Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

French (and German) children don’t throw food

114 replies

Summersummersun · 04/09/2022 19:24

I have heard of this book and think I need to read it.

Just got back from a foreign holiday where the majority of families were German.

All I saw around me were well behaved,
placid children. I lost count of the number of couples I saw on sun loungers at the pool whilst their (young) children played nearby, nicely, in the shallow pools. I also saw so many parents on their phones or reading, ignoring the children completely, whilst the children either sat and played at their feet, or just sat on the sun beds not really doing anything. Just…sitting. Quietly.

My children are not like this. They’re 6 and 3, and whilst the eldest is a decent swimmer he still needed a lot of interaction in the pool. And they would never just SIT THERE whilst DH and I ignored them. Ever. We were staying in a caravan and granted had limited stuff to entertain them there and then (mainly just stickers/books, no real toys) they rush around the house at home anyway and never sit and play with toys nicely (unless eldest is doing a Lego set).

I’ve never been so conscious of my inadequate parenting and children before, and we have been on plenty of Center Parcs/UK holidays. In fact one of the things I like about CP is the fact that you can relax with DC as there is always another one having a meltdown in the vicinity.

AIBU to think this? Are European children just better behaved?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notimeforaname · 05/09/2022 11:24

Lived in France for a few years and I really noticed this. French children expected to entertain themselves a lot and rarely had to be told off as much as children back home.

Of course this is just my experience.

Very polite at the table, ate 2 - 3 courses and always asked if they could leave the table before getting up. Always cleared their own plates too.

LeevMarie · 05/09/2022 10:06

European in peace, here, with a few observations . . . 😅

German kids can also be horrible. Often we don't really tolerate them well and there are places that ban them altogether. That said, there is certainly much less focus on places being child-centric. Kids are expected to integrate and fit in to a greater extent than here in the UK, I think.

I think, however, what the op describes is pretty common. I recently went on a Spanish resort holiday with DH, DS and British MiL and FiL who were horrified at my 'hands off' parenting. I was prepared to let DS make his own friends, play alone and I was equally confused by their assertion that DS needed entertaining the whole time. This is completely at odds with the way in which I was raised as a kid and I don't think it is particularly healthy to helicopter around your kids. I don't want my role to be the entertainer.

It was very easy to spot the British families in the restaurants, as they almost always had their kids plugged into a device of some sort.

British kids often have a bad rep, some of which I think is a little unfair. In general, I find that British parents place more emphasis on manners and politeness than I was ever exposed to as a kid, which I think is positive. DH and I have tried to take the best parts of the very different ways we were raised as kids and create a bit of a hybrid between the two. This would suggest that continental parents don't always get it right!

antelopevalley · 05/09/2022 10:02

covilha · 05/09/2022 09:22

Ha ha ha ha ha
Former Nanny to European children here.
Italian toddler meltdowns anyon?😂

All countries have some toddlers who have meltdowns. And the Italians are known to be pretty lenient with their young children.

zingally · 05/09/2022 09:53

It's a mix of parental expectations, children's personalities, and culture.

covilha · 05/09/2022 09:22

Ha ha ha ha ha
Former Nanny to European children here.
Italian toddler meltdowns anyon?😂

whoamI00 · 05/09/2022 09:11

I think YABU. I'm not sure if it's the correct phrase to describe it but I'd say Grass is greener on the other side?
I'm not British. For me British babies and young children appear to behave well for their age.

balalake · 05/09/2022 08:55

I've not been on holiday in recent years to resorts such as the OP describes. What I have noticed in cities I have been to is that those from the UK, be it child or adult, stand out, partly because they are noisier, and especially because of complete lack of any dignity and style in the way they dress.

WhereshouldIgo · 05/09/2022 08:54

It’s BS - just depends where you go! European kids are as good/bad/naughty/difficult/noisy as anywhere else’s!
we happen to have kids who behave well in public, sit and eat at table, we don’t allow devices in holiday etc and have had French waiters, staff and passers by comment on how ‘good’ they are compared to French kids. So just goes to show… it’s a myth that ALL French kids sit nicely in restaurants.
we saw one through the MOTHER of all tantrums ( age about 6/7) because he wanted his iPad back in a cafe…

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 05/09/2022 08:51

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 19:51

Nobody in England seems to want to discipline their children. It's always "don't do that" but no actually REMOVING a child from the situation and actually STOPPING them doing something. It drives me mad.

I agree with this. The amount of time you see children misbehaving or being rude when out and about and the parents solution is to buy them something to keep them quiet 🤯.

