are huge. You are paying way over the odds for your phone and internet.

Your mortage and council tax are , in comparion, quite low. (My coucnil tax is more like £280 a month.)

I can't get my head round these outgoing.

Have you thought of asking a professional to help you with your budgeting?

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:17

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 09:58

The last post is utter rubbish, you choose to pay for subscriptions, you choose to do activities and to have 2 cars and have pets and all the upkeep that goes with both.

You can’t blame everyone else for problems with things becoming more expensive. You have to cut your cloth accordingly and know when and where to cut back.

Yeah, just get rid of your pets all of a sudden.
And don’t go out and do things and also cancel anything remotely pleasurable on TV subscription wise.

Also, get rid of a car. Never mind if you need it and will end up paying extortionate fees on public transport instead of it, just get rid of it.

CoastalWave · 06/09/2022 10:16

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:10

@andymary WOW! I could get rid of 70% of what is on your list!

Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100 NOT ESSENTIAL
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) VERY HIGH
Internet £40 VERY HIGH
Sky/Virgin TV £60 NOT ESSENTIAL
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each) SEEMS HIGH (MINE IS £150 pa)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40 NOT ESSENTIAL
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100 A LIFETYLE CHOICE
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200 POOR FINACIAL PLANNING
Family Activities £200 AS WELL AS ALL THE ABOVE?
Holiday Savings £200 SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?
Christmas Savings £100 £1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?
Clothes £100 EVERY MONTH? NOT ESSENTIAL
Eating Out £100 NOT ESSENTIAL

Pets - a lifestyle choice?

Well yes sure they are, but is she suddenly supposed to just get rid of them!

Behave yourself.

OP - one thing that is massively helping me at the minute is that we take out £120 each Friday. That's our food, petrol, clothes anything money (basically anything that's no direct debit bills)

It really doesn't go very far, but it stops unnecessary spending on the cards. Those little £10, £5 shops add up. Put your cards away for a month, see how much you can save.

HillyBillyBumkin · 06/09/2022 10:16

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 09:32

I love how everyone is quick to critiscise anything that they see as frivoulous spending without thinking of the knock on effect of when this is stopped.

To some people getting your nails done may be a waste of money, or getting a takeaway, or a coffee and cake but that spending creates jobs. So yes now that we are in this cost crisis people who could previously afford to get their nails done now can't, so the salon loses customers and cuts jobs or closes. The takeaway loses customers so cuts staff and closes, so does the coffee shop.

People get rid of their cleaners, stop using their dog walkers, stop going to restaurants, stop getting their hair done etc. etc. this all has a knock on effect. So yes people will just have to cut down but everyone needs to wake up to the serious consequences of this instead of acting like people were silly to be spending this money in the first place, back when they could comfortably afford it.

I agree with this on a basic level. There are many businesses than no longer exist because they were unable to react to economic and environmental factors. People who work in any industry where their income is based on a healthy economy will need to think about strategies moving forwards because this may no longer be the case. I am not basing my personal financial security on continuing to spend to keep businesses afloat, and I don't know how many people would tbh. I don't know what the answer is.

I do agree that for some people spending on their nails, or hair, or daily coffee is part of their lifestyle they maintain for good mental health and shouldn't be judged. But some people don't even know the Direct Debits they have coming off their bank account, only look at their bank balance when it gets to the end of the month or don't consider the cost of something when they go to a restaurant or bar. I'm not judging them, I know what can cause this kind of attitude and know many people with it, but this may have to change for them if they want to get a handle on their finances. The future is not looking very bright at all at the minute, but we have been here before (well not exactly HERE, I have no idea where here is 😁). I just want as many people to come through it as unscathed as possible.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:16

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:10

@andymary WOW! I could get rid of 70% of what is on your list!

Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100 NOT ESSENTIAL
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) VERY HIGH
Internet £40 VERY HIGH
Sky/Virgin TV £60 NOT ESSENTIAL
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each) SEEMS HIGH (MINE IS £150 pa)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40 NOT ESSENTIAL
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100 A LIFETYLE CHOICE
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200 POOR FINACIAL PLANNING
Family Activities £200 AS WELL AS ALL THE ABOVE?
Holiday Savings £200 SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?
Christmas Savings £100 £1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?
Clothes £100 EVERY MONTH? NOT ESSENTIAL
Eating Out £100 NOT ESSENTIAL

The problem with getting rid of every lifestyle choice item is where does that leave the economy?

