Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To switch to "pay for only what you use"?

109 replies

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 08:28

Apologies for posting in AIBU. Happy for it to be moved to a more appropriate section.

I contacted my energy company on FB after days of not being able to get through on the phone to speak directly with someone. I wanted to get a rough estimate of my bill for October.

They replied that they can't give exact figures right now and they would update in the next few weeks, but they advised to expect an 80% increase. We pay £269 pm already so we are looking at £480 ish pm. We can't afford this.

I replied to this effect and asked what options they could offer us?

They listed a few, the first of which was: "you can change your direct debit to pay for only what you use rather than spreading the cost over 12 months".

This confused me. Why am I not already just paying for what I use? Why would I pay for what I haven't used?

Looking at my last statement we used £155 worth of gas and electricity combined and paid £269. So we should be in credit, right? Therefore can afford to pay less in theory?

Sorry if this is a really stupid question but the whole thing has just really confused me!!

OP posts:
MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 05/09/2022 10:46

Reading this thread posters are advising a mother not to bathe her child. Just read that again, not bathe her baby. How has the UK got to this point, and why do we all seem so accepting of it?

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 10:42

Really good tips from everyone here.

I'm from an era 70s/80s where we couldn't afford tumble driers (did have one when we were babies) or central heating so had gas fires (dried hair/clothes in front of them), outside lines for clothes and also had those awful calor gas heaters you brought from room to room. DP's Victorian house wasn't insulated at all then and we had heavy snowfall winters too. Finally got central heating reinstalled think 1980 onwards. We also had small gas fire heaters in small kitchen and bathroom at sort of ceiling level, anyone recall those? Rarely switched on though...

NCHammer2022 · 05/09/2022 10:41

If you’re using £155 in a summer month (and it’s been a hot summer) then that does suggest you might expect an extremely high monthly bill come winter and after the price cap increase is applied, unless you can reduce your usage. £155 in summer is a lot.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 10:38

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:35

I can see if you've got young kids/babies then tumble driers appeal.

Yep. DP has been saying for a while we need to get one but so far we haven't. We go through a lot of washing with a baby/toddler!

He ends up putting the heating on to dry clothes though, so may as well get a tumble dryer. Although I'm not sure what would use more energy - heating on for a couple hrs to dry clothes late at night or a blast in a tumble dryer?

Depends how warm your flat is. My DB/SIL have a very well insulated (warm) flat with those storage heaters and have only ever used airers (not even heated ones) to dry their baby/young son's clothes. They also have an outside space for driers in open air.

I'd do cost comparison with heated airer driers vs central heating on to dry clothes/heat room and also tumble drier. Which? might be useful for this. Do you have anywhere where you can dry clothes in direct sunlight and fit a French pulley or outside at all?

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 10:35

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:00

Something else the teen does, is go into the bathroom and set the shower running about 20 mins before she gets in it. Multiple, multiple times I've gone upstairs to a majorly steamed up bathroom with the shower running and no one in it, and teen faffing about in her room before getting in the shower 🙄 she says she's "letting it warm up". I've told her several times it heats pretty much instantly so this isn't necessary. I'll be coming down a lot harder on her for this in future!

You really need to speak to your teen about this. Set 10 minute shower times for every day, add on 5 minutes more and turn it off (e.g. if putting on conditioner for 2-3 minutes then rinsing). Strip washes are good - I don't do them but DP's do. And 1 shallow bath a week max if any. Also turn down hot water temperature, at least until it gets cold.

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:35

I can see if you've got young kids/babies then tumble driers appeal.

Yep. DP has been saying for a while we need to get one but so far we haven't. We go through a lot of washing with a baby/toddler!

He ends up putting the heating on to dry clothes though, so may as well get a tumble dryer. Although I'm not sure what would use more energy - heating on for a couple hrs to dry clothes late at night or a blast in a tumble dryer?

OP posts:
GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 10:33

FuzzyPuffling · 05/09/2022 10:08

We have done this, but our usage is fairly similar over the year, as we don't use the central heating or have a tumble dryer.
I like it much better.

Tumble driers are the devils own work for eating up electric. luckily both me and DP's (separate households) have those French pulley systems and lean to's (mine smaller). And it gets the sun too. I also bought a spin outside line this spring and still using it. I can see if you've got young kids/babies then tumble driers appeal.

pumpkinpie01 · 05/09/2022 10:32

@lancsgirl85 I know - unbelievable! Would love to know how long a shower he takes now he is house sharing and paying his own bills , I asked once and never got a straight answer !

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 10:31

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 08:52

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

It's not a mansion, I wish 😂

It's a 3 bed detached with high ceilings and large rooms though (Victorian style), therefore takes a lot to heat. But we have hardly had the heating on at all over recent months. I think it's been on maybe once for a couple hours to dry some clothes. So that usage of £150 is with the heating virtually off for the entire month.

If you could afford it (investment), a cast iron stove is what I'd be looking at.

I've got one and so have DP's. Yes, you need coal/wood and to have chimney swept, yes, maybe not eco friendly re smoke/dust. But it heats up draughty cold Victorian (other period houses) if you leave door open - I've only got a teeny Victorian cottage and it works well. Plus insulate everywhere, windows, attic, double glaze if you can etc. We're both fairly lucky as haven't used stove for past 2-3 years much so have got a stock of coal/wood to burn in both households. Then the central heating only goes on as and when and in certain rooms. Also invest in jumpers and thermals. Really helps.

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:30

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

We used to use a small baby bath but she's a very active toddler now and prefers the space to play in the bath, and she also tries to climb out now 🙈 But I suppose we could try to use it again and just keep her contained!

OP posts:
lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:28

@pumpkinpie01

Oh wow! That's quite a difference in your usage! I can't believe your son fell asleep in the shower 😂

OP posts:
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/09/2022 10:26

A 30-40 minute shower is just ridiculous and unnecessary. It would be cheaper for her to join a gym and shower there! I've got mine down to about 3 mins if I don't need to shave my legs.

Buy a baby bath rather than running a big one.

If you use log burner, stick a clothes horse in front of it when you go to bed at night.

I get a monthly bill from my elec supplier (no gas) so I always know where I am in terms of being behind or in front of payments.

Calmdown14 · 05/09/2022 10:22

Erm yes!

You use more electric than me and I don't have any gas so that's my heating as well (topped up with woodburner).

The good news is you have plenty of potential to cut back.

Remember your electric bill will also be credited with £66/67 a month for the winter months as a result of the £400 payment.

So with that and being more careful it might be manageable.

Can they switch you to monthly billing but with a fixed direct debit? That's what we do now so I know where I am. Use about £80 a month but pay £130 so will be £600 in credit by the start of October. It's a lot easier to see where you are and less confusing than quarterly which sometimes misses the final payment as you are seeing

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2022 10:21

@lancsgirl85 Can you have a proper chat to her about how expensive it's got and how it will affect the family budget as in less money available for (insert whatever nice things are important to her) if the whole household doesn't cut what they use? Plus how it's much better for the planet to use less?

bellac11 · 05/09/2022 10:21

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2022 10:12

From what I know of many 'young people' they seem very vocal about how environmentally conscious they are and spend a lot of time criticising their 'wasteful' 40 and 50 something parents for killing the planet that they and their DC will inherit after we are all long gone.

Doesn't really stack up with all these half hour showers, 'hauls' of Shein tat arriving from across the globe and camping equipment left as litter when they've been to festivals, does it?

Those of us who grew up in the 1970/80s with parents who lived in fear of forgetting to turn off the immersion heater and leaving a light on in an unlit room would be greeted with calls of 'it's like Blackpool Illuminations in here' on discovery by our parents don't seem anywhere near as wasteful as some of our offspring. Letting a shower run unused for 20 minutes? Shock hmm]

Totally agree with this, which is why that whiney advert with children berating 'adults' for the state of the planet wound me up so much

Of course children are not in charge but certainly for teens and pre teens, they are not keen to give up their gadgets and disposable fashion any time soon.

BMW6 · 05/09/2022 10:16

Well don't threaten and not follow through!

pumpkinpie01 · 05/09/2022 10:15

@lancsgirl85 omg I think your daughter is my son ! He used to do that in the shower ! He fell asleep in there once with it running and he was lying on the bath mat ! He has left home now , we have stopped using the dishwasher and the tumble drier and obviously the stupid showers have stopped and our usage has gone from 15kw a day to 6-7kw !

BMW6 · 05/09/2022 10:14

Dishwasher once a day, less if possible.

Cut down on washing, and wash at 30c with bio

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:14

@BMW6

I do give her pocket money yes. I've threatened to withhold it a number of times when she does this. It's infuriating. She does it less now to be fair, but this was a regular occurrence over the past year. Which probably hasn't helped the bill.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 05/09/2022 10:12

Sorry I see you have a daughter

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:12

We don't have a tumble dryer, but we do use a dishwasher and a washing machine regularly. Dishwasher goes on probably twice daily, and washing machine I'd guess about 3-6 loads weekly depending on the baby! So almost daily for the washing machine, too.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2022 10:12

From what I know of many 'young people' they seem very vocal about how environmentally conscious they are and spend a lot of time criticising their 'wasteful' 40 and 50 something parents for killing the planet that they and their DC will inherit after we are all long gone.

Doesn't really stack up with all these half hour showers, 'hauls' of Shein tat arriving from across the globe and camping equipment left as litter when they've been to festivals, does it?

Those of us who grew up in the 1970/80s with parents who lived in fear of forgetting to turn off the immersion heater and leaving a light on in an unlit room would be greeted with calls of 'it's like Blackpool Illuminations in here' on discovery by our parents don't seem anywhere near as wasteful as some of our offspring. Letting a shower run unused for 20 minutes? Shock hmm]

BMW6 · 05/09/2022 10:12

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:00

Something else the teen does, is go into the bathroom and set the shower running about 20 mins before she gets in it. Multiple, multiple times I've gone upstairs to a majorly steamed up bathroom with the shower running and no one in it, and teen faffing about in her room before getting in the shower 🙄 she says she's "letting it warm up". I've told her several times it heats pretty much instantly so this isn't necessary. I'll be coming down a lot harder on her for this in future!

Well that's just horrifying!!!!! Do you give pocket money?
If you do I'd be withholding it every time he or she does it. Otherwise it's going to cost hundreds of pounds 😮

luxxlisbon · 05/09/2022 10:09

When she said expect and 80% increase, I thought that meant whatever we are paying by DD now (ie £269) will be increased by 80%, taking it to £480. Which made me want to cry.

This is true though, if you see on the variable rate then the cost per unit will increase by about 80% next month.

You are already paying for what you use, it’s just averaged out over the year. You usually aren’t in credit at the end of a 12 month period but it makes sense for most people to have a consistent monthly payment. It’s too much of a shock to your monthly finances to pay a tiny amount in the summer then suddenly have a huge bill in winter.

FuzzyPuffling · 05/09/2022 10:08

We have done this, but our usage is fairly similar over the year, as we don't use the central heating or have a tumble dryer.
I like it much better.