Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To switch to "pay for only what you use"?

109 replies

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 08:28

Apologies for posting in AIBU. Happy for it to be moved to a more appropriate section.

I contacted my energy company on FB after days of not being able to get through on the phone to speak directly with someone. I wanted to get a rough estimate of my bill for October.

They replied that they can't give exact figures right now and they would update in the next few weeks, but they advised to expect an 80% increase. We pay £269 pm already so we are looking at £480 ish pm. We can't afford this.

I replied to this effect and asked what options they could offer us?

They listed a few, the first of which was: "you can change your direct debit to pay for only what you use rather than spreading the cost over 12 months".

This confused me. Why am I not already just paying for what I use? Why would I pay for what I haven't used?

Looking at my last statement we used £155 worth of gas and electricity combined and paid £269. So we should be in credit, right? Therefore can afford to pay less in theory?

Sorry if this is a really stupid question but the whole thing has just really confused me!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
blabberchops · 06/09/2022 09:59

@lancsgirl85 getting back to your original question, hopefully you now understand how your bill is calculated, but I don't think anyone has actually said this - your monthly direct debit set by the energy company assumes you will use the same amount of energy this year as last year. So, if you know your usage has reduced, and will reduce further due to the lifestyle changes you're making, phone them to explain that - they are then likely to suggest a lower direct debit to reflect the lower projected usage.

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 22:14

Also, for businesses, we do “Earth Hour” here in Sydney and it’s like “ooo look we’ve turned off the buildings’ lights for an hour” and then once it’s over, we just…..turn them back on again. It’s madness to have the city lit up at night and the weekend. A lot of the measures that German cities are taking seem perfectly sensible - turning off lights at night, lowering the water temperature in business buildings etc, not illuminating statues at night. How are we not already doing this, from a purely environmental point of view?

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 22:10

I’m just seeing on a lot of threads “oh we don’t want to go back to the 70s, freezing houses etc” but for most of us our houses were warm, we had hot (if short) showers, dried clothes on a line over the bath etc. It was fine, we weren’t uncomfortable but we definitely thought “put a jumper on first” before turning the heating up.
I did have relatives who lived very frugally with freezing houses and washing at the sink, but there’s definitely a middle ground between wasteful energy use and ice on the windows.

BooksAndChooks · 05/09/2022 16:48

I also agree with @Ozgirl75 .

You also don't need the heating on to dry clothes on radiators. They will still dry if they're hung up on cold radiators, decent airflow will speed it up. In this weather it's easy to keep a few windows on a locked latch or slightly open.

Blowthemandown · 05/09/2022 16:26

@lancsgirl85 some gas bills show the volume of gas rather than kwh then convert it. In which case your calculation would be wrong if you multiplied the volume of gas rather than the kwh. But it could be right? But you should be able to see that on your bills. Last full year in our old house (big - we downsized) 4550 kwh electric vs 19000 kwh gas. Back then we were paying 2p per kwh of gas plus standing charge of 2.23 per day. We no longer have gas but you can see the effect the increase in price would make?

we rarely used the heating from March to November by the way and it is heating that wallops your bill - hob and hot water for us was minimal. For electricity, set top boxes and the like use a lot of electricity on standby.

we had no incandescent bulbs, only LED, plus only 2 in the house but with an old inefficient boiler. But both wfh with laptops etc running a lot.

looking online suggests average is a lot lower but we had an inefficient old boiler and a large draughty house.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 14:30

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 12:42

We don't - I have radiators turned off in my bedroom for example as I hate being too hot especially at night. It's DP who puts the heating on a lot, as I've already said. Generally speaking, I'm not one to rush and put the heating on in this house (unless it's below zero in the winter). I could definitely do better with electricity usage I think. And baths and showers, as I've already said.

Get a smart meter. They're amazing. Also tell DP to turn the heating off unless you use it a lot. Or come to a compromise about what/where you heat as he doesn't want to be too cold either.

