Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just let DD go to school with earrings in.

306 replies

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:29

School starts tomorrow and DD is saying that she will go to school her earrings in (not allowed). Now i dont agree that earrings shouldnt be allowed however they are the school rules. Ive said to her health and safety but she says that 1) my earrings are small and screw on- there is no chance of them falling off or getting caught on something. Tbh shes right- shes worn these earring from nursery right through primary school and there has never been an issue. 2) if its health and safety concerns why are the teachers wearing earrings. Shes right on this to- in events and parents evenings ive seen the teachers wear earrings/jewellery. Shes gotten phone calls home about this and got shouted at by the school but she says to me ' its a bit hard to take them seriously about the danger of earrings when they have like 5 earrings as well'. I cant get hett up about her wearing the earrings to school. Shes doing amazing in all other areas of school so far and this seems like a pointless rule
AIBU?

OP posts:
swallowedAfly · 04/09/2022 14:45

By the time your kids are in year 10 you have no control over them? This is not a normal attitude and there would be no such thing as society if this was true.

Even if your only means of control is well it's up to you but if you leave with those earrings you'll be coming home to no wifi/playstation/phone it's still some control. It won't take long to re-establish the balance and whilst it will be uncomfortable briefly your relationship and their education and chances for coping with all the annoying rules and regulations that life throws at us will be vastly improved.

berksandbeyond · 04/09/2022 14:44

It's completely different for adults / teachers. I expect they're allowed to wear high heels too.
You're sending a terrible message to your daughter about respect for authority and knowing how to behave appropriately but then I suppose if you're the kind of person who pierced your toddlers ears then you're the kind of person who doesn't care about things like that.

swallowedAfly · 04/09/2022 14:37

Btw schools have to manage the behaviour of 1000+ teenagers in crowded conditions from very different backgrounds and manage to give those kids an education.

What seem like petty rules to you are the backbone of creating a culture in which kids can actually learn because they have accepted some common, simple boundaries and respect for the culture of the school.

If you can't even get one child, your own child, to follow a simple instruction then imagine the challenge of getting over a thousand of them to follow rules that will keep them safe and allow others to learn even if they don't want to themselves and tell you, 'their parents don't give a shit either'?

Well researched strategies and systems are put in place and it turns out, mad or not in my or your opinion, that getting kids to accept and adhere to low level simple rules of conformity such as uniform are key. You might want to also consider that if your dd is being sent to the pastoral office to sort out the fact she's wearing earrings again and has already been warned and now has to do x, y or z, she is NOT in her lesson learning as she is meant to be. She may well have also robbed her whole class of five minutes learning whilst the teacher 'persuaded' her that yes she really did have to go to the pastoral office seeing as she'd chosen to disregard the rules again and no we don't have time during our maths lesson for a one on one argument about whether she should have to follow rules or not because there are 29 (or god forbid 32) other kids in that room whose parents have sent them into school to get an education not listen to this.

If you deal with it at home it is just you who has to waste your time arguing and enforcing - if you say, 'let the school deal with it' because I can't be bothered then it impacts on a lot of people including the the kids of the parents who could be bothered having that battle at home out of consideration for the rest of the community.

If you hate the rule then complain about it, talk to other parents, write to the board of governors etc. At my school they're allowed one plain stud in each ear and one small nose stud. So there's your first argument for your case: many schools allow..... can I ask why you don't follow a similar policy? Petition, lots of emails from parents etc. The, 'this is a stupid rule', is a red herring because you could challenge the rule constructively in an adult way.

Butterdishtea · 04/09/2022 14:30

Once they get to year 10 there's very little a parent can do if their kid is a shit.

Speak for yourself.

NCHammer2022 · 04/09/2022 14:30

I heard the teachers in my DD’s school are allowed to drink wine at home but apparently that’s a “health risk” for the children!

YABU and you know it. Take them out and let the teachers get on with their actual jobs instead of dealing with shit like this because you don’t want to.

Madamecastafiore · 04/09/2022 14:26

Just parent your kid rather than inconveniencing the teachers.

raindon · 04/09/2022 14:25

swallowedAfly · 04/09/2022 14:23

Presumably this is why my school have been pushed to the point of having a policy where if something has to be confiscated twice it won't be given back until a parent comes into school to collect it.

All the, let the school with it, I cba arguing with a teen, etc does seem to go down the drain when the parent is actually inconvenienced by their lack of parenting. At my school now, and my school is not Michaela style, very restorative model orientated, etc., those earrings would be gone until you could be arsed to find a way to try and make it into school during the receptionist's office hours to collect them.

For some parents they have to go through stamping their feet and screaming at the head on the phone several times to no avail to accept that yes they really will have to come into school to get Bob's phone themselves. For some they have to go through this twice. All eventually step up and do some active parenting eg. tell Bob next time he has his phone out at school and gets it confiscated they won't be going out of their way to pick it up for at least a week or the phone will be confiscated by them for a week after collection.

They really don't give a shit until until it impacts them and their time and energy. And as said some will scream and shout and stamp their feet worse than their children (they don't lick it up off the floor as an old friend would say). Perhaps more schools should do this. If parents no longer have any intrinsic motivation to parent their children then extrinsic motivations have to be imposed. How tragic to have to deal with adults this way!

What is the point of that though. Once they get to year 10 there's very little a parent can do if their kid is a shit.

swallowedAfly · 04/09/2022 14:23

Presumably this is why my school have been pushed to the point of having a policy where if something has to be confiscated twice it won't be given back until a parent comes into school to collect it.

All the, let the school with it, I cba arguing with a teen, etc does seem to go down the drain when the parent is actually inconvenienced by their lack of parenting. At my school now, and my school is not Michaela style, very restorative model orientated, etc., those earrings would be gone until you could be arsed to find a way to try and make it into school during the receptionist's office hours to collect them.

For some parents they have to go through stamping their feet and screaming at the head on the phone several times to no avail to accept that yes they really will have to come into school to get Bob's phone themselves. For some they have to go through this twice. All eventually step up and do some active parenting eg. tell Bob next time he has his phone out at school and gets it confiscated they won't be going out of their way to pick it up for at least a week or the phone will be confiscated by them for a week after collection.

They really don't give a shit until until it impacts them and their time and energy. And as said some will scream and shout and stamp their feet worse than their children (they don't lick it up off the floor as an old friend would say). Perhaps more schools should do this. If parents no longer have any intrinsic motivation to parent their children then extrinsic motivations have to be imposed. How tragic to have to deal with adults this way!

CulturePigeon · 04/09/2022 14:20

It may seem that your daughter's earrings are a safe type, but schools have to make a blanket rule or people will push it, and teachers don't have time to faff with making judgement calls on this type of thing. It's simpler (and the only workable way) to say 'no earrings' than to have to constantly check, give reasons, deal with other students saying 'But x or y is wearing a bigger pair' etc.

I agree that, while she's at the school, she needs to obey the rules - otherwise, as with laws in adult life, where do you draw the line? We can't decide for ourselves which laws/rules are good, and which we'll ignore. Apart from anything else, your daughter may not understand the big picture which teachers have to deal with. Also, how will she feel if she loses one? I hope she won't bother a busy teacher!!

Just toe the line - it's not worth a fight with the school. And I think her analogy with what teachers are allowed to do is silly and irrelevant.

Pumperthepumper · 04/09/2022 14:09

I’d let her crack on with what she wants to do. I’d drop the thing about ‘well teachers do it so why can’t I?’ because it’s senseless.

Butterdishtea · 04/09/2022 14:00

When I was a child my mother did her own parenting and this included making sure I didn't break the rules on her watch.

Crocwok · 04/09/2022 13:47

SofiaSoFar · 04/09/2022 13:30

All these people saying they don't think their DC should have to follow rules if they think they're 'stupid'...

What marvellous children you must be raising. 🙄

I do think by year 10 though a teen doing something that isn't risking others, causing damage or harm to anything should be their decision. As a parent of course you can explain why x needs to be done and why it's important (albeit in this case would take quite some imagination as its a stupid rule), but ultimately its up to them and they can learn that these decisions have consequences. At uni met plenty of people who had evidently been told what to do past a reasonable age and they were useless at making reasoned decisions for themselves.

EthicalNonMahogany · 04/09/2022 13:44

I think the health and safety bit is a red herring. I think the best part of simple dress rules at school is that the whole rest of culture is all about creating nice little consumers - express yourself by buying stuff and adorning yourself. Your worth is your appearance. We need some spaces for young people where what you look like or what your fashion sense is, is supremely unimportant.

teenagers should be allowed to play around with their style. - yes maybe but not all the time.

Where, apart from school, can they learn that they can be impressive without the armour of hair dye or trendy clothes? Where each person is judged by what they say, do, write and think?

Screw makeup and jewellery at school. Screw hair dye and shorter skirts. Put everyone in baggy comfy jumpsuits and let them learn.

SofiaSoFar · 04/09/2022 13:30

All these people saying they don't think their DC should have to follow rules if they think they're 'stupid'...

What marvellous children you must be raising. 🙄

Maireas · 04/09/2022 13:23

If it really is unacceptable, find a non selective state school with rules to suit your daughter.

SeemsSoUnfair · 04/09/2022 13:20

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 11:32

I have pointed this all out to her. I am in no way encouraging this behaviour and have said multiple times if anything happens i shall not help

You are her parent not the school. It is your responsibility to do more than just not encourage the behaviour.

Of course teens will rebel. It is your responsibility as a parent to resolve this before it becomes another problem the school ultimately has to deal with, and a distraction from educating the children, due to feckless parenting.

The school will have behaviour problems to deal with every day, why do you think it is remotely acceptable for you to add to their load?

What consequences are you giving her? Or is that too much parenting effort for you?

Hesma · 04/09/2022 13:16

If she’s going to flout the rules she can take the punishment like you said. I’d just suggest she’s got a small box or envelope with her to keep them safe in. It sounds like she’d be devastated if one fell out of her bag and she lost it

GreenWasTheColour · 04/09/2022 13:12

Just to add - I have never agreed with school uniform and I find it immensely frustrating as a parent. But I enforced the rules rigidly when I was a teacher because if a student in my form was spotted in the day wearing something forbidden, I would get reprimanded for not dealing with it in registration. So yes, I went round checking shoes and confiscating earrings and wasting my time ringing parents about violations because it was my job, I would be in trouble for not doing it and I had zero say whatsoever in what the uniform policy was.

Oh, and I adhered to the staff dress code myself, obviously not the student one - so yes, I could wear jewellery. Children do have to abide by different rules to adults! It's really bizarre to see people arguing that they shouldn't.

I'm very glad to be out of the sometimes petty and illogical world of schools, but please know the beleaguered form tutor ringing you about your kid's haircut or whatever is not doing it for fun - particularly in the world of multi academy trusts, rules come from the top and teachers can't ignore them any more than students can.

MrsR87 · 04/09/2022 13:01

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:41

I am inclined to just let her as she is going into y10 so she can just face the consequences of her actions. So far punishments have been to take it out and on one occasion get shouted at which she was not fazed by. She says most of the girls wear earring and just hide them. They are stud earrings and were given by deceased grandmother and are considered her 'lucky earrings' so thats why she wants to wear them so much

I’m a teacher in a secondary school and I agree that it seems harsh not to allow earrings at all; most I have worked in allow one pair of studs. However, rules are rules and whether you really agree with them
or not, parents and schools need to work together to enforce the rules so that there are no mixed messages when it comes
to expectations and behaviour.

The part of this that concerns me
the most from this post is that they are earrings of sentimental value. As they are against the rules, it’s highly likely that she will be asked to take them out. This means keeping them safe on her person for the rest of the day. Pupils in my previous forms have lost no end of rings, bracelets etc that it then turns out have sentimental value in this way. Such a shame for the pupil/family but so easily avoidable and unfortunately with things as small as rings and earrings, very difficult to find in a school.

HikingforScenery · 04/09/2022 13:01

I think it’s a silly rule- simple studs should be fine.
However, it’s a school rule and really earrings are not that big a deal so I’d advise her to take them out.

SisterAgatha · 04/09/2022 12:55

Teand · 04/09/2022 11:53

I don't really understand how stud earrings can cause so much of an issue during PE either. I've got a load of them and I never remove them when I exercise. What exactly is the issue with studs during exercise?

My friends little sister got whacked somehow (not at school) and the whole stud and backing went in to the ear lobe. She had to have it cut open, taken out and sewn back together. They were the safety studs you have in at the start.

WhizzFizz · 04/09/2022 12:48

JennyForeigner · 04/09/2022 09:41

I'm going to tell you a secret. Some of these rules are just about having rules and learning to be with others.

One day your daughter might want a job in a restaurant. She will have to wear a hairnet. If she becomes a surgeon she will have to take off her rings.

The greatest favour you can do her is to teach her to play within the rules, no matter how stupid they seem to her, so she can progress and be happy without turning everything into an argument.

This. Exactly.
She is enjoying confrontation and it does her no good. The teachers have better things to do than police uniform but a line has to be drawn somewhere.

Chooksnroses · 04/09/2022 12:43

Your attitude is teaching her that she doesn't really have to have respect for rules. The fact that teachers wear earrings has nothing to do with it. They, I presume, teach, and do not have to take part in the activities that the school deems would pose a health and safety threat to an earring wearer. Deliberately wearing earrings is a form of insolence, and negates the fact that she's "Doing amazing" as you put it. Did you mean she's doing amazingly well?

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 04/09/2022 12:43

I’d point out that if the school ring you you will be backing the school and any punishment up. And I’d point out the risk of them getting lost if she is made to remove them or disappearing from the changing room during pe. Then I’d let her get on with it, she wants to fit in with her friend and if the school are lax with the rules then teenagers push back against it. When I was at school it was make up and short skirts that were a no no and at least 80% of the girls had makeup troweled on and skirts rolled up. Nothing was done so it was only an extra thing to bully the few of us too scared to break the rules about.

twoshedsjackson · 04/09/2022 12:33

I agree with @JennyForeigner; one of my former pupils ended up at an industrial tribunal because she was dismissed from her job as a dental nurse, having refused to have her nail extensions removed. She tried to claim sex discrimination, despite the fact that young chaps these days have been known to sport varnish at all.
Unluckily for her, the tribunal found that the dress rules pertaining to her work (bare arms from the elbows down, short unvarnished nails for reasons of hygiene) took precedence, and I believe she had to pay costs as well.
Your daughter observes quite correctly that some dress rules do not apply to teachers, but one difference is that, as an adult, I would not expect the school to "carry the can" for any foolishness on my part; if I chose to wear precious earrings to school (either in monetary or sentimental terms), took them out for vigorous activity and lost them, I would not expect the school to take responsibility for their loss.
I'd be surprised if there wasn't a dress code for the staff as well, either formal or informal; at my last school, I remember a gentle reminder that, as the holidays drew to a close, some pupils would be around for pre-term events, and term-time attire might be more suitable.