Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think trigger warnings are pointless?

112 replies

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:06

I have just come across this meta-analysis of the research on the effectiveness of trigger warnings.

twitter.com/paytonjjones/status/1563950340944560128?t=wiSabn0PLlY2d2NEo2TSDQ&s=19

TL;DR: they don't work.

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

Has anyone ever found them useful?

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 15:19

@neverbeenskiing , I find it incredible how fragile this makes people sound. Life is full of this stuff. Letting young people think they have a right to TWs on ever piece of art they might encounter is simply unrealistic.

OP posts:
Oysterbabe · 04/09/2022 13:37

I think they have their place if you are posting something upsetting that people may not want to read. I read the most horrific birth story while pregnant, I literally cannot imagine a more upsetting birth, it was absolutely horrific. I really could have done without that.

It's gone too far though. I posted a picture of a spider that I crocheted on a crochet Facebook group. The admin told me to add a trigger warning and to next the photo in the comments. It's a fucking toy spider.

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 13:34

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

I don't understand why it's 'astonishing' that some universities feel a sense of responsibility to young people who might be vulnerable? Let's say you're a student who has lost a parent to suicide, for example. Reading a text that contains detailed depictions of suicide is likely to be distressing for you but if you know in advance it's coming you could make sure take care of yourself by, just off the top of my head, making sure you read it when you're house-mates are in rather than when you're alone and plan something nice to do afterwards to distract yourself. If you're already accessing the University wellbeing service you could let the therapist/mental health practitioner you talk to know that you've got to read something that's going to be really tricky for you so you can discuss coping strategies together beforehand. Yes, this will only apply to a small number of students, but that doesn't mean that small number don't deserve some consideration.

CheapBeersFilledwithCrocodileTears · 04/09/2022 13:33

Problem: if you read that Twitter thread, about the meta-analysis, he talks about A/B testing, that between stimulus A and stimulus B, people chose the one that has a trigger warning, so they don’t work. But nearly everyone who has commented has shown real world effect - they don’t choose between two written pieces of material about something traumatizing, one with or without a trigger warning. They choose C - to use the trigger warning and not read an option at all. I would have to know a lot more about the study design of the studies they used for the meta-analysis. And I can think of a very clear reason why, if only given an A/B choice of reading something traumatizing, you’d read the one with the trigger warning - because you might feel the person giving the trigger warning would treat the material more sensitively.

Maybe I’m way off base and the study design of the studies they used were fine, but it sounds like there’s a shitload of margin for error - how in the world could they possibly have tailored double-blind studies about trigger warnings, without knowing each individual’s fears? So they relied on something less than the gold standard, and then mistakes happen. I mean, they may even have relied on self-reporting, which is basically saying, “Random university volunteers who needed good will from their tutor just told us whatever they were feeling on a random Tuesday morning, and that’s what this study is based on.”

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:26

maybe just be grateful that you're not one of the unlucky people they're intended for.

Fair point.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 13:21

I was sexually abused as a child. I can watch/read/listen to media that features CSA and be fine but it helps massively if I know it's coming. That way I can mentally prepare myself or avoid it altogether if I'm going through a rough patch emotionally. I went to a stand up comedy gig a few years back and the support act, a bloke I'd never heard of, started talking about being sexually abused as a child in quite graphic detail. I found it very distressing, I felt like I couldn't breath and wanted to walk out but we were near the front so I was worried he would take the piss as some comedians do when people leave. The only reason I found it upsetting was that it took me by surprise. Rightly or wrongly, it didn't enter my head that a stand-up comedy gig would feature that subject matter, certainly not that it would be talked about at length or in detail.

I understand that the existence of TW just irritates some people. But if that's the case then they're not for you, maybe just be grateful that you're not one of the unlucky people they're intended for.

Bonjovispjs · 04/09/2022 13:21

I'm grateful for them with threads about spiders, complete with pictures. As a complete arachnophobe, that's the last thing I want to see.

Questionaboutjoboffer · 04/09/2022 13:17

Very useful on Mumsnet - I rarely open a thread with a trigger warning in the subject.

RagzRebooted · 04/09/2022 13:14

There was a piece in radio 4 about this a few weeks ago, saying the research indicates they are either pointless or harmful. Which in many cases, they probably are.
However, I agree with PP that with things like forum threads when you have little indication of the topic, then it is helpful.

FlimsySteve · 04/09/2022 13:10

I've found them useful. I follow a FB group in which sometimes people talking about baby loss and I don't want to read about it, so I ignore the posts that say TW baby loss.

IHopeYouStepOnALegPiece · 04/09/2022 13:09

I find them useful on Mumsnet because people don’t always title a thread appropriately.

so I would open “AIBU about this friend” and have no clue what it’s about but if it says “AIBU about this friend TW:SA” I can go, yup not for me

ofwarren · 04/09/2022 13:07

They are useful in mumsnet. I don't want to read posts about suicide or about child abuse so the trigger warning means I don't open those posts by accident.