I know it sounds silly but things like weighted blankets, weighted throws, decent warm slippers, jumpers etc really do help to keep warm. Plus hand warmers. If you go to work, DP to work, baby to nursery, teen to school then you won't need to worry about heating the house/water but when teen returns from school (does he/she?) then see what they do/need re heating and also warm food. Might be an idea to have them have a hot snack (cheese on toast, cup a soup, Pot Noodle, hot Ribena/hot chocolate?) when they come in so it warms them up. I know this also sounds daft but friends with teens who try to save on heating swear by bedsocks, electric blankets, warm PJs etc.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 14:23

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 12:35

Thing is (and I’m not getting on at you @lancsgirl85 , more a comment on energy use in general), I think lots of people have got very used to cheap energy and so didn’t even think to limit their use.
Growing up in the 80s, we weren’t poor at all, but my parents drummed into me about turning lights off, short showers (mainly because we were on a tank and the water would run out and go cold!), closing doors between rooms to keep the heat in etc. It wasn’t uncomfortable (we lived in a very old house with no central heating but it was cosy and warm with a fire), it was just normal.
Then as people moved into their own homes a lot of that seems to have been forgotten. Friends houses would be roasting all the time, every room warm whether you were in it or not, long showers, tumble driers were normal (quite a luxury in the 80s).
So I think that there has been a lot of talk of the extremes of either using loads of energy or going back, as someone suggested above to once a week baths, limited kettle use, no heating etc, but I do think there’s a sensible middle ground.

I agree with @Ozgirl75, grew up in 1970s, it was a bath a few times a week and stand up wash at sink every days which wasn't bath day. Washing machine on a lot and floors mopped weekly if not more but my DB had chronic asthma so needed that level of hygiene. My DM rented out rooms when we were small and had electric meters fitted. We used the plastic shower attachment for hair (over sink). We also washed hair in bath (not often though). We did use water for washing up, watering garden and paddling pool/swimming pool in summer (and for pond).

When we finally inherited, had money in 1980s central heating was back on, we had an electric shower fitted in a large bedroom (with sink) and used that plus the electric shower in the bathroom. Even then, in 1980s I washed my hair with shower over the bath not stood up in bath. When my DNana wanted to buy DM a dishwasher when we were kids/teens (we got one in teens) DM refused for some reason! DP's boiler was only renewed about 10-15 years ago. Was same old one from years ago and they lagged attic, got double glazing or film over windows (Victorian house).

Heated airers weren't a thing then. We did use a French pulley/line dry/central heating and outside spin line to dry clothes.

DP's only just gone back to stand up washes, shower once/twice a week, fill flasks with kettle, smart meter etc. I have smart meter but use water sensibly. I lag attic etc - but its been converted over lockdown.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 05/09/2022 14:14

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 05/09/2022 10:46

Reading this thread posters are advising a mother not to bathe her child. Just read that again, not bathe her baby. How has the UK got to this point, and why do we all seem so accepting of it?

I'm not saying that at all.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 05/09/2022 13:05

A couple of suggestions for you, I’ve teen with ADD who drifted away in showers so we got a cheap timer from Amazon and set him a 5 minute time limit which is what is recommended, now a noisy alarm goes off and he gets out pretty quickly

Not all tumble dryers are evil, heat pump ones cost about 75p per cycle to run, about a third of the cost of standard ones so if you’re considering buying it’s worth the investment

You say you’re in rented accommodation, has an energy rating been done on the property, it may be that your landlord is legally required to upgrade insulation with the new regulations that are coming in

Proudboomer · 05/09/2022 13:05

I have given my adult sons shower timers and they are allowed 5 minutes each which is plenty of time to shower. I have also set the boiler to only come on twice a day for an hour at a time so there is a tank of hot water for the morning and then another for the evening so if one gets greedy and takes more than their 5 minutes there will be none for anyone else. This way they stick to the 5 minutes.
my tumble dryer has been unplugged and will stay unplugged as when the rates go up next month a c rated tumbler dryer will cost about £2.30 a hour to run. I do 6 washes a week which will be dried on airers and a pulley I have put up in the utility room.
I will only be heating the rooms I have got to so my mums room downstairs as she is old and disabled, her disabled bathroom which I will leave the door open to so the heat will also heat the hallway a bit, one dining room radiator as I will put the air in there, 2 towel rails in the other bathrooms and one radiator in the annex. Upstairs will stay off and the lounge I use will stay off and I will use a heated throw. In previous years I have been a high energy user using over 19000 of gas and 6800 of electric. This year I want to half the electric and knock a couple of thousand units off the gas. I will still have high bills but it is the best I can do and still keep mum warm.

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 12:46

Yes, I didn’t mean you in particular - it was more a comment on what I’ve experienced with my friends and their hot houses! While energy has been cheap it’s been easy not to have to think about it too much.
The good thing for you @lancsgirl85 is that by doing things like addressing the long showers (I also have a son who adores just standing there and letting the water flow for ages unless I chivvy him along), it’ll probably make a big difference.

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 12:42

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 12:38

So for example, we have split level heating (like central heating but either air con or heat and through vents as we’re in Aus), so we only heat or cool the rooms we’re in. No need to have radiators blaring out heat in the spare room, or the dining room if you’re not in it.

We don't - I have radiators turned off in my bedroom for example as I hate being too hot especially at night. It's DP who puts the heating on a lot, as I've already said. Generally speaking, I'm not one to rush and put the heating on in this house (unless it's below zero in the winter). I could definitely do better with electricity usage I think. And baths and showers, as I've already said.

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 12:38

So for example, we have split level heating (like central heating but either air con or heat and through vents as we’re in Aus), so we only heat or cool the rooms we’re in. No need to have radiators blaring out heat in the spare room, or the dining room if you’re not in it.

Ozgirl75 · 05/09/2022 12:35

Thing is (and I’m not getting on at you @lancsgirl85 , more a comment on energy use in general), I think lots of people have got very used to cheap energy and so didn’t even think to limit their use.
Growing up in the 80s, we weren’t poor at all, but my parents drummed into me about turning lights off, short showers (mainly because we were on a tank and the water would run out and go cold!), closing doors between rooms to keep the heat in etc. It wasn’t uncomfortable (we lived in a very old house with no central heating but it was cosy and warm with a fire), it was just normal.
Then as people moved into their own homes a lot of that seems to have been forgotten. Friends houses would be roasting all the time, every room warm whether you were in it or not, long showers, tumble driers were normal (quite a luxury in the 80s).
So I think that there has been a lot of talk of the extremes of either using loads of energy or going back, as someone suggested above to once a week baths, limited kettle use, no heating etc, but I do think there’s a sensible middle ground.

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 12:21

No it's not an electric shower

OP posts:
sevenbyseven · 05/09/2022 11:51

A 5-minute shower uses roughly a third the amount of water as a bath. So a 30-40 minute shower will use as much as 2-3 baths! Is it an electric shower or not? Buy a 4-minute shower timer (like an egg timer with a suction cup) and ask teen to stick to it.

No more turning on the heating to dry wet washing - the bill payer (you) is in charge of the heating from now on.

Good luck with reducing your usage!

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 11:49

@LittleOwl153

No our shower is separate to the bath.

Yes absolutely- DD loves bath time, playing with her bath toys and pouring water etc keeps her occupied for at least a good 10/15 mins! 😃

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 05/09/2022 11:44

I was playing with the proce predictor on Octopus yesterday. From paying £100pcm combined for many years it seems to think we'll need to pay £475 going forward to break even....

On the bath front, does your shower run over the bath? If it does run the shower for 5 minutes with the plug in and see where the water gets to. I think many people assume that showers are more efficient but alot of these power showers use loads of water so I'm going to suggest that your babys/toddlers shallow baths are perhaps using less water than your power shower....

