Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just let DD go to school with earrings in.

306 replies

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:29

School starts tomorrow and DD is saying that she will go to school her earrings in (not allowed). Now i dont agree that earrings shouldnt be allowed however they are the school rules. Ive said to her health and safety but she says that 1) my earrings are small and screw on- there is no chance of them falling off or getting caught on something. Tbh shes right- shes worn these earring from nursery right through primary school and there has never been an issue. 2) if its health and safety concerns why are the teachers wearing earrings. Shes right on this to- in events and parents evenings ive seen the teachers wear earrings/jewellery. Shes gotten phone calls home about this and got shouted at by the school but she says to me ' its a bit hard to take them seriously about the danger of earrings when they have like 5 earrings as well'. I cant get hett up about her wearing the earrings to school. Shes doing amazing in all other areas of school so far and this seems like a pointless rule
AIBU?

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 04/09/2022 10:01

I get what she’s saying tbf. However, if she chooses to disobey the rules, let her face the consequences. But please don’t go running to the local paper with sad faces (there will be a few of those in APILN this week no doubt).

Seafretfreda · 04/09/2022 10:00

I take her point. Some schools forget they’re there to educate. The mums in our school year challenged the school re swimming and the removal of earrings. They kept saying the DC had to take earrings out to go to the local pool, but half the kids had lessons at the local pool and this was not a pool rule at all! Head soon changed his tune when this was pointed out.

raindon · 04/09/2022 09:58

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:45

Honestly if it were up to me the earrings would be out. However i think its good for her to learn the consequences of her actions and will be backing school if she gets in trouble

Seems fair enough. Let her learn the hard way.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/09/2022 09:56

She can wear them but I wouldnt get into the arguments about it to be honest they are not valid.

They can be a health and safety issue in PE, which teachers don't participate in the same way. Teachers don't have to wear the uniform and never have so the fact that teachers wear them is irrelevant.

They probably are ok to wear if they are just small studs in all honesty but can you imagine having to sort out hundreds of girls and classify which earrings are and arent acceptable? They would start wearing bigger and bigger studs, higher and higher up the ear, and what about the bit between the lobe and the upper ear, where is the cut off, what about two tiny ones instead of one big one, etc etc...no one has time for all that shit. It's much easier to have a simple enforceable blanket rule of no earrings. If she wears them they might confiscate them and not give them back for a while (what happened to me when I wore some jewellery to a new school when I was a teen after coming from a school of no rules).

It's not a massive hardship to take them out before school and put them back in after surely

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/09/2022 09:55

notonur · 04/09/2022 09:36

Stupid rule that I wouldn't be getting my DD to follow. A simple, small stud is fine. Taking them out even for a few days can cause some peoples holes to start closing.

Given she's had them in for years this winter happen in a week. She can wear them Fri night to Monday morning, so closing over isn't an issue.

nothing to stop her wearing them after school each night, overnight.

Sunnyqueen · 04/09/2022 09:54

Yanbu its a pathetic rule, studs are in no way dangerous so no need to have the rule in the first place. It's just a rule for the sake of having a rule. Let her wear them.

notonur · 04/09/2022 09:54

headinabook · 04/09/2022 09:38

We’ve got teachers dealing with kids who haven’t had a hot meal in the last 48 hours. Do you think they need the hassle of adding rule-breakers to their list?

Nope. So don't add to the list of 'rule breakers' by adding pupils on for wearing a simple, plain set of studs ffs

SallyWD · 04/09/2022 09:52

We're in exactly the same situation and will be taking out my daughters earrings during the school day. There's no way we're going to break the rules on day one! Don't want my daughter or me as a parent to be identified as trouble makers so early on. It's a silly rule in my opinion but it's a rule nonetheless and pupils should follow the school rules. It would be anarchy if the kids chose to disobey all the rules they didn't agree with.

bellac11 · 04/09/2022 09:52

Although I dont agree she should wear them, I do find it a bit galling when teachers go on about how much time and admin this all takes up to enforce this and that

Fine, then dont have stupid rules about tiny little earrings then you wont have to spend time dealing with it, or just dont enforce it.

Same with length of skirts, the odd bit of colour on an all black shoe, tie done up the wrong way. If these petty rules were not in place then teachers wouldnt need to deal with all that.

But as I say,, for parents who have signed up to it, thats what you have signed up for

lizziesiddal79 · 04/09/2022 09:52

Adults don’t have to follow the same rules as children. ‘Twas always thus.

In the same way teachers don’t have to wear a specific uniform and can dye their hair unnatural shades, they can wear jewellery. Teachers don’t tend to get into fights or competitive one-upmanship i.e. my earrings are bigger, brighter, more offensive than yours etc. They are adults and have more autonomy. Having said that schools do hold teachers to certain standards i.e. no visible tattoos, no political pin badges, always wear your lanyard etc.

Teachers tend not to moan that those in other professions can show tattoos and they cannot. They recognise they are in a school environment where certain standards are expected.

As a child, your daughter needs to follow the standards expected of her.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/09/2022 09:51

barelyfunctional · 04/09/2022 09:33

YANBU, if she’s not bothered about getting into trouble for it then it’s fine. I’ve never come across a school that doesn’t allow any earrings at all, normally rules say just studs and only lobe piercings, so the school is being abnormally strict with their rules for no apparent reason. Also totally agree that the teachers should have to follow the same rules, setting a good example and all that.

Also totally agree that the teachers should have to follow the same rules, setting a good example and all that

Don't be daft. Staff are not students.

JennyForeigner · 04/09/2022 09:49

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:45

Honestly if it were up to me the earrings would be out. However i think its good for her to learn the consequences of her actions and will be backing school if she gets in trouble

OK, that's a little different. In that case I would be clear with everyone involved that's what you're doing so school don't feel they are going to be asked to serially fight your battles.

Hbh17 · 04/09/2022 09:49

We all have to live with rules, including those we don't like. You are the parent and so you need to support the school and make it clear that the rules must be followed.

chilliesandspices · 04/09/2022 09:49

the teachers don't tend to get into fights or get their earrings caught during PE.

I didn't get into a single fight at school. Neither did any of my friends. As for PE, we just took them out and put them back in afterwards.

I think these rules are silly but if it were up to me, teenagers would be allowed to play around with their style. They have the rest of their lives to dress to rules if they choose to go into a profession that requires it.

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:48

I also think the punishments at this school arent strong enough which is why they deal with this problem- i know that she definitely wouldnt get detention nor get them confiscated. At the worst it was a shouting - a mild one at that- and a phone call home. She was apparently wearing them for months (unknown to me) so she didnt lose them.

OP posts:
SageRosemary · 04/09/2022 09:48

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:41

I am inclined to just let her as she is going into y10 so she can just face the consequences of her actions. So far punishments have been to take it out and on one occasion get shouted at which she was not fazed by. She says most of the girls wear earring and just hide them. They are stud earrings and were given by deceased grandmother and are considered her 'lucky earrings' so thats why she wants to wear them so much

Just so long as you realise that it can be upsetting for other students who are fully uniform compliant to have a peer "shouted at". It's exhausting for everyone.

bellac11 · 04/09/2022 09:47

Are they just plain gold studs, I thought screw on earrings were quite a modern thing I didnt realise that they had been around when her grandmother would have worn them, which Im assuming is many years ago but perhaps not

I dont really like uniform rules but equally if you dont like the rules of a certain school then change school, or home educate. You signed up to accepting the school rules when you signed her up at the school so you have to accept it

AntlerRose · 04/09/2022 09:47

Having seen they are lucky earings from a much loved grandmother, I wouldnt let her take them in. If she is asked to remove them, they could very easily get lost. Especially if they are put in some communal tub of removed items.

Squirrelsnut · 04/09/2022 09:47

When pupils ask me why I can wear earrings and my own clothes, I tell them that their school is my place of work and that I followed my own schools' uniform rules for 12 years.
Agree with a pp that having something harmless to rail against is actually good for kids.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 04/09/2022 09:46

What I really hate are rules that aren't actually enforced. If most girls wear them then yes- it's a stupid rule.

Having said that, if they are special, she might lose them when she's caught and has to remove them, which would be totally her fault. It's not a risk I'd want to take and I'd drum that into her.

Singleandproud · 04/09/2022 09:46

Just take them out, it's saves hassle when someone loses an earring, it gets stuck, gets caught during PE or tech, they have a fight etc etc. Tomorrow pastoral staff will be busy dealing with abuse disclosures that always increases on the return to school, making sure girls have access to sanitary products, making sure children with families who haven't eaten properly all summer get food and support. Don't waste their time having to deal with uniform issues.

Lots of jobs have dress codes that you have to abide by, for teachers in most schools they can't wear jeans on a normal school day or have tattoos showing. In food prep you can't have false nails.

Also having a negative experience in the morning with her form teacher and other staff members and kicking off about her earrings isn't going to do her frame of mind any good for later in the day, she'll be negative and her education will suffer.

BeyondMyWits · 04/09/2022 09:46

At my daughters' school ( 3 years ago) it would have meant a uniform demerit. 3 in a week and you got detention. 10 in a year and you didn't get an invitation to prom.

Very few rule breakers.

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:45

Honestly if it were up to me the earrings would be out. However i think its good for her to learn the consequences of her actions and will be backing school if she gets in trouble

OP posts:
Poppyblush · 04/09/2022 09:45

It’s a rule, tough, tell her to deal with it. There will be lots of rules in life which may not be fair or logical but she will need to follow them so get her to grow up.

ShaneTwane · 04/09/2022 09:45

Teachers and students are not the same. Of course a teacher has different rules to students.