Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

French (and German) children don’t throw food

114 replies

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 19:24

I have heard of this book and think I need to read it.

Just got back from a foreign holiday where the majority of families were German.

All I saw around me were well behaved,
placid children. I lost count of the number of couples I saw on sun loungers at the pool whilst their (young) children played nearby, nicely, in the shallow pools. I also saw so many parents on their phones or reading, ignoring the children completely, whilst the children either sat and played at their feet, or just sat on the sun beds not really doing anything. Just…sitting. Quietly.

My children are not like this. They’re 6 and 3, and whilst the eldest is a decent swimmer he still needed a lot of interaction in the pool. And they would never just SIT THERE whilst DH and I ignored them. Ever. We were staying in a caravan and granted had limited stuff to entertain them there and then (mainly just stickers/books, no real toys) they rush around the house at home anyway and never sit and play with toys nicely (unless eldest is doing a Lego set).

I’ve never been so conscious of my inadequate parenting and children before, and we have been on plenty of Center Parcs/UK holidays. In fact one of the things I like about CP is the fact that you can relax with DC as there is always another one having a meltdown in the vicinity.

AIBU to think this? Are European children just better behaved?

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 04/09/2022 21:15

Well German kids are not 'better' but they are definitely encouraged to be more independent and self sufficient than in the UK. When we lived in Berlin all the kids were walking to school on their own by 7 or 8 years old. They were doing 5-day residentials in kindergarten. They're not supervised as much anywhere and there isn't the same level of child-centred activities, it was more the whole family doing a sport or hobby together.

Tillsforthrills · 04/09/2022 21:12

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 19:51

Nobody in England seems to want to discipline their children. It's always "don't do that" but no actually REMOVING a child from the situation and actually STOPPING them doing something. It drives me mad.

I don’t even see a ‘don’t do that’. Children where I am in London are basically begged to behave and their tantrums are met with more choices, more pleading.

You can tell the parents are purposefully raising them to be extremely entitled adults.

Kanaloa · 04/09/2022 21:10

Yep. As per the usual mumsnet rhetoric Europeans are better in every way - slimmer, more stylish, more civil, funnier, cleverer, better parents, and so on and so forth as nauseam.

Or they’re just people like we are. Varied. Some good some bad. I’ve looked after British, French, Polish, and American children and found them much like British children. Some of them are lovely and wonderful. Some are naughty and annoying. Most are somewhere in between!

Ramblingnamechanger · 04/09/2022 21:09

You can always spot the foreign children in Spain. The local children out to lunch with relatives can be given a table to themselves, and help each other eg cutting up food for the youngest , chatting to each other, no whining ,no food refusal, no tantrums or arguments or throwing food. Very socialised from an early age. Remarkable.

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 21:08

Vallmo47 · 04/09/2022 21:01

Ugh, I disagree with Scandinavian kids being well behaved and/or parents not pandering to them. Whenever I’ve visited home in Sweden I have witnessed absolutely appalling behaviour in shops from kids not asking, not begging, but DEMANDING treats and parents giving in. I’ve met many rascals both here and in Sweden and at least here people attempt to discipline. A very stern voice and a consequence. Back home I’ve witnessed eye rolls and a lot of excuses like “he’s tired/hungry/being silly” or parents even asking me to share bad behaviour I’ve experienced myself. Don’t worry about my parenting, sort your kids out instead.

This is my experience of kids back home, it doesn’t mean it applies to everyone, obviously. I’m not a perfect parent by any means but my kids will be well behaved in public or there will be consequences and they do NOT want to face my wrath.

All kids are little shits in shops sometimes, it’s kind of universal I think..But yeah, some parents have gone too far in not saying no. They’ve sort of missed the whole point. Good luck when their kids are teenagers I always think..

babyjellyfish · 04/09/2022 21:08

My child is French and he definitely likes to throw food.

And the French children I used to au pair for were absolutely feral. One of them memorably took a shit in the children's playground.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/09/2022 21:06

@thunderhoney I actually wished we had moved there when our son was young and it was easy to do so- I think life in scandi land with young families is terrific - tax is high- but you get quite a lot for it and it shows. I also saw a lot more 'father' involvement with young kids , a lot more men in town on their own with toddlers and teens than I ever see here.