(there is also the entertainment/learning value of a bath for a little one. My youngest (primary aged) showers when he needs to but still enjoys an hour in the bath ~6inches of water with his ducks/boats etc and it keeps him busy for that time period as much as a console/ book / any other toy!)

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 11:19

We were paying £170 a month this time last year and had been doing so for ages. It had allowed a £1300 credit to build on our account, of which we got 1k refunded. As I say, we could more than afford our usage at previous energy prices. Of course we will cut down where we can now (in particular the teen's showers!), and I'm not home every day on mat leave this winter like last year, so heating won't be on most days etc ..... but there's only so much we can do given an 80% price increase!!

OP posts:
lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 11:11

@bellac11

I can make whatever comment I like on my own thread, surely?

Yes, we appear to have areas where we can cut back but before the price hikes we could more than afford our usage so 🤷‍♀️

prices are absolutely sky rocketing, that's the issue here.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 05/09/2022 11:08

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 11:00

Dreadful isn't it (the situation, not the advice on the thread, I mean). We shouldn't be in this situation in 2022!

Of course I will continue to bath my baby as and when she needs it (usually daily, sometimes I can skip a day if she hasn't put porridge or jam in her hair 😂), but I will maybe just use less water or go back to the smaller baby bath as another poster suggested.

I dont agree that government shouldnt have (and I mean from years ago) protected our energy supplied, I did not agree with privatisation.

But you cant really make a comment like that after reviewing your household usage where you are a really wasteful household. I often wonder why people pay so much for their energy use and this is why

Our usage is said to be on the high side and we're going to cut down but we do absolutely nothing near your usage. We use around 5k gas units and 4700 electric units a year, I think the electric is on the high side so we're going to look at that.

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 11:00

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 05/09/2022 10:46

Reading this thread posters are advising a mother not to bathe her child. Just read that again, not bathe her baby. How has the UK got to this point, and why do we all seem so accepting of it?

Dreadful isn't it (the situation, not the advice on the thread, I mean). We shouldn't be in this situation in 2022!

Of course I will continue to bath my baby as and when she needs it (usually daily, sometimes I can skip a day if she hasn't put porridge or jam in her hair 😂), but I will maybe just use less water or go back to the smaller baby bath as another poster suggested.

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 05/09/2022 10:54

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/09/2022 08:49

If you have a smart meter, you don't have to put up with any of this 'predicted usage' rubbish.

The whole point of a smart meter is that you know what you use, and they know what you use.

I have switched from a direct debit to requesting an actual bill every month. They had tried to increase my direct debit to £90 per month. My actual bill for last month was £47.

Just take control of it and stay on top of it each month. £500 per month is insane. Do you live in a mansion?

Cancel DD through your bank.

I think you may have misunderstood. Previous posts explain it!

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 05/09/2022 10:48

lancsgirl85 · 05/09/2022 10:00

Something else the teen does, is go into the bathroom and set the shower running about 20 mins before she gets in it. Multiple, multiple times I've gone upstairs to a majorly steamed up bathroom with the shower running and no one in it, and teen faffing about in her room before getting in the shower 🙄 she says she's "letting it warm up". I've told her several times it heats pretty much instantly so this isn't necessary. I'll be coming down a lot harder on her for this in future!

I think you are going to have to get a bit draconian to stop this urgently.

How old is she?

If she's an older teen with her own money start charging her when she has the shower on for longer than a specific time. Make it an accurate estimate of the cost and she can decide whether it is worth it.

If she's younger and just getting distracted can you supervise for a while, and make sure she doesn't turn the shower on before she has done all her faffing in her room and that she doesn't leave the bathroom once she has turned the shower on.

You may need to start turning the hot water off after a specific time if she doesn't get the message. She can finish off in cold. Plenty of us managed with a limited supply of hot water with old style boilers.

PinkSnowAndStars · 05/09/2022 10:47

Get a heated airer. It costs pennies an hour to run, and heats our living room up in process! I didn’t have our heating on at all last winter. Ours is a Lakeland one that I’ve had for about 12 years now!