Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

French (and German) children don’t throw food

114 replies

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 19:24

I have heard of this book and think I need to read it.

Just got back from a foreign holiday where the majority of families were German.

All I saw around me were well behaved,
placid children. I lost count of the number of couples I saw on sun loungers at the pool whilst their (young) children played nearby, nicely, in the shallow pools. I also saw so many parents on their phones or reading, ignoring the children completely, whilst the children either sat and played at their feet, or just sat on the sun beds not really doing anything. Just…sitting. Quietly.

My children are not like this. They’re 6 and 3, and whilst the eldest is a decent swimmer he still needed a lot of interaction in the pool. And they would never just SIT THERE whilst DH and I ignored them. Ever. We were staying in a caravan and granted had limited stuff to entertain them there and then (mainly just stickers/books, no real toys) they rush around the house at home anyway and never sit and play with toys nicely (unless eldest is doing a Lego set).

I’ve never been so conscious of my inadequate parenting and children before, and we have been on plenty of Center Parcs/UK holidays. In fact one of the things I like about CP is the fact that you can relax with DC as there is always another one having a meltdown in the vicinity.

AIBU to think this? Are European children just better behaved?

OP posts:
Ilikecheeseontoast · 04/09/2022 22:52

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 19:51

Nobody in England seems to want to discipline their children. It's always "don't do that" but no actually REMOVING a child from the situation and actually STOPPING them doing something. It drives me mad.

A very sweeping statement!

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 22:34

@Fluffruff i had assumed your DS was much younger too, don’t blame you for bollocking an 8 year old for that!

@SnackSizeRaisin any insight into what that telling off could be I’m all ears! The only way to make my DS cry from a telling off is to really shout, I mean REALLY, or take something he really loves.

OP posts:
GGGD · 04/09/2022 22:32

This discussion reminds me of a holiday at a small farm converted to a hotel with pool which we often stayed in whilst in Tuscany.
On one occasion an English family of three generations arrived. As soon as one of her primary-aged grandchildren complained/put a foot wrong by the pool the grandmother (in her 50s, probably) instantly and, without being quiet, commanded the child to return to the hotel room. No one in her family challenged her. Obedience was quietly accepted and instant.
Each time she did this our eyes opened as wide as dinner plates, thinking her domineering and excessive. She was someone we’d never seen before or have since. Life carried without the child and the atmosphere round the pool immediately reverted to harmony.
At the time we thought her draconian. Now we think she had very firm boundaries, was very considerate to other hotel guests and, as parents and grandparents with decades of embarrassing moments and meltdowns, we often recall her. She was a one-off.

HRTQueen · 04/09/2022 22:18

And in southern Europe/North Africa and ME strangers will pull up children for bad behaviour and will also fuss over them

Rosebel · 04/09/2022 22:18

When my DDs were about 3 and 1 we were in holiday in France and a woman came up and complimented me on how well behaved my children were.
So I'm not convinced children in France and Germany are better behaved. We always think other people's children behave better than our own. I'm not sure it's always true.

HRTQueen · 04/09/2022 22:16

I have found in Spain, Italy, North Africa and ME children are babied longer and they are not expected to be like little adults but when they are told off it’s harsher

in America similar to us but as a culture they are less reserved

not so sure about Germany of children behave better by they are far more independent from a young age what I have noticed (visited a number of times as best friend lives there) is there is very little interaction with young children from strangers i know some on here dislike adults they don’t know interacting with their children but when always found this interaction lovely

South asian well in my experience always treated like little princes and princesses for boys this often doesn’t change 🙄

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/09/2022 22:13

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 04/09/2022 21:51

today in a shop both my DS’ were standing on something they shouldn’t have, so DH asked them to get off. They ignored him, and when he physically moved them, 3 year old got in a strop and the 6 year old blew a raspberry at him!

@Summersummersun I dont know if its difference of country or not, but I'm American and if that had been my kids I would have immediately removed them from the shop. I still remember my youngest throwing a tantrum in the shop, I picked him up and we walked out. Was it convenient for me to do that? No, but the next time he started acting up and I said "we will leave if you dont stop" he KNEW I meant it and he stopped.

That's really rude behaviour towards their father.
Someone said to me that there's no point in telling off a child unless you make them cry and although that is a bit extreme I do get the point that they have to feel uncomfortable when told off. If they think they can completely ignore or respond by blowing a raspberry, clearly the telling off doesn't mean anything and you may as well keep your mouth shut and let them carry on doing what they're doing

NeverHadANickname · 04/09/2022 22:10

Arewerelated · 04/09/2022 19:30

I loved american children most on my travels 😁 confident, chatty and incredibly polite. Any bad behaviour was swiftly stopped by parents and apologies given immediately by the offending child.
There was absolutely NO tepid 'no.. no... stop that tabitha... tabitha stop... now stop that....' british parenting to be seen there

I work in childcare in America and their behavior is exactly the same as UK children.

fallfallfall · 04/09/2022 22:06

well my uk grand children just moved to france, maybe there is hope for them yet...

BellePeppa · 04/09/2022 22:02

When I lived abroad I found Italian children to be much worse behaved than mine.

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/09/2022 22:02

Fluffruff · 04/09/2022 21:53

re My son dicking around behind the car, I guess I could have held his hand but at nearly 8 I expect him not to be so dim and I also had two cats in their carriers and a 4 yr old plus luggage to watch out for. So when he didn’t listen to me for the third time I flipping well did shout at him to stop being so stupid. We can’t always forecast and pre-empt what kids are going to do! I rarely hear children being sharply ticked off in public for misbehaving but I am more than willing to do it and I’m mild compared to how my mum would have reacted!

Fair enough I assumed he was much younger. It sounds like the situation was unusual for him and just one of those awkward parenting moments!

lllllllllll · 04/09/2022 21:59

Not this rubbish again 🙄

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/09/2022 21:56

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 21:47

Another thing I noticed is that the adults (and children) were much less overly polite like us Brits. Much less waiting for others to walk through doors first, much more accidental barging into others and not apologising profusely like we would. Swings and roundabouts?

I think that's a cultural difference, adult french and other Europeans probably are less likely to queue nicely or apologise all the time. On the other hand they are more likely to greet everyone present, introduce others, and less likely to complain about you behind your back.
I haven't found UK teenagers much good at queuing so maybe those cultural differences are less marked in young people.

Fluffruff · 04/09/2022 21:53

re My son dicking around behind the car, I guess I could have held his hand but at nearly 8 I expect him not to be so dim and I also had two cats in their carriers and a 4 yr old plus luggage to watch out for. So when he didn’t listen to me for the third time I flipping well did shout at him to stop being so stupid. We can’t always forecast and pre-empt what kids are going to do! I rarely hear children being sharply ticked off in public for misbehaving but I am more than willing to do it and I’m mild compared to how my mum would have reacted!

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/09/2022 21:51

Can't really comment on the different nationalities but there's a reluctance to say no to children. For example my daughter (3) was asking for ice cream when we were at a cafe with a friend. I knew friend didn't want her child to have ice cream (she never lets him which is fair enough, her decision). Therefore I told my daughter she couldn't have an ice-cream today. Friend immediately started lying saying they had run out of ice cream! It's not the first time I've heard this kind of thing either, people coming up with very creative lies to justify why their child can't have something. It must be exhausting. Or alternatively they let the child do what they want every time, resulting in ridiculously inconvenient arrangements that just cause problems for everyone.

I'm a believer in making the important rules clear and enforcing consistently, and letting the child have as much freedom as possible within that, only intervening if it's properly dangerous (life and death not just falling over) or damaging property or hurting someone. Whereas what some parents seem to do is helicopter all the small stuff but he unable to enforce rules on the big stuff

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 04/09/2022 21:51

today in a shop both my DS’ were standing on something they shouldn’t have, so DH asked them to get off. They ignored him, and when he physically moved them, 3 year old got in a strop and the 6 year old blew a raspberry at him!

@Summersummersun I dont know if its difference of country or not, but I'm American and if that had been my kids I would have immediately removed them from the shop. I still remember my youngest throwing a tantrum in the shop, I picked him up and we walked out. Was it convenient for me to do that? No, but the next time he started acting up and I said "we will leave if you dont stop" he KNEW I meant it and he stopped.

