Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be struggling to survive on 65k household income

581 replies

Soddinghell · 05/09/2022 20:38

By the time we have paid mortgage, phone bills, bills car insurance, kids activities etc we barely have anything left. I don’t know what’s going on. DH earns 50k and I earn 15k part time. Please somebody help me I am thinking of going full time to stay afloat, I don’t know where we are going wrong, we are not in London or an expensive area, just outside manchester and people keep telling us we should be fine. We are not though!

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:34

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:21

@Quincythequince Now you are being the silly one. That list of TV stuff is mind boggling. I wonder how I've lived with just my TV licence for decades without the need for all those other subscriptions? Truly amazing. Maybe it's because I have hobies and interests that don't depend on watching other people do stuff on a box!

And, being very serious, pets are a commitment both in terms of finance and time. No one is saying get rid of the pets, but there is a huge amount of unnecessary spending on that list.

Yes fine,

but to get rid of pets and car, and also and mocking for existing debt.

Then get rid of all activities etc ?

Some of that can be removed for sure, but some of that advice is just rubbish.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 10:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Crocwok · 06/09/2022 10:33

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:28

Hmm, you've pissed me off because high earners benefit from being at the top of an economy that enables you to earn what you do. Your tax contribution goes into sustaining the very system you are benefitting from.

I am not a race to the bottom person but your comment is pretty annoying so you can have Biscuit and if you want to do an experiment, bugger off to somewhere with no lower paid workforce propping up your earnings and see how you get on.

What would be the incentive to go into careers that require a lot of training and responsibility if you didn't earn more? It's not about working harder or anything as plenty of lower paid people work bloody hard in challenging jobs; but just curious about why having people that earn is an issue. Sure big corps on huge money or whatever, but a consultant for example no one would touch that with a barge pole if it was similarly paid to other jobs.

Isonthecase · 06/09/2022 10:32

This has got ready judgey. I can well believe that someone on a family income of £65k would struggle with the nursery years - we still found it tight despite higher wages and used savings to top up at the height of the costs. Our household income will reach a similar point next year due to some long planned choices and I'm still worried about it because everything is getter more expensive, despite having a sensible savings buffer.

An awful lot of people have stretched themselves based on the last 20 years things being cheap. It's pretty disgusting judging them based on life experience with high interest rates that in some cases happened before they were born. How on earth are they meant to have known to anticipate what that means?!

I bet the people judging this would also be the ones judging those trying to have babies later because they couldn't afford the house and childcare without really stretching themselves. So glad for them being able to predict the future, not just being lucky at the right time...

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:31

BUT THEY WERE NOT WHEN THEY MADE THE CHOICE TO TAKE THEM ON

They also weren’t struggling with constantly increasing costs, high inflation etc when they took them on. Should OP apologise for not having a crystal ball.

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 10:31

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:24

Unlimited data that is.

And don’t come back with the ‘who even needs that’ because that’s not what you said.

I said 'near unlimited everything' for £10 a month.

Dozens of 10 Gb+ data plans, which is absolutely loads, plus calls and texts from about £8

www.moneysavingexpert.com/cheap-mobile-finder/sim-only-filters/,

The list also had £40 of home broadband, which is also well above the minimum available, so its not like its the only source of data for the household.

Obviously you need a phone as well, but that doesn't need to cost much. My last one was on a Prime Day deal for £150 reduced from £250 for a decent spec Samsung and I sold my old one that I'd had for 3 years for £60, so my cost of owning a phone over the last few years was about £3 a month.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:30

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:27

So much ignorance and judgement on here!

Yes, try reading your latest post.

It's all a lifestyle choice.

They may be locked in now, with pets and subs for things, BUT THEY WERE NOT WHEN THEY MADE THE CHOICE TO TAKE THEM ON.

And you come along defending debts as if they just happen. No, people make choices.

@JaneBrowning do you understand economics at all? Do you just want other people punished? What do you think will happen to the UK economy if all 'lifestyle' spending is cut - do you understand how bad that will be for services and the poorest?

I am a fairly low spender, but people who want the economy to fail are very strange.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:30

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:27

So much ignorance and judgement on here!

Yes, try reading your latest post.

It's all a lifestyle choice.

They may be locked in now, with pets and subs for things, BUT THEY WERE NOT WHEN THEY MADE THE CHOICE TO TAKE THEM ON.

And you come along defending debts as if they just happen. No, people make choices.

Telling someone to get rose of pets, and a car and calling them lifestyle choices that you don’t need to spend on, is deluded.

Just dump your pet? Really.

Just sell your car and use public transport.

Just waiting for someone to come on and say you don’t need new shoes. Just repair the holes with cardboard and tar.

People should expect more! Competitive poverty is so tiresome. The OP came on for help.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:28

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:24

@Cherryblossoms85 I agree. My DH's tax was around the same as some people earn- around £27K pa. We were not living in luxury, as we were supporting 2 DCs for a total of 7 years at uni, at one point. (And before anyone says anything on that, they were doing degrees that did not allow time to work during term time, only in the holidays.)

People forget it's high earners who are paying their benefits and for the NHS.

Hmm, you've pissed me off because high earners benefit from being at the top of an economy that enables you to earn what you do. Your tax contribution goes into sustaining the very system you are benefitting from.

