Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well off children & children who attend private school spend alot less time on screens?

134 replies

Ewetoo · 04/09/2022 21:55

www.screenfreeparenting.com/rich-get-smart-poor-get-technology-new-digital-divide-school-choice/

Interesting article & I agree.. Well off parents can spend more time & money on enriching educational after school activities & sports. It's a no brainer... My wealthier friends are all off hiking, camping or biking with the kids who do a host of extracurriculars during the week & also happen to read loads.. My normal circles kids like my own love roblox & Minecraft & don't have the same after school activities & weekends spent chilling...

OP posts:
KarmaComma · 04/09/2022 22:50
  1. that article is by 'screen free parenting' so potential bias. I'd be wary of the 'conclusion'.
  2. it's US data, not Uk
  3. the article is about the use of screens for learning. In schools. And how wealthier families can pay for an alternative like Montessori. The poorest cannot. And yet some posters have jumped straight on the 'poor parents are bad parents' bandwagon.
  4. saying camping, hiking, biking are cheap activities emphasises to me that there are people completely clueless to the extent and effects of poverty and the extent of the cost of living crisis. If you live in inner city Birmingham, for example, where the hell do you think people are going to go hiking and camping? How will they travel there? How will they get time off to do that? How can they buy a tent? How can they get a bike and where can they store it? I'm alarmed whenever I read these sorts of threads on MN how ignorant some people are to the concept of financial barriers.
AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 04/09/2022 22:49

I don't think it's a wealth thing for us - it's an active choice we've made irrespective of arbitrary markers like that. We have never wanted kids who crave screens and have a screen habit.

My kids are state schooled but we do biking, camping, sailing, hiking, reading, loads of extra curricular. Sometimes nothing much happens and they just make their own fun for hours.

We both work super hard but feel that defaulting to screens is something we want to avoid during our kids' free time - that has been an active choice for us a family because we want our kids to be fit, resourceful, outdoorsy, imaginative and well-read. I'm sure you can be all these things if you have loads of screen time too, but for us we've chosen not to and it's worked well.

lightisnotwhite · 04/09/2022 22:48

I agree but I think the “ bookish” kids of the past are the computer kids of today. The ones without the opportunity to go out or wanting to escape problems but with imagination.

I’ve taught lots of poorer kids who had zero interest in screens. The difference was they were out and about on their own. No parents supporting hiking, kayaking or cycling. Often their bikes were nicked and they’d nick one back.

Livinginanotherworld · 04/09/2022 22:45

I don’t see it as a wealth/class divide. You can make a conscious choice to keep your kids as screen free as possible. Plenty of outside activities, local football clubs, athletics, parks are free. A love of reading encouraged early on. It’s a parenting choice, not a lack of money.

MoreTeaLessCoffee · 04/09/2022 22:39

It's not about being cash poor necessarily but time poor. As a lone parent (widowed so no 2nd parent at all) working ft I don't have many hours in the week spare to go biking /hiking etc or even to the park. I need to use a fair bit of our downtime to catch up on chores, cooking etc. That's when they end up on screens. The difference between my family and that of those around me is having the extra parent (sometimes a sahp) to actually take the children to activities and engage with them, I often envy it.

Mrssophie · 04/09/2022 22:38

I grew up on a council estate which also has a lot of grass areas. My mam still lives on the same estate and children are always out playing, so I can't imagine they spend much time on screen and certainly aren't well off. They don't need parents to pay for extra activities they just knock on the neighbours door "is X playing out".

ilkleymoorbartat · 04/09/2022 22:37

For those who have a culture of reading at home, how do you do it?? Our kids aren't on screens much at all but I'd love to know how you carve out time to read in front of the kids?

We read to them absolutely loads, and have plenty of books around the house. But I don't think I've ever had time to set an example of reading for my own enjoyment in front of them (apart from on holiday). Kids ate 5 and 7 btw.

liveforsummer · 04/09/2022 22:35

My dc have very little screen time. They both horse ride and as I'm a single parent on low income I can't afford normal lessons for them so they have to put the hours and work in to get to ride. I also have a relaxed attitude towards it when they do have free time so it isn't something they are desperate to get their time on while they can so they generally do other things. We've holidayed with far weather friends who set limits and the whole day revolves around the hour they are allowed where as mine couldn't care less as they know they could have it if they wanted. I don't think it's all to do with income more to do with lifestyle

earsup · 04/09/2022 22:35

2 rich friends of mine inherited loads , went to private schools, dad had a rolls royce as a runabout car....!!...they wake up and tv goes on ...full blast...they sit on the sofa and watch it all day and night while snacking....if not watching the tv, they on amazon buying non stop....go on luxury hols and spend the days in the room watching more tv....bonkers....yet they probably had books and lots of activities while younger....!!...they are also now obese...!! so cant really get off the sofa...!!

SNWannabe · 04/09/2022 22:34

It’s another example of the socially influenced determinents of health- where children from poorer backgrounds have lower life expectancy overall and poorer health outcomes due to a HUGE and interactive number of influences and factors. Many out with their or their parents control…

And these poorer areas often don’t have good travel links so the “local skatepark” is inaccessible or council run gyms with reduced price activities are similarly hard to get to without transport. Habits are formed in childhood and a child of a poor single parent with no spare money, low education and no transport is less likely to be signing their child up for swimming lessons or football. But they can give them an old phone or tablet…

Goawayangryman · 04/09/2022 22:33

I was state educated all the way through (relatively poor background, not penury, not affluent either).

