Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well off children & children who attend private school spend alot less time on screens?

134 replies

Ewetoo · 04/09/2022 21:55

www.screenfreeparenting.com/rich-get-smart-poor-get-technology-new-digital-divide-school-choice/

Interesting article & I agree.. Well off parents can spend more time & money on enriching educational after school activities & sports. It's a no brainer... My wealthier friends are all off hiking, camping or biking with the kids who do a host of extracurriculars during the week & also happen to read loads.. My normal circles kids like my own love roblox & Minecraft & don't have the same after school activities & weekends spent chilling...

OP posts:
Hoowhoowho · 05/09/2022 00:22

Confusing correlation and causation is an elementary error that is as common among the anti screen time group as among their cousins the homeopaths.

Rich parents can outsource childcare, cleaning and other chores so indeed can spend their time with their kids engaged in activities. Normal parents have to sort the laundry, cook the dinner, answer a work email and use the free childcare calked Peppa Pig to cope. There is absolutely zero high quality evidence that this causes harm.

Of course rich parents also have the time to set up wanky websites called ‘Screen free parenting’ and pander to the anxieties of their fellow yummy mummies and daddies. Frankly do what you like. Whether you hand your 2yo an iPad on demand or ban screens of all sorts until they’re 21, the ultimate outcome will be very little different.

LBOCS2 · 05/09/2022 00:21

My DC have unlimited screen time. They also have unlimited access to crafting things, and reading materials, and outside space, and and and...

They do spend time on their screens but they also spend hours creating things - crafting models out of air drying clay most recently; they independently found and watched a tutorial on what they wanted to make on YouTube then they gave it an excellent go themselves.

They also read. A lot. The elder (9) more than the younger (6) but I think that's because 6 wants to read the same things as her sister and it wears her out. She's trying to read the first Harry Potter at the moment and won't have it that it might be better if she left it for a year or so. 9yo has to be told to turn off her light well after bedtime because she's engrossed in her reading, but that's fine as far as I'm concerned!

I can't get worked up about this, these children have just spent the best part of two years in which everything was via a screen, give them a break. 9yo DD did (and still does) a huge amount of socialising via FaceTime/video calls and she's been speaking to her friends almost every day this holiday. That's social capital even if they're not there in person. Give them lots of opportunities to do different things and they'll find the stuff that interests them.

I do model reading for them, I get my
Kindle out and ignore them unless someone is bleeding. It's effective because I get to read my books and they get to see it and also sort out their own arguments which is a good life skill IMO.

Sunnytwobridges · 05/09/2022 00:15

I’m middle class and my kid spent a lot of time in screens. However she was on the track team, the basketball team, and did karate. She spent a lot of time on screens cause she doesn’t make friends easily so screens were her go to in her down time. She turned out just fine and is in a successful career.

worriedatthistime · 05/09/2022 00:13

@fratellia yes mine are 19 and 17 and spend less time on phones / screens that we do in fairness and we have never limited it

fratellia · 05/09/2022 00:03

@worriedatthistime Yes as mentioned in my PP a lot of adults (myself included!) struggle with screen addiction and screen time despite the fact tablets and smart phones didn’t even EXIST in our own childhoods.

So clearly, going by the amount of adults who are glued to their phones and have trouble regulating screen time, a screen-free childhood doesn’t seem to have any bearing on how we manage screens as adults.

I sometimes wonder if children manage better in adulthood with more access to screens and learning to regulate it.

worriedatthistime · 05/09/2022 00:03

@Minimalme exactly mine did a fair amount but because they wanted to it was never forced and they knew they could give up whenever ( they never did though so no sat/ sun lie in ) but some I know have there kids doing all sorts but its not always about what the kids want , its want they think is expected and how other parents may portray them
Already on here its without being said , screen time - not such a good parent
Limit or no screen time - extra parenting points

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 05/09/2022 00:03

earsup · 04/09/2022 22:35

2 rich friends of mine inherited loads , went to private schools, dad had a rolls royce as a runabout car....!!...they wake up and tv goes on ...full blast...they sit on the sofa and watch it all day and night while snacking....if not watching the tv, they on amazon buying non stop....go on luxury hols and spend the days in the room watching more tv....bonkers....yet they probably had books and lots of activities while younger....!!...they are also now obese...!! so cant really get off the sofa...!!

Hate to say it but that shows the difference between inheriting money and earning it.

worriedatthistime · 05/09/2022 00:00

@ElspethTascioni so your older ones don't have phones ? No ipad or laptop to complete homework on ?

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:59

Why do people who limit screen time automatically pretty much put down those that do allow screen time ? Or think it makes there children better or more intelligent or themselves better parents
Nobody knows anyone else's circumstances and how do all these children do homework without a screen ?
Like I said we had no limits but mine managed their time pretty well , maybe because it wasn't so taboo or such a small timeframe to enjoy something they wanted to do

fratellia · 04/09/2022 23:59

i always remember that screens were barely even a thing when I was little- certainly smartphones and tablets didn’t even exist!

Yet despite having zero exposure to iPads or phones during childhood I struggle with screen addiction and being glued to my phone as an adult.

ElspethTascioni · 04/09/2022 23:56

18 down to 4

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:56

@Apollonia1 come back to us when they are 9/10

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:55

@ElspethTascioni and how ild are your children ?

