Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Party bags, again

59 replies

FiveSatsumas · 04/09/2022 19:02

Sorry, I know it’s a perennial question on here but I’d like opinions.

Party for my just-turned-five year old. Kids will be 4/5, one seven year old. Not a big party.

I hate tat in party bags. Not just the stuff that breaks in minutes but the colouring books that go unused, tiny tubs of Playdoh etc. I equally hate the virtue-signalling brown pencils + seeds + organic quinoa type. Which leaves me a bit hamstrung.

I’m planning on giving a small Lego set (example attached) and mini bag of Haribo (or maybe one of those Bear / yoyo snacks?). Is this OK do you think, or does it look miserly because it’s only two things? This would be my ideal to receive as a parent but that’s not the point clearly otherwise all the other parents would be handing out gin miniatures.

And advice welcome for a total fussbudget. I’d look normal if you met me, honest.

YABU - bring on the tat, they love it!
YANBU - that is fine/thoughtful/lovely/less likely to end in the bin.

Party bags, again
OP posts:
FiveSatsumas · 04/09/2022 20:50

They were in the Lidl aisle of doom at (?) £3 a few weeks back @Shinytaps , so I nabbed them (plus one Duplo equivalent for the little sibling toddling with). There's only five or six kids coming so it feels manageable; don't think I'd do it for a class of 30.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 04/09/2022 20:48

sunandheatwave · 04/09/2022 20:42

I understand your opinions of party bags but what you think of as tat may not be a child's opinion.

My kids love love love play doh, but would ignore colouring in books or books in general. My son loves lego but those small sets would get ignored.

That's exactly why the custom of party bags should end, you're never going to give 15/20/30 kids a bag full of inexpensive small gifts that they all like and use. It will always, always be landfill.

Kids do like tat, they'd probably also like a planet that's not been ruined by rampant consumerism. Party bags must be one of the very easiest things to cut out. That and those magazines with 200 pieces of plastic crap on the front.

Shinytaps · 04/09/2022 20:42

Mine would have loved this at that age. Will it not be quite pricey though?

I agree that the lovely seed packets, hand whittled pencils, etc often end up unused and we’ve had some books which never get looked at. Mine love punch balloons. Not environmentally friendly I must admit but at least they deflate eventually and don’t clutter up the house. I’m just going to max out on the sweets this year 😬

sunandheatwave · 04/09/2022 20:42

I understand your opinions of party bags but what you think of as tat may not be a child's opinion.

My kids love love love play doh, but would ignore colouring in books or books in general. My son loves lego but those small sets would get ignored.

Thehonestbadger · 04/09/2022 19:50

My favourite party bags are mini bubbles and a few edible bits with a piece of cake.

I recently did my two year olds with a pack of organix crisps, milky bar, mini bubbles a small book and piece of cake. Seemed to go down well.

TwiggletLover · 04/09/2022 19:46

Lots of people do the book idea. Usually the books are a bit rubbish/ or we already have it plus my kids are always a bit disappointed with them tbh. They are expecting some sort of toy.
Lego would go down very well with my DC. I've seen these sets for £3.50 in Tesco. More than I'd spend on a party bag personally but it's a good idea in my opinion

Needmorelego · 04/09/2022 19:45

@reelcat you can't put Lego in the 'tat' group...
It's a highly sophisticated interlocking brick system 🤣

reelcat · 04/09/2022 19:40

Lego is a great idea! I know people love the books but usually we got duplicates or books too young for her age. Kids love tat and sweets!

MsChatterbox · 04/09/2022 19:32

My son would love to receive that. I would deffo do more sweets/chocolate and also a balloon though.

Needmorelego · 04/09/2022 19:30

@thinkover the polybag the OP showed goes for up to a fiver on eBay.
I am slightly traumatised of the thought of you chucking Lego in the bin. Even the individual minifigs sell secondhand.
I may have to lie down now.....

georgarina · 04/09/2022 19:28

A few things in a bag is fine, kids just like the excitement of seeing what's inside. I don't do plastic but Lego is at least not disposable tat. Other stuff we've had that are in between the two extremes have been miniature instruments (maracas, flutes), wooden Rubiks cube type toys, flip books, and mini watercolour sets.

