Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well off children & children who attend private school spend alot less time on screens?

134 replies

Ewetoo · 04/09/2022 21:55

www.screenfreeparenting.com/rich-get-smart-poor-get-technology-new-digital-divide-school-choice/

Interesting article & I agree.. Well off parents can spend more time & money on enriching educational after school activities & sports. It's a no brainer... My wealthier friends are all off hiking, camping or biking with the kids who do a host of extracurriculars during the week & also happen to read loads.. My normal circles kids like my own love roblox & Minecraft & don't have the same after school activities & weekends spent chilling...

OP posts:
Feetache · 04/09/2022 23:30

I really resent the 'uneducated poor use devices to entertain kids' line.
The truely poor do not have iPads / PS / Xbox. They can barely feed & cloths their kids. In vast numbers.
I know a lot of private school kids who have all the screens and games as play on them plenty

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:30

Mine both went to state school and we live on a council estate fo further add to the stereo type
We had no real screen time limits as such , but mine played rugby and footie so took up a lot of weekend , also they often played out at park with mates etc , so naturally they just didn't over a year have tons of screentime
I also have never taken phones at bedtime , they just know they have to switch off and get up in the morning and manage it themselves
They do know I would step in if needed though
So some weeks mine might of had a fair bit screen time and the following couple weeks nothing , its all evened itself out

surreygirl1987 · 04/09/2022 23:27

You don't get kids who "happen to read loads". There will be a reading culture within the family and there is likely to be a strong parental example to follow.

Not always. My parents didn't read at all, and were glued to the TV my entire childhood. I devoured books. I was a kid who 'happened to read loads'.

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:26

@CantFindTheBeat mine played football for a team and it costs money to play sometimes up to £5-8 a week , plus travel to games which can be far away , football boots aren't cheap either and mu dh coaches rugby and again fees ( although cheaper ) travel and time , lots of parents now have jobs that involve working weekend , this we found is why many parents cannot commit to a weekly game and training nights

MelodyPondsMum · 04/09/2022 23:26

It's always been the case that Montessori etc were low tech, as were Silicon Valley schools. I don't think it crosses over to private schools in the UK at all. Most of them are very tech dependent for homework and in-school work.

Yy DC at our private school have clubs and hobbies but they also tend to have mobile phones from a young age; and age inappropriate social media. The parents refuse to limit electronics or put parameters around social media.

WeAreThePigs · 04/09/2022 23:24

ilkleymoorbartat · 04/09/2022 22:37

For those who have a culture of reading at home, how do you do it?? Our kids aren't on screens much at all but I'd love to know how you carve out time to read in front of the kids?

We read to them absolutely loads, and have plenty of books around the house. But I don't think I've ever had time to set an example of reading for my own enjoyment in front of them (apart from on holiday). Kids ate 5 and 7 btw.

We talk about books a lot. they listen to us chatting about books and see us charge into bookshops all the time especially second hand ones. If you genuinely love reading they will pick up your enthusiasm anyway!

Feetache · 04/09/2022 23:23

Well yes. Money buys privilege.
Longer days. Long journeys. Loads of clubs. Money buys endless enriching activities. Money buys nannies & holiday clubs.
I'm comfortably middle class.
My kids do stuff every night.
But walk home by 3.15-4pm
So yes screens it is as I'm working

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:22

Private school children seem to often have longer school days , they don't all do cheap camping and biking either
Horsseriding , sailing etc are expensive hobbies , many can afford swimming lessons and many extra circular which people on lower incomes can't always

BabyDreamers · 04/09/2022 23:21

Everything you listed is very low cost yabu.

WeAreThePigs · 04/09/2022 23:20

My children are privately educated geeky types who spend their time playing musical instruments, going to museums, reading and screening although they’re quite proactive and make videos and do coding courses rather than just sitting there for hours.

However from the outside it will look like: they’re on screens… again

compared to their classmates. Theyre honestly unusual though I think and yes I think the old trope of the middle classes and sports is completely true.

Snugglemonkey · 04/09/2022 23:19

ilkleymoorbartat · 04/09/2022 22:37

For those who have a culture of reading at home, how do you do it?? Our kids aren't on screens much at all but I'd love to know how you carve out time to read in front of the kids?

We read to them absolutely loads, and have plenty of books around the house. But I don't think I've ever had time to set an example of reading for my own enjoyment in front of them (apart from on holiday). Kids ate 5 and 7 btw.

After I read to DS (6), he picks a book from his week library and we snuggle in his bed. I read my Kindle and we just chill out and read together for about 20/30 mins.

CocoC · 04/09/2022 23:17

I would say it really depends!
My DS is in a top private school and the devices are EVERYWHERE. All homework is done on a ipad, and has to be sent in electronically, it's all on google drive. This drives me mad, as we are very anti-screentime, but this has made us lose control. He sits at the ipad and it's hard for me to know what he is actually doing on it. He is the only one of 3 in class with no phone (age 11), and the vast majority have PS.
A lot of the children are of SE Asian origin, and they don't seem to have the same aversion to screentime as the European parents, if I am honest, so it's definitely cultural : our French/Spanish/Italian friends are much much stricter.

larry4PM · 04/09/2022 23:16

High achieving adult with a private school education here.

Spent loads of time on screens. Even as a child, I was a massive introvert and had zero interest in sports. It's not as if my parents didn't encourage me to do other stuff - I just didn't want to. Children, much like adults, are individuals who like different things.

I can give you plenty of examples of people I went to school with who did and didn't spend loads of time on screens and did and didn't do well for themselves. Whether kids like spending time playing with tech is to do with their interests and personalities - it's not an indication of anything other than that.

This is propaganda by people with an agenda. Look at the source of that article. Obviously they want to support their own parenting decisions.

