Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think the nurse crisis could be solved if they had an incentive for people to become nurses

354 replies

Starsinyoureyes13 · 04/09/2022 17:52

A student nurse doesn't get paid to study and train on the wards. 37.5 hours and due to lack of nurses they are working alongside nurses wouldn't it be better to pay the trainee nurses and give nurses a payrise rather than NHS squandering money on £60 pound an hour agency staff?

OP posts:
kenadams86 · 05/09/2022 07:05

PuttingDownRoots · 04/09/2022 18:14

For maths with mature students, wouldn't a functional skills test as part of the application process be more informative than an exam done 10-20+ years before? Obviously they need Maths skills, but education is something that happens over life, not just at school

They do this already.

Student nurses also have several maths calculation exams during the 3 year training

Snog · 05/09/2022 07:02

We need to stop charging people to become nurses- scrap the tuition fees and give decent bursaries.
We need to pay nurses well.
We need to improve working conditions for nurses. They need proper staffing levels on the wards, they need to be able to take their breaks and not to be working unpaid overtime every shift.
We need to end the bullying from other nurses and managers - this is a huge issue in the NHS.
We have been hiding from addressing the real issues in nursing by raiding nurses from other countries such as the Philippines. Shame on the UK for not getting to grip with these issues. We have had nursing shortages for at least 25 years and have still not solved the problems.

Notplayingball · 05/09/2022 06:58

Lex345 · 05/09/2022 06:43

Yes, @Lougle the mix and match as well. First nursing job on a busy renal ward, 3 months qualified and one of my shift rotas was: 30th 730am-330pm, 31st night shift 830pm-730am, 1st 3pm-9pm, 2nd 730am-330am. It was EXPECTED. No one can do this long term.

That's utterly daft. I used to do ten day stints years ago which was bad enough.

Midsomerwine · 05/09/2022 06:57

Topgub · 04/09/2022 19:24

Isn't it weird how no one ever suggests we should solve the medical staffing crisis by making the medical degree easier ?
The sexism is striking

This would terrify me.

QuebecBagnet · 05/09/2022 06:57

Sorry, that was a reply to someone saying back before it was a degree you needed 3 A levels. You didn’t. Now it’s a degree you obviously do, although not in maths.

QuebecBagnet · 05/09/2022 06:56

Nurse training never required 3 A levels as until recently you could start at 17yo. I had 17yos in my cohort who had left school after one year of sixth form.

Notplayingball · 05/09/2022 06:55

Thank you to whoever started this thread. I had a tiny fleeting delusional moment earlier this year where I was considering returning to nursing after a long career break but this has just made sure that I will not be returning due to all the stuff discussed in this thread.

I have a lot going on in my personal life, I don't need to add to it.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 05/09/2022 06:55

Lex345 · 05/09/2022 06:34

The problem with constantly going back to "nursing being a vocation" is it an emotionally loaded statement which is used as an indirect way to justify poor working conditions-put up, or shut up, basically. If nursing is your vocation, you shouldn't care the pay is poor, the hours too long, the expectations unrealistic, the mental strain too much. "But its your vocation!"

Anyone who thinks nursing is not a degree level profession simply does not understand the complexities involved in the job. Our nursing programme covered anatomy & physiology, pharmacology, advanced pharmacology, sociology, ethics, informatics, pathology, clinical decision making, epidemiology, evidence based nursing, microbiology, palliative care, infection control, mental health, emergency medicine and had a dissertation to finish. In addition to practice based assessments and full time placement.

You certainly can't teach kindness and you do have to have a certain set of personal attributes to be a good nurse, but that is not an excuse for justofying crap conditions.

You show me any other job where someone is forced to work 36 hours straight-no sleep-because another registered nurse has not turned up for their shift. It HAPPENS. It happens a lot. And you have no choice but to stay as there is no one to handover to.

those topics were also covered during non-degree nursing of yore...and as today, there were good and bad nurses
Don't make out nursing is so much more complex. Patients have the same diseases, some have new diseases. Nurses may be more involved in the mdt approach to care, but nursing is nursing.
If you asked patients what they want from a nurse, a degree would barely feature on the list. Care and competence would be high

Vecnasnurse · 05/09/2022 06:52

I can't think of any better job (in theory) than a nurse or care worker. I would love to do it and genuinely enjoy caring for others and feel passionate about advocating for people in their hour of need. That said, I would never work for the NHS in its current state. I'm a single mum with no childcare so I couldn't do the shifts required to be a nurse, and care worker pays absolute pennies. I also couldn't cope with the stress of being spread so thinly that patients suffered as a result of understaffing and budget cuts. If there were better support for nurses and carers, a decent level of pay, and a pleasant environment to work in I'd do it in a heartbeat.

