Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be struggling to survive on 65k household income

581 replies

Soddinghell · 05/09/2022 20:38

By the time we have paid mortgage, phone bills, bills car insurance, kids activities etc we barely have anything left. I don’t know what’s going on. DH earns 50k and I earn 15k part time. Please somebody help me I am thinking of going full time to stay afloat, I don’t know where we are going wrong, we are not in London or an expensive area, just outside manchester and people keep telling us we should be fine. We are not though!

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2022 15:46

Cycling in Denmark is a completely different undertaking to cycling in the UK.

Denmark has proper cycle lanes everywhere.

The population density is much lower. Nearly all Danish motorists also cycle so you don't have a good proportion of them that despise cyclists and think they shouldn't exist.

In Denmark you can leave your bike on the street and expect it to still be there when you get back. This is an alien concept to any British cyclist, where bike theft is rife in many areas.

Denmark is, in the main, mostly very flat. A lot of the UK is very hilly which is not conducive to arriving at work looking neat and tidy. Plus in the UK you have many people who live a long way from work, because they can't afford to live where they work and there are no jobs where they live.

So it's really not a case that 'they all cycle in Denmark so we should do the same here' I wish it was, but it's not.

Aintnosupermum · 07/09/2022 15:39

Yup I rented a cargo bike and cycled with my 3 children. Worked far better than I thought it would and they enjoyed it. Of course they have to wear cycling helmets but really not an issue.

I cycled on the road a lot and traffic was quite aggressive. When it came to crossing traffic I used the pedestrian crossings and walked my bike across. Felt much safer than cycling into the middle of the road.

dianthus101 · 07/09/2022 15:26

Aintnosupermum · 07/09/2022 15:09

Guys, instead of a second car, how many of us could be cycling?

When living in Denmark I used a bicycle as the second mode of transport and paid the extra for a good quality second hand one. I do recommend getting one which is electric if you have hills. Instead of £350 a month cost for a car, I paid about £25 a month as I didn’t do the maintenance myself. Upfront cost was £450 for the bike, accessories and lock, rain gear was £130 and I paid about £100 for a full service twice a year. I took the bike to the UK and keep it at my fathers house. I use it all the time when I am visiting him. It’s absolutely brilliant for getting around. The baskets on the front and back and the backpack I use holds a lot of shopping. Certainly enough for a family of 4 for the good part of a week.

If you have children the cargo bikes are great. They are about £3500-5000 new and definitely get the electric one because cycling with 3 children in the bucket is quite the workout.

No it’s not ‘cheap’ but it’s a lot cheaper than a second car. It’s also a choice which is towards what is needed than a car, which I see as a want. I make enough to have a second car and just bought one of the damn things because the road I need to take with the children doesn’t allow bicycles! Yes I’m currently in the US. For all the green energy legislation they should have started by forcing towns and cities to be bike friendly.

Cyclng in the countryside is great but there is no way I would want to cycle in my nearest city.. There are no cycle lanes and it's quite dangerous some areas. As for cycling with three children in a cargo bike- wtf?

Aintnosupermum · 07/09/2022 15:09

Guys, instead of a second car, how many of us could be cycling?

When living in Denmark I used a bicycle as the second mode of transport and paid the extra for a good quality second hand one. I do recommend getting one which is electric if you have hills. Instead of £350 a month cost for a car, I paid about £25 a month as I didn’t do the maintenance myself. Upfront cost was £450 for the bike, accessories and lock, rain gear was £130 and I paid about £100 for a full service twice a year. I took the bike to the UK and keep it at my fathers house. I use it all the time when I am visiting him. It’s absolutely brilliant for getting around. The baskets on the front and back and the backpack I use holds a lot of shopping. Certainly enough for a family of 4 for the good part of a week.

If you have children the cargo bikes are great. They are about £3500-5000 new and definitely get the electric one because cycling with 3 children in the bucket is quite the workout.

No it’s not ‘cheap’ but it’s a lot cheaper than a second car. It’s also a choice which is towards what is needed than a car, which I see as a want. I make enough to have a second car and just bought one of the damn things because the road I need to take with the children doesn’t allow bicycles! Yes I’m currently in the US. For all the green energy legislation they should have started by forcing towns and cities to be bike friendly.

Mascia · 07/09/2022 11:01

BarbaraofSeville · 06/09/2022 15:24

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior That's true and it is likely that there's going to be closures in the leisure and hospitality sector, but it's not up to other members of the public to threaten their own financial stability, get themselves into debt and potentially lose their homes to prop up these businesses.

Can you imagine having to explain to your credit card provider why you hadn't paid your bill but were still spending on meals out and activities? 'I knew I didn't have any money, but was trying to stop the local restaurant or the soft play centre from going bust'.

No need to get into debt, just be aware of how everyone cutting out the “non-essentials” affects those providing these services.

RJnomore1 · 07/09/2022 10:31

I think people are missing the point if those with a bit more money didn’t so end it when they have it, there would be less service, hospitality, manufacturing jobs and it would be worse for longer for those in lower paid posts, less VAT etc so less money for the government, but they would be sitting on tidy sums and probably accused of hoarding wealth… you can’t win sometimes.

Mascia · 07/09/2022 10:01

bringincrazyback · 06/09/2022 10:52

You can live off one car easily, just car share or use public transport.

Not true for everybody. Depends entirely on where the individuals in question work, and what other transport needs they have through the day.

Definitely not true for everyone.
We didn’t have a car at all for several years, but we lived in a big city with excellent public transport.
Now we live in a smallish town and definitely need at least one car, better two. If you work outside that town the busses are once every hour or even less often, so public transport is not a great option.

Mascia · 07/09/2022 09:46

JaneBrowning · 06/09/2022 10:27

So much ignorance and judgement on here!

Yes, try reading your latest post.

It's all a lifestyle choice.

They may be locked in now, with pets and subs for things, BUT THEY WERE NOT WHEN THEY MADE THE CHOICE TO TAKE THEM ON.

And you come along defending debts as if they just happen. No, people make choices.

So nobody should get pets even if they can afford them, because their circumstances might change at some point in their life?
And all the non-essential businesses can just close down?

Mascia · 07/09/2022 09:27

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 09:44

Oh totally agree.

Why has the UK become a race to the bottom? We used to be an aspirational country where you could earn a decent wage and build some security - which also meant paying others for services which helped build jobs across the economy. It is just getting tougher all round now.

Fully agree with both. @ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler you’re making a very important point.
I know several small business owners - what they offer would either be classed as non-essential or could be purchased elsewhere (from bigger companies and not of the same quality) for less.

But if they all closed down, not only would all these people lose their income, but our already struggling town would become even more depressing.

Believeitornot · 07/09/2022 08:21

CherryGenoa · 07/09/2022 07:51

It may become impossible for some families to afford two cars, in which case they will be forced to think more flexibly and change something, be move jobs, move house or ask for a pay rise to cover higher commuting costs… I have a really good electric bike and use a pool car when I need one for work. It would have been unthinkable a few years ago but it works well in reality. The culture is changing.

“Move house”. Yes because that’s cheap.

CherryGenoa · 07/09/2022 07:51

It may become impossible for some families to afford two cars, in which case they will be forced to think more flexibly and change something, be move jobs, move house or ask for a pay rise to cover higher commuting costs… I have a really good electric bike and use a pool car when I need one for work. It would have been unthinkable a few years ago but it works well in reality. The culture is changing.

TartanGirl1 · 07/09/2022 07:01

Can we all stop taking the piss out of the one car suggestion? For some people it is a very viable option for others it is impossible.

The OP has so little information on it helping is only ever going to be vague suggestions.

EntertainingandFactual · 06/09/2022 22:12

Ah yes, get rid of one of the cars…
I’d end up with no job as well as no car if I did that.
A 20 min walk to the station, 30min on the most unreliable train service to ever exist (if I’m lucky) followed by another 30 min journey on train 2, finishing off with another 20 min walk to work.
Or, I could drive there in 30 min…

DH used to get the train to work & it took him a ridiculous amount of time. It also cost him a fortune compared to fuel & car costs.
Unless you live somewhere with an amazing transport network you have no option.

AprilRae91 · 06/09/2022 22:01

@Zeus44 lots families need two cars what the heck are you on about? I couldn’t get to work without my own car!