FiveSatsumas · 04/09/2022 19:28

Thanks all. @LimeTwists I think we’re onto something you know. Next year the kids can have a balloon and I’ll do gin and those poncy boxed single choc truffles you get at French hotels.

I wish I had the resolve for book + cake. I’d like to be that person but I’m just not, even though my kids are finally there on reading books instead of hopefully nibbling the corners. I hope that Lego plus Haribo plus cake is an intermediary step to lucky dip of random crap <parenting goals>.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 04/09/2022 19:27

I'd just go cake and sweets.

Lego is still plastic and if you don't like Lego then it's tat.

Be the change you want to see OP! No party bags, just cake and some sweets.

Kids don't need a present for attending a party, they've just had a lovely time not been through a terrible ordeal!!

thinkover · 04/09/2022 19:24

Not a boxed set no but Lego isn’t a big thing in our house so I’d assume a little bit in a plastic bag is worthless/not worth sending to charity shop. I stand corrected.

NerrSnerr · 04/09/2022 19:24

thinkover · 04/09/2022 19:16

I like the book idea. The lego thing is just more plastic to me, mine aren’t into it so it’d be random and go in the bin. £1 book and a mini bag of chocolate or animal biscuits or a slice of cake. I wouldn’t give sweets.

Would you really put it in the bin and not pass it on to someone else or the charity shop? What a waste.

anotherscroller · 04/09/2022 19:21

My kind of parent 👌

Needmorelego · 04/09/2022 19:20

@thinkover please tell me you wouldn't actually put a Lego set "in the bin".
The secondary selling market for Lego (even polybags) is massive.
Or just give to a charity shop 🙄

thinkover · 04/09/2022 19:16

I like the book idea. The lego thing is just more plastic to me, mine aren’t into it so it’d be random and go in the bin. £1 book and a mini bag of chocolate or animal biscuits or a slice of cake. I wouldn’t give sweets.

Flutterbybudget · 04/09/2022 19:16

When my own children were young, most years I’d buy a set of books and split it, putting one in each bag, along with a balloon and a small bag of sweets/ mini bar of chocolate.
One year, I trawled for bargains through the year, and set a budget of 50p per gift (downside, it takes time) and did a lucky dip at the end of the party. That went down really well.

Whatafool123 · 04/09/2022 19:15

I agree. Add some cake and that is perfect.

I also agree about right on party bags. DS went to a party with fabulous party bags including a hard back book. As he was looking through it, he opened a little paper bag with a few round brown things coated in what looked like icing sugar. DH and I said ‘ooh, chocolate truffles!’ and luckily we were by the party mum at the time who looked horrified and said ’No, don’t eat them, they’re seed bombs!’

LimeTwists · 04/09/2022 19:13

Don’t dismiss the idea of gin miniatures, OP - you would become locally renowned for making the best party bags EVER 😁

BusyMum47 · 04/09/2022 19:11

@FiveSatsumas Looks perfect to me! Chuck a bit of cake in & job done! I did similar one year for our son - went down really well. All parents hate party bag shite/landfill!!

One year I was desperate to do something a bit different & took a great idea from a friend - I bought some cheap, white, supermarket t.shirts & some fabric pens so that the kids could make their own - that was a really popular one!

ZenNudist · 04/09/2022 19:10

My dc liked tat. I'd buy Baker Ross toys and spend quite a lot on good quality tat that gave a really good fun bag. my dc were still pinging stretchy aliens or throwing crawling octopuses at windows for months.

I don't like mini colouring books or pencils but maybe suit some dc.

Some toys are cheap so get overdone. bouncy balls, bubbles, but kids love em.

I said yanbu because I also like when parents do one good thing well. My friend did giant bubble wands one year which went down well.

The only problem is your nicely thought out toy might not appeal to all but lego is a safe bet and there's always one child unhappy.

Hugasauras · 04/09/2022 19:10

@loudlylikealion Yes, definitely not for a whole class party!

Cherrysherbet · 04/09/2022 19:09

Looks great to me!

My kids always looked to see if there were any sweets in the bag first😁. I’d go with a small bag of sweets as opposed to yo-yo bears.

Swipe left for the next trending thread