Lex345 · 05/09/2022 06:43

Yes, @Lougle the mix and match as well. First nursing job on a busy renal ward, 3 months qualified and one of my shift rotas was: 30th 730am-330pm, 31st night shift 830pm-730am, 1st 3pm-9pm, 2nd 730am-330am. It was EXPECTED. No one can do this long term.

hashbrownsandwich · 05/09/2022 06:41

I am a TNA (trainee nursing associate) and I am paid to do the apprenticeship which is 1 uni day a week, 1 PLT day and 1 clinical day. This is a 2 year course. Then we can do an additional 18 months to top up to RN.

I'm paid better than a some actual RNs but that's probably because I'm GP based .

Lougle · 05/09/2022 06:41

The rigidity of nursing rotas doesn't help. I was forced into a position where I had to quit. I couldn't make the shifts work. I could have done a Twilight (7pm-3am, or 7pm-6am, say) but they wouldn't take it, despite knowing they are the busy times. Another nurse was not allowed to go part time as a band 7, so had to return as a band 6. Work-life balance is a huge factor in people leaving the profession.

PanicAtTheBigTesco · 05/09/2022 06:40

Slightly different but I'm an accountant primarily for GP practices and for the last 2 years there has been an incentive for newly qualified doctors to become GPs (£20k cash payable within the first few years (I would need to double check the exact details), I've not seen a single doctor take up the offer. Also as others have said, it's retention that is the issue not training levels.

OddsandSods · 05/09/2022 06:34

WHY do these threads always go down a route of arguing against degrees? Nursing has been a degree profession for many years and modern nursing is a safety critical and highly complex profession. This won’t and can’t change. I also agree this is misogyny as no one ever argues that medicine or AHPs abandon their degrees or put up with being on the lowest pay bands.

Anyway it’s a moot point, getting people through the door is a much smaller issue than retaining them during and after training. Nurses soon learn it’s a horrid, badly paid and poorly treated job and we don’t hold into them. Most ward nurses are very junior especially in cities, as no one wants to do it. We have a ridiculously low hospital bed to population ratio coupled with a record number of nurse vacancies. A toxic combination.

You can of course retain people in miserable and stressful professions by paying them adequately and ensuring they are supported with clear role boundaries. Nursing is none of those things and quite rightly these bright and motivated people decide it’s not worth doing.

Lex345 · 05/09/2022 06:34

The problem with constantly going back to "nursing being a vocation" is it an emotionally loaded statement which is used as an indirect way to justify poor working conditions-put up, or shut up, basically. If nursing is your vocation, you shouldn't care the pay is poor, the hours too long, the expectations unrealistic, the mental strain too much. "But its your vocation!"

Anyone who thinks nursing is not a degree level profession simply does not understand the complexities involved in the job. Our nursing programme covered anatomy & physiology, pharmacology, advanced pharmacology, sociology, ethics, informatics, pathology, clinical decision making, epidemiology, evidence based nursing, microbiology, palliative care, infection control, mental health, emergency medicine and had a dissertation to finish. In addition to practice based assessments and full time placement.

You certainly can't teach kindness and you do have to have a certain set of personal attributes to be a good nurse, but that is not an excuse for justofying crap conditions.

You show me any other job where someone is forced to work 36 hours straight-no sleep-because another registered nurse has not turned up for their shift. It HAPPENS. It happens a lot. And you have no choice but to stay as there is no one to handover to.

adamanti · 05/09/2022 06:23

Secure job for life, reasonable salary, pension. There's not many jobs where non academic people can become professionals. The NHS is a ball of shit but so are state schools and social services. Plenty of private alternatives.

Restlessinthenorth · 05/09/2022 06:18

Dalaidramailama · 04/09/2022 22:38

I have a first class degree in health and social care plus ward experience but no maths GCSE. So nursing is out for me. I get that you need to be literate in maths but they don’t even accept the maths equivalents. I was willing to do the functional level 2 as this is day to day maths applications, however I wasn’t willing to do a maths GCSE due to my dyscalculia. I can’t understand formulas etc, and that sort of maths is not used in nursing so it is a bit of red tape that I can’t get past.

. Nursing admissions tutor here. This doesn't make sense. Functional skills is widely accepted as a GCSE maths equivalent?

newbiename · 05/09/2022 05:40

@CornishGem1975 do you know what nurses actually do these days ?

cocktailclub · 05/09/2022 04:41

I also think social care staff are treated appallingly and don't even get a professional qualification. They are paid minimum wage with a huge amount of responsibility and often undertaking tasks which traditionally nurses would do with minimal supervision such as administering insulin or tube feeding.

Stoptheworld99 · 05/09/2022 03:02

Starsinyoureyes13 · 04/09/2022 19:59

HCAS are terribly underpaid and have been screwed over for years. 100 percent agree with your comment. They get a little over 11 maybe 12 pounds an hour to do the jobs that was once only performed by trained nurses. It's scandalous!

I'm HCA, been on my ward 19 years, so on the highest wage a HCA can be..... £11.16 an hour (band 3) Minimum wage increases far more each year than my wage. Give it another 3 or 4 years and my wage for 22+ years service and experience will be akin to minimum wage.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/09/2022 02:11

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 05/09/2022 01:54

I think I responded to you in error.. i apologise
My point was, when nursing was not degree, but hospital based, maths a level was required (at least it was in london teaching hospitals), so a level of maths knowledge was essential to get into training.
And essential to do the job, even if you can use a calculator now!

Fair enough.

Maths A level though! That's hardcore.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 05/09/2022 02:02

SaggyBlinders · 05/09/2022 01:44

I don't think there was much need for drugs calculations 100 years ago. Some of my colleagues were around in the 80s and 90s when nurses didn't have to give intravenous medications; they were all done by the doctors.

Nurse training seems to have gone full circle, the nursing associate route seems pretty similar to the old state enrolled nurse, with an option to "top up" to being a band 5 nurse.

i can assure you that in the 1980s nurses were doing drug calculations for addatives to IV bags, and were calculating drip rates (this was pre machines that automate drug delivery). They not have been inserting the actual cannula, but were very much involved with ensuring that the fluid ran according to prescription and timeframe

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 05/09/2022 01:54

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/09/2022 01:28

A levels are harder than GCSEs.

The person I was responding to was upset about the idea that to train as a nurse, candidates need to already have a maths GCSE (or equivalent qualification). I was trying to point out that it's not unreasonable to set these requirements as a practical way of making sure these prospective nurses will be capable of the mathematical skills required.

The pre-training maths requirements you're talking about are even higher (A level maths… really? That seems excessive) so I'm not sure why you're responding to me, when I was saying that having some pre-training maths requirements is understandable.

I think I responded to you in error.. i apologise
My point was, when nursing was not degree, but hospital based, maths a level was required (at least it was in london teaching hospitals), so a level of maths knowledge was essential to get into training.
And essential to do the job, even if you can use a calculator now!

Goosygandy · 05/09/2022 01:46

annoyedneighbour1 · 04/09/2022 18:09

& midwives.

For every 30 new midwives that qualify, 29 of them leave.

I'm in my 3rd and final year of training, and I certainly won't be the 1 idiot staying. There is no support for newly qualified midwives and the preceptorship is laughable.

I pay £9,250 a year for the pleasure of working 37.5 a week. I love the women, but the job is completely unworkable.

How I've managed to stay afloat financially over the last 2 years, I don't know. I've just about managed to keep up with my mortgage payments, god knows what will happen this year with the energy costs.

Don't forget... they're trying to make the NHS fail. Don't be fooled into thinking they care. There are plenty of simple things that could be done to make the NHS more efficient.

This is the issue, it's not the training, it's the retention. I know two people who've recently trained, one as a nurse, the other a midwife. Neither have done a day's post training nursing.

It's the experience they had during their training that has completely put them off working in the profession.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 05/09/2022 01:45

SaggyBlinders · 05/09/2022 01:21

The bursary covered the fee, so it was free for the student nurses...🙄🙄🙄

Semantics. Most on the thread were discussing the cost to do the course. I pointed out that with the bursary, fees were paid, so it was free to student. Never said the course was free