Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be struggling to survive on 65k household income

581 replies

Soddinghell · 05/09/2022 20:38

By the time we have paid mortgage, phone bills, bills car insurance, kids activities etc we barely have anything left. I don’t know what’s going on. DH earns 50k and I earn 15k part time. Please somebody help me I am thinking of going full time to stay afloat, I don’t know where we are going wrong, we are not in London or an expensive area, just outside manchester and people keep telling us we should be fine. We are not though!

OP posts:
Weirdlynormal · 06/09/2022 11:10

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/09/2022 10:09

but I could afford frivilous spending and savings. Now I can't but I won't be stopping saving, my savings don't help the poor people who will be out if jobs when more and more people cut their spending will they?

No it won't, but structurally we are an economy that is built of services. This is a government level issue and not one that is solved by you going bankrupt.

WrongWayApricot · 06/09/2022 11:07

If OP had called the thread aibu to struggle paying for swimming lessons there wouldn't be people offended. But OP called it struggling to survive, OP and her family are not going to die because they can't afford after school activities for a few years. Yes it is annoying and saddening to have to give up the few things that make us happy but it's definitely not struggling to survive and that's what pissed people off.

And OP said that after paying for the activities there's barely any left over. Even more offensive to call it struggling to survive when what you're actually complaining about is not having enough (not none at all) spare money to save or spend after you've paid for non essentials. OP will survive without all the spending money she's used to 🙄

HillyBillyBumkin · 06/09/2022 11:06

There will always be times when two cars are necessary to get to work and school. There are also many instances (Mine included) where a household could make a few inconvenient changes (but nothing mind blowing), and go down to one car. it's personal choice.

I remember when the shops limited their customers during the pandemic, I have type 1 diabetes and always have sweets in case of a hypo. I went into a local store and was actually shouted at for breaking rules just to buy sweets , fat cow that I was! - (I am not fat, and I wasn't breaking rules either). That still pisses me off 😂.

This is the same parallel. Don't make judgements based on what you think other peoples priorities are. A lot of us, from different incomes need to re-evaluate our choices, and our priorities. People generally know themselves and their life choices and why they were made. We need to stop judging them for circumstances we know nothing about.

Well we don't need to.... but wouldn't it be lovely!

FayeGovan · 06/09/2022 10:59

Exactly @Hagpie

CoastalWave · 06/09/2022 10:57

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 10:19

You don’t need to have two cars, you choose to have them.

It’s because of the choices you made to live to 99% of your income then you’ve left no capacity to weather any increase in costs.

Same goes for all the other optional costs like subscriptions etc.

You can’t whinge and say you have no money when you’ve spent it all.

You don't 'choose' to have two cars when you live in the countryside with zero public transport - and the kids school is one direction when other person's work is in the other (and other person starts work at 5,30am anyway so irrelevant really)

I have to have two cars. Trust me - would much rather have neither, but needs must. Or else are you suggesting my kids walk 5 miles there and back to school each day?

andymary · 06/09/2022 10:57

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:18

@andymary Seriously, you need some good financial advice.

You ought not to be paying off £200 pm in debts owed (which you have ramped up) while saving for things like holidays and Xmas presents.

Your debts are presumably credit cards so you are spending yet paying interest, but at the same time putting money away for things like holidays and presents.

Your spending on non-essentials is very high.

Your 'entertainment' costs are huge. You are paying way over the odds for your phone and internet.

Your mortage and council tax are , in comparion, quite low. (My coucnil tax is more like £280 a month.)

I can't get my head round these outgoing.

Have you thought of asking a professional to help you with your budgeting?

Nowhere did I say that these are MY figures. They are estimated, from doing actual research. So before you go attacking somebody online, think before you act.
The £200 in debt repayments is estimated based on the average UK household debt. £200 / month is the estimated repayment on the average household debt. Just because you may not be in debt, doesn't mean to say others aren't.

Council Tax - Have you considered that the cost changes quite a lot throughout the country? Again, if you bothered to do real research before talking, you'd see that Council Tax in the UK varies from between £870 - £2300 per year depending on the location. Not every body lives in the same city as you, so the whole country isn't paying £280 / month.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:56

andymary · 06/09/2022 10:48

Can the outgoings be cut down? Of course they can. Should they have to be in this day and age? No.

"POOR FINACIAL PLANNING" - 95% of the country is in debt in some way. Don't be so naive.

"£1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?" - Have you ever had children? A £600 games console for one child could take half this budget. Then £600 left for the parents to get each other something for Christmas, any other children's presents, parents, grandparents, sisters, brothers, Christmas decorations, Christmas food. Be serious. But we already know your answer back to his "Don't buy them a games console the". Ok, we'll just buy them a colouring book and some crayons.

"SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?" - Sorry, are you not allowed to take your children away on holiday if you have debt? Sorry kids, we can never take you away to experience a holiday until the mortgage is paid off in 30 years.

Did you even read my post???
Every household is different, and no family should be compared to the next. No-one should be comparing themselves to your situation to try and put you down OP.

Ignore Jane.

She is deluded, seems to have no clue about modern finances and probably only ever has to budget to spend her PIN money. That’s how it comes across anyway. Probably also doesn’t appreciate the genuine advantages that Boomers had either.

Headabovetheparakeet · 06/09/2022 10:55

@Zeus44

The fact that you said upthread that someone should reduce mortgage payments and stop contributing to their pension suggests that you are not a financial advisor and actually know nothing about good financial planning.

bringincrazyback · 06/09/2022 10:52

You can live off one car easily, just car share or use public transport.

Not true for everybody. Depends entirely on where the individuals in question work, and what other transport needs they have through the day.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:52

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 10:48

It’s your single track mind that results in responses such as this.

You can live off one car easily, just car share or use public transport.

Nonetheless, the answer is you have to make decisions yourself to cut costs from your own budget. If you don’t then you’ll go broke.

Simples.

No, you can’t!

You are talking absolute rubbish.

It would be cheaper for us to run a second car where we live to get my boys to school, than it would to use the only transport there is. I live 25 minutes outside of kings cross in Herts.

There is no suitable public transport in many places in the UK and I’m not even rural.

Let that sink in why don’t you.

Your earlier reponses are shockingly rude and I would suggest you are totally detached from reality as it stands. Some savings to be made, sure! But your general narrative around this is appallingly ignorant.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/09/2022 10:51

There are some real arseholes on here this morning tbh.

There really are. I'm not sure if it's down to jealousy, as soon as they hear someone's on a higher wage than them. They just don't seem to get that inflation has affected everyone, not just those on the lower income.

Hagpie · 06/09/2022 10:51

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 08:42

I'm laughing at the posters saying they are high earners.

£65Kpa is the same as 2 full time earners on £32K ish.

That's the low salary of teachers, nurses, some PAs, admin staff in local government, etc.

Most graduates now start on £26K+

People on these threads who say they only earn £x are unqualified and in low skilled/ no skilled jobs. Funny how they have so much time to waste online on forums, rather than looking for better paid work, or training for something paying more.

This. This is it. This is why we can’t have solidarity and improve everyone’s situation. If OP’s household income was £15K then people would be telling her that frost on the inside of her windows was a perfectly acceptable situation in winter etc. So you have the money saving experts lower earners who are sick to death of being told to stop buying flat screen TVs or whatever on one side and you have the sneering middle classes that overwhelmingly think (out loud or not) that poverty is a moral choice. That to be poor you have to have done something wrong and because you did everything right, you deserve to look down on McDonald’s workers, unemployed single parents and the like, not thinking it could be you. Although I don’t feel the same way about OP and I do feel for her, this sentiment is why a lot of people on lower incomes see the “squeezed middle” and roll their eyes - now it IS you. Welcome to Tory Britain my love where going above and beyond extends to everything but your pay. Have you tried putting another jumper on and stop spending all your money on fags and alcohol?

andymary · 06/09/2022 10:48

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:10

@andymary WOW! I could get rid of 70% of what is on your list!

Mortgage £1000
Electric/Gas £250
Food Shopping £500
Nursery £600
Gymnastics/Swimming £100 NOT ESSENTIAL
Mobile Phones £40 (2x £20 Sim Cards) VERY HIGH
Internet £40 VERY HIGH
Sky/Virgin TV £60 NOT ESSENTIAL
TV License £12
Council Tax £150
Car Insurance £80 (Two Cars at £40 each) SEEMS HIGH (MINE IS £150 pa)
Petrol £100 (Two Cars at £50 each)
Subscriptions (Netflix/Prime/Disney/Spotify) £40 NOT ESSENTIAL
Home Insurance £35
Life Insurance £20
Pets £100 A LIFETYLE CHOICE
Debt Repayment (Loan/Credit Card based on the UK debt average) £200 POOR FINACIAL PLANNING
Family Activities £200 AS WELL AS ALL THE ABOVE?
Holiday Savings £200 SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?
Christmas Savings £100 £1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?
Clothes £100 EVERY MONTH? NOT ESSENTIAL
Eating Out £100 NOT ESSENTIAL

Can the outgoings be cut down? Of course they can. Should they have to be in this day and age? No.

"POOR FINACIAL PLANNING" - 95% of the country is in debt in some way. Don't be so naive.

"£1200 ON XMAS PRESENTS?" - Have you ever had children? A £600 games console for one child could take half this budget. Then £600 left for the parents to get each other something for Christmas, any other children's presents, parents, grandparents, sisters, brothers, Christmas decorations, Christmas food. Be serious. But we already know your answer back to his "Don't buy them a games console the". Ok, we'll just buy them a colouring book and some crayons.

"SAVING FOR HOLS YET PAYING OFF DEBTS?" - Sorry, are you not allowed to take your children away on holiday if you have debt? Sorry kids, we can never take you away to experience a holiday until the mortgage is paid off in 30 years.

Did you even read my post???
Every household is different, and no family should be compared to the next. No-one should be comparing themselves to your situation to try and put you down OP.

Zeus44 · 06/09/2022 10:48

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:25

You don’t need to have two cars, you choose to have them

You don’t know what she needs though do you. Stop talking utter crap Mrs 1950s stay at home servant.

It’s your single track mind that results in responses such as this.

You can live off one car easily, just car share or use public transport.

Nonetheless, the answer is you have to make decisions yourself to cut costs from your own budget. If you don’t then you’ll go broke.

Simples.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:46

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/09/2022 10:42

But if they cannot understand everyone's circumstances are changing, not just the lower income individuals, they are a bit dim. I don't see that that poster was wrong to point it out.

She wasn’t wrong to point it out.

There are some real arseholes on here this morning tbh.

ColadhSamh · 06/09/2022 10:45

Someone asked for help and support and although many are supportive some responses are a disgrace. How do we know the OP's situation or how desperate they are? What we do know is that they have left this thread possibly never to return. Why when someone is desperate enough to post on here are there some who cannot wait to put the boot in.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/09/2022 10:42

HillyBillyBumkin · 06/09/2022 10:36

FFS, can we not call other posters slow and dim? It completely undermines any point you are trying to make. This is a forum and if you can't have a discussion without personally attacking someone else you need to have a word with yourself.

But if they cannot understand everyone's circumstances are changing, not just the lower income individuals, they are a bit dim. I don't see that that poster was wrong to point it out.

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 10:40

Crocwok · 06/09/2022 10:33

What would be the incentive to go into careers that require a lot of training and responsibility if you didn't earn more? It's not about working harder or anything as plenty of lower paid people work bloody hard in challenging jobs; but just curious about why having people that earn is an issue. Sure big corps on huge money or whatever, but a consultant for example no one would touch that with a barge pole if it was similarly paid to other jobs.

It is not a problem having people earn plenty, but there is a point where the gap between top and bottom is too wide. You could read The Spirt Level if you cared.

But I am not arguing for that poster to have lower wages, I am just pointing out that their taxation funds the very system that delivers those wages in the first place. So they are paying in to keep getting out. Tax is not a charitable donation - it is a rational investment in a society that supports our way of life.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:40

Nobody below a certain age calls Or texts btw.

You seem not to realise this. They give it out for free because it costs them nothing as it’s under utilised.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:39

Dozens of 10 Gb+ data plans, which is absolutely loads, plus calls and texts from about £8

Yes, enough for you maybe!

My kids use their phones and data at school (for work btw, not just browsing) and 10GB per month would not allow for that.

So your statement doesn’t hold true for everyone.

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 10:38

Leaving aside all the arguments, it's a huge risk to spend all your money on your current lifestyle when you have a decent income and can afford to put some money aside for a rainy day as well as having nice things and experiences.

That shouldn't be too hard for anyone to work out and put into practice.

Tanith · 06/09/2022 10:37

“WTF is the UK coming to when people are blaming ordinary people for buying ordinary things.”

I bet Johnson, Truss, Mogg et al won’t be sat knitting jumpers to keep their families warm.
Perhaps if they and their cronies stopped fleecing the country with expenses claims and dodgy companies, there’d be more for the rest of us.
Their party is in no position to lecture us on frugal living.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This! 💯

HillyBillyBumkin · 06/09/2022 10:36

FFS, can we not call other posters slow and dim? It completely undermines any point you are trying to make. This is a forum and if you can't have a discussion without personally attacking someone else you need to have a word with yourself.

Quincythequince · 06/09/2022 10:35

And we have no TV subscriptions in our house either - just Netflix. No sky, no other paid for TV at all.

I can’t believe some of the snide remarks directed at this poor OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread