Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think trigger warnings are pointless?

112 replies

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:06

I have just come across this meta-analysis of the research on the effectiveness of trigger warnings.

twitter.com/paytonjjones/status/1563950340944560128?t=wiSabn0PLlY2d2NEo2TSDQ&s=19

TL;DR: they don't work.

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

Has anyone ever found them useful?

OP posts:
NotBaffled · 05/09/2022 11:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Marvellousmadness · 05/09/2022 10:53

Trigger warnings could be great if well executed. Most of the time the sentence is a mere: "trigger warner" but it doesn't actually say what it is about.

Ans sometimes it is just a bit too much really
But yeah I think it could be great

The news should have it

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 10:52

LaundryBin · 05/09/2022 07:50

Is there a link to the study itself- I couldn’t see one. I’d like to know how they defined TWs. Here many people are talking about TW on MN threads (which seem a good idea- just a way of titling your thread carefully so people know what it’s about). OP is talking about TWs on things like literary texts, which is a slightly different question.

No, but I cut and paste the title and the study comes up.

I linked to the twitter thread because I assumed it would be easily digestible😕 for the majority of busy MN readers...

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 10:49

I agree that the word 'trigger' is itself over-used to the point that it can now be mocked. I feel people are, to a large extent, responsible for due diligence (i.e looking the story up) when seeing a play or film, or not reading further into a thread entitled 'bf raped me' if they are feeling very vulnerable.

In the context of a university degree, it would let me know that I might need to arrange some extra support, like a counselling session, or a phone call with a friend, or that I should sit by the door in case I need to leave halfway through to have a quick cry in the loo.

Over a book or a play? I honestly find this baffling. Especially in terms of literature, where reading a quick synopsis ahead of time gives you that sort of information. Everyone knows that art is full of sex and death. And that it is there to challenge or make us think. I cry quite frequently at art, and I don't go to the loo to do it. It's part of the experience.

I also find myself wondering whether the preponderance of trigger warnings are partly to do with a culture now where people seek out or dwell upon the ways in which they might be fragile. Their 'trauma' (another grossly over-used word) has become part of their personality.

I found this discussion about disability - but specifically autism spectrum disorder - absolutely fascinating. Freddie deBoer is a man with Bipolar disorder who is frank about his experience and hugely intelligent in analysing this recent form of identity politics.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/honestly-with-bari-weiss/id1570872415?i=1000569731362

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 05/09/2022 07:58

That was really interesting in the study that it said that the trigger warning can actually make it more likely for people to read the material in some cases. That is definitely true for me some times. Once I see the trigger in the title and I am triggered by it I often then feel I NEED to read the content to process what this is about and find some relief that way. I may or may not regret that afterwards. I’ve never heard anyone talk about this.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 05/09/2022 07:51

helpfulperson · 04/09/2022 20:19

I like 'content note'. I do worry that somehow woman are starting to portray themselves as fragile when actually given what many of them cope with we are strong.

I don't think people/women finding TW on certain things makes them seem fragile.

TW v CN - there's no difference. Dimwits who think TW, makes people seem fragile will think the same of CN.

those of us fortunate not to 'benefit from TW can just ignore either and act like grown ups. It doesn't matter if it's on a lot of threads or if it's on things YOU can't see the benefit of, if it helps someone it's all good.

@Oysterbabe I can understand why you didn't think to put it on your post about your crochet S, but that will trigger some people - I'm just grateful I'm not one of them. As long as you were just asked to change the title & werent 'told off' I think it's fine.

LaundryBin · 05/09/2022 07:50

Is there a link to the study itself- I couldn’t see one. I’d like to know how they defined TWs. Here many people are talking about TW on MN threads (which seem a good idea- just a way of titling your thread carefully so people know what it’s about). OP is talking about TWs on things like literary texts, which is a slightly different question.

slashlover · 05/09/2022 07:42

I do get annoyed on here when people post titles like "Am I Wrong - trigger warning" without saying what the warning is for, it's useless.

PurpleDaisies · 05/09/2022 07:33

There was an episode of Antisocial on BBC four called “trigger warnings” recently. It was interesting listening. Available on BBC sounds. I think a lot of people don’t understand what being triggered actually is in a similar way that they don’t understand narcissism or gaslighting.

slashlover · 05/09/2022 07:32

rosettesforjill · 04/09/2022 20:06

For years and years TV and radio have been warning about "scenes of XYZ that viewers may find distressing" and I don't think a trigger warning is any different really apart from the specific words used.

Often on the back of DVDs it has a little box for violence, nudity, language etc. which will tell you exactly what to expect in the film. e.g. language - infrequent, mild in a PG or language - frequent, strong in an 18.

FloorWipes · 05/09/2022 07:24

I can get triggered from the trigger warning.

A lot of my triggers don’t tend to get TWs attached anyway.

Avoiding the triggers can be a double edged sword and make things worse anyway.

So on the whole they don’t help me personally.

Sagealicious · 05/09/2022 07:14

Instead of being astonished that there are people who need trigger warnings maybe you should be appalled at WHY they need those warnings. Child rape, sexual assault, suicide, domestic violence, war, etc. That's what's shocking but instead there are those who think it's more important to focus on the use of the word trigger rather than the causes of those triggers.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/09/2022 06:44

Also, it can sometimes be the unpredictable stuff, things that people wouldn't think to (or couldn't) put a content warning on, that are really difficult to deal with.

I did a load of therapy for the traumatic shit that happened to me, no longer had other symptoms, and thought I had really dealt with the problem as much as reasonably possible. What suddenly, unexpectedly got me, years after the therapy, was one scene out of a short "fun" promotional video for an NHS mental health trust, showing some nurses on their new ward running down a corridor towards a camera. For other people, it could be something else equally apparently innocuous (though I do think if they'd thought about that scene of the video a little more they'd have noticed it could be… unhelpful for people with certain experiences). Early on, before the years of forgetting and learning to cope and eventually talking about it in therapy, it was things like the smell of dust, or seeing a dent in a skirting board, or being hugged in a particular way. I was never really badly affected by descriptions or portrayals in media.

For people who benefit from content warnings then fair enough, but they're really limited, and I think they need to be applied carefully rather than indiscriminately or you're making it impossible for traumatised people to distinguish graphic/detailed stuff from mentions that are no more detailed than the content warning itself.

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 05/09/2022 05:56

On the whole they’re pointless.

I’ve seen thread titles along the line of “my friend committed suicide,” which is naturally a triggering post for some. However someone will then come on to the thread and say “your thread title should have a trigger warning.” Except that surely the mention of suicide is a trigger warning in itself?

Also trigger warnings have been trivialised. people are expected to add trigger warnings on to threads about spiders, about dogs, about heights, dogs and spiders and heights are a fact of life. if your phobia is such that you can’t even read about them or see pictures on the internet then you need to step away from the internet and seek professional help.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/09/2022 05:16

Changemaname1 · 05/09/2022 04:31

I’m a little suprised they don’t work altho my experience of them is limited to online forums / social media

i think they are a great idea

If we're talking about whether they work and what this study tells us about that, first we'd have to decide what "working" means or would look like (helping people avoid stuff altogether, and in what contexts? or helping them be prepared for upcoming material?), and then we'd have to decide whether this study is evaluating that.

Usually in order to be able to create a feasible study, researchers would have to define what specific outcomes they're testing and create a carefully defined way to test them, which will be quite narrow and won't always reflect the wide and varied ways something is used, or any of the broader effects.

Like, it's theoretically possible that content warnings are great at helping people avoid things that trigger unpleasant symptoms, but that people who get content warnings and avoid triggers tend not to recover from PTSD, while people who don't get content warnings and do get triggered are more likely to recover. (I don't think that's true, but just for the sake of argument.) So whether or not they work depends on what you mean by work. But this study couldn't evaluate anything like that. (Plus, if that were the case you'd then have an ethical dilemma — is it okay to expose people to distressing stuff because you think it's probably going to be good for them?)

It's an interesting-looking study but I'd like to see someone who knows how to do these things doing a breakdown of the methodology and the stats and stuff, to check if it holds up. It looks like more of a preliminary look at content warnings than an comprehensive analysis of how and whether they work.

Changemaname1 · 05/09/2022 04:31

I’m a little suprised they don’t work altho my experience of them is limited to online forums / social media

i think they are a great idea

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/09/2022 04:22

They can be irritating and unhelpful if inappropriate.

I read an article on the front page of a student newspaper that had "Content warning: suicide" at the top, just below the headline.

The sum total of the offending material in the article was something like "may have thoughts of suicide", towards the end of the piece somewhere. Which is not significantly more likely to cause someone problems than the word "Suicide" in big letters at the top, where far more people will glance at it and see it when they walk past someone reading it, or come across a stack of newspapers.

And people who do need to avoid graphic descriptions of suicide or suicidal ideation have unnecessarily avoided an article that's probably no more triggering than the content warning itself.

People giving a generic content warning before even very minor mentions of a topic, a content warning that's indistinguishable from the one they would give for a lengthy, detailed treatment of the subject, are not helping. If you want to avoid coming across descriptions or portrayals of actual suicide or of suicidal ideation, but everything which even makes brief mention of it is marked equally, then you either have to miss out on a lot of stuff that would've been fine, or risk exposing yourself to the thing you wanted to avoid (albeit with a vague warning).

MangyInseam · 05/09/2022 03:57

No, they are useless.

When people talk about trigger warnings on threads, really what they are is just an appropriate title. They aren't really trigger warnings as such.

The main reason they aren't really very useful in most settings is that the things that trigger people are not necessarily straightforward or directly related to any kind of trauma. And they tend to be highly individual.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 05/09/2022 01:16

I think they're vital on certain threads.

Chouetted · 05/09/2022 01:11

As for fragility vs strength - a stick is strong until it breaks, but a blade of grass flexes in the wind and flourishes.

Which is more fragile?

Chouetted · 05/09/2022 00:44

A trigger warning lets me know that this might not be appropriate to read on the bus. Or on the day before my period, when I'm ready to burst into tears on the drop of a hat.

In the context of a university degree, it would let me know that I might need to arrange some extra support, like a counselling session, or a phone call with a friend, or that I should sit by the door in case I need to leave halfway through to have a quick cry in the loo.

I think testing that sort of effect would be both difficult to execute, and extremely challenging to get past an ethics committee.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 00:07

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 15:19

@neverbeenskiing , I find it incredible how fragile this makes people sound. Life is full of this stuff. Letting young people think they have a right to TWs on ever piece of art they might encounter is simply unrealistic.

Oh good it's been over a week since the last trigger warnings bashing thread (though this one thankfully has a lot less moaning about woke snowflakes).

Why on earth are you so surprised that raped children, or refugees, or kids who watched their dad beat up their mum every night, might have mental illnesses like PTSD? These threads are so snobbish. The assumption is that it's Cressida who has blue hair and goes to Kings demanding TW, when in reality it's Chantal who was gang raped on her estate by local boys who then called her a slut, or Chilemba who was a child soldier. It's the assumption that only naice middle class white kids go to university , and that minorities and people who have been oppressed and abused don't know how to stand up for themselves and can't possibly be educated enough to know what a trigger warning is.

I posted about this in the last thread, but I was forced to read a book about incest for my A Levels while I was living alone in a bedsit having escaped an incestuous abusive home, and reading it caused me to develop psychosis and very seriously self-harm.

A classmate of mine was a mature student and a refugee who worked as a translator, and due to the languages she spoke all she did all day was translate testimony about torture and genocide, and she was assigned 'An Evil Cradling' and had to request another book because otherwise she would have been exposed to nothing but graphic torture both at work and at uni.

Anyone who hasn't been raped or experienced other major trauma please fuck the fuck off this thread.

Why are you so very very angry and incensed at the mere existence of something that saves child rape survivors from potentially kill them that literally does not affect you in any way whatsoever?

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 04/09/2022 23:58

And to pp who said we can't have tws on every piece of art we encounter - you're right on that. However if I open up a book in day to day life to find something hugely triggering of my mental illnesses, I have the option to close it again, to take a break and come back to it, or to not read it at all. If I have to do it for uni I have usually a week to read a couple of novels and write an essay on them alongside whatever else. So I don't have the luxury of saying "you know what, I can't cope with that rn, I'll maybe read it next month", therefore I need to be able to make an informed choice of text in advance. Believe me, I'd rather not have cPTSD and be able to read whatever I like whenever I like!

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 04/09/2022 23:53

I think trigger warnings on literature courses can be vital. Often in a literature based degree the student has a choice of works to study (eg pick this or that topic, each topic has these 4 books or similar). So a brief content note is useful to help a student to decide if it's something they can effectively study. Or if it's a compulsory text, then they can mentally prepare themselves.
Personal experience: at uni, I had a choice of topics, two books per topic, no info on the plot of said books online (too niche/ not well known). I chose a topic only to discover that both of the books centred around graphic descriptions of suicide, both the act and the mental torment leading up to it. At the time I was in an abusive environment and actively suicidal. So, predictably, I had a breakdown, emailed my tutor to request a topic change, for which I then had to read the novels and produce the essay during the vacation, when everyone else was already revising. So yeah, a content note on the book list would've been handy. Not snowflake behaviour, but a survival mechanism.

Ihatethenewlook · 04/09/2022 23:48

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 15:19

@neverbeenskiing , I find it incredible how fragile this makes people sound. Life is full of this stuff. Letting young people think they have a right to TWs on ever piece of art they might encounter is simply unrealistic.

This is the reason why I find it helpful on mn. There are so many threads that are deleted by sensitive mods because they’ve been complained about by sensitive people. At least if you have a Tw in the title you can argue that you made it clear what the thread was about, and you have more chance of keeping it