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 21:47

Another thing I noticed is that the adults (and children) were much less overly polite like us Brits. Much less waiting for others to walk through doors first, much more accidental barging into others and not apologising profusely like we would. Swings and roundabouts?

OP posts:
Teapot13 · 04/09/2022 21:39

If the French do so much better at childrearing (i.e., Bringing up Bebe), wouldn't we expect French adults to be way more kind, polite and well-adjusted than other nationalities? I can't see this. I'm not saying they're worse, just that I don't thing they're miles ahead of any other nationality.

SnackSizeRaisin · 04/09/2022 21:29

Fluffruff · 04/09/2022 19:51

I don’t know, we had a week long holiday in the Netherlands recently on a site with mainly Dutch, French and German families and I saw the usual range of bad behaviour.

the thing is everyone complains about British parents being so wish washy but then you get looks if you’re sharp with your children. Last week my son was being silly and running back and forth behind my husband reversing our car so he had to break sharply, I called him over three times which he ignored, lost my patience and grabbed him by the arm to get him by my side and yelled ‘stop being so bloody stupid.’ I got a lot of looks from people in the carpark and afterwards my husband said I was too heavy handed and embarrassed him. Can’t win!

Surely in that scenario you hold your child to stop them running behind the car from the start? The fact that you actually let him ignore you 3 times while repeatedly running behind a moving car is the problem here. I guess it wasn't great to shout and swear but that isn't the worst bit.

Sandra1984 · 04/09/2022 21:28

Spaniard here. Just spend a month in Spain with my nephews ages 2 and 5. We were all day in the beach, they were a nightmare, shouting, throwing sand and needing our constant attention. I don’t agree that European children are better behaved, maybe German children, certainly not spanish ones 🤣

Ithinkwemightgetaholiday · 04/09/2022 21:23

Kanaloa · 04/09/2022 21:10

Yep. As per the usual mumsnet rhetoric Europeans are better in every way - slimmer, more stylish, more civil, funnier, cleverer, better parents, and so on and so forth as nauseam.

Or they’re just people like we are. Varied. Some good some bad. I’ve looked after British, French, Polish, and American children and found them much like British children. Some of them are lovely and wonderful. Some are naughty and annoying. Most are somewhere in between!

Agree... British are so shit blah blah

Been on holiday twice this summer and seen good and bad behaviour from kids of various nationalities.

Lasting memory of a small French toddler being followed round the buffet breakfast crying (I think with tiredness) whilst his parents just kept offering different food options. He clearly wasn't interested and needed a nap or just other distraction.

Changechangychange · 04/09/2022 21:22

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/09/2022 19:29

Soft play in Canada and soft play in England are VERY different places.

That really wasn’t my experience! The Canadian ones are bigger for sure, but the kids’ behaviour was about the same in all of them.

adhdforme · 04/09/2022 21:22

I find many British parents are just too soft. They don't want to cause a scene by scolding and upsetting the children. There are also a lot of helicopter parents - very evident on the playgrounds.

Today we were at a large event with a Punch & Judy show. 50+ kids and their parents gathered around on the grass watching and one 4/5 yr old boy at the very front kept standing up and grabbing at the puppets. His mother was off to the side and either a) didn't care too much or b) didn't want to make a scene in front of everyone because she didn't get up from the side to remove her child and stop him from doing it again, but she just kind of mouthed and gestured at him to stop and sit down. Did he? No! He kept bloody grabbing at the puppets.

laurzf1 · 04/09/2022 21:18

I'm in Germany and can assure you that you get your fair share of little terrors here and also of parents just ignoring their kids as they tear the place apart (i.e. soft play) I was really self conscious at first that we were the loud Brits in the village but the houses behind us all have noisy kids and crying babies so it doesn't worry me as much now. In fact the other day I could hear a dad yelling at 6am! Ha! It's not just us!

TenoringBehind · 04/09/2022 21:17

I lived in Germany for a while. The primary age children I encountered were very badly behaved!