I am not a race to the bottom person but your comment is pretty annoying so you can have Biscuit and if you want to do an experiment, bugger off to somewhere with no lower paid workforce propping up your earnings and see how you get on.

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:27

So much ignorance and judgement on here!

Yes, try reading your latest post.

It's all a lifestyle choice.

They may be locked in now, with pets and subs for things, BUT THEY WERE NOT WHEN THEY MADE THE CHOICE TO TAKE THEM ON.

And you come along defending debts as if they just happen. No, people make choices.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:26

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:25

@Quincythequince I will. We pay £8 per month for unlimited.

Umlimited data?

Not texts or minutes (those aren’t used a lot nowadays).

Which provider?

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:25

You don’t need to have two cars, you choose to have them

You don’t know what she needs though do you. Stop talking utter crap Mrs 1950s stay at home servant.

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:25

@Quincythequince I will. We pay £8 per month for unlimited.

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:24

@Cherryblossoms85 I agree. My DH's tax was around the same as some people earn- around £27K pa. We were not living in luxury, as we were supporting 2 DCs for a total of 7 years at uni, at one point. (And before anyone says anything on that, they were doing degrees that did not allow time to work during term time, only in the holidays.)

People forget it's high earners who are paying their benefits and for the NHS.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:24

Unlimited data that is.

And don’t come back with the ‘who even needs that’ because that’s not what you said.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:24

AprilRae91 · 06/09/2022 10:22

No you are not BU. We have a similar income and have no clue how to afford full nursery fees. Our mortgage is too high we should have bought a cheaper home but didn’t anticipate other living costs going up so much. Recently confided in a relative and she had a right go at me for ‘earning loads and complaining’.

It is the rapid change that is causing the problem.

People are rational and sensible, mostly, but we now have an energy crisis that the government did not know was coming and inflation that Johnson (the useless twat) said was not going to happen.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:23

Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) You can get near unlimited everything for £10 a month

Rubbish! Show me where you can get unlimited for £10 a month.

Additionally,

-Pets are not a lifestyle choice.

-Whether it was poor financial planning or not, the debt still needs to be paid now

-Car insurance depends on many thing so to blanket compare it to yours with no other information is just stupid.

-If you’re locked into a sky contract, or an internet contract, again, it has to be paid now. You can’t always just swap.

So much ignorance and judgement on here!

AprilRae91 · 06/09/2022 10:22

No you are not BU. We have a similar income and have no clue how to afford full nursery fees. Our mortgage is too high we should have bought a cheaper home but didn’t anticipate other living costs going up so much. Recently confided in a relative and she had a right go at me for ‘earning loads and complaining’.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:21

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 10:19

You don’t need to have two cars, you choose to have them.

It’s because of the choices you made to live to 99% of your income then you’ve left no capacity to weather any increase in costs.

Same goes for all the other optional costs like subscriptions etc.

You can’t whinge and say you have no money when you’ve spent it all.

This is such a ridiculus thing to say. Some families have two cars to get two people to two different workplaces.

Our family has no cars, but I can understand why other people have them.

Do you live in 1955 where wives stayed home and men walked to work round the corner?

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:21

@Quincythequince Now you are being the silly one. That list of TV stuff is mind boggling. I wonder how I've lived with just my TV licence for decades without the need for all those other subscriptions? Truly amazing. Maybe it's because I have hobies and interests that don't depend on watching other people do stuff on a box!

And, being very serious, pets are a commitment both in terms of finance and time. No one is saying get rid of the pets, but there is a huge amount of unnecessary spending on that list.

Crocwok · 06/09/2022 10:21

Some families do need 2 cars though depending on the public transport network locally and whether they are required for work or not. The bitterness and desire for everyone to suffer because some are is part of what's dragging this sorry little island down the toilet.

Cherryblossoms85 · 06/09/2022 10:20

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 06:32

And FWIW our household is an extremely high earning household, and we have noticed the difference in our monthly outgoings.

@Quincythequince Never allowed to earn money on mumsnet! It would be nice if there was ever a positive view of high earners and the tax they pay that (amongst many other taxes) funds every single government stimulus package. Social housing, schools, benefits, furlough, energy bills, it's all based on tax take that provides the collateral for governments to borrow on top. People invest in government bonds, the underlyer is tax. If my DH and I both worked and earned, say, 70k each, our take-home household income would be 96k. As it is, the income is from a sole earner on 140k, so our household income is 83k. So that's 13k additional tax a year (and a total of 57k) that is being redistributed, which is fine by me, but it would be nice if it wasn't always somehow a negative to earn a lot. If nobody earned that much, we'd all be even more utterly fucked.

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 10:19

You don’t need to have two cars, you choose to have them.

It’s because of the choices you made to live to 99% of your income then you’ve left no capacity to weather any increase in costs.

Same goes for all the other optional costs like subscriptions etc.

You can’t whinge and say you have no money when you’ve spent it all.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:19

Maybe people can eat their pets, save on food costs and the upkeep.

WTF is the UK coming to when people are blaming ordinary people for buying ordinary things.

I have much lower income than the OP, by far - but I can see it is not really in my interests for everyone in the country to be tightening their belts and stopping spending.

Comedycook · 06/09/2022 10:18

I can see how if you have a big mortgage and childcare costs, 65k could be quite tight. It might sound like a lot to earn but you won't be living a very lavish lifestyle on that.