AprilRae91 · 06/09/2022 21:59

How are some people saying a couple doesn’t need two cars?! My partner travels all over the country in his car for work and I wouldn’t be able to get to my work without my own car as there’s no public transport routes

Jmaho · 06/09/2022 21:01

YoniWheretheSunDontShine · 06/09/2022 20:48

I can't plough through this but it's perfectly normal for wealthy earners to spend what they earn.
Books like the millionaire nextdoor are about people who earn more but keep their lifestyle the Same.
It's very common to earn more and spend more.
People often don't actually know how to budget or save!
There will be people on far more , struggling more!

I absolutely agree with you. We are in a good financial position now and able to live a nice life and save (still a far way from the £100k household income though!) but this is due to payrises over the last couple of years and childcare costs ending. We didn't suddenly change our lifestyle spending or upgrade our cars etc. We've had a similar budget for a fair few years now and any payrises have covered additional savings and increases in bills etc
I know people already in debt as they are big spenders, always had lots of debt, always will, get a promotion and then immediately take out an even bigger HP or lease on a nicer car. Wouldn't even consider paying off debt or saving
Everyone has a different attitude towards money
I work in mortgages and some cases I see are quite shocking. People earning serious money but blowing through it with tons of debt and huge overdrafts so big that they're both on 6 figures yet don't even get out of the overdraft every month on payday. I couldn't live like that but people do. Lots of people on high salaries are literally living paycheck to paycheck but they would likely have more means to handle a bad situation than a much lower earner would
For us if we ever do get to £100k household which I hope we do in the next 10 years it would just mean maybe a few more treats and more in savings and pensions

YoniWheretheSunDontShine · 06/09/2022 20:48

I can't plough through this but it's perfectly normal for wealthy earners to spend what they earn.
Books like the millionaire nextdoor are about people who earn more but keep their lifestyle the Same.
It's very common to earn more and spend more.
People often don't actually know how to budget or save!
There will be people on far more , struggling more!

carefullycourageous · 06/09/2022 18:39

AKnitterofThings · 06/09/2022 18:32

Can someone explain what the term “ it’s not a race to the bottom” means? I keep seeing it on this thread.
Thank you

It comes from international industrial competition/globalisation etc - where everyone competes by cutting to the bone: www.investopedia.com/terms/r/race-bottom.asp

What people mean on here is we should be trying to improve things, not drag everyone down to the lowest level. Basically let's all try to bring everyone's living standards up, not bring them all down.

"I am struggling on £65k"
"Tough shit, you should try it on £40k"
"WTF! I'm only on £20k, suck it up!"

These energy prices are fucking us all over. We need to stand together. If those on £20k (or less!) just attack those on £40k, the people who get let off the hook are those in power who are creating the problems.

Wouldloveanother · 06/09/2022 18:35

AKnitterofThings · 06/09/2022 18:32

Can someone explain what the term “ it’s not a race to the bottom” means? I keep seeing it on this thread.
Thank you

It means it isn’t a competition to see who is the hardest done by etc - you can be in a shit position, the fact someone else is in a shitter one doesn’t make it okay.

AKnitterofThings · 06/09/2022 18:32

Can someone explain what the term “ it’s not a race to the bottom” means? I keep seeing it on this thread.
Thank you

Jmaho · 06/09/2022 18:16

knickersniff · 06/09/2022 17:04

It's the 50k , you'll be paying in the higher tax band so although it sounds a lot it's really not that much .

It doesn't work like this. The higher tax bracket kicks in at £50271 and you only pay 40% tax on any income earnt above this figure
If apps husband/partner is on £50k they will also still be able to get child benefit

steppon · 06/09/2022 17:54

Well I live in a labour stronghold & agree with the OP.

FayeGovan · 06/09/2022 17:51

I'd like to know if the op did..

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 06/09/2022 17:47

FayeGovan · 06/09/2022 17:33

Someone died and left everyone on this thread in charge apparently

im just wondering how many of the squeezed middle now complaining like the op, voted tory when it suited them? Loads on mn I reckon.

I dunno, we hear all the time that MN is a Labour stronghold. Usually from right wingers who think it's somehow telling that a site skewing younger and more female than voters as a whole doesn't accurately reflect the national demographic.

steppon · 06/09/2022 17:43

im just wondering how many of the squeezed middle now complaining like the op, voted tory when it suited them? Loads on mn I reckon.

I think it's the ones who are so critical of the OP that likely voted tory.

Swipe left for the next trending thread