Apollonia1 · 04/09/2022 23:54

My toddlers are 2.5. They've never seen the TV in our house turned on (they think it's broken). They LOVE books. Their favorite thing is to sit on my knee and read books.
However, I sometimes let them watch Peppa Pig on my iPad, and they'd happily spend hours doing that if I let them. I restrict it to the weekends. I want them to be outdoorsy kids, rather than glued to screens.

Minimalme · 04/09/2022 23:49

My kids have as much screen time as they want.

They don't do any extra curricular stuff (other than swimming lessons to learn how to not drown).

DS1 is a very academically able student, works hard, enjoys school.

Ds2 I has an intellectual impairment and screen time, along with crafting are the only two things he wants to do.

DS3 is rarely in the house, preferring to bike outside and do all the things we used to do in the 80s like building a camp and playing out with friends.

They are all awesome kids who make me proud. They have each learnt young to work out their own thoughts and feelings and take responsibility for their happiness.

I was a middle class child who did every extra curricular going. My abusive parents farmed me out and kept me so busy that I was well into adulthood before I could work out what I enjoyed and who I was.

I feel sorry for some of these hot houses kids whose time isn't their own. I remember it being stressful and exhausting.

pinok · 04/09/2022 23:48

Okay so IF it is true what is the reason?

Is it that wealthy people have the privileges that allow multiple extracurricular activities/hobbies/sports, days out away from home/screens at weekend, holidays, large gardens, free time and correct clothing/equipment to utilise outdoor space and go on hikes/bike rides.

Or is it that they are just inherently ~better~ than lazy poor parents?

ElspethTascioni · 04/09/2022 23:46

I can’t speak for anyone else, but certainly one of the reasons my kids are “bookish” is that they don’t have tablets. It’s not a private school / middle class / money thing, it’s a choice we’ve made based because we don’t want them idling their childhoods away on screens. Things like reading, junior parkrun, scouts/guides are all low-cost or free. The correlation of making these kinds of choices is the education level of the parents or their engagement at least, not private school.

CaptainBarbosa · 04/09/2022 23:41

State school here. Lone parent household so just me and DS. One income and social housing.

DS 8 does, rugby, boxing, boys brigade, church on Sundays.

He's not a reader mainly because he's dyslexic, but what he does love is Lego!! He spends most if not all his free time building with Lego. He does have a Nintendo switch which has Minecraft and Pokémon on it, but it probably gets used once or twice a week. He might watch the odd hour or two of TV now and again, but mostly it's Lego.

I've never really had to put a screen time limit on, or have a rule. It's never been needed. I do however spend far too much money on Lego 😳 if only I was a shareholder!! Lol

Intothewoodland · 04/09/2022 23:39

My children (state educated and a toddler) don't have limits to screen time but they do do a range of other things. Lego building, playing in the garden, wild swimming, country walks, creative play, E.t.c...

Stylishkidintheriot · 04/09/2022 23:38

We are not wealthy and DS doesn’t go to private school. But he goes to after school club most evenings, and does a few evening a weekend activities during the school term.

most other spare time he’s at play dates, parties, playing with his cars or just activities (ie park, science centre, day trip, beach, walks, museum, zoo etc).

we aren’t rich, but not poor either, and only have one child, so that helps lots

SummerInSun · 04/09/2022 23:37

I live in a fairly wealthy part of London, and it would be socially unacceptable to give you kids a free home or iPad to entertain themselves in a local cafe or restaurant. People would be judging you for sure! Books, colouring in, sticker books, etc, but no devices.

Another vote for all the private school parents I know are strict about screen time, at least during primary school. But they have longer days. I'm always amazed by the Mumsnet threads about families where the kids watch TV in the morning until they leave for school at 8:45. Mine have to be at school by 8:15 at the latest!

worriedatthistime · 04/09/2022 23:35

@surreygirl1987 at that age mine also loved books , by 7 /8 hated them , I blame you accelerated reading
Both had very high reading levels throughout school though
Now as older teenagers barely read a book at all

Feetache · 04/09/2022 23:35

The article is from a web site called 'screen free parenting'
In most high schools everything and homework is heavily on devices

SummerInSun · 04/09/2022 23:33

ilkleymoorbartat · 04/09/2022 22:37

For those who have a culture of reading at home, how do you do it?? Our kids aren't on screens much at all but I'd love to know how you carve out time to read in front of the kids?

We read to them absolutely loads, and have plenty of books around the house. But I don't think I've ever had time to set an example of reading for my own enjoyment in front of them (apart from on holiday). Kids ate 5 and 7 btw.

Start a separate thread on this topic! But at that age (ms DC are a year or two older) start with comic type books for the younger one (Dogman, Catkid) and ones with lots of pictures (eg Diary of a Wimpy Kid, the 7 sorry treehouse books) for the older one.

surreygirl1987 · 04/09/2022 23:31

*For those who have a culture of reading at home, how do you do it?? Our kids aren't on screens much at all but I'd love to know how you carve out time to read in front of the kids?

We read to them absolutely loads, and have plenty of books around the house. But I don't think I've ever had time to set an example of reading for my own enjoyment in front of them (apart from on holiday). Kids ate 5 and 7 btw.*

My kids are far younger (2 and 3) but if they're playing nicely with their trains or on the garden, I'll open a book. There 3 year old often asks me about what I'm reading (the 2 year old wanders over and peers). We take books in the car every day. Today we went to a cafe and my 3 year old asked if he could bring his book. We read it while waiting for the food to arrive. It might all go wrong for me but at the moment I'm just trying to embed reading into day to day life as a normal thing we do. We strictly limit TV. Long way to go I know...

Swipe left for the next trending thread