Must admit we came back for various practical reasons but given the shit show here I'm really missing Copenhagen and my frequent jaunts to Sweden too.

I can honestly say I never once saw a parent shout 'oi ,come back here you little shits' etc - as I've witnessed here.

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 21:03

Another thing which I actually think is more important than we might think, is that here we without fail would eat dinner together around the table every night with our children. Same food (some variations if it’s spicy etc) but we talk, and they are just expected to interact and not jump down as soon as they are finished.

Vallmo47 · 04/09/2022 21:01

Ugh, I disagree with Scandinavian kids being well behaved and/or parents not pandering to them. Whenever I’ve visited home in Sweden I have witnessed absolutely appalling behaviour in shops from kids not asking, not begging, but DEMANDING treats and parents giving in. I’ve met many rascals both here and in Sweden and at least here people attempt to discipline. A very stern voice and a consequence. Back home I’ve witnessed eye rolls and a lot of excuses like “he’s tired/hungry/being silly” or parents even asking me to share bad behaviour I’ve experienced myself. Don’t worry about my parenting, sort your kids out instead.

This is my experience of kids back home, it doesn’t mean it applies to everyone, obviously. I’m not a perfect parent by any means but my kids will be well behaved in public or there will be consequences and they do NOT want to face my wrath.

TheNefariousOrange · 04/09/2022 20:59

I used to nanny, and later teach, in Germany. The behaviour was no different. Parents could still be wishy-washy, make excuses for bad behaviour instead of deal with it, or also be super strict, or somewhere in between. Just like in the UK.

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 20:56

@mathanxiety I always give consequences! I am forever threatening the loss of something and see it through.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 04/09/2022 20:53

@Summersummersun - responding the first time happens when there have been consequences for not doing so and when it's made clear that the big problem is 'not listening to parent' as opposed to running away or demanding candy in the supermarket, or whatever the child did.

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 20:52

The thing I notice when in the UK is parent shouting at their very young children, and giving them constant ’warnings’. If you don’t behave this will happen. And the children couldn’t care less, they obviously stopped listening to the threats a long time ago. It doesn’t work, it’s not helpful to anyone. It’s very stressful just to listen to it as an outsider. I even heard a dad in a shop threatening a toddler with getting a smack if he didn’t do as told. My 18 and 20-year old were honestly shocked, and it never happens. It truly opened their eyes, so I guess something good came out of it.

IaltagDhubh · 04/09/2022 20:51

My German nephews are little shits.

SeasonFinale · 04/09/2022 20:47

I think if you set boundaries from a very young age them kids know them from a young age and know there are consequences to misbehaviour. Mum of 3 boys who can be brought under control with the raise of an eyebrow rather than a raise of the voice.

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 20:42

*climbing frame, obviously

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 20:41

British parents are also often incredibly risk averse and reluctant to allow their DC to figure things out for themselves and take the accompanying knocks - hence the constant supervision, which children then grow accustomed to. As the parent of a 4 year old I see it constantly in the playground - parents discouraging their DC from attempting to climb things, saying it’s dangerous and they won’t be able to do it etc.

This is true. I’m a nursery teacher in a Scandi country, and the approach is very much to let the kids try until they succeed. For example if they can’t climb the climing frame themselves I would give them tips on how they could try and do it, but I would not help them. They need to figure it out. And I would not be overly enthustiastic when they make it (eagerly clapping my hands and yelling ’yeeeayhh!!!’), it’s more Well done, you could do it on your own. It’s important they know what it’s like to be bored, so they will invent their own games. And I think we talk to them much more in an adult way, no baby talk. Not saying it’s better, it’s just different..

Mamoun · 04/09/2022 20:40

I am French and I don't think it has anything to do with nationality but culturally children are expected to behave in certain circumstances (a restaurant for example).

My children (6 and 4) are not allowed to "buzz around" during adult quiet time. Not at all all day but maybe 45 minutes in the morning and 1 hour after lunch in the afternoon. It forces them to find something to do.

Before we enter a restaurant I will always warn them that we are going to a place with other adults and we can't be all over the shop or super loud.

Before going to a friend's place I also warn them that I want to talk to my friend so they can't buzz around us all the time.

If my child whines after a while I'll give them the choice to either stop or go to another room because it is annoying for everyone.

I think I am doing them a favour as it teaches them that there are rules to follow and that in a way life can be unforgiving.

By no means my children are perfect and they remain a full time job but I am also convinced that they thrive with boundaries and that it gives them security to know that me and my DH make the rules, not them.

We also spend a huge amount of time doing things with them and for them but there are times that are for mummy and daddy and that is non negotiable!

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 20:40

I do think the comments on here about expectations are interesting. Other parents might expect compliance first time etc. I expect it, but it bloody well doesn’t happen often! I fully see where the wishy washy parenting comes from too as I witness it a lot, but it does seem to almost be what’s expected in the UK. And I also struggle to see a way around it - today in a shop both my DS’ were standing on something they shouldn’t have, so DH asked them to get off. They ignored him, and when he physically moved them, 3 year old got in a strop and the 6 year old blew a raspberry at him!

@NameChangeLifeChange I secretly wish I’d had two girls instead of two boys as that’s exactly how I imagine it 😫although I’m one of two girls and was definitely “spirited”.

OP posts:
Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 20:34

@ElvisLeftTheBuilding I definitely agree with that. I’m guilty of it too, also of helicopter parenting.

@CustardCreamsAndMintTea Quite comforting to read about the birthday party!

OP posts:
Askinforabaskin · 04/09/2022 20:30

Just back from a week in Germany and I can see where you are coming from. Children over there seem to fit in to day to day life much easier. You see so much more children out and about in the city (not doing child oriented activities at all).

At the time I didn’t think they were particularly well behaved, but looking back I didn’t see a single temper tantrum or the classic trying to run away.

NameChangeLifeChange · 04/09/2022 20:29

Objectively my children are well behaved. They’re two girls, both love colouring, happy to potter around the table if allowed (eg on a square on holiday) but also will sit down. I can’t ignore them (would have to give them an activity or talk to them!) at the table but at the beach they will play happily with small amounts of input.
Not my parenting really- just their temperament. I appreciate I’m lucky and don’t judge other kids!

thunderhoney · 04/09/2022 20:28

Crikeyalmighty · 04/09/2022 19:50

Certainly in Denmark when we lived there I thought a lot of children seemed more controlled in behaviour in public, but in all fairness a lot of life was more 'ordered' - most families with both parents working, cheap childcare, good nurseries, parents working less hours, kids sitting down together at8am for breakfast at school. It did seem a different kind of parenting

Spot on. It goes for all of Scandinavia.

tarheelbaby · 04/09/2022 20:27

American here (as you might guess from my name) but moved to UK ages ago and my children have only ever lived here. I read the book a few years ago whilst we were on holiday in Charente-Maritime and enjoyed it but it's not just a French/German thing.

It's all variable. Some parents and children work well together and some don't. Some parents have one kind of expectations and others have another kind. Some children respond to this and some don't. Some people have two bookish boys and some people have two tear-away girls; Or a mix of these and more.

At 3 and 6, I would expect your children to need a certain amount of attention and close supervision in a pool or the sea no matter how well they get on in swimming lessons. At that age, they can't read chapter books independently and probably need regular physical exercise. My girls, although you would probably see them as sedate, were the same. I used to think about the irony of holidays: leave all your toys behind and go to this empty flat ...

Arbesque · 04/09/2022 20:26

I live in Ireland. A friend has just moved back from England where she worked in a school. She was aghast at the pandering that went on. Don't tell a child that a spelling is wrong, just advise them there might be a better way of spelling it etc. Absolute nonsense.

Not saying Irish child rearing is perfect. Far from it. But there seems to be a cohort of English parents that are going way too far and creating spoilt monsters.