I watched so much tv and practically fell on my computer and consoled when they landed aged around 11-14. Hasn't impinged on my curiosity and love of practical, creative things.

Any orthodoxy/ system of strict rules and restrictions is suspect, I reckon. Bit of screen time is fine. Too much of anything (and that includes hiding in books) is less than ideal. I think the important thing is social connections, however you come about them.lots.of.kids socialise via screens, phones and consoles these days. Am ok with that, as I don't think it's hugely different from spending hours on the phone, which I also did when younger.

declutteringmymind · 04/09/2022 22:32

My DS has moved from state primary to private secondary and there is a difference.

Parents are generally a lot more wary of technology and giving it to their children. The school also provides a lot of advice, talks etc on online safety. There were a good few who didn't have phones when they started in Y7 for example. This suited us as our DS got his phone late in Y6 and doesn't have any consoles.

Towards the end of primary he had very few friends to play out with as they were all indoors gaming, and there is still a divide between the online gamers and the non gamers.

My DS does play on his PC occasionally, but as a PP mentioned, we have a big garden, and the kids who agree to play out with DS -football, cycling, are those whose parents aren't keen on too much screen time.

Also, the earliest DS gets in is 5:15pm. With regards to extra activities, he does football and cubs. Everything else is provided by school.

They don't have tvs in their rooms.

He is glued to his phone sometimes and we have to actively spend time with both children to play board games, watch movies, cook. But we are lucky to have the time and know how to do this. It's not easy but worth the effort in my view.

We also include the kids in chores. Contributing to the household is a non negotiable.

Then there's not much time to play computer games.

Snugglemonkey · 04/09/2022 22:32

I have a child at a private school. He is 6 and has a lot of after school activities. He also has some screen time daily, mostly reading eggs and math seeds, but he sometimes watches 15/20 mins of whatever he fancies if there is time before his bath. He reads daily before bed and I often read to him.

KensingtonStation · 04/09/2022 22:31

Mine is in private school, I work full time. He lives on his screens. It is how he chats to his friends because they aren't within walking distance.
I am juggling many balls at the moment, screen time is the least of my concerns

CantFindTheBeat · 04/09/2022 22:29

FrecklesMalone · 04/09/2022 22:21

My kids are at state school, we are really strict about screens even with the older teens. They go to the park and play football, read books, cook, play games, draw. the 14 and 16 year old and have jobs. Doesn't cost anything other than the mither especially when they are younger. It's easy/lazy to default to screens. Everything is easier if you are rich but don't use it as an excuse.

💯 this.

CantFindTheBeat · 04/09/2022 22:28

Rubbish.

My eldest DD used to do gymnastics in a poor London borough. Tonnes of kids doing the same, night after night.

Skateboarding - nothing more than a board required.

Local Football: kick a ball around the park, join a local team.

There are tonnes of activities that don't require much money. It's the encouragement that's needs, not wealth or class.

Sometimeswinning · 04/09/2022 22:28

We go biking. It's a bit of a thing for us. Ds does football and dd enjoys running. Youngest one gets dragged along but keeps up. I'm not sure it's money which makes the difference. We're by no means wealthy. My friends around me are also at many of the activities we are part of.

I actually enjoy the times my kids plug themselves in! It's literally the one time I think they have a bit of down time. That includes me and dh. Again youngest dd doesn't so much but she's happy to watch a bit of Bluey. I think there needs to be a balance.

MintJulia · 04/09/2022 22:24

I'm a single mum with a ds at independent school on a scholarship. I work full time and have no support..

My ds plays his fair share of Minecraft etc, but I find time at the weekend to hike & cycle with him, we run parkrun together - because they are free. He does have a council swimming lesson on a Saturday but that's all.

FrecklesMalone · 04/09/2022 22:22

Should add they do go on screens, just much less than their peers

GoldPig · 04/09/2022 22:21

Loads of DS homework is online/app based so that doesn’t help

FrecklesMalone · 04/09/2022 22:21

My kids are at state school, we are really strict about screens even with the older teens. They go to the park and play football, read books, cook, play games, draw. the 14 and 16 year old and have jobs. Doesn't cost anything other than the mither especially when they are younger. It's easy/lazy to default to screens. Everything is easier if you are rich but don't use it as an excuse.

Forestgate · 04/09/2022 22:21

I think it's an education thing to be honest nothing to do with money. The psrk is free but If you haven't educated yourself about the dangers of screens for children, the screen is easier.

feckoffbrian · 04/09/2022 22:20

We don't do afterschool clubs, except swimming

Ewetoo · 04/09/2022 22:19

SunflowerOrange · 04/09/2022 22:18

Ah yes also the overprogramming with clubs every day! No time to be home resting...

Or gaming!

OP posts:
feckoffbrian · 04/09/2022 22:19

I work in a private school (and DC are schooled there). We are screen free in school and they get 30 mins each, 3 times a week. That can be for games or tv.
We read a lot.
Films are kept for special occasions as we all find them a bit long (and it will often end with all of us falling asleep before the end).

Swipe left for the next trending thread