Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well off children & children who attend private school spend alot less time on screens?

134 replies

Ewetoo · 04/09/2022 21:55

www.screenfreeparenting.com/rich-get-smart-poor-get-technology-new-digital-divide-school-choice/

Interesting article & I agree.. Well off parents can spend more time & money on enriching educational after school activities & sports. It's a no brainer... My wealthier friends are all off hiking, camping or biking with the kids who do a host of extracurriculars during the week & also happen to read loads.. My normal circles kids like my own love roblox & Minecraft & don't have the same after school activities & weekends spent chilling...

OP posts:
riotlady · 05/09/2022 07:39

In my experience, less well off kids often get a lot of free play time that privately educated kids don’t. My younger half sisters were privately educated and did endless activities, “educational” screen time etc, but never seemed to have a free afternoon to get out all their toys and make an imaginary world, or go play with their friends. Similarly you see a lot of parents on here that are baffled by the idea of “playing out”. So I think the ability to do lots of activities can be a bit of a blessing and a curse- you’re not glued to the iPad, but you’re not getting lots of time for unstructured play either

goldfinchonthelawn · 05/09/2022 07:33

I know a lot of wealthy kids who were glued to screens. It's their schools, not their parents who made sured they got detached from them, with D of E and trips abroad and loads of sports fixtures and choir tours and debating soc meet ups and art exhibitions etc.

Going hiking and reading are both free activities. Anyone can do them. But if you work long shifts and are knackered when you get in, you might be less inclined to go for a hike or trek to one of the few existing libraries that haven;t been closed down.

Endlesssummer2022 · 05/09/2022 07:32

I must add that I really don’t get the stress over screen time that many seem to have. DH and I grew up in the 80s and did a lot of ‘playing out’ but we also watched SHED loads of tv. We had early consoles too. We both managed to get through uni and get good jobs.

Our jobs are in tech and have given us the opportunity to earn enough to put our kids through private school. We just don’t fear tech. There needs to be a balance but I don’t get this ‘15 mins of screen time a day or they will fail at life thing’. DC spent lots of time playing Robolox but still aced her SATs and Entrance Exam and has many offline friends. Her private school uses screens a lot. They all have their own iPads or MacBooks for class and homework.

The future is digital and kids need to be able to engage with this or fall behind.

user5587553798654345678 · 05/09/2022 07:31

@thegreenlight completely different for children with SEN and I really don’t think that all screen time is bad at all. If your child finds it soothing and helps to regulate then I’m sure you’re making the best decisions for him x

Capturetotalelotion · 05/09/2022 07:30

Same as you, my DS is 10 autistic and happiest when in the digital world. He was at independent mainstream school until recently. My DSIS kids all went to state school and one of them is often on her phone that the other two aren’t. It depends on the child, not how much money you have or don’t have. HTH.

user5587553798654345678 · 05/09/2022 07:29

Also, I think that not all tech is bad. YouTube/Roblox are blocked on our Wi-Fi. They’re 99% utter, utter dross for children. (I can unblock it when I need to look up how to fix the dishwasher etc 😂)

thegreenlight · 05/09/2022 07:26

this post makes me feel awful. My DS9 has autism and finds literally every thing other than gaming anxiety inducing. We have given up on limiting screen time. We have tried all sorts of activities - piano/sailing etc but he will have a meltdown that requires days to get over. We used to go out EVERY weekend to museums and national trust but now he just can’t cope with it. It makes me so sad but the screen is his safe place.

user5587553798654345678 · 05/09/2022 07:26

We’re not wealthy (lone parent, two children) but both children at independent school. We have no screens/tech in the week because there really isn’t time (longer days + homework + music practice + reading together). It has a natural limit at weekends because we go out lots and I encourage lots of bike rides etc.

Some of their friends at school have a lot of tech (generally children who have parents working very long hours with no additional childcare so children left to own devices).

But most parents limit tech and their peers do lots of sport/riding etc at weekends.

PotatoHammock · 05/09/2022 07:13

I'm sure it's easier to keep kids off screens if they're literally busy doing other expensive hobbies all the time. But it's not so difficult without much money. My kids don't do a single paid extra curricular activity, but I'm still very strict about screen time. We spend try and spend a good chunk of the weekend outside, or at a free museum (my kids are still primary, I understand this will change!)

But we do have a decent sized garden, and I'm not counting the pennies on petrol just yet, so I do understand that it must of course be much more difficult if you're genuinely struggling financially.

So basically, it's not exactly easier if you're rich, but it's definitely harder if you're poor.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 05/09/2022 07:13

FrecklesMalone · 04/09/2022 22:21

My kids are at state school, we are really strict about screens even with the older teens. They go to the park and play football, read books, cook, play games, draw. the 14 and 16 year old and have jobs. Doesn't cost anything other than the mither especially when they are younger. It's easy/lazy to default to screens. Everything is easier if you are rich but don't use it as an excuse.

Just a quick derail - mine are 13 and 15 and would love jobs but can't find anything which will take under 16s. There are no paper rounds here. What do yours do? Perhaps there is a route we can take which we've not thought about.

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 05/09/2022 06:58

@surreygirl1987 I was exactly the same, but this is much less common now than when we were kids because in the 80s and 90s there were far fewer things for kids to do other than read!

Nowadays kids don't tend to just become readers without some effort on the part of parents. It does happen, but it's very rare.

I'm an English teacher in a state school. My two teenagers are both still readers, although my 16 year old son much less than his sister, but he's studying for 4 A Levels so has less spare time.

My 9 year old rarely actively chooses to read. At the weekend I sit with him for an hour and we read. I read to him before bed every night. He reads to himself for a bit before going to sleep. This is enough to make him consistently in the top 3 readers in terms of number of words read in his class on Accelerated Reader, which is a bit worrying really, because compared to me as a kid he barely reads at all! This is in quite a nice state school in a relatively leafy area too.

