Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This Is Going to Hurt

234 replies

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 10:27

I read this book a while ago but just re-skimmed it while bedridden with pregnancy sickness. I’d forgotten how funny it is, although the ending is tragic and poignant. I thought it gave a really good insight into the pressures on maternity staff and why it’s not always realistic for us to have the exact care we want in labour. I think it’s a shame he left medicine, but can see how he lost his nerve and didn’t feel able to go back. Anyone else read it?

OP posts:
GelatoQueen · 05/09/2022 13:58

I just think he's a sad arse who trots out all the so called 'funny' stories that are cliched, relying on cheap humour that pokes fun at (vulnerable) people in (vulnerable) situations and therefore isn't very funny at all. It's lazy and not very original either. I hope that this type of cheap humour is not deemed acceptable in 20-30 years (in the same way all the 'jokes' about and stereotypical portrayals of gay men from the 1970s is no longer tolerated).

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/09/2022 13:58

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 13:28

I’ve worked with cancer patients and have laughed (with them, often at jokes they told) at some things I’m sure you would find highly inappropriate. Humour helps some people. It’s nothing to do with being “cool”. It’s about finding ways to cope with horrible situations.

Yeah but you didn’t then write them down, put them in a book and sell them for money which you spent on yourself, did you?

we must hope not.

Seriously, I think you are being a bit over protective here to an ex member of your profession. Because people are critical of the attitudes of one ex doctor, doesn’t mean that they thinks all doctors are rubbish, or horrid. It’s just that there is a difference between one to one communication, and the stand up stage.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 13:57

describing an injured penis as an aubergine attacked by a tiger (and not mocking the actual penis, it’s owner, nor the circumstances in which the injury occurred) is hardly comparable

Have you read the book? It was a long anecdote about his student who asked him to look at his penis because in a moment of sexual bravado he became convinced his ‘throbbing hard on’ (or words to that effect) could stop the rotating blades of a fan so he had stuck his penis into it. If you think Kay didn’t poke fun at that student and his macho-gone-wrong antics then you’re just making it clear you haven’t actually read it. You’re just rehashing an article from unherd.

OP posts:
TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:54

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 13:47

@TheClogLady I read the review. (Also the first comment which I wholeheartedly agree with.) This line was telling “I would love to read her story.” The reviewer wanted to know more about the women in the book. She wasn’t interested in the experiences of medical professionals. But Adam Kay wasn’t telling his patients’ story. He was telling his own. And, like him or loathe him, that is something he is allowed to do. All the review shows is that this was not the book the reviewer wanted to read.

I expect she didn’t want to read a book full of misogyny!

TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:53

Instead, we have his disgust, for instance, for old women. He hates the urogynaecology clinic: “a bunch of nans” — defined, with the use of “nan”, by their child-bearing — “with pelvic floors like quicksand and their uteri stalactite-ing into their thermals”. No matter their predicament, the misery is all his: “And then a patient sneezes, you have to get a mop and bucket.”

describing an injured penis as an aubergine attacked by a tiger (and not mocking the actual penis, it’s owner, nor the circumstances in which the injury occurred) is hardly comparable.

you aren’t being unreasonable to laugh at black humour (even misogynistic black humour), but you are being very, very unreasonable to continually defend a man against accusations of obvious misogyny because ‘he makes jokes about men too’.

Quote from: unherd.com/2022/02/adam-kays-dangerous-misogyny/

RunningSME · 05/09/2022 13:51

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 11:47

But he jokes about the men in equal measure. The degloved penis, the elderly man with the butt plug(!!), the useless/annoying dads in the delivery rooms, the arrogant consultants who ‘probably wished they were on the golf course’ etc.

But that’s not really appropriate as a doctor is it ?

pinok · 05/09/2022 13:50

‘Women reduced to orifices with imbeciles attached’ ahh perfect summary

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 13:47

@TheClogLady I read the review. (Also the first comment which I wholeheartedly agree with.) This line was telling “I would love to read her story.” The reviewer wanted to know more about the women in the book. She wasn’t interested in the experiences of medical professionals. But Adam Kay wasn’t telling his patients’ story. He was telling his own. And, like him or loathe him, that is something he is allowed to do. All the review shows is that this was not the book the reviewer wanted to read.

StellaAndCrow · 05/09/2022 13:44

And yes I found the Anaphylaxis's Patience video very funny - a lot of effort must have gone into that.
So many of Kay's songs and anecdotes are focused on how awful women and their bodies are.

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 13:42

You seem to think his making jokes about men's bodies makes the fact that he does arguable far worse about women's OK.
It's not a race to the bottom.
How do you feel about what he thinks about women who discover their unborn child has DS?

pinok · 05/09/2022 13:41

Those who disagree that it’s misogynistic... why do you think so so many women DO feel it’s misogynistic?

StellaAndCrow · 05/09/2022 13:40

EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/09/2022 13:37

That is appalling.

I've always thought his attitude to women is misogynistic, but to see this language used about people with Downs Syndrome is beyond belief.

Yes, I understand medical humour, but there's humour and then there's just being horrible.

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 13:39

His misogyny is why people find him sorepulsive I suppose. As much of his material is based around women's bodies and how disgusting he finds them. And women's behaviour. And how he finds that disgusting too.

Though you're right on one thing, OP (stopped clocks etc) he isn't JUST misogynistic. He's disablist and ageist too. And often the Venn diagram crosses over. His foulest anecdote for me was the dying elderly lady at Christmas and his resentment at having to be there together with his thinly veiled abhorrence of her dying body.

He tends to do the tired old "cock shock" shmuck when men are concerned.

StellaAndCrow · 05/09/2022 13:39

And calling women "slags" definitely feels misogynistic to me.

When we went back to mine I was up for a shag.
In the bedroom I realised you're a dumpy old slag.
Your pubes reach your navel and they cover your thighs,
Didn't know they made arses that size.

etc

pinok · 05/09/2022 13:38

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 13:00

Of course the final decision should belong to the woman (or any patient). But how can anyone make medical decisions unless they have someone with medical knowledge to guide them? What do you suggest patients base decisions on if not guidance from their doctors?

Yes absolutely- doctors advise, women decide. Women have the right to unbiased, balanced and accurate information and discussion about their different options so they can make a decision. Drs can share their knowledge and expertise whilst ‘the only person who has the final say over this body is the person this body belongs to’ remains true.

We start veering into dangerous territory of this does not remain true.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/09/2022 13:37

StellaAndCrow · 05/09/2022 12:48

One of his songs and not even the worst (though it is to me)

Your baby's got Trisomy

He'll have abnormal motor function
That's to meiotic non-dysjunction
You shouldn't have kids at 53
He'll have severe mental retardation
How would you feel about a termintation
I doubt he'll live past 10 years old
Check out his epicanthic folds and his single palmar crease
A bit of a mong your baby
Your baby has trisom, it's what he will die from,
Your baby has trisomy.

That is appalling.

I've always thought his attitude to women is misogynistic, but to see this language used about people with Downs Syndrome is beyond belief.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 13:36

TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:35

You didn’t read it, did you?

misogyny can be funny (sadly) and some misogynists are also racists/homophobes whatever, but hating people for various immutable characteristics doesn’t make the misogyny disappear.

I did read it. It’s just a rehash of all the jokes he made where the patients were women. It didn’t include any of the many jokes he made about men. If he’s a misogynist then he’s also a misandrist for calling his student’s injured penis ‘an aubergine that had been savaged by a tiger’.

OP posts:
Crocwok · 05/09/2022 13:36

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/09/2022 13:06

There is a long tradition of med students writing parody songs, so the verses that Adam Kay wrote are nothing new.

There used to be an awesome Parody video on youtube of Take Thats Patience ('Patients') by Students from Cardiff Med School. The boys in it will now be Consultants if they stuck with it, and I can no longer find the Video, but they did manage to get the lyrics "Vaginas Warty and smelly not like you see on the telly" to the music, which whilst vulgar is still pretty funny.

And women have statistically worse outcomes than men pretty much across the board in healthcare in this country- it's not a surprise that a lot of men find this kind of thing funny, doesn't mean it's alright.

TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:35

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 13:32

To me, to be misogynistic he would have to solely treat women in the way that he does. It can’t just be that any treatment of any woman you find objectionable is ‘misogyny’. He writes so much about men as well that I just don’t see it I’m afraid.

You didn’t read it, did you?

misogyny can be funny (sadly) and some misogynists are also racists/homophobes whatever, but hating people for various immutable characteristics doesn’t make the misogyny disappear.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 13:33

Funnily enough one of my schoolfriends (not close) was a head midwife in a home counties town/city. She made lots of improvements to midwifery in her area before moving. I've got no idea what she thinks about Kay and his like though. And I'm also sure that not all male doctors and midwives are like Kay and his ilk.

Having said that, last week when I saw a young male GP at my surgery and spoke to him re underactive thyroid, HRT etc - he was ok but not that knowledgeable and didn't seem that bothered (not all the male GPs at the surgery are like that) but it seems like it's his first proper GP job since out of med school and whereever else they're placed. A bit irritating to see someone dressed in flamboyant scrub type overalls (office wear, trendy?) and then not have much/if any, knowledge of 'women's issues'. Hmm

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 13:32

TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:28

To me, to be misogynistic he would have to solely treat women in the way that he does. It can’t just be that any treatment of any woman you find objectionable is ‘misogyny’. He writes so much about men as well that I just don’t see it I’m afraid.

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 05/09/2022 13:29

NGL I absolutely HATED it. I saw the programme. Awful programme IMO.

TheClogLady · 05/09/2022 13:28

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 11:41

Why is he misogynistic? Cannot anyone give me an example from the book?

This review is pretty good:

unherd.com/2022/02/adam-kays-dangerous-misogyny/

LizaSimpson · 05/09/2022 13:28

@GonnaGetGoingReturns true, I just meant at the end of the series I watched but you're right

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 13:28

MissingNashville · 05/09/2022 13:24

Like I said, you are so cool. 😎

That example is hardly the same as many of the things in the book though.

But you are cool. 😎

I’ve worked with cancer patients and have laughed (with them, often at jokes they told) at some things I’m sure you would find highly inappropriate. Humour helps some people. It’s nothing to do with being “cool”. It’s about finding ways to cope with horrible situations.