Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think trigger warnings are pointless?

112 replies

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:06

I have just come across this meta-analysis of the research on the effectiveness of trigger warnings.

twitter.com/paytonjjones/status/1563950340944560128?t=wiSabn0PLlY2d2NEo2TSDQ&s=19

TL;DR: they don't work.

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

Has anyone ever found them useful?

OP posts:
PostmortemNow · 05/09/2022 14:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sagealicious · 05/09/2022 14:24

@JemimaPuddlegoose

I'm so sorry for what you went through xxx

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 14:17

Over a book or a play? I honestly find this baffling.

Really? You find it "baffling" why a minor who recently escaped an abusive incestuous home who's living alone in a bedsit without any support would self-harm when forced to read a book about incest over and over? Oh and there is nothing on the book jacket of that particular book that indicates that it's about a man raping his daughters. Do you not realise that reading a book for school or uni means that you don't have the option to put the book down, you have to read it over and over in depth?

And that it is there to challenge or make us think

Why do raped children need to be challenged?

But I am wondering how people coped before trigger warnings.

They died, Agnesta. People with severe mental illness living in the past were either locked up in mental institutes, or they lived their lives housebound, or they died. Most of them died. Google average life expectancy for people with mental illness in the past.

I also find myself wondering whether the preponderance of trigger warnings are partly to do with a culture now where people seek out or dwell upon the ways in which they might be fragile. Their 'trauma' (another grossly over-used word) has become part of their personality.

What the actual fuck is wrong with you? Go do a degree in psychology then come back with your ableist, ignorant, victim-blaming nonsense about how people who have been diagnosed with PTSD are just snowflakes using their fragility as a personality.

Oh and insisting on putting the word trauma in quotes is beyond the pale cunty.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 14:15

On the whole they’re pointless.
No, they are useless.

They literally save lives. There are people alive today who would be dead without them.

But fuck raped children, right? If something doesn't benefit you personally, no one should have it.

What about those woke snowflakes who insist on using wheelchairs? Just get some resilience and walk!! Statistically most people don't even need wheelchairs, so clearly on the whole wheelchairs are pointless.

It's honestly disgusting the amount of survivors who are sharing extremely personal stories of horrendous personal suffering, and the OP and the rest of the anti-woke gang are either stonewalling them or being goady and attacking them.
I wonder what the agenda is in trying to provoke people into sharing rape stories, and into seemingly trying to actively goad and attack survivors. Some people really get off on upsetting women and disabled people.

There are men who actively make a hobby of invading support groups for women who have survived sexual violence because they get off sexually on upsetting women who have been raped.

There are people who actively invade groups for disabled people and actively target disabled people and really enjoy hurting and trying to goad and try to wind up disabled people.

Some people's instinct towards seeing an injured animal on the side of the road is to give it a good kicking. They simply relish in inflicting pain.

WaitingRoomBoredom · 05/09/2022 14:04

I just can't see why anyone would care. Some people will choose not engage with a thread/show/whatever if it's a subject they don't want to hear about. That's helpful for them and in no way harms anyone else.

SpiritedSneeze · 05/09/2022 13:36

@AgnestaVipers
Thank you, I'm glad I made sense.

In relation to people being angry on the thread, I do understand what you mean and I am really not having a go at you, it's just when it's coming from someone who does not need the adjustment, it can feel a bit patronising. Like if a right handed person made a thread, saying stuff like
"Aibu to think left handed scissors are pointless?
Its annoying that more left handed stuff keeps turning up, like can openers and I even saw a left handed spiral notebook and folders for students, its gone too far. The world is set up to be right handed and we can't keep letting young people make left handedness their whole identity. If they are feeling vulnerable about their left handedness- they should adapt products themselves, before trying to use scissors in public".

And linked to articles and books where people say how there is no need for left handed products because everyone uses the right handed ones anyway, even if it hurts their hands. And maybe they are doing that anyway to revel in the difficulty of being left handed.

Except if left handedness was the worst thing in your life- the cause of significant pain, humiliation and shame and the reason you have been in therapy for 10 years.
You are made to constantly see people discussing how left handed products are for snowflakes and young people and are silly because some people have decided that its just as important to make left handed mugs so people can now see the picture printed on them.

And then told maybe they shouldn't talk about left handed products as a left handed person if they are going to get angry about it.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 13:06

@SpiritedSneeze , you're quite right - people have always been upset by stuff. I expect that's why Mary Whitehouse held such sway for a time! And yes, we now have trigger warnings because people asked for them. What I am wondering aloud about is whether that it has gone to a point that it is meaningless. Clearly there are people on here who feel TWs have a lot of value. That said, really angry people have come onto this thread to tell me off for even thinking about the issue, when presumably they should have read the thread title and stayed away?

And I completely agree about the ultra-realism of violence in the media. I personally can't handle gruesome violence, which is why I have avoided certain genres of film and TV shows that friends have raved about. I just can't bear it. I occasionally find it pops up in books unexpectedly, and this is unpleasant. But as people have pointed out, I am not suffering from PTSD so have survived the experience relatively unscathed.

OP posts:
SpiritedSneeze · 05/09/2022 13:00

@AgnestaVipers
The thing about how people used to deal with things without TWs is sort of false.
For one- people were upset by them, thats why decades ago we got age ratings and descriptors like foul language and sexual content- because they knew they might upset people and were letting people choose what they wanted to see. So realistically these warnings have been around since before the 60s.
People were upset and asked for warnings, just because sometimes it can be taken 'too far', does not mean the concept or the majority of uses are incorrect, or pointless. Where do you think the warnings came from if not from people in the past asking for them? They are not new.

But also media has never been as realistic as it is now, even 15 years ago things were still limited. The sorts of shows and films that were being made were different as well. Espcially before the 60s before those warnings existed.

Violence in films was cloaked and eluded to rather than shown graphically. Like when Nancy was murdered in Oliver, you dont really see it happen, shes in the dark and there is a wall in the way.
The darkness is spoken about and showed softly- he stage slaps her and shouts, as art it works- I can empathise with her, I feel what she's going through and I can imagine what happens to her the rest of the time- it does not however, look real. It looks like a play, and not a great one.

The media that is made now is more graphic, more violent and so much more realistic. I'm not saying I forget that its not real, it just looks the same now as it does in real life and that just is harder to deal with. Media art is good now- they are very good at making assaults and injuries look real, so much more than it ever has been. So along with harder topics and more explicit staging, it also looks real.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 05/09/2022 12:59

I don't pay much attention to them, personally. In my head, they're not much different to what we might call 'content context' that has been around for ages; 15/18 certificates on films, for example, or the parental advisory sticker (remember those on CDs? Showing my age here...)

latetothefisting · 05/09/2022 12:54

I think it depends what the warnings says. I imagine the vague "catch all" warning that come on before tv shows "some viewers may find some scenes distressing" are useless because they don't say what the distressing thing might be or when it will happen.

Warnings like "contains scenes of sexual assault/severe cruelty to children" etc. I can imagine would be useful in some cases.

I don't really see the issue with putting warnings on books for English literature students - most books are studied because they are well written and depict social issues of the time so its a reasonable deduction that unexpectedly coming across a realistic and emotive depiction of something might be very upsetting to someone who has experienced similar issues, whether its rape, racism, war etc. I did eng lit and the reading list was such that you could skip some books per topic and focus on others, so can't really see the issue with giving students advance warning so they can make an informed decision.

I am a bit bemused at the idea of a teenage rape victim getting a "heads up" that "book a contains violent sexual assault so you might want to read books b and c and base your essay on those" being "wrong" and "snowflakey" tbh?

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:27

Sagealicious · 05/09/2022 07:14

Instead of being astonished that there are people who need trigger warnings maybe you should be appalled at WHY they need those warnings. Child rape, sexual assault, suicide, domestic violence, war, etc. That's what's shocking but instead there are those who think it's more important to focus on the use of the word trigger rather than the causes of those triggers.

Imagine if I cared about those things as well?

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:26

Hvergelmir · 05/09/2022 11:45

Please, you're not interested in anything. You're just being goady and superior.

In the same spirit, I am going to accuse you of projection.

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:24

What does this have to do with trigger warnings for serious topics like infant loss, childhood abuse, suicide?

I'm exploring, broadly, the idea of people seeming to be very fragile in our culture, and that can co-exist with the idea that there are people who have genuinely had very painful and upsetting experiences that they are recovering from.

I am sorry if there are individuals here who feel these ideas somehow personally attack them. That is not the intention.

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:20

So you disagree with trauma on the basis of perceived wokeness.

No, I think trauma is a word used when other words might be more appropriate.

I have also found this book interesting, as it unpacks the issue in a direction I hadn't thought of before:
news.columbia.edu/news/george-bonnano-new-book-the-end-of-trauma

OP posts:
cont · 05/09/2022 12:15

Their 'trauma' (another grossly over-used word) has become part of their personality.

So you disagree with trauma on the basis of perceived wokeness. Yes, there are people, many teenagers, who misuse psychological terms like trauma. What does this have to do with trigger warnings for serious topics like infant loss, childhood abuse, suicide?

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:13

"Don't bother replying" - on my own thread?😀

I responded to you, then quoted someone else and replied to that point. Sorry if it baffled you.

OP posts:
KatVonlabonk · 05/09/2022 12:12

The analysis was really interesting op.

Chouetted · 05/09/2022 12:12

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 10:49

I agree that the word 'trigger' is itself over-used to the point that it can now be mocked. I feel people are, to a large extent, responsible for due diligence (i.e looking the story up) when seeing a play or film, or not reading further into a thread entitled 'bf raped me' if they are feeling very vulnerable.

In the context of a university degree, it would let me know that I might need to arrange some extra support, like a counselling session, or a phone call with a friend, or that I should sit by the door in case I need to leave halfway through to have a quick cry in the loo.

Over a book or a play? I honestly find this baffling. Especially in terms of literature, where reading a quick synopsis ahead of time gives you that sort of information. Everyone knows that art is full of sex and death. And that it is there to challenge or make us think. I cry quite frequently at art, and I don't go to the loo to do it. It's part of the experience.

I also find myself wondering whether the preponderance of trigger warnings are partly to do with a culture now where people seek out or dwell upon the ways in which they might be fragile. Their 'trauma' (another grossly over-used word) has become part of their personality.

I found this discussion about disability - but specifically autism spectrum disorder - absolutely fascinating. Freddie deBoer is a man with Bipolar disorder who is frank about his experience and hugely intelligent in analysing this recent form of identity politics.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/honestly-with-bari-weiss/id1570872415?i=1000569731362

It's there to make you think.

It's not there for me to re-live in front of everyone exactly how it felt at the moment of attempting suicide. To go into gruesome details that would probably put them off their lunch. To make the session about me, in a very public, embarrassing way. My trauma is not there for classmates to dissect academically - it is mine, and I deal with it privately. So yes, I would discuss that with a friend or professional.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 12:11

Perhaps you should take responsibility for the fact you read a thread where trigger warnings were being discussed?

OP posts:
NotBaffled · 05/09/2022 12:09

@AgnestaVipers

I don't rage against studies, I generally find that they are not conclusive and MAY form PART of an argument for or against something. We live in a time with many studies. Subjective data can be manipulated and any study (on it's own) is just an idea that at that time gained backing. As you didn't actually provide a link to the study, I can't be arsed finding it, because it does not interest me.

Please take my rudeness in the manner it was intended. I will tell you what you could be doing. A study why people trawl spaces like mumsnet intentionally goading and pissing off people who are trying to be part of something good. You have the perfect data starting point. Yourself.

Don't bother replying (You aren't very good at it - Your last reply to me was a bloody mess - You highlighted someone else's comment for a start). It Baffled me!

Nice name btw. Very clever. If you think tediousness is clever I mean. (It's clear you do)

cont · 05/09/2022 11:59

saraclara · 04/09/2022 19:04

I'm glad not to need them. But I'd do hate the term 'trigger warning'. I prefer 'content note' which is starting to be used. I think trigger warning is quite a stressful couple of words in itself. Also people mock the word triggered.
Content note is much more neutral, while still getting the message across to those who need it.

Yes, this.

I'm with @neverbeenskiing that they are sometimes necessary. After family loss, I find depictions of suicide in the way my family me never died and offensive options very distressing.

But trigger warning as a phrase has negative connotations with 'snowflakes' who can't cope, which is why many people automatically are 'against' it.

Hvergelmir · 05/09/2022 11:45

Please, you're not interested in anything. You're just being goady and superior.

bicyclesaredeathtraps · 05/09/2022 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Exactly!
Character dies in film/ book / play = I have a cry just like anyone else if I was invested, more so if it's done well, no harm done.
Character is intently suicidal/ kills themself/ has vivid flashbacks to child abuse = I have flashbacks and nightmares that stop me eating, sleeping, plus ocd flares up sometimes to point of not being able to leave the house.
Not the same fucking thing is it.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 11:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SpiritedSneeze · 05/09/2022 11:19

@AgnestaVipers
The due diligence bit is tripping me up. I get that in some cases it is clear what the content will include, and people are largely responsible for choosing to view media that clearly contains things that may upset them. But that is sort if the point- the information is only sometimes available and when it is not, TWs are useful.
So for example I would not go and see a film where the main point of the story is about SA but lots of films and TV have a SA secondary storyline and so it is not mentioned in the description. And if it is a new film there may be nowhere to do this due diligence of finding out everything about what the story will entail.

For example a show like Casualty, or silent witness where there are multiple story lines and an episode when it is shown initially will not have an available synopsis anywhere. Unless you ask someone else to pre watch shows for you (ridiculous) or wait and hope somebody mentions it online, (does not always happen). There is nothing you can do. This is fixed by a line of white text at the top of the screen for 5 seconds that says TW- Sexual Assault and Graphic Violence.

It helps- and its a bit weird that you could read this whole thread and still come to the conclusion that people who are 'feeling fragile' are just not trying hard enough to not be upset by sudden, unexpected and incredibly realistic depictions of the worst things that have ever happened to them.

Most people who like trigger warnings being put in those scenes are not asking for it to annoy other people or to revel in their snowflakery, expecting the world to pander to us because we are feeling delicate. Its because trauma is hard, PTSD is hard, flashbacks and the realities of dealing with the aftermath of horrific events is hard and TWs on media can be useful.