Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This Is Going to Hurt

234 replies

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 10:27

I read this book a while ago but just re-skimmed it while bedridden with pregnancy sickness. I’d forgotten how funny it is, although the ending is tragic and poignant. I thought it gave a really good insight into the pressures on maternity staff and why it’s not always realistic for us to have the exact care we want in labour. I think it’s a shame he left medicine, but can see how he lost his nerve and didn’t feel able to go back. Anyone else read it?

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:29

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/09/2022 12:28

He is a misogynistic knob

end of

HTH

crikey and people are saying he’s directive and closed to the opinions of others!

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 05/09/2022 12:28

He is a misogynistic knob

end of

HTH

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:28

CarmenBizet · 05/09/2022 12:17

Jesus christ. That made me feel physically sick.

We had a male midwife (along with female and male doctors) during our very long and complicated birth and he was absolutely exemplary, the most compassionate care imaginable. Helped with DC's first latch. This guy gives men working in obs and gynae a bad name, no doubt contributes to discrimination against them at work too.

That’s false.

the patient’s husband says to dr Kay that he’s ‘wearing her like a puppet’.

OP posts:
CarmenBizet · 05/09/2022 12:17

RhodaDendron · 05/09/2022 12:02

I’m glad the book is so successful, I think it really illustrates the horror of working within the NHS, the trauma faced by our junior doctors who are doing something so important and should be looked after.

But I can’t forgive some of the portraits of patients. The bit where he has to hold the umbilical cord inside a woman whose labour is going pear shaped and plays it for laughs - he has to ‘wear her like a puppet’ - horrible.

Jesus christ. That made me feel physically sick.

We had a male midwife (along with female and male doctors) during our very long and complicated birth and he was absolutely exemplary, the most compassionate care imaginable. Helped with DC's first latch. This guy gives men working in obs and gynae a bad name, no doubt contributes to discrimination against them at work too.

pinok · 05/09/2022 12:16

Quite heartening to see about two thirds on this thread agreeing that it is misogyny

threads on the books a few years back had far more support for him so I think more and more are seeing it

When you have so many women (not just on here but other platforms) saying ‘we are women this is offensive, this is misogynistic’ then you have to accept something is wrong with the book

bloodyunicorns · 05/09/2022 12:14

kateclarke · 05/09/2022 10:35

I'm a hcp and hated it. He is an absolute misogynist, and spoke appallingly about both patients and midwives.

This

dworky · 05/09/2022 12:13

Oh, did you not notice the misogyny?

pinok · 05/09/2022 12:12

@Wouldloveanother No a doctor would only be responsible for an adverse outcome if it was their own choices and negligence that lead to it happening. They do not have ownership over a woman’s body and a woman is not compelled to give consent for anything. If a woman with capacity would not give consent and that lead to an adverse outcome then that would not be the responsibility of the doctor.

The Montgomery case was a dr doing exactly what Kay thinks is good care. It wasn’t so much the adverse outcome but the fact the woman had not been able to make an informed decision, not spoken to about alternatives or given non-bias information.

Fififelix · 05/09/2022 12:12

A lot of HCP have dark humour and banter it's not really done outside the staff room or the office. It's probably a shock to the general public hearing it.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 05/09/2022 12:12

i enjoyed the book mostly
the tv show was excellent - so well done. big ben wishaw fan anyway

Americano75 · 05/09/2022 12:11

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:09

Oh, I thought that was funny!

Really? Well, there you go.

chilliesandspices · 05/09/2022 12:10

Well he's completely killed that line of "don't worry, doctors have seen it all. They won't judge you."

I don't feel vulnerable going to see my GP about a sore throat but I do worry before an appointment in Obs and gynae. It is the very worst place for a man like him and this has only made my nervousness worse.

Cantanka · 05/09/2022 12:10

So I do understand where he is coming from - this is what I recommend, why should I take responsibility for what I know to be the wrong decision?

If a woman is advised to have a section and refuses, and as a result has a poor outcome, the doctor won’t be accountable for that. They gave the advice, and aren’t responsible for the patient refusing to take it.

On misogyny, its not misogyny in the sense of he likes men but not women or anything like that. But he mocks and belittles the experiences, anatomy and injuries of those who are giving/have given birth. Given this only applies to women, it’s misogynistic.

laughing about prolapses doesn’t really apply to men in the same way.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:09

Americano75 · 05/09/2022 12:09

Brats and twats?

Not for me.

Oh, I thought that was funny!

OP posts:
Americano75 · 05/09/2022 12:09

Brats and twats?

Not for me.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:08

Novum · 05/09/2022 12:04

I didn't get any sense that Kay is misogynist. I think in many respects the point he was making is that working in that system beats you down and dehumanises you, so that you begin to view all patients as objects. Because all or most of his patients were inevitably women it looks as if it is directed at them, but he would have behaved in exactly the same way with male patients.

It certainly gave me pause for thought in terms of how people complain about doctor’s actions, and that maybe there are good reasons behind it.

For example the part where he has to leave a c-section patient lying on a table with a compress over her uterus to run to another emergency. I can imagine a patient telling this story as ‘I was left on the operating table while the surgeon vanished for 20 minutes, I’m furious’ whereas he literally didn’t have a choice.

OP posts:
Crocwok · 05/09/2022 12:07

I mean he wrote and performed a song about babies with down syndrome and a song about 'northern birds'- all for a laugh of course so the really offensive lyrics are fine naturally. You can tell what kind of person he is from the fact he found that acceptable- thank goodness he left working with vulnerable women.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:05

pinok · 05/09/2022 11:57

Another passage where he rolls his eyes at the concept of informed choice and confidently says that obs&gynae patients (so basically female patients) prefer the doctor to just make a decision and tell them that ‘this is what will happen’ rather than having patient choice. He jokes that ‘patient choice’ should be a case of- ‘This is what we will do, it is your choice whether to take it or have nothing’

This is very outdated now when you think of the Montgomery case and the rights of women to be the autonomous decision-makers in their own care.

As far as I know (correct me if I’m wrong) women would never be held accountable for insisting upon the wrong procedure if it resulted in harm to their baby or themselves. If they absolutely refused a c-section, and the baby died, they wouldn’t be prosecuted for that, nor would they be held professionally responsible.

A doctor would however. The buck stops with them and they take ultimate responsibility for whatever the outcome is.

So I do understand where he is coming from - this is what I recommend, why should I take responsibility for what I know to be the wrong decision?

OP posts:
pistachi0nuts · 05/09/2022 12:04

God it's awful, even the title makes me so angry, like thank you Mr important doctor for letting us know it's going to hurt. There is such a nasty misogynistic tone to the way he speaks about women's health issues that really got under my skin (and about all his patients in general). Really classic male saviour doctors view on childbirth and labour...urgh I can't stand it!!

Novum · 05/09/2022 12:04

I didn't get any sense that Kay is misogynist. I think in many respects the point he was making is that working in that system beats you down and dehumanises you, so that you begin to view all patients as objects. Because all or most of his patients were inevitably women it looks as if it is directed at them, but he would have behaved in exactly the same way with male patients.

pinok · 05/09/2022 12:04

@EmmaH2022 thats the thing with this book once you’ve seen the misogyny you can’t unsee it. Regardless of what arguments you read in its favour (and I’ve read many)

Thankfully it does seem to work the other way round with readers who don’t initially have a problem then realise just how sexist the book is

RhodaDendron · 05/09/2022 12:02

I’m glad the book is so successful, I think it really illustrates the horror of working within the NHS, the trauma faced by our junior doctors who are doing something so important and should be looked after.

But I can’t forgive some of the portraits of patients. The bit where he has to hold the umbilical cord inside a woman whose labour is going pear shaped and plays it for laughs - he has to ‘wear her like a puppet’ - horrible.

EmmaH2022 · 05/09/2022 12:00

OP there's some examples here

unherd.com/2022/02/adam-kays-dangerous-misogyny/

it's clearly a matter of taste but I can't see the "humour" as anything other than misogynistic.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 12:00

LaundryBin · 05/09/2022 11:47

I thought it was great. I think a lot of the criticisms missed the point- he wasn't presenting himself as some kind of exemplar but telling the story of why he wasn't up to the job and how screwed the health service is.

I agree. He was very frank about his own shortcomings, how he didn’t feel up to the job, the mistakes he made when caring for people.

There were some very touching parts, such as the lady with ovarian cancer and the elderly lady he visited regularly as she was dying without too many visitors.

I disagree with PP about him ‘fobbing off’ women. He went against a consultant’s instructions to discharge a woman because he felt something was wrong, turns out she had a ruptured ectopic.

OP posts: