Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving Tests every 25 years?

233 replies

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 14:02

I’m learning to drive right now... I’m in my mid 30s. I think everyone should have to retake their driving test every 25 years. To both raise revenue and get higher standards of driving. I feel if you have nothing to improve then nothing to worry about. If you’re good enough to pass the test you deserve to drive on the road. If not, then buses for you.

OP posts:
Abraxan · 05/09/2022 15:31

Giveaschitt · 05/09/2022 15:26

It used to be said that Learner Drivers learnt to pass their Driving Test. It was only after that they actually learnt to drive... I suspect this is still very true. So testing people 'regularly' (which 25 years isn't...) would do the same thing - people wouldn't drive during their test the way they drive the rest of the time.

But I suspect you're just being goady...

This is very much the case in many ways.

And the current system is a flawed system as it doesn't actually result with a good driver necessarily. It results in someone who does well in the day, for 45 minutes or so. Where you take your test, the time of day, the level of traffic in the road, and the actual examiner on the day varies so much across the country it isn't even the same test they all do. A person could pass one day, but fail the next.

Simonjt · 05/09/2022 15:30

As an experienced driver I can drive to test conditions to pass a test, do I drive like that day to day, no, and I would say most people don’t. If I paid for another test after 25 years it would have zero impact on my day to day driving skills.

As a driver of over ten years I’m well aware how driving has changed as being a driver I have experienced those changes, be it higher congestion, smart motorways, changes in the highway code etc. Lets hope you also notice these changes, it would be quite worrying if you needed a test in 25 years to alert you to changes.

OldTinHat · 05/09/2022 15:29

Have you heard of this word OP? It's 'experience'.

Driving for 34yrs (in my case), a member of the IAM for 25yrs (you'll ptobably have to look that up as you've no idea what driving means yet) equals 'experience'. A test every 25yrs (where did you even get that number from?!) is irrelevant.

Have you stopped to wonder why car insurance gets cheaper every year you drive without incident? Oh, silly me, of course not. You don't have that 'experience' yet...

Abraxan · 05/09/2022 15:27

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 14:02

I’m learning to drive right now... I’m in my mid 30s. I think everyone should have to retake their driving test every 25 years. To both raise revenue and get higher standards of driving. I feel if you have nothing to improve then nothing to worry about. If you’re good enough to pass the test you deserve to drive on the road. If not, then buses for you.

It's currently around 5- 6 months to book a practical test nearby and none available for even longer in the city we live in. Theory tests are 2-3 months minimum.

There are hardly any instructors to be had nearby. All have huge waiting lists and some have closed theirs.

We can't keep up with the current level of demand for learners following covid. There are thousands of young people having to redo (and replay to do) theory tests as, due to covid, they've not been able to secure a practical lesson within the required 2 years due to covid restrictions.

So no, no point in doing it every 25 years. Maybe consider anyone who is being stopped for poor driving or speeding above a set amount having to be retest, it not just generally, no.

And I'd like to see a total change to the system anyway. I'd like it to be based in a continued assessment model for learners, who would need to clock up x number of supervised hours with competences that need to be checked off 2-3 times each. Examiners would be redeployed to do spot checks in instructors cars, during lessons, rather than doing one off tests for learners. A little more like the system for pilots, etc.

DobbyHasASock · 05/09/2022 15:27

So what happens when people who rely on cars for their jobs, disability, school fail with a few minors op?
Are you in favour of providing them equivalent funding till they pass? Rent, food, disability suitable taxis, exemption from school attendance figures, free supermarket home delivery and priority slots?

How can you be in your thirties and be so unaware of the realities of people's lives?

Btw people who think they are great drivers never are. Good luck with the test.

Giveaschitt · 05/09/2022 15:26

It used to be said that Learner Drivers learnt to pass their Driving Test. It was only after that they actually learnt to drive... I suspect this is still very true. So testing people 'regularly' (which 25 years isn't...) would do the same thing - people wouldn't drive during their test the way they drive the rest of the time.

But I suspect you're just being goady...

IceStationZebra · 05/09/2022 15:25

But those people haven’t been doing nothing since they took their tests - they’ve been building on their skills, experiencing a myriad of driving conditions, learning how to deal with other drivers and emergency situations

or the opposite - I passed my test at 17, then moved to London at 21 and didn’t drive a car again for 15 years. The next time I got in a car I was extremely anxious and I now avoid driving at all costs. Under this plan my licence would expire and I’d be too anxious to re-take the test. Is that a good thing? Maybe. Am I going to drive again? Probably not, but the starting point of having a licence is better.

Agrudge · 05/09/2022 15:24

AntiHop · 05/09/2022 15:16

I agree, in fact more often.

You've hit a sore spot op with the pps who think it is their human right to drive a car.

I don't drive. Personal choice- one of the main reasons I don't drive is because I believe the planet needs way fewer cars on the road. I'm lucky that there is public transport where I live, but being a driver would certainly make my life easier. But I choose not to.

I've been a passenger on a couple of journeys lately and was shocked by the dangerous driving I saw on motorways. Most recent example was a driver far too close to a car in the middle lane - with their left indicator on??? Presumably trying to intimidate the car in front- and to then try to undertake???

I'd suggest a different solution- lower the bar for removing people's licenses when they've been caught driving dangerously.

Like with the op. Pass a test then your opinion might be worth something.

At the minute it means nothing

MissPinkCakeyBun · 05/09/2022 15:23

Well how can you tell the OP does not
Daffodillive rurally
Daffodilhave children at schools miles apart
Daffodilhave a disability that requires them to drive not walk
Daffodilnot live on a bus route
Daffodilnot have to commute by car due to no public transport
Daffodil not have elderly parents that need them to have a car to take them to appointments
...... the list goes on and on
Just because you see it as a privilege doesn't mean for someone it's not a necessity. Anyone living outside of a largish town it's a lifeline to work, Drs, schools, food and heaven forbid holidays

chipsandpeas · 05/09/2022 15:23

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 14:40

Most people don’t realise how much driving has changed over time, what rules are different and also what they do that they shouldn’t have started in the first place. So many people just had 10 lessons and then did a test, so much fewer hours of lessons than is normal now. Theory test knowledge is bound to be way out of date. People unsafe on the road. My driving instructor used to drive ambulances, witnessed a lot of crashes. This has influenced my thinking.. they agree with me.

oh come on now
you have never driven alone so dont talk bullshit about driving changing over the years

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 15:21

NewYorkLassie · 05/09/2022 15:15

You are a great advert for my view that people should be made to pass an IQ test before they are given a provisional.

did you not get the memo? IQ tests are a flawed concept.

OP posts:
Wherearemymarbles · 05/09/2022 15:20

But would be pointless with the current infrastructure.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 05/09/2022 15:19

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 14:29

Yes we have a capacity issue now but that is pandemic related. I’m trying to come up with new ideas for improving our country. In my opinion it’s gone to s**t. Posting on here seems good start, at least people read it. Too many drivers on the roads full stop. Let’s get rid of the bad ones who aren’t up to standard. Driving isn’t seen as difficult as it should be.

Liz I’m sure there are other things you should be focusing on in your new job.

HappyPeach · 05/09/2022 15:19

DiscoBadgers · 05/09/2022 14:30

Liz, are you shopping for new ideas already? First cheese, and now driving......

Grin
Wherearemymarbles · 05/09/2022 15:17

I’d say every 10 years and 5 years over 65 with mandatory eye tests.
driving isnt a right and there are so many appalling drivers of all ages

AntiHop · 05/09/2022 15:16

I agree, in fact more often.

You've hit a sore spot op with the pps who think it is their human right to drive a car.

I don't drive. Personal choice- one of the main reasons I don't drive is because I believe the planet needs way fewer cars on the road. I'm lucky that there is public transport where I live, but being a driver would certainly make my life easier. But I choose not to.

I've been a passenger on a couple of journeys lately and was shocked by the dangerous driving I saw on motorways. Most recent example was a driver far too close to a car in the middle lane - with their left indicator on??? Presumably trying to intimidate the car in front- and to then try to undertake???

I'd suggest a different solution- lower the bar for removing people's licenses when they've been caught driving dangerously.

NewYorkLassie · 05/09/2022 15:15

Scrambledeggyegg · 05/09/2022 14:29

Yes we have a capacity issue now but that is pandemic related. I’m trying to come up with new ideas for improving our country. In my opinion it’s gone to s**t. Posting on here seems good start, at least people read it. Too many drivers on the roads full stop. Let’s get rid of the bad ones who aren’t up to standard. Driving isn’t seen as difficult as it should be.

You are a great advert for my view that people should be made to pass an IQ test before they are given a provisional.

daisyjgrey · 05/09/2022 15:15

Upskilling 😂

We should probably have to do something similar to America where they have an eye test and a theory type bit plus a bit of manoeuvring refreshing every 10 years or something.

What you're suggesting and the terms and reasoning around it is quite hilarious though so do carry on.

purpleboy · 05/09/2022 15:14

I kinda agree and am questioning why so many posters are jumping on op just because she doesn't yet drive, you don't have to be driving to notice how appalling the standard of driving is in the uk.

I have been driving for about 25 years and I find driving getting worse. I think it would be great for drivers to retake their tests and also agree with some kind of refresher course if caught speeding, tailgating, lane hogging. There are so many RTCs we really need to look at the system as a whole and figure out why there are so many dangerous drivers out there and how we can make the roads safer for everyone.

cathcath2 · 05/09/2022 15:13

Why not just encourage more people to do advance driving courses

NightmareSlashDelightful · 05/09/2022 15:12

This has been looked at, several times in fact, by various government administrations going back to the 1970s. It's not necessary and it's not cost-effective. The administrative cost (and burden) would be enormous, and the practical gain negligible. The people who cause accidents on the roads tend to be newly qualified drivers or those in their 20s anyway, which this proposal wouldn't capture because the majority of drivers would be in their early 40s by the time their first retest came around (assuming they first passed aged 17 or 18).

This is one of those things that the right-wing press gets hold of every so often and likes to get itself in a froth over, like cyclists, the death penalty, or benefit fraud. But the amount of outrage-frotting is disproportionate to the impact of the thing itself.

anotheropinion · 05/09/2022 15:10

Retesting sounds sensible, but the evidence is against it. New drivers (who've just passed their tests) are higher risk. Middle aged drivers who haven't passed a test in years are lower risk. Retesting wouldn't touch the former.

No idea what the logic of 25 years would be. Every few years once past 70, or within a year after any points acquired might make some sense maybe?

TheLeadbetterLife · 05/09/2022 15:07

OP I live in Portugal. You haven’t experienced bad driving until you’ve driven in Portugal. U.K. drivers are really not that bad on the whole.

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 15:03

I agree, or even every ten years. But I don't think it would work logicistically, not without a lot of money and investment in testing centres and examiners.

gatehouseoffleet · 05/09/2022 14:57

It's also worth knowing that middle aged drivers have better reactions when driving than youngsters do, because they have the experience to anticipate situations on the road.

There are some awful drivers on the road but much is to do with personality, not skills. And I don't think we're about to start doing personality tests before we let people behind the wheel. Quite apart from the issue of people changing personality when they drive - I saw a meme last week which was along the lines of when people walk and get in each other's way they apologise and say "after you". When they get in each other's way when they drive they try to ram each other and swear. It's largely true.