Indoctro · 05/09/2022 06:56

My kids go to state school

We have after school activities ever day

Running club, trampolining, swimming, drumming lessons and a tutor 2x a week also

Yet my kids still seem to find plenty of time for Minecraft etc.. Confused

Endlesssummer2022 · 05/09/2022 06:48

I can state from personal experience that this is bollocks. I have one kid in private secondary school and another in state primary. Both spend more time than I would like on devices.

DH and I don’t spend all of our spare time devising ‘enriching’ activities at all.

1AngelicFruitCake · 05/09/2022 06:37

@Apollonia1 my two loved reading, we’re obsessed with books as toddlers. It’s become more of a challenge now they’re getting older!
We’ve got a nice lifestyle, have enough money and I worry about a screen time a lot. We enforce limits. They have after school activities a few times a week, when not on tablets they play, draw, the younger one likes writing stories. At the weekends we go for long walks, go on scooters. I’ve noticed that many of my friends with a large disposable income will spend a lot of money on a day out/food out/gift shop. A walk picking blackberries or a walk into the hills and back doesn’t seem as appealing and I find that a shame, that children are being brought up to get used to these big days out all the time and won’t learn to appreciate more simple pastimes.

Hellothere54 · 05/09/2022 06:18

It’s not wealth, as much as time wealth. With more money, there is more time. Even if you are working long hours at a stressful job, money will give you less stresses elsewhere. If you spending every waking minute worrying and wondering how the hell you are going to feed your family as well as working long hours at a stressful job it’s got to be easier to throw a tablet at a kid than argue with them to find something else to do.

botleybump · 05/09/2022 06:03

I'm sure if you took this study to the next level and examined whether 'wealthier parents' are the kind of people who engage in more of these outdoor/healthy/beneficial activities, you'd find a similar correlation.

It's a culture of people thing rather than a privilege thing in most cases.
Of course, there will be exceptions, and I'm likely talking more 'self made' well off than generational wealth.

mathanxiety · 05/09/2022 05:13

@worriedatthistime
Mine were never restricted from TV. DD1 had a tv in her room from age 12, and a dvd player. They got phones as soon as phones were available. I bought DVDs and before that, video tapes. We watched lots of TV together, and movies too, and chatted about what we were watching. I lost count of the number of times I watched The Lion King 2. Sometimes when I closed my eyes at night the songs kept going in my head.

I think it's a mistake to make big distinctions between what kids watch and what they read, to look down your nose at one and fetishise the other. Everything and every activity that children enjoy is an opportunity for a parent to connect with them, to let them feel that their opinions and feelings matter. It's a short hop from enjoying a movie together to chatting about a book you've both read. You won't transmit your love of books (or anything else important to you) to a child who feels no connection to you or who feels you're only going to engage with them on your own terms, not theirs.

My observation about current strict rules on screens that some parents impose is that restrictions are used as a class marker. They also turn screen time into forbidden fruit.

mathanxiety · 05/09/2022 04:52

I bought lots of books for the DCs via school - you could buy cheap editions of books from an order form that was sent home monthly. On top of that, we had our calendar marked for the biggest event of the year as far as I was concerned, the annual library book sale where hundreds of thousands of books donated by the community and offloaded by the library were sold for between 25cents and $2 each. We spent a lot of time in local second hand bookshops too.

SallyWD · 05/09/2022 04:50

Maybe this true in general but the 3 children I know who go to private school (not siblings, all live separately) are all pretty screen obsessed and spend many hours on them.

mathanxiety · 05/09/2022 04:45

@ilkleymoorbartat
I used to sit on the couch and whip out whatever book I was reading at the time and read if the DCs were watching TV. I took out books for myself when we went to the library.

My DCs went to bed quite late by MN standards and all at the same time, so we had time together in the evenings after dinner. They could watch some pre watershed TV or something on the VCR (so long ago!) or sit with me and read, or do something else quietly likenfinishing up homework, etc. You have to make time for it, I found, and evenings were really the only time available when they were little and not involved in school sports but still dealing with homework and playing outdoors earlier in the afternoon.

They were also allowed to read in bed.

TheNefariousOrange · 05/09/2022 04:44

It's nothing to do with wealth, it's all to do with aspirations. People who are forking out for private school are more likely to be on it regarding homework being done properly and engaging in extra curricular activities. It's not to say it doesn't happen in poorer areas but from colleagues I've definitely noticed immediate happiness of the child trumps academics, so more time for screen time etc.

MangyInseam · 05/09/2022 04:04

And it did make a difference to their functioning in school. The kids who were on screens all day were really limited in their experiences and things they had to talk about. Not just compared to better off kids, but also compared to poor kids pre-screen, who in the past were often much better than the well off kids at entertaining themselves. it's a real change.

MangyInseam · 05/09/2022 04:02

This fits my observations.

When I was tutoring , a lot of the kids I saw who were low income were on screens most of the day apart from school. Not all, but a significant proportion. Middle class kids were on them too but they also did other things a fair bit.

BuzzBuzzBuzzLightyearToTheRescue · 05/09/2022 01:12

I’m also a little bit unconvinced about the extent to which you can “instil a love of reading”. I mean sure, you read to them and you talk about it and you model it etc. But like everything else, some will love it and some won’t.

i was an avid reader. My sister is like 15 months younger than me, same upbringing, same stories etc and can’t be arsed with it.

BuzzBuzzBuzzLightyearToTheRescue · 05/09/2022 01:11

I’m very good at restricting my kids’ screen time.

I wish I was as good at restricting my own…