They can raise their kids with as little screen time as they like, but they shouldn't make anyone feel bad if their children happen to like technology.

Hollyhobbi · 04/09/2022 23:06

When my two were younger they had swimming lessons, dance lessons and were in Scouts so were away camping a lot of weekends. I wouldn't describe us as wealthy by any stretch of the imagination, but their friends were also attending these activities. Their public school (non fee paying in Ireland) also had after school classes, for a nominal fee, such as crafts, gymnastics or drama. In other words they were kept busy partly because we both worked outside the home and partly because I attended piano lessons, brownies and girl guides, and swimming lessons when I was a child and wanted them to have the same experiences I and my sister's had. They are both dyslexic so used to attend workshops for dyslexia every Saturday morning too. One of my children isn't a fan of reading but the other likes reading for leisure now especially science fiction which is great.

Hawkins001 · 04/09/2022 23:02

Some of my YouTube watching is junk, some of it is teaching myself about finance, and politics.

I prefer outdoors e.g. Woodlands bike riding and nature exploration.

At times I do photography, but that has phases where I'm active and other times im mellow.

Mumsnet is the majority of my screen time.

underneaththeash · 04/09/2022 23:01

How can it be a class thing to not let your children be on screens all the time? It's just laziness.

I took my brownies away on camp recently and on the training session beforehand we had a discussion (lead by me) about phones and I said that there was absolutely no way that any of them were bringing a phone. (apart from our type one diabetic who uses a phone to monitor her sugar levels).
Everyone was up in arms saying that the parents would revolt - but I pointed out that barely any of the children actually had phones in my unit and my daughter didn't either - and she was a year older.

Dreamingcats · 04/09/2022 22:59

My sister is a single mother with two boys. She is definitely classed as poor.

But she takes them camping and they do lots of outdoors activities. She's very clever about it. They don't want to watch TV. Not being rich doesn't have to mean being stuck on a computer.

My SS on the other hand has a wealthy mother and spends a fortune on computer games.

howoriginal · 04/09/2022 22:59

I dunno, I know a lot of parents who send their kids to private schools and the kids do nothing but play on their consoles or watch tv all day. Our son goes to a private school - we live in a non-English speaking country so my husbands employers pay for him to go to a private English speaking school - but if we lived in the UK he would be going to a state school because we are not in a position to pay for school fees ourselves. Some of the wealthier parents at this school spend very little time with their children and the Nannie's will often just plonk them in front of a screen, or the kids are so spoiled that the parents/nannies just don't say ever say no when they ask to watch tv or play their switch.
We are quite relaxed about screen time. Our son (7) has to get the school bus at just gone 7am and three days a week he has after school activities (football and cooking class) so most days he he is home by 4:30 - it's a long day. I have no issue with him coming home and watching tv or playing Mario kart when he's tired and in need of switching off. At the weekend he walks the dog with us, goes to the park, sees his friends, rides his bike etc - as long as he is not just spending time on screens then we don't really limit it on weekends. He's pretty good at saying he's bored of it and wants to build Lego or starts doing some drawing. And at bedtime he reads for an hour or so. I think there's a balance to be had, and I don't think it's always as clear cut as private school vs state school / rich vs poor.

thefamilyupstairs · 04/09/2022 22:59

walking the dog as a family*

lechatnoir · 04/09/2022 22:58

And agree, having a garden to play out in (or kick a ball) is a huge benefit that if you have it you don't appreciate what a difference it can make - I say that as someone who had a garden and now doesn't!

thefamilyupstairs · 04/09/2022 22:58

I volunteered in dc's primary school and one thing that really stuck out was the more MC families filled their weekends with outdoor activities. Walking, hiking, kayaking, even just walking the dog as an These children would spend an hour before bed reading. I also know they were far more restrictive about screen time, having mobiles and consoles.
The more economically deprived children tended to have the latest consoles and spent most of their free time playing them. 'Family time' really didn't seem to feature, they would play in their bedrooms as they had their own TVs.

Louise0701 · 04/09/2022 22:57

@KarmaComma feral is the new cool for the middle classes! It gets thrown around at my DCs private school, usually followed by the infamous tinkly laugh.

Louise0701 · 04/09/2022 22:56

My 3 are privately educated and all of DDs homework is online. They also have reading eggs, TT rockstars etc. DD plays on Roblox with school friends too. They all do a few extra curricular activities each and DD loves playing out with friends. DS 1 & 2 are too young to play out but spend loads of time in the garden playing and all 3 love Lego and would do it for hours.

we’ve never enforced strict rules around screens, just provided and suggested alternative entertainment and we’ve found they’ve struck a nice balance. I think holding something back so much often has the opposite effect and leads to the restricted thing being craved.
DD enjoys Roblox with friends but isn’t glued to it and if her iPad runs out of charge, she will happily leave it 1/2 days before popping it on charge as she’s busy doing other things.

KarmaComma · 04/09/2022 22:55

outdoorsy

Wondering what a working class 'outdoorsy' type does. I've only ever heard that word used to describe middle class kids. If they were working class, they'd be called feral.

lechatnoir · 04/09/2022 22:53

My kids get in from school (state secondary albeit 2 at grammar if that makes a difference) and they have 2-3 hours screen time every week day - we both work ft and don't get home until gone 6 and they all switch on the minute they are home which varies from 4-4:30pm. All those at private school get home a good hour later some nearer 6 will travel plus more have one SAHP (or now more likely to WFH due to higher propensity for white collar jobs)

Mine all do sport at the weekend and we do stuff as a family but they definitely have more screen time than I'd like but unless they self-regulate, not much I can do. (Did try switching off the Wi-Fi - they just go to mates houses!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread