Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think trigger warnings are pointless?

112 replies

AgnestaVipers · 04/09/2022 13:06

I have just come across this meta-analysis of the research on the effectiveness of trigger warnings.

twitter.com/paytonjjones/status/1563950340944560128?t=wiSabn0PLlY2d2NEo2TSDQ&s=19

TL;DR: they don't work.

I have been astonished lately that trigger warnings are put on things like books on English Literature degree courses.

Has anyone ever found them useful?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PostmortemNow · 05/09/2022 16:38

Here it is again verbatim quote:
(By @JemimaPuddlegoose
"Oh and insisting on putting the word trauma in quotes is beyond the pale cunty."

And it seems that @NotBaffled is quite baffled
not by the use of this offensive language but
by my reaction to it. It's "goading & provocative".
Calling someone else "c...y" is perfectly ok
on the other hand, as it was expressed in advancing
the righteous cause.

That'll teach me.
What baffles me at this point is the fact that
@NotBaffled is so concerned I have NO personality
to speak of.
I can only apologise for this malfunction.
Unreservedly.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 16:33

@JemimaPuddlegoose
I appreciate that, and sorry for being harsh earlier.

(Though weirdly I quite like King Lear.)

Apology accepted. I hope my explanation for why I care about this (above) also reassures you I am not trolling.

As for King Lear - nothing will convince me! 😁

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 16:26

Why do you care so much anyway? Why can't you just ignore them?

That's a fair question.

First, let me reiterate that I do know that real and profoundly disabling trauma exists, often in the form of sexual abuse or violence. That - and the need for proper psychiatric/therapeutic care - is not up for debate in this thread.

Why am I interested? Firstly, again, I was intrigued by the study described in the OP. It was not what I expected to hear.

I care because I perceive our society to be pathologising everything. Medicating everything. And that young people (whose welfare I care about) perceive themselves to be far more fragile than they really are. And for people to go through life perceiving themselves as fragile is a dangerous and unsustainable situation. This comes from years of experience in interacting with young people (in personal and professional ways), as well as the simple observation of the wider culture.

I think there's a blame culture, and that young people increasingly look to some sort of authority figure to help them manage their difficult feelings. This is borne out in university contexts, where academics are accused of hurting their students if their work is criticised. To the point where medical students may not have been robustly examined, for fear that the profs get accused of something. So that system is producing second rate doctors, or (more widely) second rate critical thinkers.

It intersects with the 'woke' issue because at the heart of that is the critical social justice movement, which reduces everyone down to oppressed/oppressor, and in order to avoid being 'oppressor' people need to find themselves an aspect of victimhood. Straight white men are the most reviled. Middle class straight white girls or women are second in line.

Going through life thinking in terms of grievances and micro-aggressions is reducing our culture's robustness. It is highly divisive. It is churning out people who are medically damaged or reliant on antidepressants. It's a culture full of people hopelessly reliant on the opinion of others. It is profoundly unhealthy. Which is surely borne out in the staggeringly depressing stats around young people's mental health.

So I would argue that we should not be coddling young people. I think, given the challenges ahead, we need stronger people. And I am interested in how that can be encouraged.

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 16:07

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:54

Well, now I understand the context. The being forced bit was because it was on the A level syllabus, and you didn't feel confident enough to ask the teacher if you could change it. Yes, that would have been very troubling for you, yet I think ironically your teachers would have quickly let you switch if they had known the distress it would cause you. I'm guessing it's The Wasp Factory, which is a really messed up book. I struggled with it myself, despite having no related issues. (I realised I've just 'spoiled' the book now for any passing prospective readers.)

I am trying not to be flippant and offering my condolences at you being forced to study King Lear, too. (I hate that play.)

I appreciate that, and sorry for being harsh earlier.

(Though weirdly I quite like King Lear.)

Hvergelmir · 05/09/2022 16:06

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:38

Yes, because people have their own perspective.
You might find them helpful; other people say they click or read on anyway, or ignore them.

77% so far are saying YANBU.

People's pain and trauma are not denied by differences of opinion on a topic. And, because I am not the boss of everything, I am not going to decree that TWs should be banned.

The are saying that they don't work, not that they don't work for them. If they help some people they're doing their job.

Why do you care so much anyway? Why can't you just ignore them?

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:57

77% so far are saying YANBU.

Statistically it's unlikely the majority of MNers have experienced the kind of major trauma this thread is discussing.

Plus, MN tends to skew pretty right wing and there's a lot of real anger and vitriol towards anything perceived as "woke" or "snowflakey" right now.

There is a recent influx of posters - and I am not accusing the OP since I don't think she's one of them at all, but sometimes you get a large group of posters who all post identical political threads at the same time. Recently there were about half a dozen threads started within a short space of time promoting the idea that disabled people are benefits cheats and pondering if the Tories should cut disability benefits, which definitely felt like orchestrated propaganda, or someone testing the waters.

A recent thread about trigger warnings was full of very similarly worded rants about "woke liberals censoring books" but actual book banning (which is usually done by conservatives/right wingers) on books discussing LGBT issues or racism are either completely ignored or applauded. I looked for and couldn't find a single thread about the major news story about Maus being banned, but there were at least two threads about a very minor news story about a uni letting students opt out of reading books about sexual abuse. There are posts saying it's fine to ban books about gay kids because those books are "dangerous" and "grooming", but that letting teenagers opt out of reading books about rape is "fascist censorship."

There's a very very clear political bias at play here (not in this thread, but in general on MN) and trauma survivors are basically being exploited as pawns in the so-called culture wars.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:54

Well, now I understand the context. The being forced bit was because it was on the A level syllabus, and you didn't feel confident enough to ask the teacher if you could change it. Yes, that would have been very troubling for you, yet I think ironically your teachers would have quickly let you switch if they had known the distress it would cause you. I'm guessing it's The Wasp Factory, which is a really messed up book. I struggled with it myself, despite having no related issues. (I realised I've just 'spoiled' the book now for any passing prospective readers.)

I am trying not to be flippant and offering my condolences at you being forced to study King Lear, too. (I hate that play.)

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:43

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:34

I was forced as a very vulnerable teenager to read a book about incest

So, to be clear - how were you forced to read it? I am genuinely interested to understand that for various reasons. If there was a TW, you are saying you could have chosen not to read the book?

It was the book assigned to me as my A Level English Literature set text, as part of the Comparative Literature part of the course (reading and comparing this novel with King Lear).

I had no idea it was about incest and a father raping his daughters until half way through reading the book (the fact the dad raped them is a plot twist that is revealed later in the book, so the book jacket is careful to not give any indication of this to avoid being a spoiler).

By the time I got the the part of the book where the spoiler is revealed I'd already done too much work to be able to change to a different book, since we were reading and analysing it chapter by chapter. If I'd known from the start I would have had time to change books.

Also, a teacher using TW indicates that that teacher is aware of issues like PTSD and will be sympathetic towards students saying "I can't read this book because it's triggering." As a very mentally unwell and abused teenager, do you think I would have had the confidence to approach a teacher to demand to read a different book from everyone else? No - but a teacher using and discussing trigger warnings would have reassured me that I was allowed to, and would have implicitly given me permission to request a new book.

Kinsters · 05/09/2022 15:41

I actually find them really handy, I prefer content warning over trigger warning though. I don't know whether it actually has any effect on my anxiety levels but I like the control that a content warning allows.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:38

Hvergelmir · 05/09/2022 15:34

There have been multiple posts on this thread stating that trigger warnings are useless and don't work despite posters describing how the have worked for them.

Yes, because people have their own perspective.
You might find them helpful; other people say they click or read on anyway, or ignore them.

77% so far are saying YANBU.

People's pain and trauma are not denied by differences of opinion on a topic. And, because I am not the boss of everything, I am not going to decree that TWs should be banned.

OP posts:
Hvergelmir · 05/09/2022 15:34

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:02

It's honestly disgusting the amount of survivors who are sharing extremely personal stories of horrendous personal suffering, and the OP and the rest of the anti-woke gang are either stonewalling them or being goady and attacking them.

I do feel I should point out, though, that this hasn't actually happened in any way.

There have been multiple posts on this thread stating that trigger warnings are useless and don't work despite posters describing how the have worked for them.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:34

I was forced as a very vulnerable teenager to read a book about incest

So, to be clear - how were you forced to read it? I am genuinely interested to understand that for various reasons. If there was a TW, you are saying you could have chosen not to read the book?

OP posts:
NotBaffled · 05/09/2022 15:33

@JemimaPuddlegoose

I don't understand why anyone would think that either. A trigger warning is not censure. It is not stopping people from taking enjoyment out of the book/play/online discussion. It just gives them information that may help them make a clear and valid choice in their own life. Something that everyone should be able to do. If someone has trauma (and some trauma is life-long), and there was no trigger warning then they are more at risk of avoiding MORE things. For instance when I was first diagnosed with c-ptsd I avoided the cinema because I wasn't sure how I would act in public, if I didn't know what potential triggers were in the movie this worry would have increased significantly.

Now I can review the movie or whatever it is I want to do and look out for trigger warnings if necessary. It is helpful, It makes me more able to make clear choices on my history/mental health and circumstances. Trauma is part of my life and my personality because that is how trauma works. It is not part of my personality because of trigger warnings. In fact one of the reasons I like TWs in general is because I want to avoid situations where my history comes into discussion. My life is personal to me.

@SpiritedSneeze

I bloody loved your left hand scissors analogy. I thought it was very relevant.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:21

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:18

The point is no one is forcing anyone to do anything. Including reading this thread.

But by advocating against content warnings, you are basically saying that it's fine that I was forced as a very vulnerable teenager to read a book about incest that resulted in me having an episode of psychosis and self-harming, without having any way to know upfront that it was about incest.

A TW would have saved me from that.

I don't see how anyone could find that objectionable since it literally does not affect them in any way.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:19

And, frankly, if you are finding the thread so distressing, why not stop engaging with it?

I don't find it distressing.

I'm pissed off because I think people are acting like goady arseholes.

You do understand that there's a difference between being triggered (in the medical sense) and being pissed off, don't you?

Sorry but you don't get to start a thread about people with PTSD then dictate that people who actually have PTSD shouldn't post, just because we prove your ableist goady posts wrong.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:18

The point is no one is forcing anyone to do anything. Including reading this thread.

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:17

Art is different. If we bowdlerise it , it loses a lot of its point.

No one is talking about censorship or bowdlerisation. People make choices every single day what art they choose to consume, and every single commercial art form spends huge amounts of money in things like publicity and market research to decide on cover art and book jacket blurbs, with the sole intention of reaching the audience demographic who are most likely to choose that particular item.

Giving someone a tiny bit of extra info about content doesn't affect, change or impact the actual book or piece of art in any way. It simply doesn't.

The suggestion that films are mere "entertainment" and thus unimportant while books are "art" and sacred to being cheapened by content warnings is just bizarre. How does a Barbara Cartland or Dan Brown novel stack up against an arthouse film or a documentary film about Rwanda?

Giving major trauma survivors a choice of what art to consume is not remotely bowdlerising things.

but if I hadn’t read. It, how could I have hoped to understand what Hardy was about?

There are far more books in the world than any of us can possible read. Nobody needs to read any one specific book. I read at least 100 books a year, but I'm sure there are plenty of books you've read that I have not read, and vice versa. Because people have different tastes.

I read King Lear, Macbeth, An Evil Cradling, and tons of non-fiction books covering everything from the Wars of the Roses to the Belgian Congo atrocities while a student during the same time period I didn't want to read the incest book.

Why should I be forced to read a book about a father raping his daughters, when there are so many other wonderful and important books in the world?

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:11

In what way am I meant to engage here? I have acknowledged that people on this thread find TWs helpful. I have made clear that I think PTSD exists and that people do feel traumatised by events.

What exactly do you think I should have done, besides that?

And, frankly, if you are finding the thread so distressing, why not stop engaging with it?

Again, this somewhat proves the findings in the analysis I linked. People click even when they know they may not like the content.

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:07

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:02

It's honestly disgusting the amount of survivors who are sharing extremely personal stories of horrendous personal suffering, and the OP and the rest of the anti-woke gang are either stonewalling them or being goady and attacking them.

I do feel I should point out, though, that this hasn't actually happened in any way.

It literally has.

Oh wait I forgot, you refuse to engage with actual survivors.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 05/09/2022 15:05

Sagealicious Flowers

While we're talking about academic studies, there are studies showing that rape survivors and survivors of major violent crime, as well as people with serious illness like cancer, often experience hostility, stigma and rejection.

Go to any forum or conference for people who have survived any serious crime or illness (or for disabled people), you'll often see people talking about how merely existing as a person with cancer, or existing as a wheelchair user, or a existing as a rape survivor, incites total strangers to anger and hostility.

It has its roots in evolutionary biology: people perceived as weak are considered a threat to the rest of the tribe and as unfairly getting a free ride since they can't fight or hunt and need others to care for them.

Fortunately most people are capable of not acting like cavemen.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/09/2022 15:02

I think there is a difference between fora like this, where the title often bears little relation to the content, and where people are detailing and discussing their own experiences and views, and a university course. English Literature, like it or not, is pretty much based on trauma of one sort or another, and on the characters’ reactions to it. So are most, maybe all, western literatures. I don’t know a great deal about non-western cultures. Certainly the Japanese Novels, I have read didn’t shy away from distress. History is full of dark and unpleasant events, but you can’t make a balanced picture or draw any conclusions from it if you are just going to erase them.

I find the trigger warning for sex and violence on TV shows very useful ,it generally means drag the remote out from where it is lurking under the cushion so you can fast forward through the grizzly bits. Contains adult humour = don’t bother, you won’t enjoy it.

But this is entertainment,,or at least attempted entertainment. I was terribly upset by Jude the Obscure when I read it as part of the prep for an essay on Hardy , but if I hadn’t read. It, how could I have hoped to understand what Hardy was about? Romeo and Juliet is tragic, but a nice anodyne story about two lovers ignoring their families feud and living happily ever after wouldn’t have much moral impact. Art is different. If we bowdlerise it , it loses a lot of its point.

AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:02

It's honestly disgusting the amount of survivors who are sharing extremely personal stories of horrendous personal suffering, and the OP and the rest of the anti-woke gang are either stonewalling them or being goady and attacking them.

I do feel I should point out, though, that this hasn't actually happened in any way.

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:01

NotBaffled · 05/09/2022 14:59

@PostmortemNow

You are clearly just posting that to goad and be nasty.

What is the point?

Do you even HAVE a personality or is it just whatever happens to be antagonistic and annoying to others? Because that is clearly your goal.

It baffles me. It really does.

You really do have the wrong username.

OP posts:
AgnestaVipers · 05/09/2022 15:00

@SpiritedSneeze "Aibu to think left handed scissors are pointless?

If they were pointless, they'd be safer I guess. 😀

But seriously, I think where the analogy falls down is that left-handedness isn't a disability. It doesn't matter whether someone is left-handed, and it doesn't negatively affect people's lives. Whereas PTSD does - hopefully temporarily - disable people (assuming we take mental health as seriously as physical health.)

Perceiving oneself as fragile or vulnerable in a way that is cosseting or that stops one from healing, or that devalues the genuine trauma of others - I think that's what I am focussing on.

@JemimaPuddlegoose , you are just shouting and if I tried to address anything you wrote you'd accuse me of victim blaming. So I won't bother.

OP posts:
NotBaffled · 05/09/2022 14:59

@PostmortemNow

You are clearly just posting that to goad and be nasty.

What is the point?

Do you even HAVE a personality or is it just whatever happens to be antagonistic and annoying to others? Because that is clearly your goal.

It baffles me. It really does.