Everything you have cut directly affects someone else's job.

I am a low consumer and do not have expenses anything like the list above, largely for environmental reasons but now of course costs would make it necessary anyway - but what is your answer for the economy when holidays, haircuts, clothes shopping, gym use, activities etc are all cut? Those people will be made redundant.

The UK is in an economic death spiral Sad

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 10:16

Hurrrrrah · 06/09/2022 10:11

Just noticed 3% pension? That's not very much to be paying in, the minimum for our schemes is way more than that.

Their total income, including CB for 2 DC with 5% pension contributions, and plan 1 student loan repayments DH is a little over £4k, slightly less than the example given, but not considerably so.

CoastalWave · 06/09/2022 10:12

Ignore the idiots commenting.

DH brings home £2k a month, I bring in £1.2.

We are massively struggling. Mortgage is £1000. Still trying to pay back credit cards after DH losing his job during Covid - so paying back £500 a month on those. That's half our income gone just like that. Adding in normal bills, food and fuel, literally bugger all left.

Crocwok · 06/09/2022 10:12

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:10

@andymary WOW! I could get rid of 70% of what is on your list!

Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100 NOT ESSENTIAL
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) VERY HIGH
Internet £40 VERY HIGH
Sky/Virgin TV £60 NOT ESSENTIAL
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each) SEEMS HIGH (MINE IS £150 pa)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40 NOT ESSENTIAL
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100 A LIFETYLE CHOICE
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200 POOR FINACIAL PLANNING
Family Activities £200 AS WELL AS ALL THE ABOVE?
Holiday Savings £200 SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?
Christmas Savings £100 £1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?
Clothes £100 EVERY MONTH? NOT ESSENTIAL
Eating Out £100 NOT ESSENTIAL

Well of course, but what a miserable existence when but a few months ago even it was affordable.

Hurrrrrah · 06/09/2022 10:11

Just noticed 3% pension? That's not very much to be paying in, the minimum for our schemes is way more than that.

gamerchick · 06/09/2022 10:11

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 09:32

I love how everyone is quick to critiscise anything that they see as frivoulous spending without thinking of the knock on effect of when this is stopped.

To some people getting your nails done may be a waste of money, or getting a takeaway, or a coffee and cake but that spending creates jobs. So yes now that we are in this cost crisis people who could previously afford to get their nails done now can't, so the salon loses customers and cuts jobs or closes. The takeaway loses customers so cuts staff and closes, so does the coffee shop.

People get rid of their cleaners, stop using their dog walkers, stop going to restaurants, stop getting their hair done etc. etc. this all has a knock on effect. So yes people will just have to cut down but everyone needs to wake up to the serious consequences of this instead of acting like people were silly to be spending this money in the first place, back when they could comfortably afford it.

Absolutely agree. Frankly I'm alarmed at the more frequent these posts are happening. Middle to high income earners who are feeling the pinch. Yes they could tighten their belts but at what cost?

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:10

@andymary WOW! I could get rid of 70% of what is on your list!

Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100 NOT ESSENTIAL
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) VERY HIGH
Internet £40 VERY HIGH
Sky/Virgin TV £60 NOT ESSENTIAL
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each) SEEMS HIGH (MINE IS £150 pa)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40 NOT ESSENTIAL
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100 A LIFETYLE CHOICE
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200 POOR FINACIAL PLANNING
Family Activities £200 AS WELL AS ALL THE ABOVE?
Holiday Savings £200 SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?
Christmas Savings £100 £1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?
Clothes £100 EVERY MONTH? NOT ESSENTIAL
Eating Out £100 NOT ESSENTIAL

Hurrrrrah · 06/09/2022 10:09

andymary · 06/09/2022 09:54

£65k doesn't get you nearly as far as it did 10 years ago. Every household is different, and no family should be compared to the next. No-one should be comparing themselves to your situation to try and put you down OP.

Monthly Incoming After Tax, NI & 3% Pension
£4150

Monthly Outgoings
Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards)
Internet £40
Sky/Virgin TV £60
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200
Family Activities £200
Holiday Savings £200
Christmas Savings £100
Clothes £100
Eating Out £100
Total Out: £4027

So taking this into consideration, it's very tight - one extra bill could easily take you over your budget.
Could you cut down on a lot of stuff? Sure. Should you have to? No. It's not you and your families fault that the world is falling apart and the price of everything is dramatically rocketing up.

You've missed off student loans and pensions, that's a considerable chunk for 2 people it's around £600 combined for my husband and I, we don't earn loans more compared to op.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 10:09

Weirdlynormal · 06/09/2022 09:45

The point is that the economy has grown on the back of excess spending, but when we go into a recession - which we always do, then you going into debt quickly because you have no savings, isn't helping anyone, least of all yourself.

The not spending on the 'frivolous' doesn't mean I don't spend, but it does mean I save for a rainy day. Right now it's fucking pissing it down.

but I could afford frivilous spending and savings. Now I can't but I won't be stopping saving, my savings don't help the poor people who will be out if jobs when more and more people cut their spending will they?

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 06/09/2022 10:09

DH and I are on combined of £45,000 before tax. Two children and a dog. A mortgage, bills, car. We are managing fine. Yes, we don't just go on holiday or buy extravagant things. But I cannot understand why people are struggling on combined salaries more than ours. We still get takeaways or go our for dinner. It blows my mind that people think £65,000 is a struggle. I'm sure someone on here the other day was saying they couldn't survive off of £75,000.

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 10:04

andymary · 06/09/2022 09:54

£65k doesn't get you nearly as far as it did 10 years ago. Every household is different, and no family should be compared to the next. No-one should be comparing themselves to your situation to try and put you down OP.

Monthly Incoming After Tax, NI & 3% Pension
£4150

Monthly Outgoings
Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards)
Internet £40
Sky/Virgin TV £60
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200
Family Activities £200
Holiday Savings £200
Christmas Savings £100
Clothes £100
Eating Out £100
Total Out: £4027

So taking this into consideration, it's very tight - one extra bill could easily take you over your budget.
Could you cut down on a lot of stuff? Sure. Should you have to? No. It's not you and your families fault that the world is falling apart and the price of everything is dramatically rocketing up.

That's not 'very tight' there's quite a lot of slack in that budget.

Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) You can get near unlimited everything for £10 a month

Sky/Virgin TV £60
TV License £12
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40

You've got £100 on pay TV here - either get Sky or a couple of the subscriptions and swap and change, you don't need all that

Home Insurance £35 quite a lot, we pay just over half that and that includes extra for expensive bikes

Quite a lot of lifestyle spending here
Gymnastics/Swimming £100
Family Activities £200
Eating Out £100

Plus you've accounted for just about all annual/irregular expenses like clothes, Christmas, holidays so there shouldn't really be 'unexpected bills', only thing you seem to have missed is car repairs and white goods replacement, but the cost of that could be found by reducing the cost of some of the things mentioned above that you're overpaying for plus you've got over £100 'spare' in that list.

Shineshinecoast10 · 06/09/2022 10:04

Day20 · 05/09/2022 20:42

Poor money management and I think people will be offended by your post who are less fortunate.

So many variants how much is your weekly food shop? How expensive are your phone contracts? You could use sim only once they have ended. Gymnastics could be dropped. Do you have sky? Takeaways?

Yes I agree. I wish I could send my DS to more kids clubs but unfortunately it's not an esstential cost.

I'm sure there is stuff you could cut down on if you really needed to

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:02

Not all boomers had it easy. There was a lot of social and economic upheaval in their lives too. Opportunity for things like Uni just weren’t there. Todays cost of living crisis also happened in the 70s. You can’t directly compare where a boomer is today after sixty years hard graft to where a younger person is today with decades fewer of hard graft

@Discovereads You're talking about me. (YES some of us are on MN)

I think you have got your figures worng. No one works for 60 years (unless they carry on till they are 80.)

I graduated in the mid 1970s. We had the winter of discontent, fuel rationing, blackouts (homework by candlelight) , water from standpipes in 1976, high inflation and a few years later when buying my first home, interest rates of 15%.

The big difference is housing costs. We managed to buy on 1 salary and I was a SAHM for 4 years, followed by working p/t when DCs were at school. Never paid for child care - there was very little around then, other than a few very pricy nurseries or childminders - and didn't have any family nearby to help.

We didn't over stretch ourselves with a super- high mortgage, but when the DCs were at uni we had the equlivalent of 2nd mortgage as we were paying a lot of their living costs.

We never had expensive holidays, were good at saving and were pretty frugal a lot of the time. Now, our savings are going towards the DCs own house purchases to help them out.

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 09:59

Personally, I would step down the mortgage, switch off pension contributions and look for a pay rise or better job.