I am fortunate that my two eldest (11 &13) children are very polite and respectful of others. Even my youngest (7 with severe developmental SEN & Asd) knows if she screams about getting stuff in shops she gets nothing and goes home empty handed.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 05/09/2022 08:38

leaving Your kids unsupervised in a pool is aspirational parenting ??

5zeds · 05/09/2022 08:33

My children ate out and travelled a lot so could “do” restaurants. They didn’t throw food (I’m not sure I’ve really ever seen anyones child do that). Surely it’s just what they are used to, not something magical based on nationality. They definitely DIDN’T sleep through at three months!

PestoPasghetti · 05/09/2022 08:24

DelilahBucket · 04/09/2022 19:41

I see far too much wishy washy parenting. Just yesterday we witnessed a boy about 8 throwing a house brick towards a glass door to a pub, not once, but he went and picked it up and did it again. The chef came out and played Hell. Dad "come here" in light wispy voice. Boy ran off. Dad tried again, like a little mouse. He even tried "you're not in trouble just come here" along with "you're only making things worse by not coming". Mum attempted to step in and was met with "I've got this, I'm handling it". When he eventually got his mitts on said child, the "story" was the brick fell off the wall 😂. My husband turned around and said exactly what had happened. Cue child having the biggest rolling round on the floor meltdown I have ever seen. This kid put toddler's to shame. He was literally dragged off on his knees by dad to apologise.
We were just sat there aghast. Never mind stern voice, there was no consequence, and to be honest, the story made up by the boy suggested that kind of behaviour was a regular occurrence and he was usually allowed to get away with it.
And that is what I see day in day out. You don't need to be shouting the odds at your kids, but dear God get a grip and learn a stern voice and how to carry out appropriate consequences for behaviour. I've managed to raise a polite, caring, boy who wouldn't even dream of throwing bricks at a glass door. Why can't everyone else?!

I had an interview for a nanny job once. The eldest (around 5 I think?) started pushing and pummelling his dad. His parents praised him for 'only hitting gently'!!! I had to scoop my jaw up off the floor at that.

Kanaloa · 05/09/2022 08:15

So that person’s ‘travels’ might well have been in America. So meeting regular/average people.

Kanaloa · 05/09/2022 08:15

donquixotedelamancha · 05/09/2022 08:10

I loved american children most on my travels 😁 confident, chatty and incredibly polite. Any bad behaviour was swiftly stopped by parents and apologies given immediately by the offending child.

Most Americans don't travel abroad. You are meeting a very self selecting bunch of kids.

Well you don’t know that - I’ve spent time in America so meeting an average bunch of kids from the country. I’ve found some of them lovely, and some horrible. Like British kids. Like literally all kids, and all people.

donquixotedelamancha · 05/09/2022 08:10

I loved american children most on my travels 😁 confident, chatty and incredibly polite. Any bad behaviour was swiftly stopped by parents and apologies given immediately by the offending child.

Most Americans don't travel abroad. You are meeting a very self selecting bunch of kids.

Caspianberg · 05/09/2022 07:52

There’s definitely a more communal thought of bringing up child here. Many families live in multi generational houses.

We have no family here, but all neighbours and friends here will equally tell Ds not to do something as well as equally shower him with hugs and affection.

Theres also less closed off houses near us. Ie most houses have open gardens with no high fences, so the children can just wander in and out of neighbours. This is encouraged and allowed. Our two neighbours 3 year olds just appear in our garden to play with our 2 year old. No parent in sight, and they both live 6-8 hours along.

Summersummersun · 05/09/2022 07:08

Interesting what’s been said about meal times in the UK as we try and make a big effort to eat with the DC. It’s not every single night due to work or other commitments, but definitely more than 50% of the week’s evening meals. A lot of my friends are the same once their children are past weaning stage, so I wasn’t aware of the separate eating culture.

@antelopevalley interesting and I agree I think. There’s also such a difference in the way children are viewed - I feel in many other cultures they are valued a lot more than in the UK. At the airport in the European country, everyone with small children was given priority to the front of the passport check queue. I can’t imagine that ever happening in the UK! I had neighbours from Hong Kong until very recently, and not only were their own teenage children polite and beautifully behaved, the parents doted on my DC immediately.

I think we live in silos a lot more in this country? But that can’t always be helped, not everyone has family nearby.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 05/09/2022 00:38

There are badly behaved and well-behaved children in every country, and great and useless parents everywhere. And what is considered polite and rude varies from country to country.
There are differences though. In general, British parents are more risk averse and there is less encouragement of independence. There is a lot of focus on making children's childhoods special and memorable, which translates into lots of children's activities and entertaining children.
There is very little focus on eating together as a family around a table, unlike in some countries and the idea of children's food is different from adults' food. There is also not that much concern about poor diets amongst children. A lot of British children seem to have very poor diets. Much fewer children go every week to church in comparison to some countries, so most children have not learned how to behave in church e.g. at a wedding.
In some countries, if your parenting is weak, others, including strangers will intervene and tell your child off. That is a big taboo in the UK.
Some cultures/countries have a stronger valuing of education than British culture does. And alongside this a strong respect for teachers.
British culture is quite anti-authoritarian in small ways, but not in large ways. This seems to translate into things like parents saying their children do not have to respect an adult unless they earn their respect. This idea is totally alien in some countries. There is a concern that children should not be robots and should think for themselves. I think this can lead to behaviour that appears poorer as children are expected to figure out more for themselves.
There is a strong focus on children's mental health in the culture and children being able to express their feelings. So fairly old children will cry in the classroom, for example if they are told they can not do something, something that was a bit of a shock to me.
The big difference though us that the UK is an individualist culture where the focus is on individuals getting what they want out of life, and that follows through in the parenting. In the UK the parents "own" the child. In some cultures the focus is on the community and the extended family "own" the child.
The UK is very good at safeguarding and takes it more seriously than a lot of countries.

mishmased · 04/09/2022 23:48

Arewerelated · 04/09/2022 19:30

I loved american children most on my travels 😁 confident, chatty and incredibly polite. Any bad behaviour was swiftly stopped by parents and apologies given immediately by the offending child.
There was absolutely NO tepid 'no.. no... stop that tabitha... tabitha stop... now stop that....' british parenting to be seen there

This is so funny 😆

UWhatNow · 04/09/2022 23:46

It’s not necessarily a continental thing. I would also ignore my children to a degree on holiday knowing they could entertain themselves and behave well. They weren’t scarred - they were perfectly happy and loved and are now resilient, independent young adults. It never ceases to amaze me what a huge rod for their own back some parents make with the constant entertaining and cajoling and pandering.

Feetache · 04/09/2022 23:38

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/09/2022 19:29

Soft play in Canada and soft play in England are VERY different places.

Please tell us more

SweepItUnderTheCarpet · 04/09/2022 23:26

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/09/2022 19:29

Soft play in Canada and soft play in England are VERY different places.

Sorry but that's bollux! Two of my kids ARE Canadian and we lived there 12 years. I've four kids and lots of experience of kids soft play in both countries. I don't think there is a difference. There are good kids and bratty kids in both countries.

Ace56 · 04/09/2022 23:16

I agree OP, I do feel like parenting styles are different in Europe which (on the whole) leads to better behaved children. They are left to get in with it/entertain themselves a lot more, so aren’t so demanding of their parents for attention.

I’m always amazed at the differences when at the beach in a European country, for instance, compared with a beach in the UK, in terms of kids behaviour.

Ilikecheeseontoast · 04/09/2022 22:59

IaltagDhubh · 04/09/2022 20:51

My German nephews are little shits.

😂😂😂

oakleaffy · 04/09/2022 22:58

DelilahBucket · 04/09/2022 19:41

I see far too much wishy washy parenting. Just yesterday we witnessed a boy about 8 throwing a house brick towards a glass door to a pub, not once, but he went and picked it up and did it again. The chef came out and played Hell. Dad "come here" in light wispy voice. Boy ran off. Dad tried again, like a little mouse. He even tried "you're not in trouble just come here" along with "you're only making things worse by not coming". Mum attempted to step in and was met with "I've got this, I'm handling it". When he eventually got his mitts on said child, the "story" was the brick fell off the wall 😂. My husband turned around and said exactly what had happened. Cue child having the biggest rolling round on the floor meltdown I have ever seen. This kid put toddler's to shame. He was literally dragged off on his knees by dad to apologise.
We were just sat there aghast. Never mind stern voice, there was no consequence, and to be honest, the story made up by the boy suggested that kind of behaviour was a regular occurrence and he was usually allowed to get away with it.
And that is what I see day in day out. You don't need to be shouting the odds at your kids, but dear God get a grip and learn a stern voice and how to carry out appropriate consequences for behaviour. I've managed to raise a polite, caring, boy who wouldn't even dream of throwing bricks at a glass door. Why can't everyone else?!

Agree totally.
So much insipid wet parenting around.
As if parents think that their hellions won’t “ Like them” if they are firm and no nonsense.

Parents wheedling and pleading at children in a weak voice.
We had a great teacher at school, “ Foxy”
He could walk into a class and everyone would fall silent.
He had natural authority.
Some people exude it- No punishment needed.

One sees it with dogs, too.
Running rings around a wet owner, while someone with quiet authority manages very well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread