Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think trigger warnings are pointless?

112 replies

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:06

I have just come across this meta-analysis of the research on the effectiveness of trigger warnings.

twitter.com/paytonjjones/status/1563950340944560128?t=wiSabn0PLlY2d2NEo2TSDQ&s=19

TL;DR: they don't work.

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

Has anyone ever found them useful?

OP posts:
SpiritedSneeze · 04/09/2022 23:40

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 22:49

They're pointless.

If I see TW: suicide, I'll be thinking about suicide.

We just need to learn to get on with life and deal with hard stuff.

@ChagSameachDoreen There is a massive difference between reading the word suicide in a TW note at the start of a show and being suprised by a sudden graphic depiction of suicide.
I read the TW sexual assault and can think "yeah watching that might be hard for me" and then I can decide not to, therefore I can 'get on with life and deal with hard stuff' by not choosing not to watch horrific depictions of events that destroyed me.
I like having the choice to 'deal with hard stuff how I want to'. All of the sexual assault was pretty hard to deal with. I don't consider being lead, without warning, into watching scenes of gratuitous sexual violence, an important part of me getting on with my life.

oopsfellover · 04/09/2022 23:17

The phrase itself may be a bit annoying but the idea of letting people know they might be about to encounter something traumatic is perfectly sane and legitimate. I teach literature and sometimes mention that a difficult subject is going to be touched on - not so that students can run from the room and avoid it all, but so they can mentally prepare themselves if necessary, and also to remind me to handle it thoughtfully without making assumptions about how people ‘should’ feel. @AgnestaVipers is this the sort of thing you find ‘astonishing’ and ‘incredible’? Because it’s really not that big a drama.

entropynow · 04/09/2022 23:04

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 22:49

They're pointless.

If I see TW: suicide, I'll be thinking about suicide.

We just need to learn to get on with life and deal with hard stuff.

You don't mean "we". You mean "you traumatised people" and you have no right to demand that of them. None.

XenoBitch · 04/09/2022 23:02

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 22:49

They're pointless.

If I see TW: suicide, I'll be thinking about suicide.

We just need to learn to get on with life and deal with hard stuff.

I remember a poster on MN saying she was triggered by the word in the trigger warning. So for some, it is pointless.

Trigger warnings certainly have their place with the big usual ones like suicide, abuse, death etc. I have seen people insist on trigger warnings for things like mothers/fathers day, or dogs. I have seen someone ask for one about bicycles, and another about houses.

Saying that, I do like the quote... "It's easier to put on slippers than to carpet the whole world".

hyperbyke · 04/09/2022 22:55

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 22:49

They're pointless.

If I see TW: suicide, I'll be thinking about suicide.

We just need to learn to get on with life and deal with hard stuff.

Multiple posters on this thread have said they find them helpful.

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/09/2022 22:49

They're pointless.

If I see TW: suicide, I'll be thinking about suicide.

We just need to learn to get on with life and deal with hard stuff.

CoffeeIsForClosers · 04/09/2022 22:31

rosettesforjill · 04/09/2022 20:06

For years and years TV and radio have been warning about "scenes of XYZ that viewers may find distressing" and I don't think a trigger warning is any different really apart from the specific words used.

This is fair enough if it's graphic. I don't want to watch scenes of child or animal abuse.

BUT I watched Pam and Tommy recently and in the long list of content warnings was "contains scenes of tobacco use". C'mon now 😂

Bloodoranged · 04/09/2022 20:57

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 15:19

@neverbeenskiing , I find it incredible how fragile this makes people sound. Life is full of this stuff. Letting young people think they have a right to TWs on ever piece of art they might encounter is simply unrealistic.

I don't get why people get so incensed at thr idea of trigger warnings. You're free to ignore them. You're accusing people of being fragile but getting worked up at a couple of words at the start of a piece of work. Maybe we need trigger warnings for trigger warnings.

Oh, and why not link to the actual study instead if a twitter thread?

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 20:29

helpfulperson · 04/09/2022 20:19

I like 'content note'. I do worry that somehow woman are starting to portray themselves as fragile when actually given what many of them cope with we are strong.

We are not portraying 'ourselves' as fragile by finding TW's beneficial, others are portraying us as fragile despite the fact that as pp's rightly point out there have been announcements prior to tv shows and films warning about "distressing content" or "scenes some viewers may find upsetting" for donkeys years.

VladmirsPoutine · 04/09/2022 20:25

I find it more bizarre that people would rail against increasing compassion. It's not soft or indeed 'woke' to apply TW to upsetting content. Surely it can only be a good thing. I was once in a talk and the presenter steered into an issue that had had a profound effect on me. Had I known that she would have steered in that direction I would have gladly waited outside.

helpfulperson · 04/09/2022 20:19

I like 'content note'. I do worry that somehow woman are starting to portray themselves as fragile when actually given what many of them cope with we are strong.

rosettesforjill · 04/09/2022 20:06

For years and years TV and radio have been warning about "scenes of XYZ that viewers may find distressing" and I don't think a trigger warning is any different really apart from the specific words used.

riotlady · 04/09/2022 20:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

XenoBitch · 04/09/2022 19:39

Bonjovispjs · 04/09/2022 13:21

I'm grateful for them with threads about spiders, complete with pictures. As a complete arachnophobe, that's the last thing I want to see.

For some reason, those threads seem to attract arachnophobes.

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 19:28

saraclara · 04/09/2022 19:04

I'm glad not to need them. But I'd do hate the term 'trigger warning'. I prefer 'content note' which is starting to be used. I think trigger warning is quite a stressful couple of words in itself. Also people mock the word triggered.
Content note is much more neutral, while still getting the message across to those who need it.

The term trigger has been used for decades by HCP's to describe anything that can bring on or exacerbate symptoms of distress in people with MH issues. Unfortunately, the tabloids love to stoke division and their "war on woke" nonsense has led to the word being misused, mocked and sneered at. As if people with MH issues aren't stigmatised enough, even attempts to manage their condition sensibly by knowing their triggers planning for them effectively is open to ridicule. If 'content note' feels more palatable to some people and leaves those who need one less open to ridicule or accusations of being a "snowflake" then I'm all for it.

helpfulperson · 04/09/2022 19:23

I think instead of trigger warnings which suggest you should find something upsetting people should title threads appropriately, provide short summaries of texts detailing potentially distressing points etc to ensure no surprises.

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 19:19

I suffered from PTSD due to being gang raped as a teenager, so yes maybe that made me “fragile”.

We are not "fragile", the men that did these things to us are the fragile ones and don't let anyone tell you different 💐

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 19:15

Its never nice to be happily watching a nice TV show or reading a book in my safe and secure house and then be ripped right back to the worst time in my life.

This is exactly what I was trying to say but you've articulated it much better. Many people don't understand that trauma isn't something you ever get over, it follows you throughout your life and you have to find ways to live with it. Even once it's over and you're safe, you can be plunged right back to that feeling of complete terror and helplessness in an instant. TW's can give you a modicum of control over it, and I'd like to think that even if I hadn't experienced it myself I'd have enough empathy not to begrudge others who have.

riotlady · 04/09/2022 19:11

I find them very helpful. I suffered from PTSD due to being gang raped as a teenager, so yes maybe that made me “fragile”. I accidentally went to a theatre show that featured a very intense monologue from the point of view of a rapist and the resulting flashback and panic attack was one of the worst of my life. Like a pp, I can often manage media about rape if I prepare myself, but sometimes it’s just too much and I really appreciate the option to opt out. Especially when it’s in an unexpected place.

I don’t understand why some people are so aggressively anti trigger warning. It barely affects your life at all if you don’t need it, and can be really helpful to those who do.

saraclara · 04/09/2022 19:04

I'm glad not to need them. But I'd do hate the term 'trigger warning'. I prefer 'content note' which is starting to be used. I think trigger warning is quite a stressful couple of words in itself. Also people mock the word triggered.
Content note is much more neutral, while still getting the message across to those who need it.

jimmyhill · 04/09/2022 19:00

Why wouldn't you want help people to decide for themselves whether to watch / read something potentially traumatising? In what world is surprising people with rape / sexual assault / death / pregnancy loss material a good thing!

trigger warnings are just good manners and only abusive weirdos are against them

SpiritedSneeze · 04/09/2022 18:56

I find them helpful,
I know that what happened to me is fairly common, and something that people often like to portray in films and TV and I know that they often like to start it with a jumpscare. I know that when those depictions are intense, graphic and so incredibly similar to my experiences it feels awful. Its never nice to be happily watching a nice TV show or reading a book in my safe and secure house and then be ripped right back to the worst time in my life.
I like that TWs are around more, and websites like doesthedogdie, it lets me control what I am exposed to and minimise how often it happens.
They are not perfect and I don't expect to be warned about everything and I know I will still stumble across things that show SA and DV etc but I would never choose to see it and the TWs mean I get to choose and thats nice.

Hillrunning · 04/09/2022 18:52

I appreciate a trigger warning on mumsnet. They also come in handy on tv shows and movies. I've been in horrible situations where a trigger warning was an obvious need (graphic discussions and images of bombings I experienced) and it wasn't provided. The fall out for me was really terrible so was a waste of my time and my employers money.

I don't feel I or any other participants had a 'right' to a warning necessarily, but had there been one the outcome would have been better for everyone involved. Warnings on University content is very sensible, it means people can make an informed decision and prepare.

You say 'life is full of this stuff' but why have you got an issue with the people who want to minimise some of the 'stuff' when they have the power too?

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 04/09/2022 18:39

I feel like trigger warnings have a place but they are starting to be over used and used in some ridiculous situations.

The examples given above (Tw for baby loss and CSA) make sense if they are being discussed in depth or detail. Tw for violence on the news etc make sense.

However I do think they’re being overused and I don’t think TW should be necessary for something briefly being mentioned or in places where it is obvious there will be mention of a subject.

I heard about TW for human remains on an archeology text. That kind of feels like putting “may contain nuts” on a pack of nuts.

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 18:30

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 15:19

@neverbeenskiing , I find it incredible how fragile this makes people sound. Life is full of this stuff. Letting young people think they have a right to TWs on ever piece of art they might encounter is simply unrealistic.

I don't think I'm "fragile" for finding it helpful to know in advance if I'm going to see something that might bring on flashbacks to my experience of being sexually abused as a child so I can then manage the situation better. I don't think the posters on this thread who have their own reasons for finding it helpful to know if they're about to see something related to baby loss or suicide are necessarily "fragile" either. Nor do I think anyone has a "right" to a trigger warning, I'm just saying I personally find it helpful and clearly some others do too. No one is saying that every piece of art has to come with a trigger warning, but there will always be some who resent any sort of reasonable adjustments for people who have experienced trauma and bang on about "slippery slopes" and "its gone too far".