Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This Is Going to Hurt

234 replies

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 10:27

I read this book a while ago but just re-skimmed it while bedridden with pregnancy sickness. I’d forgotten how funny it is, although the ending is tragic and poignant. I thought it gave a really good insight into the pressures on maternity staff and why it’s not always realistic for us to have the exact care we want in labour. I think it’s a shame he left medicine, but can see how he lost his nerve and didn’t feel able to go back. Anyone else read it?

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 05/09/2022 20:01

@Wouldloveanother

y r u being so weird op

it’s like your Adam Kay’s PR manager or something

pinok · 05/09/2022 19:25

You can simultaneously think drs and healthcare staff need better working conditions whilst also acknowledging nasty misogynistic attitudes and culture pervading women’s healthcare

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/09/2022 18:48

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 18:37

The student doctor was invented for the TV series. That never actually happened. You are free to dislike him, of course, but your opinion is more credible if you dislike him for things he actually did. 🤦‍♀️ Perhaps read his book before voicing your opinions.

Gosh, read the book AND watch the whole series before deciding the man should be cancelled/burnt at the stake/etc... What sensible, open minded shiz is this?

The book and to a greater extent, the TV series, is NOT a detailed and accurate account of exactly what happened with various patients - that would be identifiable and he'd get sued.

It is obvious (well to anyone with half a brain) that these stories are manufactured from various events across several years, tweaked and pulled, added to and in some cases, invented to cover a topic (medical student suicide) that needed highlighting.

Are there lots of stories that paint women in a negative light - well he worked in Obs and Gynae so that does stack the odds somewhat!

As for the Amateur Transplants songs - wheres the flack for Suman Biswas who is still in medicine?

I thought (as a fat northern bird!) they were hysterically funny and outrageously offensive at the time - but then we're talking almost 20 years ago, I thought a lot of stuff was funny/clever/brilliant that in hindsight wasn't so great. Now I think they're a rather ill thought out reaction to the pressures of being a medical student and crashing into a world full of pretty horrific things, surrounded by people experiencing the same, plus large quantities of alcohol and not enough sleep.

But this is mumsnet so obviously the majority here have never made poor decisions in their early adulthood.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 18:43

pinok · 05/09/2022 18:32

Well Bodies and TIGTH being ‘accurate’ is all the more reason to say ‘wow these attitudes towards women are shameful, they show misogyny is still alive and well in women’s healthcare and this gross disrespect, attitudes and culture needs to die’

No it’s all the more reason to say doctors are overworked and we should be looking after them
more.

OP posts:
PSG · 05/09/2022 18:40

I love his books. Haven’t seen the series yet.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 18:37

SammyScrounge · 05/09/2022 16:13

He was so superior in his attitude to his patients and to nurses who actually knew more than he did about maternity care. And the student doctor who killed herself could have done with some support but he was unfailingly unpleasant to her. I really disliked him

The student doctor was invented for the TV series. That never actually happened. You are free to dislike him, of course, but your opinion is more credible if you dislike him for things he actually did. 🤦‍♀️ Perhaps read his book before voicing your opinions.

pinok · 05/09/2022 18:32

Well Bodies and TIGTH being ‘accurate’ is all the more reason to say ‘wow these attitudes towards women are shameful, they show misogyny is still alive and well in women’s healthcare and this gross disrespect, attitudes and culture needs to die’

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 05/09/2022 18:22

ShaneTwane · 05/09/2022 17:46

You seem to really struggle with reading comprehension. I agree with free speech. I agree with your right to have enjoyed the book and the humour and to discuss it openly. I disagree with you saying someone is not misogynistic simply because you enjoyed it. You are free to find misogyny funny. And everyone is free to call you out on supporting it and pretending its not there in the book.

She didn’t say it’s not misogynistic because she enjoyed it though did she? 🙄

neverbeenskiing · 05/09/2022 17:53

Mrsnononsense · 05/09/2022 11:50

Brilliant show, and pretty accurate too.

Another good show I can recommend is Bodies, available on Netflix.

Both shows perfectly depict the toxic culture in the NHS.

I was an HCP in a former life and I found elements of both Bodies and TIGTH so accurate it was painful to watch.

Fififelix · 05/09/2022 17:51

Sheepy11 · 05/09/2022 15:52

I'd love to write an undercover 'warts and all' expose of what it's like to work in an NHS frontline primary care mental health team.

Spoiler alert: it's fucking fantastic. Well paid, brilliant patients/clients, amazing management, support but hands off, lots of personal autonomy, plenty of time for notes and admin, zero unpaid overtime, investment in training of staff, great colleagues, I could go on. Best job in the world. Remember: for every person you hear loudly complaining about their job in the NHS there are many quietly happily working away who don't feel the need to blast about how great it is!

Meanwhile on the ward we have to watch patients ligaturing , headbanging inserting things into wounds I once watch someone put food in an arm flap. Constant de-escalation and restraints. Causing burnout and dehumanisation. I don't like what he wrote and how he made money from it. The book is about burnout really and the trauma from it.

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 17:49

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 17:36

Cancelled? 🙄 I would say there’s little chance of that.

The only outrage I have seen is here! Most viewers loved the program.

Funny innit?
A social media platform populated mainly by women taking umbrage at a man who finds their very woman-ness disgusting.
Wonder why that might be?

I haven't watched the programme (obviously, the books were enough for me) Is his language about women's bodies and frailties the same as the words he uses in the books?

ShaneTwane · 05/09/2022 17:46

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 17:35

Why? You support freedom of speech unless it’s telling you you are wrong?

You seem to really struggle with reading comprehension. I agree with free speech. I agree with your right to have enjoyed the book and the humour and to discuss it openly. I disagree with you saying someone is not misogynistic simply because you enjoyed it. You are free to find misogyny funny. And everyone is free to call you out on supporting it and pretending its not there in the book.

GreenestValley · 05/09/2022 17:46

The fact that he had to apologise for & remove that paragraph from his next book is quite telling. Clearly his default mind frame is one of everyday sexism.
that aside his style of humour is so puerile and smart alec. I cant bear him.

MissyB1 · 05/09/2022 17:41

Elderemo · 05/09/2022 17:26

Of course I read the book! I'm not in touch with him these days - not regularly since about 2015 I don't think. But I read the book, remember what it was like for him when he qualified and I'm certainly not rushing to get him cancelled.

So you read the book and you are surprised that he gets called mysoginistic? You are surprised that lots of women don’t like how he talked about his female patients? Really?

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 17:36

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 17:02

Are you still in touch with him? I'd really like to know how he feels about the fact that so many women (in particular) feel so disgusted by what he writes and thinks.
And yes, what he has said and done in the past is very relevant. You don't get to sweep your prejudices and abhorrent opinions under the carpet by airily declaring "but that was 20 years ago".
The sooner he is exposed, and hopefully cancelled for the bigot he is, the better.

Cancelled? 🙄 I would say there’s little chance of that.

The only outrage I have seen is here! Most viewers loved the program.

OP posts:
Cocolapew · 05/09/2022 17:35

I read the book when it first came out. An online book club I'm on was raving about how hilarious it was.
Apart from the sneery tone throughout it I didn't find any of it amusing. I'm baffled what people found so uproariously funny in it.

Wouldloveanother · 05/09/2022 17:35

ShaneTwane · 05/09/2022 17:06

I support freedom of speech and the right to enjoy dark humour. However i do not support people defending and outright denying someone's poor behaviour (in regards to misogyny and laughing at and using offensive words to disabled babies).

If you enjoy dark humour own it. Say you understand its controversial but you enjoy it. Dont outright tell a whole host of people they are wrong for finding him unpleasant and offensive.

Why? You support freedom of speech unless it’s telling you you are wrong?

OP posts:
Elderemo · 05/09/2022 17:26

MissyB1 · 05/09/2022 17:06

Did you actually read the book? Look he may not spout mysoginistic views in every day conversations, but he certainly chose to do so in his book. We can only judge him by how he chooses to present himself.

Of course I read the book! I'm not in touch with him these days - not regularly since about 2015 I don't think. But I read the book, remember what it was like for him when he qualified and I'm certainly not rushing to get him cancelled.

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 17:17

ReneBumsWombats · 05/09/2022 17:04

The sooner he is exposed, and hopefully cancelled

However offensive you find him, is that the answer?

Yes, in some cases, I believe it is
Nobody has the right to talk about unborn disabled children the way he does. Or elderly dying women.
Nobody.

MissyB1 · 05/09/2022 17:06

Elderemo · 05/09/2022 16:15

I first met Adam when he was still in medical school and I'm always astonished when people call him out like this.

I would never think of him as misogynistic. I just can't see it. As for the Am Tram stuff from back in the day? Parody songs written by students to amuse other students. Nobody is going after Suman who was responsible for a lot of those songs and is still practicing medicine.

Did you actually read the book? Look he may not spout mysoginistic views in every day conversations, but he certainly chose to do so in his book. We can only judge him by how he chooses to present himself.

ShaneTwane · 05/09/2022 17:06

I support freedom of speech and the right to enjoy dark humour. However i do not support people defending and outright denying someone's poor behaviour (in regards to misogyny and laughing at and using offensive words to disabled babies).

If you enjoy dark humour own it. Say you understand its controversial but you enjoy it. Dont outright tell a whole host of people they are wrong for finding him unpleasant and offensive.

ReneBumsWombats · 05/09/2022 17:04

The sooner he is exposed, and hopefully cancelled

However offensive you find him, is that the answer?

PAFMO · 05/09/2022 17:02

Elderemo · 05/09/2022 16:15

I first met Adam when he was still in medical school and I'm always astonished when people call him out like this.

I would never think of him as misogynistic. I just can't see it. As for the Am Tram stuff from back in the day? Parody songs written by students to amuse other students. Nobody is going after Suman who was responsible for a lot of those songs and is still practicing medicine.

Are you still in touch with him? I'd really like to know how he feels about the fact that so many women (in particular) feel so disgusted by what he writes and thinks.
And yes, what he has said and done in the past is very relevant. You don't get to sweep your prejudices and abhorrent opinions under the carpet by airily declaring "but that was 20 years ago".
The sooner he is exposed, and hopefully cancelled for the bigot he is, the better.

Fauxgina · 05/09/2022 16:47

daisyjgrey · 05/09/2022 12:46

I find as someone who has work in the NHS for 2 decades that it gives a useful and realistic, if extremely uncomfortable, insight in to the NHS, its staff and the humour we use to cope, SPOILER ALERT the staff ain't saintly!

Considering the never ending campaigns for smear tests, mammograms, prostate exams etc and how patients "don't need to be embarrassed, we've seen it all before" then the NHS need to step their PR game up when it comes to ex-medics releasing books...trust is thin on the ground as it is.

Reading some of the comments, and the Unherd article, has given me some upsetting flashbacks I didn't even know I had. Just wanted to repeat how shit the "we've seen it all before" chatter is in light of books like his.

I hope he's proud.

WorthThe · 05/09/2022 16:41

@MissingNashville I do take this point on board and think its a very valid one.

But I also think there is an importance in people being able to express their opinion and experiences freely and to not constantly be afraid of causing offence.

It's dark humour and not everyone's cup of tea, but we're all adults here and I think it would be a sad day if material like this were ever censored.

The insights he shares are valuable, especially to those considering a similar career. Would he have reached such a wide audience with a dry, factual account of events? No.