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 09:58

The last post is utter rubbish, you choose to pay for subscriptions, you choose to do activities and to have 2 cars and have pets and all the upkeep that goes with both.

You can’t blame everyone else for problems with things becoming more expensive. You have to cut your cloth accordingly and know when and where to cut back.

andymary · 06/09/2022 09:54

£65k doesn't get you nearly as far as it did 10 years ago. Every household is different, and no family should be compared to the next. No-one should be comparing themselves to your situation to try and put you down OP.

Monthly Incoming After Tax, NI & 3% Pension
£4150

Monthly Outgoings
Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards)
Internet £40
Sky/Virgin TV £60
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200
Family Activities £200
Holiday Savings £200
Christmas Savings £100
Clothes £100
Eating Out £100
Total Out: £4027

So taking this into consideration, it's very tight - one extra bill could easily take you over your budget.
Could you cut down on a lot of stuff? Sure. Should you have to? No. It's not you and your families fault that the world is falling apart and the price of everything is dramatically rocketing up.

Klippetyklip · 06/09/2022 09:54

Middleagedandcreaking · 05/09/2022 22:26

@ImAvingOops those on much lower incomes can often be better off since their housing costs/council tax are supplemented with benefits, free prescriptions, winter fuel allowances (if pensioners), bus passes (again if retired) and many on lower income will be getting extra cash going towards the heating bills. I honestly don't think the help is as much as you think. If you get all you have listed you will be on a very low income and even with help it will still be relatively low to average earnings. I think entitlement to prescriptions, winter fuel allowance etc goes I've you earn £9k a year.

Very true. At the beginning of this year our income dropped to 12k gross for a few months. We weren’t entitled to any financial help at all except contribution based USA for 6 months and after that nothing.

Tanith · 06/09/2022 09:51

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 09:32

I love how everyone is quick to critiscise anything that they see as frivoulous spending without thinking of the knock on effect of when this is stopped.

To some people getting your nails done may be a waste of money, or getting a takeaway, or a coffee and cake but that spending creates jobs. So yes now that we are in this cost crisis people who could previously afford to get their nails done now can't, so the salon loses customers and cuts jobs or closes. The takeaway loses customers so cuts staff and closes, so does the coffee shop.

People get rid of their cleaners, stop using their dog walkers, stop going to restaurants, stop getting their hair done etc. etc. this all has a knock on effect. So yes people will just have to cut down but everyone needs to wake up to the serious consequences of this instead of acting like people were silly to be spending this money in the first place, back when they could comfortably afford it.

Exactly! And why shouldn't people spend money doing these things instead of invoking the miserly spirit of Edwina Currie as we rush to knit our wooly scarves and pad our radiators with tin foil?

EarlofShrewsbury · 06/09/2022 09:51

Metabigot · 05/09/2022 22:20

I'm the same OP and the simple but boring answer is learning to say no.

No to the coffee at the coffee shop
No to the expensive haircut
No to non essential new clothes
No to impulse supermarket buys
No to a drink out with friends even occasionally

Etc

I only earn 17k a year and I am just about getting by OK as I have family helping with childcare and I live in a house with fairly cheap rent (council house). I would be saying no to most of those things and that's fine, I don't earn much.

However, if I had an income of 65k I would feel very hard done by if I still had to say no to those things.

Times are shit right now and its OK to be disheartened by it, whatever you earn.

HeyBlaby · 06/09/2022 09:48

Unfortunately unless you have an income of less than the square root of absolutely nothing and claim every benefit known to man kind, you're classed as 'well off' on Mumsnet.

notalwaysalondoner · 06/09/2022 09:46

I know what you mean, we’re about to start paying for dc to go to nursery four days a week and it’s £1200, that’s a lot to find on top of tripled energy bills which in our freezing ancient cottage will likely be near £1000 per month too by January thanks to an electric boiler. We’re not low earners at all but I’m very aware if we earnt what you do or less we’d really struggle. I do think there is a lot of lifestyle creep, in our mid twenties DH and I only earnt about a quarter of what we do now but it doesn’t feel like we have a crazy different lifestyle, but then when I think about it, I always buy lunch when we go out for the day, I always buy coffee and cake when I’m meeting friends, I don’t really carefully check prices any more… it’s not like I go nuts and have loads of designer labels but I’ve got lazy about spending, and I think that’s where a lot of the money winds up going. It’s going to have to change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread